News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clean Up Your Mess - A Guide to Visual Design for Everybody by nonrecursive on Sunday May 01, 2011 @08:35AM (#2502958)
All very true! I am taking a break from this site for the time being, but when I revisit it, I plan on:

* Creating new before & after examples from scratch, hopefully with fewer flaws

* Adding a section on going through the process of redesigning something

* Adding more resources

But no, I'm probably not ever going to do the science, unless somehow I get paid for the time I spend doing so.

Re:Clean Up Your Mess - A Guide to Visual Design for Everybody by ZoFreX on Sunday May 01, 2011 @11:08AM (#2503133)
I would heavily recommend "doing the science". It's a lot of fun, and it has one of two outcomes: You confirm what you think is true, in which case your argument has a LOT more weight (as so few people will "do science"), or you disprove your idea, which means you get to find a way to make your design even better. Win-win!

It really is a lot of fun, too. We had a university assignment to investigate a particular public-facing system, and while most of my peers turned to Google I hit the streets with a clipboard. I had a really great afternoon, learnt a huge amount about the system, and discovered data that no one else did.

Re:Clean Up Your Mess - A Guide to Visual Design for Everybody by nonrecursive on Sunday May 01, 2011 @02:54PM (#2503711)
You make it sound very fun :) I've done some usability testing, and I've really enjoyed it in the past. But really, I'm not sure how I would realistically test a flyer.

Actually... it could be quite fun to create a couple flyers with links listed, post them around town, and see how many hits I get. I don't think it would be a true a/b test, though, as it wouldn't be possible to alternate different flyers at the exact same location.

Re:Clean Up Your Mess - A Guide to Visual Design for Everybody by gallamine on Sunday May 01, 2011 @04:10PM (#2503940)
You could use a tool like fivesecondtest.com. Not affiliated, btw.
Re:Clean Up Your Mess - A Guide to Visual Design for Everybody by andrewcooke on Sunday May 01, 2011 @08:41AM (#2502966)
you could look at a/b testing. it might be interesting to learn how to set that up... (not sure how you'd use it to measure this particular case though)