News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by jostmey on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:06PM (#24974025)
Many paragraphs into the article and I still don’t know what important discovery or observation has been made
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by random023987 on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:21PM (#24974161)
If you're looking for the summary, it's about 1/4 the way in.

> Usually, the viruses that humans care about are successful because they shut down both of these signalling programs. The coronavirus is different. “It seems to block only one of those two arms,” tenOever told me. It inhibits the interferon response but does nothing about the cytokines; it evades the local defenses but allows the cells it infects to call for reinforcements. White blood cells are powerful weapons: they arrive on an inflammatory tide, destroying cells on every side, clogging up passages with the wreckage. They are meant to be used selectively, on invaders that have been contained in a small area. With the coronavirus, they are deployed too widely—a carpet bombing, rather than a surgical strike. As they do their work, inflammation distends the lungs, and debris fills them like a fog.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by nextos on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:08PM (#24975670)
I've been doing some lab & modeling research on this, and it's more complex. I think it's a non-linear dynamics problem.

In a nutshell, SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) does block interferon response by using molecular mimics. Some of the proteins encoded in the virus are really similar to proteins in the interferon pathway, so this is not surprising. Still pretty unexplored and a nice route towards finding treatments.

Now, the interesting part is that the dynamics of interferon is very non-linear. Cells exchange interferon signals with other cells in the same tissue to pass information and coordinate with the immune system. There are fairly sophisticated models (using stochastic message passing!) that confirm lab observations on regular non-infected cells [1].

My hypothesis is that by blocking interferon in a sufficient number of cells on individuals with already disrupted innate immunity (due to ageing, insulin resistance, etc.) the system becomes chaotic. Infection by e.g. pneumococci is tolerated because the signaling is perturbed and then, all of a sudden, you get a massive amount of proinflammatory molecules secreted and cells decide to undergo apoptosis. That's the cytokine storm that everyone talks about.

Sadly, pursuing these ideas within academia is hard as most (but not all) biology labs are really hostile to mathematical models, even if they explain or predict things they can't using hand waving. Perhaps I should seek VC funding.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02640-8

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by projektfu on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:13AM (#24976567)
I’m a bit surprised by that statement about biology labs being hostile to mathematical models. Care to go more in depth?
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by tehjoker on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:16AM (#24977230)
bio people are not frequently math people and vice versa. The undergraduate departments make fun of each other. This is changing slowly. I suspect that a big part of the reason is that biology is complicated while math is good at dealing with distilling the behavior of a few essential elements.

When you start to find essential elements, they get mathified (look at DNA) but look how much experimental work it takes to do that? Scaling up experiments can also take some math, but once you figure out the trick, you just have a lot of experiments to run....

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by hanklazard on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:50PM (#24975187)
And this is why steroids like decadron are helpful in the second phase (now being called the inflammatory phase by many in the ID community) of the infection. Steroids decrease inflammation / immune response.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by AstralStorm on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:24AM (#24979873)
That's not exactly why it's steroids. If this was the main mechanism we'd use more effective immunosuppressants. As is, stronger immunosuppressants show worse survival rates. You want to keep some immune system activity to not get a secondary infection and fight the virus.

Corticosteroids also kickstart healing process (not really in COVID) and regrowth - you also race against tissue destruction. Most importantly they barely reduce scar formation. And they actually improve breathing via action on alveoli as well as reduce swelling.

The specific two to use are hydrocortisone and dexamethasone based on studies thus far, in critical patients - ones put on respirators. (Prednisolone could also work.)

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by rurban on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:03PM (#24974516)
This would be the proper description for the spanish flu. But with Covid-19 it's different. No cykotine, but BK overreaction. Healthy immune systems are not triggered to kill the body, only weak and old are in danger. Besides the neurological damage in some.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by ane on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:11PM (#24974078)
This kind of reporting interleaved with storytelling in a really weird voice is frustrating. Why do journalists write like this? What purpose does this word salad serve?

I can do this myself! "On a bald September day, a man walks into a barber shop, languishes at the occupied seats, and voilà, while sensing upcoming bowel movements, he discovers the next great theory of economics."

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by dTal on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:34PM (#24975087)
Cosmos was written in a similar style. Try reading it in Carl Sagan's voice and see if it's any more interesting to you.

The purpose of longform writing is to provide flavour and context, which are important parts of an information diet. Not everything has to be about the freshest facts delivered to your brain as urgently as possible. Just because you've happened across this in a frenzied binge of clicking HN headlines, doesn't mean it was designed to be consumed that way. If you don't feel you have time to sit through a New Yorker article, save it for later.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by FooHentai on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:39PM (#24974312)
This is 'Long Form Journalism'. The 'dip in, dip out' paragraph structure is a dead giveaway.

Not always what you're looking for but it can be a good way of cracking into a subject you're unfamiliar with, or a good way of merging the human element with something that would otherwise be quite dry.

By no means a substitute for regular news, but a good complement to it.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by ReptileMan on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:24AM (#24977262)
The problem is not the long form per se, but its misuse. Since usually journalists try to implant human interest stories etc where they don't fit.

Long form is good if you have something long to say. Trying to construct a story where there isn't one frustrates the reader.

I enjoy in depth exposes, but I don't need the alice, bob and malory viewpoint anchoring.

This is my general attitude towards this style of writing, not this specific piece.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by paganel on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:05AM (#24977827)
Related to unnecessary words inside a newspaper/magazine article, this interview [1] with Georges Simenon is the best example of why those articles look like crap (at least for people like me, I do realize that there are other people with different tastes):

> Just one piece of general advice from a writer has been very useful to me. It was from Colette. I was writing short stories for Le Matin, and Colette was literary editor at that time. I remember I gave her two short stories and she returned them and I tried again and tried again. Finally she said, “Look, it is too literary, always too literary.” So I followed her advice. It’s what I do when I write, the main job when I rewrite

> I: What do you cut out, certain kinds of words?

> Adjectives, adverbs, and every word which is there just to make an effect. Every sentence which is there just for the sentence. You know, you have a beautiful sentence—cut it. Every time I find such a thing in one of my novels it is to be cut.

[1] https://www.theparisreview.org/interviews/5020/the-art-of-fi...

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by eplanit on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:23PM (#24974657)
"but a good complement to it"

Clearly a matter of opinion whether it's good.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by TwoBit on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:59PM (#24975906)
> it can be a good way of cracking into a subject

You mean it can be a good way of stretching an article to fit more ads and increase monetization.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by dougmwne on Monday November 02, 2020 @10:25PM (#24976005)
I think it is actually optimized for print magazines where someone can be expected to dip in and out when they have a few minutes on the couch and the publisher has a set number of pages to fill. It's not as well suited to the internet where 25 words surrounded by 10 ads seems to be the norm and 5 minutes is an eternity.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by FooHentai on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:37AM (#24978005)
I don't disagree but national geographic, time, and now the same formats transposed into the online world all have their place. They can act as fantastic springboards into underlying news, scientific research, and other further reading in a way that's similar to but far more engaging than a dry wikipedia article.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by aeyes on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:23PM (#24975021)
You can condense the facts into 3 paragraphs but why don't we just go all in and present them as bullet points instead of full sentences?

When I see a five page article, I know that I'll get background information and I might discover something I didn't expect from the title. While you might only be looking for the study results, I like spending my Sunday afternoon reading long articles teaching me all kinds of interesting information I wouldn't have looked up on my own.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by Tomte on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:18PM (#24974139)
> Why do journalists write like this?

The New Yorker is known for that style, it may even be the prime example of it.

People who don't like that style are not the audience. And there are many people who like it.

It's like asking why Linux Weekly News never runs poetry. Because it's not that kind of publication.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by dTal on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:13PM (#24974955)
And what a shallow, frenetic dystopia it would be if nobody even attempted to write compelling longform anymore. Remember, 90% of everything is crap. Imagine reading 3 disappointing novels and concluding that novels, as a format, were a waste of time!

(Or worse - being unable to appreciate a good novel because you're too impatient for it to get to the exciting bits!)

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by projektfu on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:17AM (#24976592)
Compelling means that the reader doesn’t give up after a few paragraphs. I like long form, like I have subscribed to Harper’s since forever, but sometimes an article is just extended and not more interesting.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by SN76477 on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:28PM (#24974233)
I find NPR guilty of the same. I want to hear a story about how fear affects the lives of primates. And it begins on a cool October day with thoughts of coffee.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by clairity on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:09PM (#24974556)
...and a partisan obsession for relating every participant’s mask usage (or lack thereof).
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:48PM (#24974391)
I suspect that it's a holdover from the past. There once was a time when many people had more time to read than they had stuff to read. This kind of writing was fine. Better than right-to-the-point writing, in fact, because it expanded the amount to be read without actually needing to have more to say.

Alternately, it's a way of expanding readership. If you don't know anything about molecular biology, they have to write an article at a layperson's level to explain what they mean. But if you, the reader, don't want to go through the effort of trying to understand even that, then there's this human-interest stuff that may still cause you to decide to buy their magazine.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by jonas21 on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:26PM (#24975411)
Be kind! The author is a long-time HN user and is probably reading this.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by rq1 on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:23PM (#24974662)
Logorrhoea.

In French, “logorrhée”, means literally “verbal diarrhoea”.

It’s symptomatic of people who have not much to say.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by usrusr on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:20AM (#24979834)
I'd wholeheartedly agree with your critique if the text was published as a tweet storm.

The thing is, this isn't news reporting at all. It's a popsci writeup of the history of the immune system, the history of the discovery of the immune system and a glimpse into its complexity that uses Covid news as the textual equivalent of a cover image. If you have a print of 20000 Leagues under the Sea and the cover shows the kraken attack, would you complain about the number of chapters that don't contain a kraken at all?

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by nineparts on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @10:36PM (#24986304)
It's because students are being admitted to universities (including ivy league ones) based on informal political quotas. Once inside they don't learn per se but are indoctrinated with the virtues of diversity and tolerance. Nobody should be amazed that when they graduate, they write like a 12 year old: that was the whole point.
Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by mssundaram on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:06PM (#24974532)
> Why do journalists write like this?

It's journalists writing for other journalists.

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by BenGosub on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:33PM (#24974721)
The real question is who buys this BS?

George Orwell is turning in his grave...

Re:How the Coronavirus Hacks the Immune System by BenGosub on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:31PM (#24974711)
Indeed, lately I have lost my interest in reading long-reads, I just want to get to the point.