News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by brandmeyer on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @02:01PM (#25049915)
> The military is a political entity

Veteran here, served during the contentious 2000 election. The US military very strongly prides itself on being an apolitical entity.

There's an important distinction between the electorate having differing opinions about the role and size of the military and the scope of its missions, and the military itself being a political entity.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by isleyaardvark on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @05:49PM (#25053142)
I agree, and think that not wearing that kind of thing at the polls is appropriate to keep it apolitical.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by griffinkelly on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:11PM (#25061728)
With every election cycle, my CO has constantly reminded people that they cannot wear their uniform to political rallies, post on the internet without a disclaimer; the military is not political in any sense.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by ddevault on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @02:06PM (#25050022)
This is not a universally held belief.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by zeveb on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:19PM (#25052072)
The earth being round is not universally held, either, but it is true. The military is patriotic, yes, as are its members (it is difficult to imagine how they could be effective were they not), but the military tries very, very hard to be apolitical. Yes, individuals in the military have strong political opinions, just like many other individual Americans.

It seems to me that any country at a point where the combination of its flag together with an oath of office, oath of enlistment or commissioning oath is seen as political rather than patriotic cannot be in a good place. It is not too far from that to one where calling for fair and unbiased administration of elections is considered political rather than patriotic.

Thank you for assisting in the election, and thank you for your excellent software projects, but in this case I think that you were incorrect.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by pjc50 on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @06:14PM (#25053385)
> political rather than patriotic

Unfortunately patriotism itself is highly political; the ultimate question of "my country, right or wrong" results in some people noticing that it is in fact wrong in some cases.

Do they not teach Clausewitz in the US military? "War is the continuation of politics by other means". Every shot fired in anger is a political act. Not the politics of the person firing it, but those directing the fire.

It is possible to try to be non-partisan, but an apolitical military is an oxymoron.

The US military is the guarantor of a host of political lines across the world; supporting South Korea or Taiwan or Israel or Germany or Bosnia is a political act.

You can't sign up and then disclaim responsibility for the political results of following orders "apolitically". The last people who tried that got shot at Nuremberg.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by brandmeyer on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @07:04PM (#25053852)
> Not the politics of the person firing it, but those directing the fire.

... you're almost there... and yet ...

> It is possible to try to be non-partisan, but an apolitical military is an oxymoron. > > The US military is the guarantor of a host of political lines across the world; supporting South Korea or Taiwan or Israel or Germany or Bosnia is a political act.

At the direction of the duly elected civilian leadership.

> You can't sign up and then disclaim responsibility for the political results of following orders "apolitically". The last people who tried that got shot at Nuremberg.

This isn't considered a matter of politics. Its a matter of honor and lawfulness.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by morelisp on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:55AM (#25057607)
Who is elected as citizen leadership is a matter of politics. What is lawful is a matter of politics.

Americans need to stop confusing "non-partisan" (or worse "partisan but not along R/D lines") for "apolitical".

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by morelisp on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:50PM (#25052468)
In many countries other than the US it is uncommon for private citizens in daily life to fly or display flags at all, let alone with some nationalist or political slogan adorning it, except when associated with right-wing activism.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by giantg2 on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:17PM (#25052055)
Perhaps those with a contrary belief should review the UMJC, which restricts political statements/actions for military members, even off duty.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by toyg on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @06:09PM (#25053330)
Sadly those lines are increasingly blurry. Isn’t there an issue right now with the new Secretary of Defence, for example, who technically has not been out of Green Berets long enough to be appointed...?
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by giantg2 on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @06:32PM (#25053552)
With any laws, some of the lines can be blurry. I'm not familiar with that specific situation. I just mention this because there are laws restricting military personnel pretty heavily from many political things, even just criticizing the president. The institution itself is absolutely forbidden from being involved in politics to prevent coups.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by jki275 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:47AM (#25058795)
You're talking about the Hatch Act I presume. The UCMJ doesn't get into that that I'm aware of.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @02:38PM (#25050657)
The electorate isn't able to express meaningful opinions on the role and size of the military, thus support of the institution itself has become political.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by brandmeyer on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:02PM (#25051044)
The vote and free speech remain powerful tools for meaningful expression. And they do have an impact. Even if it seems like you're being ignored, each voice really does matter, and policy does change in response.

But that policy flows from the civilian political realm. Military leadership doesn't decide which missions to take on. Congress and the President do. The military won't decide the fate of this election, no matter how contentious it gets. The civilian bodies will.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:20PM (#25051314)
Voting between candidates that all support ongoing military actions is not meaningful. It's similar to the treasonous NSA - discussing it is simply outside of the mainstream Overton window, primary candidates who dare touch it are branded "unelectable" etc.

Speech gets swamped by mass propaganda. I don't see how it's possible to look at say the run up to the Iraq war and think that antiwar had a meaningful voice. When it comes down to it, the warmongers are just better funded, better connected, and take advantage of basic human nature.

Since it seems impossible to prevent the military from being used for elective wars, or even to simply downsize it, discouraging general support for the military makes sense (when voice fails, try exit). I'm not asking you to agree with my arguments above, but you don't get to make a unilateral call that this isn't a political viewpoint.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by rayiner on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:46PM (#25051680)
If there was any political support for changing the approach to the NSA one of the candidates would back it.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:20PM (#25052099)
That's tautological. If one of the candidates backed it, there would be more political support for holding the NSA accountable.

Democracy is a closed feedback loop, and thus causality works in both directions. Given the very few bits of input a person has into decisions, it's likely that most influence flows the opposite direction.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by knaq on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:50PM (#25052466)
It is "impossible to prevent the military from being used for elective wars" because most people disagree with that goal. (according to observed preference, not stated preference) We just tossed out the only president in many decades to refrain from starting a new war, instead choosing one who voted for the Iraq war. The people have spoken, and they want war.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @04:57PM (#25052552)
I find the narrative that Trump hasn't started a new war interesting, but not particularly compelling given his actions with Iran and ongoing incitement of civil unrest.

> The people have spoken, and they want war

I see where you're coming from, as usually I vote third party or abstain to avoid thinking I support one candidate that differs only by an epsilon of cultural preferences. But when one of the choices is responsible for the deaths of a quarter million Americans, it's a little different.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by panzagl on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @05:49PM (#25053146)
So you're saying no one would have died from CoVid-19 if Trump weren't in office? Citation needed.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by newacct583 on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @07:53PM (#25054282)
It seems likely that if the national response to covid had tracked with, say, the NY State response, that yes: we'd have seen far fewer deaths. The first 60-100k, mostly in the northeast, probably couldn't have been saved. The initial outbreak happened too fast and too hard. But after that, NY has been flat. They controlled it. The same could have been true for the rest of the country, yet we collectively chose not to.

And yeah, that national response is the job of the executive branch. So very roughly 150k americans are dead now because Trump was in office. Somewhere around there.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by BrandonMarc on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @09:53PM (#25055034)
The NY state response included sending sick patients into nursing homes. Had other states done that uniformly we'd have even more deaths, not fewer.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by newacct583 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:48AM (#25059307)
That happened in March and April, and obviously it was a mistake. But they controlled it, is the point. Their response after the initial wave has been excellent.

But it's a silly digression anyway. If you don't think NY is a good example, then pick Oregon. Or Canada. Or Germany. The point is that lots of large-scale responses of the form a "typical" democratic administration would have taken have very clearly been effective. While the US response, nationally, has not.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by knaq on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:30PM (#25061205)
Ordering people to wear masks and shut down businesses is like ordering people to exercise, avoid alcohol, eat vegetables, avoid tobacco, and wear sunscreen. It might be fine as friendly advice, but it becomes dictatorial when the leader requires it. I find the demand for less freedom to be deeply disturbing. If it wasn't so scary it would be funny, because people accuse the president of acting like a dictator and then complain when he isn't enough of a dictator.
Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:18PM (#25061803)
> I find the demand for less freedom to be deeply disturbing. If it wasn't so scary it would be funny, because people accuse the president of acting like a dictator and then complain when he isn't enough of a dictator.

You seem to be considering "freedom" as equivalent to irresponsibility. Being a leader means convincing people to do work they don't want to do, like wearing masks during a pandemic. We don't even need to debate whether the federal government should have implemented a national mask mandate. Simply having a president that recommended wearing masks instead of encouraging indignant irresponsibility would have saved tens of thousands of American lives, no laws required.

Trump gets called a dictator because he unilaterally picks nonsensical ideas and then barks them at everyone to get done, while accepting no feedback about how things are actually working out. This is the behavior of a dictator, regardless of how much power he actually wields or how effective he is. The latest example is his hissy fit over losing the election - there's no basis in reality, yet he's continuing to push it anyway. Seeing someone acting like the law does not matter sets off the fascist alarm bells.

Re:My experience as a poll worker in Pennsylvania by mindslight on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @05:56PM (#25053205)
No, but fewer people would have. By contributing to it he's responsible for the entire outcome. It's similar to how two people can both be charged for one instance of murder.