News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:14PM (#24981591)
I'm always surprised this isn't discussed more.

Big tech is accused of being monopolistic, but there is a constant flow of new players in the field, all gaining market shares and building the Next Big Thing, while telecom providers are pretty stagnant.

I'm curious why cities don't directly lay down the infrastructure work for broadband access. In some cases that might raise property value enough that the town could make it's money back in very little time.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by pottertheotter on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:31PM (#24986125)
There are a lot of municipalities doing exactly what you say and making the money back fast. But a lot of states have blocked doing this, and the incumbents fight like crazy to turn people against the idea. My favorite way of implementing it is open access. The city installs and owns the infrastructure and anyone can come be an ISP on it. You get great competition. It's basically the same as how it works with the community owning the roads and you pick who you want to service your house (FedEx, UPS, yourself, DoorDash, the local roofing guy, etc.)

The other thing that would be worthwhile is local loop unbundling, which is basically open access but with existing providers having to open their infrastructure.

I highly recommend muninetworks.org and their podcast if you want to learn more about municipal broadband.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by treis on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @10:13PM (#24986252)
>There are a lot of municipalities doing exactly what you say and making the money back fast

Can you give us an example?

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by zepearl on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:27PM (#24985194)
> I'm curious why cities don't directly lay down the infrastructure work for broadband access.

Wondering the same thing here (Switzerland), but I might not understand the context: decoupling the "cable" from the "provider" is not common in the US, or there are some other complexities that I don't understand?

In my case the company "Swisscom" opened half of the sidewalk, connected my apartment building to their FTTH infrastructure, then sent me a ton of flyers etc.. to advertise their Internet, but I still decided to use a tiny provider located 100km away (being small, high customer focus etc...) => works since 7 months perfectly, latency is good (e.g. 2-8ms to ping 8.8.8.8), etc... .

My parents had basically nothing (half-broken copper wire), then on a random day the city's electricity&water&gas company team suddenly turned up, installed the FTTH cable (old house => turned out to be super-complicated to push that tiny cable through the house's structure => took them 4hrs), then they left, that's it => me and my parents then had multiple discussions about providers and they finally chose "Sunrise" (one of the major ones in Switzerland) and everything so far has been perfect.

As far as I understand how things work here, the company that provides the cable earns money paid by the providers that use that cable, which in turn earn money paid by their customers => everybody earns money, everybody is happy.

For very small communities (e.g. the one where my parents live - ~800 inhabitants), the town/village might have to directly finance a part of the costs needed to lay down the cables (which in turn are covered by common taxes), but that in turn makes the small community more desirable by whoever takes it into consideration when moving.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by nine_k on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @01:07AM (#24986709)
Many municipalities expressly made contracts with cable TV networks to wire their towns / neighborhoods in exchange for a monopoly in cable access. Else the cable company did not have enough incentive (or pretended to) to lay the cable at all.

So the cable company owned the only copper capable of broadband internet, and also the underground channels to lay fiber in. They naturally upgraded their hub spots to allow Internet traffic, and laying the last mile all over again is prohibitively expensive, or even administratively prohibited, in a lot of places.

There is, of course, phone infrastructure! But Bell was a textbook monopoly, and pieces if it retained the infrastructure after its split. So in some places they can profitably reuse the copper they have to also provide Internet service, and sometimes you can even get fiber from them in newer houses which were wired with fiber backbone for the phone service anyway. In some areas the fixed-line copper is not good enough, and running fiber is too expensive because of low housing density.

In large proper cities, of course, the situation is much better, because infrastructure cost per reached customer is much lower.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by toast0 on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @02:20AM (#24987007)
> I might not understand the context: decoupling the "cable" from the "provider" is not common in the US, or there are some other complexities that I don't understand?

So the US context in a nutshell; in most places, the provider of the cable is the provider of the service.

In a bit more detail. Up until 1982, almost all telephone service was provided by AT&T (also known as the Bell System or just "The Phone Company"); at that point, it was split up through anti-trust into regional local phone companies (the baby Bells, ex Pacific Bell in California, Bell South in the south), and a long distance phone company (AT&T), and it became possible to choose a long distance carrier, if you wanted to make long distance calls. The local phone companies were not permitted to provide this service, although AT&T may have been allowed to be a default choice. This unleashed real competition in long distance service, it was now fairly easy to switch, and as easy to dial, and there were several companies ready to go, because they had been offering less usable services already (dial a local number, get a second dial tone and dial the actual destination, etc); prices dropped, quality improved, etc, etc.

In 1996, we got a Telecommunications Act which among other things, required the incumbent local telephone services to lease access to their lines at cost based rates. Under these terms, if there was sufficient space in the central office, a competitive local carrier could install equipment and provide local (and long distance) calling and DSL.

However, the regulator (FCC) said this only applied to telephone service and not to "new" services like phone and internet via cable TV lines.

Additionally, DSL length restrictions meant many customers weren't close enough to the Central Offices to get good service, and phone companies began building out remote terminals to house the equipment closer to the customers. But there's no space in a remote terminal for competitive carrier equipment, so that wasn't necessarily required to be available either.

Finally, courts ruled that it wasn't fair to impose leased access requirements on telephone companies but not cable companies, and the regulator declared the market competitive because consumers could chose from their telephone company, their cable company, internet over power lines (which I don't think every actually happened!), or wireless, so line sharing wasn't important.

An additional wrinkle is that although the leased access prices were regulated, and supposed to be based on cost, incumbent carriers would regularly price retail accounts below the leased access prices, making competition unfair.

There are a few open access networks that were explicitly built out for this, but it's pretty rare, or it comes with big caveats: I can get on my municipal fiber network where I live, but I'd have to pay all the construction costs to get the network extended; if I organize a group, we can split the costs, but interest is low, I'd rather be able to do it, but get partially reimbursed if someone else connects up on the line I extended (within a reasonable time).

TL;DR: we almost had it, but it was a bit broken, and then it was taken away.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by zepearl on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @02:01PM (#24991938)
Hehe, thank you for the detailed explanation!! Interesting!
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by jancsika on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:07PM (#24982205)
> I'm curious why cities don't directly lay down the infrastructure work for broadband access.

In a lot of states there is legislation banning them from doing just that.

Plus-- where are all the videos demoing what it's like having a fiber connection, to rouse all the people who live in internet deserts? For fuck's sake, the article references kids lurking around Taco Bell "scrounging for internet."

If you are a technologist with a fiber connection, please take five minutes away from overclocking your company's attention-sucking machine to see what it's like working toward a goal that is 100% non-creepy.

Edit: clarification

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by inetknght on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:21PM (#24984138)
I found this comment deep in an unrelated thread [0] a couple months ago. It describes someone who created his own ISP for his neighborhood using fiber and links to a good video [1] about it. It's worth using youtube-dl to archive it.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24410506

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASXJgvy3mEg

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by walterbell on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @03:50PM (#24983830)
Here's a success story with photos of a customer running conduit and fiber to enable Comcast service.

https://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1403795

Is there a good place to look for similar success stories on customer-initiated extensions at the edge of rural broadband networks?

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by ineedasername on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:23PM (#24981682)
There may be a constant flow of new players, but much of the time when they start to show a certain amount of success then one of the big players simply buys them up.
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:00PM (#24982129)
Correct except,

Microsoft should have won search. They had all the tools to execute and were pretty much at the right place at the right time.

Google should have won social networking and messaging. They had the userbase and the network. Yet it's Facebook that did.

Same goes for Phones, and yet it's Apple that captured the market.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by vagrantJin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:55PM (#24984995)
> Same goes for Phones, and yet it's Apple that captured the market.

Samsung and Huawei captured the market Apple created.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by Armisael16 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:10PM (#24985093)
Samsung and Huawei each ship about 50% more phones than Apple. Apple makes more than 3x the profit on phones that either does.
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by adventured on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @08:02PM (#24985772)
Ask Samsung how they're doing in the world's largest smartphone market - China (they barely exist at all now, ~1% market share).
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by TuringNYC on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:44PM (#24983218)
You phrase it as if these are hostile takeovers. Having been a founder, I can state that most of my peers wanted acquisitions. It was a way to finance the vision and growth.

Would YouTube, Instagram, or dozens of other companies have been able to get where they are w/o the support of their acquirers? Just think of the burn alone and the required investment is a scary figure.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:12PM (#24984612)
The situation isn't comparable to social media unicorns courting acquisition at all.

Comcast and the other big incumbents have one very clear overt objective: own the customer base for the foreseeable future. If you're a small independent ISP and try to go up against them, as soon as you're on their radar you can expect a pretty ruthless attack. The most mild form of this is Comcast's sales team is willing to offer something closer to fair pricing to condo properties if it involves ~5 years lockin vs a new competitor. A friend owns a business in this space and has watched a couple competitors that were growing fast locally suddenly find their entire customer base gone within weeks via this. Less fortunate people find themselves facing a legal challenge at the city or state level.

And that's not even getting into what happens if your small ISP competitor gets going well enough to start talking to the city about renting space on utility poles or doing some trenching.

These mega ISPs aren't interested in acquiring competition for the last mile. They want to pre-empt competition existing entirely, and they can and will use every single tool available to them in doing so.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by disown on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:44PM (#24984899)
> Would YouTube, Instagram, or dozens of other companies have been able to get where they are w/o the support of their acquirers?

Yes if they got access to capital, which they could have gotten easily. You forget that Google bought Youtube because google video wasn't gaining traction and youtube had the "network effect". The same goes for instagram and facebook. It's all "whatif" but youtube and instagram most definitely would have been major independent players by themselves.

Facebook, Netflix, Google, Amazon, etc were able to grow without being acquired. Remember that page/brin even tried to sell Google to Yahoo. Google did alright even though they weren't bought out.

Youtube and Instagram had no real peers like google did ( altavista, excite, etc ) and they both were able to create the network effect before they got bought out. I think google and facebook really got lucky snapping up these companies. Not just in financial benefits but look at the cultural impact these companies have on the world.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by neolog on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:56PM (#24984474)
> my peers wanted acquisitions

Yeah but the users didn't want them to get acquired, end their "incredible journey" and delete the users' data.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by TuringNYC on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:55AM (#24988544)
I understand your pain on this because i've been there. At the same time, deep down, I think many of us have also learned the truth:

If there is some startup providing some ridiculously awesome service and strangly isnt charging:

1. It will charge in the future, and even that charge may not be sufficient to cover costs (see: Quantopian recently, apparently could not find a price point which kept users and also kept the service)

2. It may get acquired, to finance long-term profitability (see: YouTube, WhatsApp, Instagram)

3. You may be giving up more than you thought you were (e.g., privacy) (see: like half the social media startups)

4. It may get acquihired, and often the product is sunset (see: Slide, Parse)

5. It may shut down (see: like 95% of your friends startups)

As a former founder, I can say most startups are just one funding round away from case 5 (bankruptcy) -- see MapR. In which case, sometimes you accept case 4 (acquihire) as a consolation prize. Many of us want to be the next FAANG, but reality strikes that obviously not all 100,000 startups out there will become a fang. Often, you teeter in case 1 (barely making it), and if that happens too long, you might go with option 2 (strategic acquisition.)

There are a lot of problems as a founder. Not all of them are actually about tech. I'll list some problems:

1. You are constantly questioning yourself -- is life just about eating ramen noodles and working? Did I really study and get top grades for 20yrs only to barely life? Mabye I can sell out. This should not be a problem post Series A, but is def an early stage issue.

2. You have liabilities - student loans, healthcare, rent, etc. Sure, you can couch surf, but should that be expected of people?

3. After marketing and ads especially, you often dont make as much as you think.

Sometimes you make a limited time bet, and if things dont catch, you move on.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by ineedasername on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:38PM (#24985266)
No, I simply said they get bought up. Any negative inference is your own. Feel free to suggest what you believe to be a more neutral term for being purchased by another company.
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by giobox on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:53PM (#24984438)
There's arguably been a few instances of "no one ever got fired for picking IBM" syndrome in neighborhoods I have lived in that considered it.

When a local authority run by people with little understanding of the technology is presented with a local infrastructure bid from a not so well known group vs a glossy Comcast/AT&T/<big telco> bid etc...

I absolutely agree though. It's an antitrust problem that has caused me genuine huge cost increases in reality (Comcast mandatory 1TB data cap in Comcast only neighborhoods. not sure if this nonsense still going on), not just hypothetically.

There are ways to expose the existing networks to competition too. There are examples out there of using careful legislation to force a big monopoly player to share cable space and so on, allowing other vendors to compete on price.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by biggermike on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @03:23PM (#24983580)
Big tech has big profit margins. Big telecom services doesn't.

Competitors don't enter the industry because there's little money to be made. The only way you make money by starting an independent ISP right now is by serving some niche clientele e.g. serving wireless internet to events at locations without enough broadband access.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by darkwizard42 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:11PM (#24984601)
I don't think competitors are avoiding telecom due to low margins. I guess you could say the high amount of start-up capital AND high regulatory hurdles AND the low margins (meaning your payback takes longer) cause it to be undesirable...then... yeah margins are (part of) the issue
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by biggermike on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @09:47AM (#24989487)
> high amount of start-up capital AND high regulatory hurdles AND the low margins

Not independent variables. The large wired broadband ISPs already enjoy economies of scale (access to capital, army of lawyers, etc.) and operate at slim margins. An independent ISP would need to reach the same size just to get the same near-zero margins.

That being said, there is a market for independent ISPs, but they tend to serve specialty customers where margins are much higher.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @03:29PM (#24983633)
Sounds like a perfect situation for coops.

As long as they break-even then it's a success.

Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by IggleSniggle on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:48PM (#24985330)
I’ve heard of communities doing this very thing, or creating city-owned ISPs, and then getting shut down as illegal due to “unfair competition” (the argument being that the government has unfair advantages vs a private company)
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by zajio1am on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:59PM (#24986219)
City-owned ISPs are unfair competition, but coops or non-gov non-profit organizations are perfectly valid approach.
Re:A tech antitrust problem no one is talking about: US broa... by austincheney on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @02:03AM (#24986932)
Stagnation isn't directly related to market dominance.