News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:29PM (#25073004)
> The only reason we are talking about fraud is because a narcissist said so, because he can’t accept he lost.

Suppose that's true. So what? We analyze the results. We apply science. It can't change the result if it wasn't supposed to.

You give the devil his due. Because then given the result doesn't change, you can't be accused of covering up a fraud when it wasn't actually there. Which is what happens in the alternative.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by lhorie on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:41PM (#25073168)
There are two separate issues at stake though that are getting conflated.

One is of whether fraud happened. So far, the stuff before the courts have mostly been thrown out due to lack of evidence. Which supports the idea of due diligence and that the system works.

The second is whether the system itself is compromised. The problem here is that one can keep irrationally escalating accusations saying that the watchmen of the watchmen of the watchmen are all in cahoots. And we know from stuff like flat earth society that there are people willing to believe anything. The danger here is that if you have a large portion of the population and their political representatives believing that the system is rigged, that they might as well do everything in their power to rig it in their favor, which erodes the pillars of democracy.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by noncoml on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:35PM (#25073073)
> Suppose that's true. So what?

Casting doubts and entertaining the witch hunt is damaging the democracy by eroding the trust of people in the election system. Opening the way for a coup in the future.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:46PM (#25073248)
If someone questions the election results and you respond by checking everything over and doing a manual recount and giving them every opportunity to make their case and it still doesn't go their way, you can claim with confidence that they were full of it. Shutting them down before that happens is how you erode the trust of people in the election system.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by dragonwriter on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:13PM (#25073646)
> If someone questions the election results and you respond by

...demanding sufficient evidence that there is reason to expend resources looking for a problem before taking them seriously, especially if they are the apparently-defeated candidate.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:23PM (#25073772)
> demanding sufficient evidence that there is reason to expend resources looking for a problem before taking them seriously

Isn't that what's happening? They make their claims, others dispute them, it's a public debate. The original post was an objection to "talking about fraud" -- but talking about it is part of the process of evaluating whether the evidence is sufficient. The answer could be no, but you don't know that before you hear them out.

> especially if they are the apparently-defeated candidate.

It would be interesting to know of a case in which the apparently-victorious candidate was making allegations of election fraud sufficient to affect the outcome.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by esoterica on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:57PM (#25073414)
No one has suggested blocking recounts in states where the margin is close enough that one candidate is entitled to a recount. You are attacking a strawman.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by benmmurphy on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:15PM (#25073660)
Even in states without a close margin a risk limited audit should be automatically performed. The good thing is if the margin is big then you only need to recount a small number of votes to prove dodgy counting didn’t change the result.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk-limiting_audit

I think PA and Georgia already do this!

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:03PM (#25073506)
One of their claims was voting machine irregularities where the machine would count votes for one candidate as being for the other. Doing a recount using the same voting machines could thereby preserve the alleged irregularity, which is why I specified a manual recount.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by esoterica on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:09PM (#25073593)
And no one is suggesting blocking a manual recount in the states where a candidate is entitled to one.

> Suppose that's true. So what? We analyze the results. We apply science. It can't change the result if it wasn't supposed to.

You are implying that it is perfectly fine for Trump to spread wild conspiracy theories with no evidence because if those conspiracy theories are false then they will be proven false and no harm will be done. Except irreparable harm WILL be done to the democratic process in America, because there are tens of millions of Americans who worship Trump as an infallible god and will forever believe his claim that the election was stolen from him, even if all the allegations are thoroughly debunked and no evidence turns up demonstrating any kind of fraud.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 12, 2020 @03:07PM (#25074243)
> And no one is suggesting blocking a manual recount in the states where a candidate is entitled to one.

There are plenty of people suggesting that Trump should concede immediately without going through any of those processes.

> You are implying that it is perfectly fine for Trump to spread wild conspiracy theories with no evidence because if those conspiracy theories are false then they will be proven false and no harm will be done.

The problem with Trump is that just about everything he says is a half-truth. It won't be entirely true but it also won't be entirely false.

Some people think he does this on purpose. It causes his opponents to cover him by pointing out the part that's false and his supporters to defend him by talking about the part that's true, but in either case they're both talking about Trump and they're both talking about the issue Trump wants people to talk about. I assume that anyone who can figure out how to get Trump to stop doing this would be awarded a Nobel Prize.

The trouble is that it means you can't just dismiss everything he says as a lie, because it's only half lie. I expect that when this is all over he'll have uncovered some modicum of voting irregularities but probably not enough to flip as many states as he needs to win, if any. But he's entitled to try.

Now if only somebody would win that Nobel Prize.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by jungletime on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:38PM (#25073133)
Isn't that what the Russia gate did. It casted doubts about the election results for 4 years of his presidency. And still no definitive proof after 4 years. I don't understand the double standard now. I hope he pardons Snowden and Manning on the way out, as a final act of revenge on the system.

During the debates Biden pledged to wait for the vote to be certified before declaring victory.

Proof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1miwDWst-IQ

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by dragonwriter on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:53PM (#25073366)
> During the debates Biden pledged to wait for the vote to be certified before declaring victory.

No, he didn't.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by jungletime on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:55PM (#25073403)
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by dragonwriter on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:08PM (#25073575)
When discussing elections, "certified" without qualifications (or, equivalently, "legally certified" or "officially certified") conventionally refers to formal action by the government entity overseeing the election results declaring them legally final (potentially, pending certain appeals), whereas "independently certified" refers to a less formal declaration of the results by a third party other than the candidates and their proxies or government administrators such as election observers or independent media outlets.

Waiting for the election to be "independently certified", which is what Biden was asked about, is a very different thing than waiting for it to be "certified" without qualification.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by westwing on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:34PM (#25073891)
> ...whereas "independently certified" refers to a less formal declaration of the results by a third party other than the candidates and their proxies or government administrators such as election observers or independent media outlets.

Can you provide a reference for that assertion? I tried to find it myself, the best thing I found is this blog post, describing the wording "independently certified" as curious:

https://excessofdemocracy.com/blog/2020/10/what-does-it-mean...

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by jcranmer on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:51PM (#25073335)
That is absolutely not what Russiagate was about. No one, so far as I am aware, was claiming that the election results were improperly counted in 2016 [1]. Instead, Russiagate was about illegal Russian interference in, and potential Republican collaboration with, political advertising that may have swayed people's votes.

[1] In favor of the Republicans, I mean. Some Republicans, primarily Trump, did claim fraud in favor of the Democrats, but were unable to find any evidence for their claims.

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by jungletime on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:02PM (#25073488)
The implication and implied end result was that he was an illegitimate president that won by cheating. Same difference. You are splitting hairs.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by jcranmer on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:09PM (#25073594)
The implication is that he committed a criminal act that he deserved to be impeached for (and indeed he was, although the Senate did not vote to convict), following the normal constitutional procedures. There is no implication that the election result should be annulled and the presidency should go to Clinton instead. Trump is no less an illegitimate president than Nixon, Bush, or Hayes was.
Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by TMWNN on Thursday November 12, 2020 @05:06PM (#25075761)
>No one, so far as I am aware, was claiming that the election results were improperly counted in 2016

The mantra for Trump's opponents and the media in the first year or so of his presidency was that "Russia hacked the election".

Re:Benford's “law” does not detect voting fraud by mcphage on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:38PM (#25073131)
> Suppose that's true. So what? We analyze the results. We apply science. It can't change the result if it wasn't supposed to.

If you're a heterosexual man, imagine asking your spouse for a paternity test on your children. And when that goes over like a lead balloon (which it would), imagine replying "So what? We analyze the results. We apply science. It can't change the result if it wasn't supposed to."

> you can't be accused of covering up a fraud that wasn't actually there. Which is what happens in the alternative.

So you think that Trump has no problem complaining about fraud when he has no evidence, but won't complain about fraud after an investigation shows there was none? Not a chance—he'll just complain that the investigation was a fraud as well.