News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by blocke on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:52PM (#2507799)
Google has done everything it can to hamstring this launch. The software sucks. Buggy, Crashy, Beta quality. The emulator's performance is so bad it's unusable. The tablet section of the market is empty of real tablet apps. The Android Market can't even handle reorienting itself.

The Android team doesn't seem to give a shit. Ask anyone who has tried to support Android is an Enterprise how bad the Exchange, VPN and 802.1x stacks have been since day one. Business as usual. Their public issue tracker is obviously intended as a space for frustrated users [1] to shout into a bottomless pit of who gives a shit.

I used to be a major Android fan but screw this. If only WebOS was open source...

[1] - Edited to substitute users for customers. Real users are not Google's customers. And the experience shows.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by ChuckMcM on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:35PM (#2507946)
Interestingly one of the things that I found most amazing when I was working for Google was a nearly total inability to grasp the concept of 'deadline.' For so many years the company just shipped it by committing it to the release branch and having the code deploy over the course of a small number of weeks to the 'fleet'.

Sure there were 'processes', like "Canary it in some cluster and watch the results for a few weeks before turning it loose on the world." but being completely vertically integrated is a unique sort of situation.

Android is much like a more traditional vendor/customer model where they are at a place in the pipeline that has to co-ordinate with other things that are in the pipeline. Except when those 'other things' are hardware it gets really strange.

I was present in meetings in which all the folks at the meeting would nod their heads at some release date which was totally and completely imaginary. It existed so that dereferencing the term 'release date' didn't return 'undefined' :-). I remember my first project there I asked SRE (part of operations) for a date when they would be done with their part. Got that date, operated my part of the project against it, the date arrived and nothing. Two days before the date I had re-confirmed it, and on the date was told, "Well its not quite ready, probably in a couple more weeks." Really? One of the reasons people do 'starter projects' there was to learn this lesson.

The 'tablet' version of Android has been a planning disaster from the moment it was conceived as far as I can tell. Why isn't ChromeOS (basically Android kernel + browser UI) not the tablet version of Android? Android/Tablet vs Android/Phone? AFAICT its because Apple pulled off making iOS work between phones and tablets, and they only pulled that off because they had the iPod Touch for YEARS before they shipped the iPad and kept asking 'what is a non-phone experience like?'

I have no inside knowledge of how the whole 3.x thing went down but if it was like other projects there, rather than get some clear thinkers together in a room and put together a plan and then manage against the risks of that plan, two or maybe three 2 or 3 person 'teams' (friends likely, in their 20% time) probably started working on their vision of how it might work as a tablet, only to be out maneuvered at a review (or not) to have several competing versions going forward which then someone checked in first and everyone else was stuck following that version until someone else checked in something better. Reasoning? Planning? Discussion amongst stakeholders? Probably not so much.

So I would certainly place the underwhelming nature of Android tablets completely at Google's doorstep. Its not like the hardware is less capable than the iPads, in some cases its even more capable.

Its not in Googles DNA (at the moment) to execute against a customer/supplier type of arrangement. Fortunately I think there are some really smart people at Google who understand that, I hope they can prevail against the inevitable corporate anti-bodies that are now doubt even now trying to marginalize them.

I do believe that Android will win here but for the same reason that lava coming out of a volcano 'wins.'

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by orangecat on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:58PM (#2508052)
Why isn't ChromeOS (basically Android kernel + browser UI) not the tablet version of Android?

Because native apps are sometimes nice. A tablet that can't play Angry Birds is a hard sell.

Interesting comments about Google's development practices. My impression is that Honeycomb's problems stem from the fact that there was a hard deadline: they wanted to get the Xoom out before the iPad 2. If that's not how Google normally operates, that would explain a lot.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by montagg on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:17PM (#2508137)
Google is also not really a hardware company. Their primary focus is software.

Competing competently in the tablet market is really stretching Google's strengths as a company. I think they can do it eventually, but it's going to be a long learning process.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by nl on Monday May 02, 2011 @11:12PM (#2508848)
My impression is that Honeycomb's problems stem from the fact that there was a hard deadline: they wanted to get the Xoom out before the iPad 2. If that's not how Google normally operates, that would explain a lot.

This.

Also, I've heard that Google developers didn't know the deadline until after the Andy Rubin demo (which was a few month before launch)

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by bstar on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:31PM (#2507927)
I've been having a ton of issues with Apple myself. I've had account issues where I keep getting denied access to many downloads in the dev center despite having paid the $99.

Their support has been atrocious, it generally takes 2-3 weeks for a response. When I do get a response they ask for a screenshot despite the fact I've given them the error message verbatim, with error code.

I had to buy x-code4 through the app store because this issue is going on 3 months- still waiting on a refund.

This isn't meant to be an apple bashing post. I'm pissed about these issues, but I don't think it's because Apple doesn't care. I think it's because they are trying to cope with enormous amounts of support tickets and are probably having trouble hiring qualified people to address them. I'm guessing that Google is experiencing a similar problem x10. There's a market demand to get these products out asap, but the infrastructure just isn't ready yet.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by warfangle on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:18PM (#2507873)
Not only that, but the Xoom is extremely expensive compared to iPad devices. And you don't even get access to WiFi unless you sign up for 3G/4G service. Two huge reasons for its downfall that have everything to do with Motorola and nothing to do with Android itself.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by orangecat on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:00PM (#2508062)
And you don't even get access to WiFi unless you sign up for 3G/4G service.

Nope: http://gregisdumb.com/2011/02/24/verizon-motorola-xoom-no-lo.... Not even Verizon could get away with screwing their customers that blatantly.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by warfangle on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:06PM (#2508271)
Aha. I'd missed this the first time around. Thanks. Looks like they have the wifi-only version out now, for $600. Still pretty expensive. Might actually stop by best buy on my way home from work and check it out though.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by guelo on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:48PM (#2508393)
>extremely expensive compared to iPad devices

They cost about the same.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by npalli on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:30PM (#2507920)
There is a wifi only model but that was introduced towards the end of the quarter. Agreed on the extremely expensive wifi/3G model.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @06:10PM (#2515504)
Is it the case, as I have seen suggested elsewhere, that the wifi-only model has a slower CPU?
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by j_s on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:10PM (#2508109)
My favorite Android bug: "Android dev team ignores its own bugtracker"

http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=7589

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by hinathan on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:10PM (#2507857)
That's not Google doing 'everything it can to hamstring' — That's Motorola shipping a product based on an OS that's obviously not ready. Motorola's fault.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by blocke on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:26PM (#2507911)
"That's not Google doing 'everything it can to hamstring' — That's Motorola shipping a product based on an OS that's obviously not ready. Motorola's fault."

Google controls Android 3.0 completely. They very intentionally did not make a source release. Google entered the relationship with Motorola and it damn well had control over who was going to ship a 3.0 device. They knew what they were doing. They HAD to beat the iPad 2 release date at all costs.

So now all we have is a buggy as hell 3.0 OS with no source release and we're still waiting for them to fix stuff. I hope the early release to beat the iPad furthered some other business goal because it didn't further Android as a great Tablet OS.

The flaws I've seen in the device are clear OS and Software issues. So unless your point of view is that it's up to other people to fix Google's fuckups... eh...

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by montagg on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:21PM (#2508156)
No, you're right. It's not Google's fault that someone at Motorola didn't have the balls to say, "This just isn't ready for prime time" and put it off until it really was done. But Google is still dragging its feet on making Android ready for tablets. They've had a year with an already successful model to look at. Building an OS isn't trivial, of course, but their commitment is clearly not behind producing great tablet software.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by r00fus on Monday May 02, 2011 @08:38PM (#2508512)
> They HAD to beat the iPad 2 release date at all costs.

I doubt they had to. They chose to, and blundered with the entire world looking at them.

If I were Moto, I would have red-lighted the project some months before deadline, when it was readily apparent that Google wasn't going to deliver a quality stable release on-time.

Competing with the iPhone (and it's carrier exclusivities and high ASP) is one thing, but if you have shoddy product, the iPad is going to wipe the floor with you unless you really offer something unique (ie, eee transformer looks interesting).

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:08PM (#2508099)
The box says Motorola. That means they signed off shipping it. Even if any problems with it can be placed firmly at Google's door, it still says Motorola on the box. I think that was the previous commenter's point.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by blocke on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:02PM (#2508261)
"The box says Motorola. That means they signed off shipping it. Even if any problems with it can be placed firmly at Google's door, it still says Motorola on the box. I think that was the previous commenter's point."

Fair enough. Motorola definitely shares blame.

But at the end of the day all that is Android ends at Google's feet. Why play games with holding back the 3.0 source if you don't at least feel you have some responsibility for how Android launches on tablets?

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by foobarbazetc on Monday May 02, 2011 @08:53PM (#2508556)
The box says Motorola AND Google.

The device has both logos on the back, and they're the same size.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @06:13PM (#2515508)
did Google order manufacturing of the device? did Google order printing of the manuals and the box? did Google stack the boxed up devices onto palettes and ship them out to shops? Is it called the Google Xoom? No no no no. All of the above are Motorola, and more. It's a Motorola product which uses hardware and software components from probably dozens of suppliers. One of those suppliers is Google. They may have supplied a shitty component, but Motorola shipped the device instead of saying "this isn't ready, don't ship it".

How are you actually arguing with this point? Is it just because this is the internet and fingertips are a renewable resource?

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by npalli on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:28PM (#2507918)
Here is the installation document for Honeycomb. http://developer.android.com/guide/practices/optimizing-for-... It clearly talks about using the Xoom for testing purposes. So, Google released Honeycomb as a finished product, used Xoom as the reference device and you are telling us that somehow Motorola shipped a product while google was looking the other way. The software is clearly a huge part of the problem (blocke mentioned some). Things which were working fine in Froyo/Gingerbread suddenly did not work on Honeycomb anymore - Flash not working until a month after release, the entire back/home/menu interface was broken. Market place not working, no apps optimized for tablet, no SD card support etc. etc.

To their credit Google recognized they messed up and are exerting more control but there is no question they share a lot of the blame on the software side here.

Motorola on the other hand messed up with pricing and the late introduction of the wifi only model but I suppose they felt confident after a good showing in CES and good reveiws.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by ChuckMcM on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:37PM (#2507953)
I'm guessing Motorola had the hardware ready, they've got an investment hanging over it which they need to recoup some of, and perhaps Google offered to cover some of their costs. Who knows.

Motorola also got some good exposure and definitely some experience in channels that will be critical in the future.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by daniel_solano on Monday May 02, 2011 @09:09PM (#2508594)
I don’t think that Motorola had the hardware, or the software, ready at all. That’s why the LTE upgrade will require mailing the tablet to Motorola and a one week turnaround time.

Apparently, it’s a software issue, but the SD card doesn't work at all. However, this isn’t a Google issue, as other Honeycomb tablets have working SD card slots.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cube13 on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:22PM (#2507891)
I don't see how it's entirely Motorola's fault, honestly. At best, both parties are equally at fault. Google could have refused to release the source, forcing Motorola to go with Gingerbread instead of Honeycomb.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by foobarbazetc on Monday May 02, 2011 @08:47PM (#2508541)
I recently bought a Xoom (since the Android Honeycomb emulator is unusable), and it's a laughably poor product from the unboxing experience all the way to the horrible UI that is Honeycomb (even worse than standard phone Android, and that's laughable UI -- where's the HIG, Google?).

Honeycomb is like taking the worst Linux WM you can find and sticking it onto a tablet with no thought for how a tablet should work. This is going to appeal to some Android fans, but that's about it.

Everything on this device is horrible. The device feels chunky and heavy, the screen looks dithered (you can see individual pixels) and unevenly lit, and you can see UI element flicker into place. And there are about 2 or 3 tablet specific apps that are actually tablet apps in the Market (Angry Birds, and some other poor quality Android games). ClockOS even lives on, with a dedicated clock on the home screen, and the bottom right corner, and there's even a 'Clock' app. Fantastic.

Oh, it also doesn't charge via USB. WTF?

Anyway, it has one thing going for it: it has Angry Birds and it works more or less like the iPad version of Angry Birds. That's about it.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by guelo on Monday May 02, 2011 @11:08PM (#2508839)
I own a Xoom, and while I agree it is nowhere near the iPad experience, the device is not THAT bad, your comment is way too harsh. There are 64 tablet specific apps. And you are lying about seeing individual pixels, it has a higher pixel density than the iPad, on par with an iPhone 3G.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by foobarbazetc on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:49AM (#2509013)
I'm not lying. I can see the dithering and have terrible eyesight.

The pixel density may be higher than the iPad, but the screen quality is nowhere near it.

And the device is that bad. What's with the system tray? And the Windows Vista style app switcher? It's like we've gone back in time to when Windows 95 was cool (and Honeycomb has a UI that is less consistent than Windows 95), except with tappable UI widgets.

Maybe 4.0 will fix it all (ala how 2.0 brought Android into the 'usable' category), but this is not a tablet for anyone but nerds.

'64 tablet specific apps' is being generous. Maybe the people developing these apps upped targetSdk and stuck in a poorly-recreated-fragment-API-using-thing-aka-UISplitViewController widget, but that's pretty much it.

The rest are games that are available on iPad.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by abrown28 on Monday May 02, 2011 @09:21PM (#2508615)
I like my Xoom and those of us without super human vision think the display looks just fine. Not charging via the usb is annoying but not a deal killer for me. The apps will come eventually plus I can write my own apps if I want without having to shell out another $800. I have no love for apple.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:27PM (#2508174)
(Disclaimer: I own a whole stack of Apple kit, including an iPad, and some AAPL).

I've not played with a Xoom, but it keeps striking me that all of the people launching Android tablets are totally the wrong people to be doing it. Apple has (at least) the following things going for it:

1) It gets great deals on components and manufacturing 2) It maintains very consistent retail pricing 3) It does a lot of retail itself 4) It gets 30% off the top of all app purchases on the device 5) It gets ?% off the top of all music/movie purchases on the device

Points 1-3 are good for initial profit margins. It means they're making decent money on every iPad sold. Points 4 and 5 are good for ARPU (average revenue per user) - it means you're continuing to make money from every device sale, long into the future.

Now look at the Xoom or the Galaxy Tab or any other android tablet currently available or announced and think very hard about which of the above points apply. I think you'd struggle to apply anything other than point 1 and even that probably only applies to Samsung. Most of the vendors do small manufacturing runs, sell them wholesale to retailers and get no money from end users until it's time for new hardware. The only exception to this I can think of would be revenue sharing deals from the mobile networks on the 3G models. I don't know what kind of deals these would be, but my guess is that the networks would demand pretty cheap unit prices on the hardware.

So who could do better? The obvious answer is Amazon, they could at least get points 3, 4 and 5 (and 3 strongly suggests they'd also get point 2) and what are they doing? Running an Android app store right now. If they can make a good tablet (and the Kindle hardware suggests they should be able to), they could really make a splash with it, and that would help them improve on point 1. Sony might be able to, in that they could arrange point 5 and potentially 1 and 2, but my general view on Sony's ability to execute in the 'digital lifestyle' arena is very very negative ;)

Alternatively perhaps Samsung's desire to copy Apple's hardware will translate into a desire to copy their services. If they could get deals on content then they could get points 4 and 5 and differentiate themselves from the Android crowd.

That's my take on part of the tablet world. I also think Android badly needs some really slick tablet apps - on a par with iMovie and GarageBand, both of which are stunningly good.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by code_duck on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:34PM (#2508201)
Those are the reasons why Apple is well situated in the market, and can offer low prices and still make great margins.

The reasons that their products are successful beyond that are even more important, IMO. Unlike Motorola, Samsung, Google, Nokia, and so many other companies in this space, Apple has been working very hard on designing interfaces for applications and personal computer operating systems for a very long time. When you put Apple with their experience with OS X and Mac software up against Motorola, even with Google's help, it's clear who has the advantage.

There's not really another company with Apple's sort of experience out there, other than Microsoft. The problem is their mobile strategy is a mess still, and they don't seem the same quality of vision that Apple does.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:06PM (#2508272)
I don't disagree with you at all. The software is a huge part of Apple's success, but I was being generous and assuming Android is as good. Even with ideal hardware specs and software quality, Android tablets would still be worse business than iPad.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by code_duck on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @12:58PM (#2514433)
Android is good, but the non-Google (Motorola) software that came with my phone is clearly not as well designed as the Google stuff, and definitely not as good as the Apple software that comes with iPhones - mail clients being a good example.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by junklight on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @11:44AM (#2510406)
Excellent take on it.

This has been bothering me for a bit in the "android takes the market share" reporting. It totally misses the point that Apple makes a ton of money off it's bit of the market but the android segment is full of lots of companies making low margins and not really doing that well.

Amazon is, on paper, brilliantly situated to do something really good in this space (including a fork of Android of their own perhaps - no idea if the licensing would allow that)

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by m0nastic on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:50PM (#2507785)
I'm not so sure that there's any useful conclusions to draw from this article (even assuming that the numbers they cite are correct).

If the Xoom turns out to be unsuccessful, there's no shortage of possible explanations as to why that was the case. At this point, I think we need to either have a successful non-iPad tablet, or a longer period without a successful non-iPad to make any kind of useful analysis.

If another Android tablet launches and is successful, than that may tell us something about what Motorola did wrong here. If the Playbook becomes successful, that might also tell us something, but again, these would be things specific to Motorola's product.

The only meaningful conclusion that this seems to suggest is that just launching a tablet doesn't guarantee success (which shouldn't be a surprise, as that's been the status quo for the past decade at least).

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by daniel_solano on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:07PM (#2508095)
Slowly but surely, there are new Honeycomb tablets being shipped. In the US, this past week has seen the release of two new tablets: the Acer Iconia A500 and the Asus EEE Pad Transformer. Both of these tablets have functioning SD card slots, showing that the lack of a working slot is Motorola's fault, not Google's. In addition, these have some neat features that, as I understand it, the iPad does not support, such as USB host mode (allowing use of a USB thumb drive, external HD, keyboard or mouse). Both of these devices also sport prices lower than the Xoom.

I am particularly intrigued by the Asus device, as it has a keyboard accessory that effectively turns the tablet into a netbook. For me, this type of versatility can have real value. Unfortunately, Asus has not done a very good job of supplying enough devices to meet the demand.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by georgemcbay on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:17PM (#2508140)
I've got the ASUS Transformer, I was one of the lucky few who got an order in around midnight of the launch date (bought mine on BestBuy.com). The device is really quite fantastic, far better than the Xoom (which I've used but don't own) and cheaper. The IPS screen is just absolutely gorgeous to look at and really elevates it over the other Honeycomb tablets I've seen.

Unfortunately the keyboard docking station is largely vaporware here in the USA -- reviewers got them but I don't believe a single unit has sold at retail here. It is somewhat puzzling why the docks are even more scarce than the tablets since the dock is a relatively straightforward piece of electronics compared to tablet itself.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by nkassis on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:49PM (#2507782)
I haven't seen them around, I mean I can buy a Playbook at Indigo ( a bookstore in Canada) but good luck finding a Xoom. Plus for the price it's hard to justify I guess for non android nerds like me.

But whatever, the Xoom is one devices, like the HTC Dream, this isn't a big deal in the Android big picture.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by cmsj on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:11PM (#2508118)
"the Android big picture" == "throw enough crap at the wall and some of it will stick" ;)
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by tzs on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:34PM (#2507942)
If Xoom had shipped six months earlier, it could have been a killer product. Sure, the OS would have been beta quality at best, but the hardware was killer compared to iPad 1.

However, compared to iPad 2, it has no significant hardware advantage. Maybe the screen aspect ratio for some people. It has no price advantage. The OS is still beta quality. For all but the small number of people who want a tablet without the restrictions of the Apple Store and who aren't willing to jailbreak an iPad 2, there is simply no reason to buy a Xoom.

Unless Motorola are idiots, they HAD to have predicted that there would be an iPad 2 and that it would be announced about a year after iPad 1. So unless the plan was for the Xoom to come out long before that and the schedule slipped, I don't understand what their plan was.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by zwily on Monday May 02, 2011 @10:30PM (#2508753)
So admitting that the OS is beta quality even now, you really think it would have been a killer product 6 months ago?
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by code_duck on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:36PM (#2508207)
While the Xoom looks pretty neat to me, I've heard of some people having problems with their XOOMs and I'm not surprised. My Moto Droid 2 phone experience has been rather shocking, quality wise. Even when the hardware seems to be working 100%, I could fill a page with all the little-to-medium software glitches I deal with daily.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by moultano on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:50PM (#2508398)
I have one and love it. My only issues with it are that some apps don't manage memory for screen rotations well, so crash when trying to allocate another buffer the size of the screen when you rotate it (Aldiko in particular). Most apps work fantastically though, and the preinstalled ones are all beautiful. Google Books in particular.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by code_duck on Monday May 02, 2011 @10:30PM (#2508757)
I like it, and I wanted to like it, but I've had so many problems. I went through several units that I returned to Verizon. Currently, now that I have what seems to be a fully functional unit, my two main issues are instability of the hotspot (which I've seen zillions of people complain about on Droid Xs, too) and poor/inconsistent camera image quality.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by code_duck on Monday May 02, 2011 @10:30PM (#2508754)
I like it, and I wanted to like it, but I've had so many problems. I went through several units that I returned to Verizon. Right now, my two main issues are instability of the hotspot (which I've seen zillions of people complain about on Droid Xs, too) and poor/inconsistent camera image quality.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by pavlov on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:52PM (#2507798)
Hmm. This article claims 25-125,000 Xoom units sold. Last week Motorola said that they shipped 250,000 units in the first quarter [0].

I'm aware of the difference between "shipped" and "sold", but the figures in the Forbes article should be taken with a grain of salt.

[0] http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2384615,00.asp

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by lotusleaf1987 on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:42PM (#2507973)
They're different verbs with different implications, I think Forbes is being pretty clear. Xoom may have shipped 250,000, but only 125k were actually sold. The other half are sitting on the shelves somewhere, which means inventory is high--a bad sign, which usually leads to price-cuts to clear space.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by razzmataz on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:42PM (#2508378)
There's probably good reason. It was way too expensive, for one thing. I haven't seen any of these tablets hit the sweet spot of pricing that a few surveys revealed a while back.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by npalli on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:53PM (#2507802)
Bogus numbers, the report is based on an analyst who predicted between 25,000 to 120,000 sales. The company reported 250,000 shipped in their earnings. Not an iPad killer for sure but not as dire as reported either. Most importantly, the wi-fi version had been on sale starting only March 27th. The initial sales were predominantly for the overpriced wifi/3G model.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by wriq on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:24PM (#2507902)
Shipped ≠ Sales
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by npalli on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:33PM (#2507938)
Yes, but motorola doesn't own any retail stores unlike Apple. So they don't have visibility into sales until a couple of months. Unless you are looking at a very high return rate, it is a good proxy for sales.
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by shaggyfrog on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:43PM (#2507977)
You forgot the existence of a very high sitting-on-the-shelf rate.

You can ship all the units you want, but unless people are taking them home, the number is definitely not a good proxy for sales.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by NickPollard on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:05PM (#2508086)
Interestingly, when I was in San Francisco I had to look in 3-4 different stores before I found one with Xooms in stock, the others had all sound out apart from the display unit.

I guess SF is a fairly large outlier when it comes to tech products though.

Personally I'm very happy with mine; the browser is definitely rather buggy right now but that's it - apart from that the software is great.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by shaggyfrog on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:29PM (#2508183)
A store can sell out of anything if it only had a half dozen in stock to begin with. This is especially the case if the store doesn't have an agreement with the supplier to return any unsold stock after N days. (This kind of free lunch hedging is probably how most units were shipped, if this 25k units-sold floor is true.)
Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by npalli on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:58PM (#2508056)
Well sure, I mean there is always the possibility that there is channel stuffing. But why take the pessimistic view that all the shipped tablets are on the shelf when you don't have any information. Things to note --

1. at amazon.com, the only site I have been tracking the tablets in actual sales, the Xoom is either #1 or #2 in tablet sales over the past two months. I mean, it is ahead of even the iPad 2 that is supposed to supply constrained. So all the guys who stood in line and brought iPad2's so they could sell for a markup -- finding it difficult to sell even for a $100 premium -- compared to the flop show that is the Xoom. http://www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/electronics/1232597011/... (this keeps changing, so don't hold me to it).

2. the wifi model is flying off the shelf at some of the local retailers. did someone earlier mention out of stock situation in Canada?

3. the wifi was introducted on Mar 26th, a couple of days before their quarter ended

4. more channels and price points are yet to be introduced.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by halostatue on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:29PM (#2508181)
1. More people, I think, are likely to buy an iPad from Apple.com rather than Amazon.com, so the fact that Xoom is higher-rated than iPad there doesn't mean much. IMO.

2. I have yet to see one in Canada, but I'm not really looking. However, it's certainly possible that people are always out of stock because they're only ordering 1 - 3 of them and there's definitely people out there who will buy things because they're not from Apple.

3. Granted.

4. If they're having problems with the channels and price points they have already, they're not likely to do much better outside. Motorola's built on the mobile phone channel. Building up a channel outside of your niche is hard.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by jeffb on Monday May 02, 2011 @08:48PM (#2508542)
>> 1. at amazon.com, the only site I have been tracking the tablets in actual sales, the Xoom is either #1 or #2 in tablet sales over the past two months. I mean, it is ahead of even the iPad 2

Amazon itself doesn't sell the iPad. It is only sold through Amazon via 3rd party merchants for a huge markup. Obviously sales are going to be low on Amazon when the cheapest price is $130 over the price in the Apple Store or other authorized resellers like macconnection.com.

It's amazing that the iPad is on Amazon's best seller list at all, since it doesn't make any financial sense to buy an iPad on Amazon.

Re:Motorola Xoom Looking Like Epic Flop by shaggyfrog on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:30PM (#2508187)
> But why take the pessimistic view that all the shipped tablets are on the shelf when you don't have any information.

Because that is the default, conservative position to take. The null hypothesis, if you will.