News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rayiner on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:07AM (#24964983)
> And I think the real synthesis of these views is that Obama-to-Trump voters are motivated by racism.

Hmm.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/18/opinion/biden-latino-vote...

> We began by asking eligible voters how “convincing” they found a dog-whistle message lifted from Republican talking points... Almost three out of five white respondents judged the message convincing. More surprising, exactly the same percentage of African-Americans agreed, as did an even higher percentage of Latinos. These numbers do not translate directly into support for the Republican Party; too many other factors are at play. Nevertheless, the results tell us something important: a majority across the groups we surveyed did not repudiate Trump-style rhetoric as obviously racist and divisive, but instead agreed with it.

Shor makes basically the same error as the authors of the New York Times piece above: assuming that opposing immigration and supporting law-and-order are inherently “racist” views.

Progressives need to ask themselves: is opposition to abolishing ICE (to use one of Schor’s examples) actually “racist?” Because if they just run with the assumption that it’s racist, they’ll force themselves into taking an incredibly unpopular position. As Shor himself points out, the people running the campaigns are ideologically progressive. Even if polling shows that abolishing ICE is incredibly unpopular, so long as they accept the premise that it’s the anti-racist thing to do, they will support it (or the far left will make them support it). This was basically the story of the 2019 Democratic primaries, where nearly every candidate embraced incredibly unpopular issues out of fear of being “called out.”

And “demographic destiny” won’t eventually vindicate progressives’ all-consuming view of racism. As the New York Times article above explains, a message focused around racial identity and the idea of pervasive “white supremacy” (like Elizabeth Warren ran in the 2019 Democratic Primary) actually polls poorly among Latinos (who are now the largest non-white group in the electorate). Meanwhile, Trump’s polling is up 100% among Black people and 60% among Hispanic people under 45 compared to 2016: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-is-losing-ground-.... If Republicans can convert that into votes, states like Texas and Georgia will stay solidly red. Shor is ultimately right. Democrats need to get back white voters in a country that will be 50%+ white for the foreseeable future. Because in the long run non-white voters aren’t as much of a lock as they assume. But they really need to introspect about why they would ever have thought otherwise to begin with.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by imperfectcats on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:25AM (#24965265)
I think this sort of response to the interview misses the forest for the trees.

This is the best article on elections I have ever read. When I first read it I felt for the first time I understood how the game is scored. These two quotes stand out and are what matter:

> Persuadable voters trust the parties on different issues. And there’s a pretty basic pattern — both here and in other countries — in which voters view center-left parties as empathetic. Center-left parties care about the environment, lowering poverty, improving race relations. And then, you know, center-right parties are seen as more “serious,” or more like the stern dad figure or something. They do better on getting the economy going or lowering unemployment or taxes or crime or immigration.

> So I think Democrats need to talk about the issues they are with us on, and try really hard not to talk about the issues where we disagree. Which, in practice, means not talking about immigration.

That's the game for both sides: Talk about issues non-partisan voters trust and/or agree with your side on, and avoid the opposite.

Simple in theory. Impossibly hard in practice.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by LaundroMat on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:19AM (#24965709)
Lakoff's "Don't Think of an Elephant" says something similar: don't let the other side provide the frame for your narrative.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rayiner on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:01AM (#24965385)
I agree the advice is astute. But you don’t necessarily get to pick what to talk about. Luckily, this election became a referendum on COVID—where the general empathetic association of Democrats plays strongly. But say COVID hadn’t happened. Instead, the last major pre-election issue was what happened this summer and law-and-order issues? (As Schor notes, this issue favors Republicans.) A whole lot of progressive Democrats turned a blind eye to police stations being burned down, etc. They had to: they had backed themselves into an ideological corner where they accepted the premise that any focus on the breakdown of law and order was “racist.” This was an incredibly unpopular position not only among white voters, but Hispanic voters of all ages and many older Black voters. Luckily, Biden was positioned to be able to say he understood the need for reform while having no soft spot for rioting. But Trump would have steamrolled over any of the other Democratic candidates by throwing their 2019 primary rhetoric back at them. And just not talking about the issue would have been a total non-starter—that’s what would have been on voters’ mind.

Democrats need positions in immigration and policing that aren’t the ones we saw from progressives over the past year and a half. Biden’s are fine. But within progressives’ current orthodoxy, Biden’s views would be deemed extremely “problematic” if Trump wasn’t there to be the bad guy.

I’ll give you another concrete example. Elizabeth Warren consistently used the term “LatinX.” This term actually polls terribly among Latinos. 70% have never heard of it. Of the 30% that have, the majority think it shouldn’t be used as a label to identify Latinos. Just 2% identified with the term themselves. Why use it? Because the people who work for Elizabeth Warren think the term “Latinos” isn’t gender inclusive. Schor would say not to use this term because of a high risk of alienating voters you need. But as Schor recognizes, the ideology of the campaign staffers has a powerful effect on the campaign’s messaging.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by pjc50 on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:30AM (#24965783)
Possibly, but you could project the same argument backwards: "why is this King guy talking about race when it's incredibly unpopular with white voters?"
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rayiner on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:45AM (#24968043)
That fails to distinguish between politics and activism.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by webmaven on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:40PM (#25051618)
> That fails to distinguish between politics and activism.

Activism is politics. I think the distinction is between activism and running for office.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by jmeister on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:26AM (#24965048)
Yes that’s one of Shor’s weak er arguments.

Shor is a self-described progressive who wants to help elect Democrats.

He’s mostly useful as a critic of the left from the centre. His “facts don’t care about your feelings” rebuttals of leftist fantasies are incredibly useful to both the centre and the left.

(This also got him fired on the first day of Floyd protests when he posted research showing that the riots will backfire in the long run, politically!)

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by unexpected on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:08AM (#24965204)
he didn't even post the research - he re-tweeted the research of a black academic that showed that violent protests are less successful that non-violent ones. His firing was a travesty.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by shoo on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:59AM (#24965621)
here's some pointers to results summarising

1. higher racial resentment correlated with higher votes for trump 2. most positive views of rising diversity correlated with switching from voting for romney to voting for not-trump ; least positive views of rising diversity correlated with switching from voting for obama to voting for trump 3. correlation of support for trump and more negative views of rising diversity

the analysis for 2 & 3 "[...] controls for education, gender, age, income, ideology, party, views on immigration, racial resentment and personal finances"

https://twitter.com/davidshor/status/1304772188030066689

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rendall on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:16AM (#24966082)
> "This is all pretty pretty clear, I don't know what else you could want."

I do wish he would have talked more about what "racially charged internet searches" meant. As Paula Wright pointed out, I'd like to know what those "racially charged internet searches" which you have described as "racist" were. Immigration is surely not a race issue in the US, an ethnically diverse culture. Wouldn't illegal immigration be just as big a concern for black wkibg [sic]* class citizens?* and There was rhetorical slippage here from "racially charged" to "racist".

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by davidshor on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:37AM (#24967975)
Hi - “racially charged” meant commonly used racial slurs against African Americans, not anything about immigration.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by webmaven on Monday November 02, 2020 @10:24AM (#24969041)
Hi there, and welcome to HN. Have you done any analysis (or know of studies) that bear on the wonky technological (or tech adjacent) issues that tend to consume this forum? Examples would be copyright and patent issues, broadband availability, antitrust, net neutrality, technological unemployment [0], free trade / tariffs / trade war, H1B visas, gig work (eg. Uber), R&D spending, space exploration, AI/algorithmic biases/ethics, open source, capital gains taxes, etc.

Conversely, how do you view the structure and detail of party and candidate platforms (eg. Warren's "I've got a plan for that" vs., well, anybody else)? Is more detail better or worse in terms of election results?

[0] I've always had a soft spot for this episode of The West Wing: http://westwingwiki.com/2014/04/season-5-episode-19-talking-...

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rendall on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:11AM (#24968265)
Hey, thanks for weighing in, David Shor. That puts a new spin on it.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rendall on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:40AM (#24977012)
Still, if it's possible, could you walk through the thinking, step by step, when you get a chance? Links to relevant results are fine, no need to write an essay.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rayiner on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:31AM (#24968456)
What does “rising diversity” mean in this context? Folks in Texas are angry about folks from California moving in and changing the culture. Is this racist? Equating anxiety about cultural change with racism is putting on ideological blinders.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by alttab on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:20AM (#24965715)
This dude knows nothing about why Trump won if he thinks I went from Obama to Trump because I'm a closet racist.

Maybe it had to do with all the war, bombing, and drone campaigns?

[dead]
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by raxxorrax on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:21AM (#24967838)
> It's the company you keep...

... is a very common saying in actually racist groups that think themselves above others.

Alternatively it can also be the language you speak... that gives you away.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by forest_dweller on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:28AM (#24966881)
> It's the company you keep ...

What is that supposed to mean?

> As if the Republican side didn't have enough bombings, drone strikes and so on.

I have a few friends at work that are from Pakistan. They prefer Trump over Obama because he isn't droning their homeland.

So they think Trump is an improvement.

> But choosing Trump of Clinton was just plain stupid, face it.

This is why everything is becoming polarised. This assumption that the other side is stupid or evil or both.

A lot of voters were turned off by Clinton calling Trump supporters deplorable. Others were worried after Clinton said she wanted to put a no-fly zone over Syria which would have meant a direct conflict with Russia.

I still remember Christopher Hitchen's scathing criticism of the Clitons.

https://christopherhitchens.net/hillary-clinton

He wrote a whole book about them IIRC.

There are a lot of valid criticisms of both Trump and Clinton however calling people stupid isn't going to convince anyone of your position.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by jmeister on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:59AM (#24967124)
It boggles my mind that there is still no sensible “establishment” understanding of why Trump was elected. There was no honest post-mortem after 2016, only blaming sexism, racism or Russian interference. No lessons learnt.

This column by Russ Douthat from a couple of days back summarizes the failure:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/30/opinion/trump-republican-...

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by finnthehuman on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:31AM (#24979929)
Any explanation approaching accuracy undercuts the establishment and can not be acknowledged. It's not the kind of tactical mistake they can own up to, but one that cuts uncomfortably close to admitting they're doing the country a deliberate disservice.

The explanation is there if anyone wants to see it. The Rolling Stone's political editor was calling it 6 months before Trump was even elected.

>It turns out we let our electoral process devolve into something so fake and dysfunctional that any half-bright con man with the stones to try it could walk right through the front door and tear it to shreds on the first go. [...] [Trump] likes being famous, which got him into reality TV. He knows show business. That put him in position to understand that the presidential election campaign is really just a badly acted, billion-dollar TV show whose production costs ludicrously include the political disenfranchisement of its audience.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by webmaven on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:44PM (#25051657)
Link?
[dead]
[dead]
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by weakfish on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:02AM (#24965176)
This comment lives in an alternative reality. Calling someone a Karen is racist? Please.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by AYBABTME on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:33AM (#24965297)
It depends how you define racism! According to "Defining Racism" by Beverly Daniel Tatum, it isn't. But in other interpretations of the word, it would be. I don't think it's far fetched to assume it might rightfully feel like a racist slur to the grand-parent.

Whether racism or not, it's probably an -ism of some sort. Despite disagreeing with the GP, at least their painting of "Karen" as an -ism gave me pause and made me consider that usage again. In truth, it's probably not a great and useful practice in discourse. e.g; do you believe calling someone a Karen will increase your chances of reconciling with them or coming to a favorable outcome with that person?

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by weakfish on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:03AM (#24968198)
No, I'm personally not a fan of the term because I generally don't like reducing people to caricatures - but IMO equating it to a slur is just... wrong. It's ignorant of what actually has been happening to the oppressed people in this country since... forever? And is trying to equate someone, who is generally in a position of power (a middle class white woman) to minority groups who have experienced racism since this country's founding.

Food for thought: In the (rough) words of John Mulaney, if you equate something to another word, but you won't even say the other word, then one is clearly worse than the other.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by EdwardDiego on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:01AM (#24965172)
What in the god damn was that.

1) Stop capitalising "white". 2) "little old White women are prohibited from attending church" - [citation needed] 3) "popularisation of "Karen" racist dialogue" - how is this racist?

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by forest_dweller on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:22AM (#24965255)
I wouldn't personally call it racist or sexist (as I've seen the term used for both men and women and of different races). However the logic works like this:

Tyrone is a internet stereotype of a thuggish blackman. The stereotype of Tyrone is considered by some to be racist (probably quite rightly). Karen is a stereotypical entitled white woman. So if calling someone a Tyrone is racist, therefore calling a woman a Karen is also racist.

Not saying I agree with any of it. But that is my understanding of how the logic works.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by tathougies on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:37AM (#24965304)
I mean... I thought so in 2016, but four years later, I simply do not believe this. There is no evidence to support this. He has constantly condemned white supremacy. He obviously is a nationalist, but for America, being a multi-racial nation, saying one is a nationalist does not mean you are a racist.

Trump has delivered insane results for minority groups, and has done things even supposed 'progressive' candidates wouldn't do. All this has convinced me that the man is clearly not a racist, despite constant claims otherwise.

Also, I suppose I am somewhat immune to the racism claims against trump. My parents are immigrants, as is my entire family. My parents were the first ones on the Trump bandwagon in 2016, followed by the rest of my family. I thought they had gone off their rocker and thought the man was nuts, despite being a Republican leaning voter. I voted against him in 2016. I thought he was clearly a racist and would hurt immigrants, like my uncle. However, Trump became president, and my uncle's case suddenly went faster. All this talk about how he was delaying immigration simply didn't pan out for anyone in my family. My uncle became a citizen a few years ago, and now the entire family is voting Trump. My sister-in-law (who is Hispanic) is also voting Trump, along with a bunch of her family. They didn't 4 years ago.

Funnily, enough, most of my friends growing up (who are mostly non-white) are either Trump voters or are okay with Trump (like they do not believe people who vote for him are racist). I do have friends who believe that all Trump voters are nuts, and they are mostly the white friends I made in my super-elite college. I do have non-white friends from college who are also against Trump, but given how few non-whites there are in elite colleges to begin with, that's the minority for me.. Even more amazingly, despite my own immigrant family and my sister-in-law's supporting Trump, the only family I have that is rabidly anti-Trump are my white relatives (who are more highly educated than anyone in my non-white family, I suppose).

The fact is Hacker News and most of these elite media outlets cater to an audience of mostly white, educated, coastal liberals. Their experiences do not match the reality of every day Americans, including black and brown and immigrant ones. I would not be surprised to see massive black and brown turnout for Trump. Perhaps not majorities, but enough to give the democrats real cause for concern.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by EdwardDiego on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:59AM (#24965163)
Curious that you're downvoted without comment. I was hoping some of your detractors would've explained why they think you're wrong.

As an outsider to the US bunfight, your statement seems, based on what we see, pretty self-evident.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by forest_dweller on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:14AM (#24966068)
I am also an outsider and it isn't obvious to me how he is both. Divisive sure (most politicians of note are), racist though? I personally don't see it.

It suits some people to conflate immigration policy and racism. It then allows them to then label anyone opposed to immigration as racist. It is further confounded by the fact that those people that are deeply racist are almost always opposed to immigration. They do it all the time in the UK and I see no reason why it would be different in the US.

For "evidence" of Trump's racism, most will bring up his clumsy statement when he first announced he was running for president. To me he was clearly referring to hardened criminals and gangs, others say he is referring to every illegal immigrant. Again if you take it in the worse possible intent yes then you could say it is racist. However that is the worst possible interpretation and it shouldn't be your default. From my observations Trump was speaking off the cuff and I can forgive a poorly worded statement.

I am not particularly partisan (I am a centre -> centre-right libertarian when taking political compass tests). However after spending a lot of time paying attention to what is going on both sides will try to spin any issue in their favour.

I've been duped a few times by both sides of the political spectrum when it comes to contentious statements. Sp when a media outlet claims someone has made such a statement, I find the original clip of what was said and listen to it in context before I form an opinion.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by raxxorrax on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:15AM (#24967804)
https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/456523-donald-trumps...

https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/456523-donald-trumps...

I don't believe he is a racist. He has strong opinions and no fear of hiding them. That is actually a huge draw for people voting for him.

Accusations of racism are mostly political play.

I don't really see how it is self-evident though. What do you think makes him racist? The Obama stuff could be seen as that but I am unsure if it is racism or craziness, but I would tend to think the latter to be more correct.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by JoeAltmaier on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:20AM (#24967837)
The whitewashing of this guy is the big issue. He can do no wrong, that supporters don't contort the evidence (and their own good sense) to struggle to reinterpret him as 'ok'.

You want to understand, read outside your bubble. Not extremist view, just speeches and responses to direct questions and whatnot.

Some reports may seem extremist because of the shocking response they have to our potus. It's a normal reaction to a fundamentally troubling character that's somehow in power. Somehow its not honest for them to speak out like that, while the candidate gets every benefit of the doubt?

I suggest using those contortionist skills, to understand outrage and shock at the spectacle of an incoherent, largely immoral money-grabber in the White House.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by raxxorrax on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:22AM (#24967844)
I think Trumps has many flaws and it is true that there is some white washing. I do think his strong opinions can be a source of much bigotry.

But he is judgmental about everyone and I don't think it is connected to race.

His voters specifically let him say controversial stuff. They like it if it hits sensibilities of his political enemies since it signals his voters that the others just think themselves to be exalted above the allegedly less sophisticated members of society.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by ZeteticElench on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:06PM (#24971791)
" I do think his strong opinions can be a source of much bigotry."

Which is funny because his "strong opinions" usually contain much bigotry.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by segfaultbuserr on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:06AM (#24965412)
> Curious that you're downvoted without comment [...] As an outsider to the US bunfight, your statement seems, based on what we see, pretty self-evident.

I didn't cast any vote in the thread, but here's an explanation. If I did decide to vote, I would definitely downvote it, since it only repeats a cliche that has been said over a thousand times, even though I, too, consider it as "fact". The problem is, saying "Trump is racist and divisive" does not add any new insight to the discussion, and the only outcome is attracting angry yelling from the most politically biased people, hence triggering an unproductive flamewar (I think you've just experienced exactly what I described. When you said "what in the god damn was that", I think you could see my points already). When I see something like this, I usually downvotes all related comments and their replies regardless of which side they're arguing for (thus, all angry pro-Trump and anti-Trump comments would be downvoted - only downvoting the original thread is unfair), as nothing good can come out of it.

I believe this strategy can promote what the Hacker News Guidelines is trying to achieve.

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

> Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.

> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.

> Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

Saying either "$controversial_politician is good" or "$controversial _politician is bad" violates all of those Guidelines above.

For controversial political discussions, I found the worst thing you can do is posting a general criticism, such as "$something is bad". Instead of doing that, a better strategy is talking about a specific issue, for example, instead of saying "$politician is bad", it's better to pick and criticize one of his policies, and to analyse its perceived harmful effects due to the policy. The more specific the criticism, the better. While it's still saying "$politican is bad", but it contains new insights and information that prevent the discussion from being dragged into a name-calling flamewar (it may still be a flamewar, but with fewer name-calling posts and more discussions). I found it dramatically improves the quality of discussions.

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by comex on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:08AM (#24965418)
Elizabeth Warren’s primary campaign message was mainly focused on the economy, not race.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by rayiner on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:15AM (#24965455)
Yes, but the major difference between her and Sanders was that she’d thread race through every issue. As an academic matter this works just fine—failing municipal water systems are disproportionately ones that affect people of color. As a matter of political rhetoric (I watched her in person at several events in Iowa last year) it’s actually quite off-putting. Also, her tripping over the phrase “LatinX” (which just 2% of Latinos identify with, and 70% have never even heard of.)
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by irrational on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:47AM (#24965107)
What do you mean by demographic destiny? I assume that means something like, over time the demographic makeup of society will come to look more and more like "college-educated coastal progressives"? Do people really believe that? If so, that is hard to believe. "College-educated coastal progressives" tend to have few or no children compared to the "majority of the country". It would seem the demographic makeup will go in the opposite direction.
Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by bumbledraven on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:54AM (#24965141)
> What do you mean by demographic destiny?

Presumably he means the same thing CNN means by it. https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/01/politics/election-2020-trump-... (emphasis mine):

“It happened four years ago when Donald Trump scored an Electoral College victory with his turn-back-the-clock campaign to Make America Great Again. He'll have trouble pulling it off again. That's partly because the pace of demographic change keeps shrinking the America Trump evokes in the rear-view mirror.”

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by salamimonger on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:17AM (#24965236)
I love how acceptable it is to brag about how eventually white people in the US will be outpopulated by non-white people who we assume will all vote Democrat. How would the reaction be if the mainstream media was bragging about white people outbirthing Mexicans in Mexico and soon taking over their politics?

Note: I'm not white btw so don't @ me, just making an observation

Re:David Shor’s Unified Theory of American Politics by pjc50 on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:34AM (#24965802)
There's an entire genre of white supremacist media that goes on about this "replacement" endlessly, and has politics to match such as the "quiverful" movement encouraging white women to have lots of children.

I don't think people on the other side are bragging.