News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by adamnemecek on Saturday November 07, 2020 @01:03AM (#25013443)
There's are reasons these technologies never took off.
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by travisgriggs on Saturday November 07, 2020 @02:40AM (#25013689)
Try adding something to the discussion. I'm not sure what you mean by "these technologies". I'm also not sure what you mean by "took off." The fact that we still talk about Smalltalk and Lisp despite their apparent lack of ascendency, and yet don't recall other languages from those eras must at least say that certain aspects of them "took hold" to the extent we still talk about them. Does explaining why they didn't "take off" add an interesting insight or corollary about whatever happened?
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by adamnemecek on Saturday November 07, 2020 @11:29AM (#25015992)
Right but what software that you use is written in smalltalk?
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by Rochus on Sunday November 08, 2020 @06:33AM (#25025043)
A great one which I used in the nineties was the Objectory software engineering tool by Ivar Jacobson and his team (later bought by Rational which unfortunately discontinued the tool in favour of Rose).
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by ojnabieoot on Saturday November 07, 2020 @09:35AM (#25015275)
That seems like a weirdly reductionist view of “taking off.” Smalltalk had always been a primarily academic language whose footprint on programming languages in general vastly exceeds its specific user base. Ruby, Python, Java, C#, etc, all owe a great deal to Smalltalk. In that sense it’s like SML and Scheme: you could fairly say “more studied than used” but that hardly makes it irrelevant.
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by Rochus on Saturday November 07, 2020 @10:37AM (#25015648)
> Smalltalk had always been a primarily academic language

There was quite a hype in the nineties with many enterprise applications based on Smalltalk; my first contact with Smalltalk was in a commercial, not an academic setting; most of it blew away when cheap, fast (HotSpot) Java became available.

> Ruby, Python, Java, C#, etc, all owe a great deal to Smalltalk.

That's a bit too optimistic. E.g. Python is not a descentent of Smalltalk (see e.g. http://python-history.blogspot.com/2013/10/), neither is Java (see e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ccRtIdlTqlU&feature=youtu.be...). C# is also rather a brain child of Java and C++ than of Smalltalk.

Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by pjmlp on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:16AM (#25013785)
They were taking off before the free beer UNIX generation took over everything, and made such enviroments a thing only enterprises care to pay for.
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by mhd on Saturday November 07, 2020 @08:31AM (#25014958)
What products in what time are we talking about here? Smalltalk environments often were priced where only enterprises could pay for them. What advanced product tried to compete on the hobbyist front, i.e. comparable to Turbo Pascal/Delphi on the pricing range?

And around here, enterprise SmallTalk is about the same size as enterprise Perl. Java, which is definitely an enterprise creation, was and is the big killer here. Both on the consuming side and the producing one.

Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by Rochus on Saturday November 07, 2020 @11:03AM (#25015805)
> Smalltalk environments often were priced where only enterprises could pay for them

There were also packages available for less than 100$. There were even free ST compilers.

Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by mhd on Saturday November 07, 2020 @11:38AM (#25016071)
Sure, but where those the advanced environments that were cancelled by people hopping on the Linux/C/etc bandwagon? I don't think that the argument goes with more funding Little Smalltalk would've been our software savior.

There sure was a lot of abandoned programming environments, but it was usually the enterprised that fathered them that killed it. NeWs was more interesting than pretty much all of its successors. And I'm sure the Lisp Machine or Oberon grognards are willing to chime in, too.

Everything being boring AF, both on the hardware and software side, certainly enabled Linux to succeed. It's a lot easier to compete if the state of the art is libc and X11.

Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by goatinaboat on Saturday November 07, 2020 @04:28PM (#25019610)
There's are reasons these technologies never took off.

Well, there is some history here. In the early to mid 90s IBM was all-in on Smalltalk, they had a product called VisualAge, they were all set to push it as the next enterprise language, replacing RAD tools like Delphi etc etc. Then Java happened and immediately developed a huge mindshare and IBM pivoted the VM and tooling they had developed for Smalltalk into Java and rode that wave.

But if Java had been a flash-in-the-pan, then Smalltalk would be today where Java is now in terms of adoption (and decades ahead of Java in terms of technology).

Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by genericone on Saturday November 07, 2020 @02:56AM (#25013730)
A commercial smalltalk implementation is used widely in Lam Research for semiconductor machine tools.
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by dunefox on Saturday November 07, 2020 @07:42AM (#25014746)
That's hardly "widely used".
Re:The Early History of Smalltalk (1993) by layoutIfNeeded on Saturday November 07, 2020 @05:39AM (#25014310)
Please elaborate.