News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by kiba on Saturday April 30, 2011 @02:30PM (#2501198)
As a bitcoin veteran, I expect carnage, always. I learn that the hard way several months ago.

Moreover, I tend to be fatalistic about the price of bitcoin. Whether or not the market is manipulated, as long goods and services are popping up in the bitcoin economy, we'll be alright in the long run.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by joe_the_user on Saturday April 30, 2011 @02:56PM (#2501260)
But isn't bitcoin supposed to not just work but actually be somehow better than ordinary currency?

Wouldn't that include being more stable? Or am I missing something?

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by gwern on Saturday April 30, 2011 @04:20PM (#2501481)
Exchange rates are set by supply, and demand. Bitcoin has through technical means controlled the supply part of the equation, but how can it control demand? So fluctuations in demand will cause changes. In the growth period, Bitcoin can't be stable, and it would be impossible for any currency to do so without extremely precise statistics on how a currency was being used and control over inflation (so you could, say, adjust supply exactly to match fluctuations in demand).

In the long run, most of the obvious equilibriums for Bitcoin are very far away from whatever it's currently trading at. If Bitcoin fails and becomes playmoney, then it's overpriced by hundreds of times; if it succeeds and replaces any sovereign country's currency, then it's undervalued by hundreds or thousands or millions of times. So in the long run, you must expect it to not be 'stable', but to change drastically - in some direction.

(If this isn't convincing, try applying the double reversal test Nick Bostrom devised for combating the status quo bias (http://www.nickbostrom.com/ethics/statusquo.pdf) and anchoring (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring). Suppose that Bitcoin were at $2 rather than $4. Would you be saying 'obviously the right price for Bitcoin is $4, so I should buy some'? I doubt it. )

When Bitcoin is supposed to be stable is when demand for it is not varying; supply will be stable by the Bitcoin architecture, and hence, the overall equation wouldn't change in that situation. This differs from fiat currency in that you are only vulnerable to changes in the demand part of the equation - there is no Fed or other cabal that can hurt you by manipulating the supply part of the equation.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by rorrr on Saturday April 30, 2011 @04:46PM (#2501530)
Imagine Amazon starts accepting bitcoins. The rate will probably skyrocket to more than 100 USD.

Actually, digital currency is inevitable, it's only a matter of time till there's some global currency not controlled by one government. Bitcoin is a pretty good candidate.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by lukev on Saturday April 30, 2011 @06:26PM (#2501738)
That depends entirely on the rate at which Amazon accepts bitcoins.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by xnerdr on Saturday April 30, 2011 @02:38PM (#2501211)
As a bitcoin veteren, what, if any, do you expect will be the US reaction once it becomes big enough to cause problems?
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by cookiecaper on Sunday May 01, 2011 @12:38AM (#2502365)
I expect that they will do everything possible to marginalize or damage it.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by 27182818284 on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:42PM (#2501388)
So far the US reaction has been positive. The CIA is paying BitCoin members to give talks about it. As someone pointed out in a Bitcoin forum, unlike Liberty Dollars or E-Gold, Bitcoin could prove to be a useful way of securely and anonymously paying people off
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by JeremyBanks on Saturday April 30, 2011 @04:22PM (#2501487)
> The CIA is paying BitCoin members to give talks about it.

A BitCoin developer to give a talk about it to them.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by borism on Saturday April 30, 2011 @05:10PM (#2501579)
I wouldn't make much out of CIA doing something. They have done crazier shit before.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by ceejayoz on Sunday May 01, 2011 @12:36PM (#2503306)
> So far the US reaction has been positive. The CIA is paying BitCoin members to give talks about it.

By that definition, the US reaction to IEDs in Iraq has been positive, as people with bomb making experience are brought in to give talks about them.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by iwwr on Saturday April 30, 2011 @02:57PM (#2501262)
What sort of problems?
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by tba on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:36PM (#2501369)
Potential issues with anonymous currency include money laundering and assassination markets.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by gwern on Saturday April 30, 2011 @04:25PM (#2501493)
Link for those not familiar: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market

Personally, I think assassination markets could be a net benefit (think of the bounties on someone like Kim Jong-Il), but then, I like them enough that I write stories about them so I'm biased: http://www.gwern.net/fiction/The%20Ones%20Who%20Walk%20Towar...

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by tba on Saturday April 30, 2011 @07:17PM (#2501844)
"think of the bounties on someone like Kim Jong-Il"

Did you ever think of the bounties on anyone inconvenient to governments or big businesses? The founders of The Pirate Bay, Julian Assange and Bradley Manning, BP whistleblowers, environmental activists and climate scientists – would society be better off with them all dead?

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by gwern on Saturday April 30, 2011 @08:34PM (#2501971)
One Kim Jong-Il is worth all of Pirate Bay combined, and heck, throw in Assange & Manning as well (they've informed the public, helped out the historians a lot, and caused some irritation, but I see few concrete changes to stack up against hundreds of thousands of dead).

So, yes, I did think of the inconvenient people.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by borism on Saturday April 30, 2011 @05:16PM (#2501591)
think of the bounties on someone like Kim Jong-Il

Now think of the bounties on average folks like you and me in comparison.

That's right, our lives will instantly be worth pennies and there'll instantly many folks around with incentive to murder.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by Unseelie on Saturday April 30, 2011 @05:54PM (#2501660)
Pennies is a bit extreme. The risk in the enterprise is pretty high, expert assassins rare, and amatures likely to get caught.

While an expert assassin may take a job on a random Joe for on the order of a hundred dollars, an amateur with any sense will not, and therefor the price will be rather high.

And, even if assassinations of pedestrians becomes realistically common..On the order of car crash mortalities, its at least a cause of death that may make people consider how they act toward one another.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by 5l on Saturday April 30, 2011 @07:00PM (#2501814)
Right, because only bad people get assassinated.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by lsc on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:06PM (#2501290)
well, I'm not a bitcoin veteran, but I lost a few bucks to the e-gold thing; what's to keep bitcoin from suffering the same fate?
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by sgornick on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:39PM (#2501380)
e-gold was a centralized system. When they got shut down, you no longer had the ability to receive value for your holdings.

Bitcoin is decentralized. The ability to spend is protected by the private crypto keys in your wallet stored locally (assuming you store your bitcoins on your own computer.)

As long as there is a network of nodes out there ( current view: http://maps.google.com/maps?q=https://smsz.net/btcStats/bitc... ) and your software can reach one or more of them means: 1.) you still have the ability to spend your bitcoins at any time 2.) the recipient has the ability to know that those coins were not spent previously

Shutting down e-gold involved taking down the center. Bitcoin has no center, no "master node" -- only peers.

The most central aspect of bitcoin is found in the exchanges. Those worried about an e-gold situation happening again do not have amounts of any significance (either USD or bitcoins) held by an exchange.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by JulianMorrison on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:20PM (#2501330)
There's nobody with an off-switch.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by lsc on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:30PM (#2501354)
yeah; this is what scares me more about bitcoin than e-gold.

With E-gold, the government went after the owners, and they were able to shut the whole operation down; I lost maybe two hundred bucks worth of gold.

Now, when the government decides to shut down bitcoin, what happens? there is no central 'off switch' - just like drugs, they will have to go after the users, or like illegal information, they will have to go after the viewers.

I mean, I think I'm being a little bit paranoid here, but I just don't see the government leaving a system that works so well for money laundering in place, and all the things I can think of the government doing to dismantle bitcoin seem like they would be quite unpleasant for the users, over and above just losing the money invested.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by JulianMorrison on Saturday April 30, 2011 @03:49PM (#2501411)
Interesting argument.

Trying to go against users is hard, the government is not as dumb as the music industry, to play whack-a-mole versus grandmothers and kids. My guess is they would attack exchanges trading BTC <-> USD. There are fewer, and separating the BTC economy from the USD one would make the currency significantly less attractive. Even the threat to do so would crash its USD price.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by lsc on Saturday April 30, 2011 @06:28PM (#2501742)
I hope you are right.

>the government is not as dumb as the music industry, to play whack-a-mole versus grandmothers and kids.

I think the war on drugs would be a counterexample to this statement. Especially considering that legitimate bitcoin use is largely confined to nerds, I don't think the government would have a hard time painting bitcoin users as people who ought to be punished.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by jerf on Saturday April 30, 2011 @09:27PM (#2502053)
When the government wages its war on drugs, it cuts supply of drugs, which raises the price, which raises the incentives to smuggle drugs. Meanwhile, there is a certain contingent of people who will basically do anything for drugs. If the government could push the price of drugs for them above "all economic value a person can possible generate in any manner including through illegal means", they would win, but they just can't do that effectively.

When the government goes after a BitCoin exchange, they make BitCoins less valuable by raising the transaction costs associated with them, and severing the BitCoin economy from the general global economy. This will cause BitCoins to reduce in value against the currencies traded in the general global economy. This will cause people to be less inclined to use them because they will be less valuable. In this case, where the economic characteristics of drug trade fights against the government's goals, the economic characteristics of alternate currencies give the government a multiplicative advantage in its efforts to shut it down.

It is not a defense of BitCoin that the government can't shut down drug trade. It's a different problem. Indeed, the question BitCoin faces is even if the government never takes exception to it, will the multiplicative advantage that any attempt to shut down or game BitCoins will obtain be insufficient to kill it or gravely wound it? I don't think the government will have a need to demonize BitCoin users, they will be perfectly capable of shutting it down without that effort.

Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by narrator on Sunday May 01, 2011 @05:47AM (#2502763)
One thing about bitcoin... since there's no central server, the bitcoin economy can live all over the world and there's no single door for the feds to bust down. A war against it would look like the music companies trying to shutdown pirates in developing countries. A decade long crusade of state department aggressive diplomacy to get a global 3 strikes copyright policy enforced.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by lsc on Saturday April 30, 2011 @10:13PM (#2502126)
that's a pretty convincing argument.
Re:Bitcoin hits US$ 4, after being mentioned on CNN yesterday by waterlesscloud on Saturday April 30, 2011 @08:44PM (#2501986)
The whole online poker kerfuffle is not an unrelated idea here.

The idea is that online poker chips were being used for money laundering, and the first point of control attempted was the exchange of chips for USD via banks.