Well-intended ideas, not fully thought out, leading to unintended consequences... nothing really new for SF.
San Francisco is overheated and a majority of residents would expect to benefit from CEOs or tech companies reducing their pressure on housing and services.
> The tax will levy an extra 0.1% to 0.6% on gross receipts made in San Francisco for companies whose highest paid executive makes 100 times or more its median worker’s salary. The amount levied will increase in 0.1% brackets proportionally to the pay ratio. A company whose highest paid employee earns 200 times more than its median San Francisco worker will get a extra 0.2% charge on its gross receipts. For companies whose CEO makes 300 more, the charge jumps to 0.3% and son on. The tax caps at 0.6%, and only companies with gross receipts over $1.17 million will be targeted.
So, for now, it's probably a non-issue... and they have time to adjust.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.414(c)-4
https://healthcareexchange.com/article/common-ownership-what...
Doesn't help at all to move high-paying managers out of SF the way this is structured.
Moving low-payed workers out of SF while keeping high-paid workers in SF, OTOH.
It has been 5 years since France tried and failed to put 75% taxes on the "super rich" and they ended up with less tax revenue than previous years. Those who don't learn History are bound to repeat it...
The median was presumably chosen because it's relatively harder to shift in this way. Although this depends on the exact pay distribution of your company, you'd expect getting rid of people from the bottom to change the median person but not typically change the median value.
(This is also a mature enough problem that I'd expect other provision in the law to prevent this - are we sure it doesn't include outsourced workforce pay?)
1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 6 60
median moves: 2 to 2 (+0%)
mean moves: 8 to 11 (+72%)
(You can make your own example.)
Usually, you expect the median to be pretty stable when you remove (or add) outliers. That's often the reason it's used in formal statistics.
e.g. let's say my employees' wages are:
[1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 10, 10, 10, 10]
Now let's say I could replace each employee with a contractor by paying 0.5 more than the salary of an FTE.
In the above example, let's say I want to raise the median salary of my employees to 10. I could do that by either:
* Paying one of my employees 9 more (boosting them from 1 to 10), at a total cost of 9
* Replacing all my 1-salaried workers with 1.5-salaried contractors, at a total cost of 2.5 (five workers, each getting a 0.5 bump)
It's clear that I'd never want to do this if contract workers and full-time workers were just as favorable for me (since I'd be paying more to get the same work done). If all of a sudden the company were incentivized to raise their median employee's salary, though, all sorts of non-common-sense solutions can come out of the woodwork, and replacing FTEs with contractors (even at a cost) could be the incentivized solution.
1) Companies may now have a direct incentive to have their lowest income earners be outsourced/contracted out to boost the median pay amount.
2) It was smart of them to include compensation such as stock options. However if a city starts to expect this income, it will all go away in recessions when CEO's stock options are not valuable. ie more money to the city in boom periods and not much in bust cycles.