News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yters on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:17PM (#24933491)
why is global warming so catastrophic? the globe has been much warmer in the past and we are all here today
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:24PM (#24933616)
I actually think this is a fair question, because I feel like there are 2 issues that get conflated:

1. First, you are correct, the Earth was much hotter in the past, and I haven't seen anything convincing that global warming will lead to a fundamental "runaway greenhouse" effect a la Venus that makes life as we know it on Earth unsustainable.

2. That said, a huge climate change in a relatively short amount of time could easily lead the the deaths of billions of people, with a B. One third of the human population lives within 60 miles of the coast. Rising temperatures will lead to huge portions of the planet that are currently densely populated that will no longer support humans. The resulting migrations, "resource wars", and overall increase in extreme weather events (more hurricanes, more droughts, more floods) will lead to death and misery to a huge portion of humanity.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yters on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:40PM (#24933909)
but if this change happens on the order of 100 years, that seems enough time to respond
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:54PM (#24934120)
But it doesn't and won't. E.g. the sea level may creep up slowly, and then all of a sudden you get a giant flood or hurricane that makes a huge portion of the coast unlivable.

And regardless, if you think moving a third of humanity to vastly different lands will be hunky dory smooth sailing, you should study history.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by InitialLastName on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:56PM (#24935761)
Not just that, but the places we currently grow our food have been primed to fertility over thousands of years of relatively stable climates. If many of those areas become substantially less useful for growing crops (because of storms, temperature changes, drought, whatever have you), it's foolish to assume that we will see just as many places that haven't had millennia of vegetation growing on them become fertile.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:10PM (#24934337)
We've known about it for over 50 years and have done basically nothing. Why would you expect another 100 to matter?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by catawbasam on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:25PM (#24936108)
US CO2 per capita is down 1/3 from peak. Europe is way down. China is peaking out. It's a start.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:10PM (#24938405)
Much of this decrease in CO2 per capita in 1st world countries is just because we have outsourced much of our CO2 production to 3rd world countries
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by adrianN on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:38AM (#24939221)
This is the graph that counts, and there is no discernible improvement in the curve: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_me...
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ldargin on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:04PM (#24934256)
That depends. Migrations and wars are the responses we can expect if its not handled in an organized way.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by ALittleLight on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:52PM (#24934084)
Yes, and we should start responding.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by core-questions on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:08PM (#24934319)
Sea level has to actually start rising enough that the rich folks who live waterfront are affected and then we will see some geoengineering efforts or at the very least some solid seawalls.

I'm waiting for someone to figure out how to use solar + hotter temperatures + seawater to give us desalinated water

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:35AM (#24950319)
You say that, but its effecting Florida now and they're still just denying AGW
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by nullsense on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:11PM (#24934361)
Hundreds of years starting in 1800s gives us until about 2100. 80 years will be within our childrens lifetimes for us millennials.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rtx on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:09PM (#24934322)
You need to look at arable land distribution, most of them are far from seas.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:41AM (#24950347)
NZ is the worlds largest dairy exporter. ALL of NZ is close to the sea. Many islands are the world's food basket for bananas, coffee, coconut, palm oil (which is MASSIVE) and those are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kanox on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:06PM (#24936656)
> Rising temperatures will lead to huge portions of the planet that are currently densely populated that will no longer support humans.

This does not seem likely, the bar for a region being "unable to support humans" is very high. People already live in cities that need to support themselves with food from elsewhere, and worldwide calorie production per capita is increasing.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by pixl97 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:13PM (#24937676)
It seems like you understand very little about systems collapse.

A huge portion of our farming is currently unsustainable. Yes, we are producing more right now, but this production is on a clock. Even without any change in climate we are screwed. Look at how many places in the world are currently undergoing water system collapse. California, a huge crop producing state, has areas that have sunk nearly 30 meters because of pumping too much water. Those same areas are highly dependant on bringing in water from long distances away. Now add unstable weather patterns the the propensity for longer droughts and tell me what you think will happen?

We are not dealing with a climate change problem. We are dealing with

A long term water supply problem

A soil salinization over vast areas problem

A soil decarbonization problem over vast areas

Increasing temperatures that are pushing our current high yield crops to their limit problem

A globalized transportation system that will quickly spread crop diseases problem

Humanity is playing russian roulette with these issues. We will get a perfect storm one of these years, for example across the midwest US being hit by a drought and crop rust and we could see a near complete failure of our corn harvest. We are talking about the potential loss of 750 million tons of calories that will rock the world to its foundations.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by doliveira on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:53PM (#24938278)
We really should learn more about the Bronze Age collapse... Interconnected empires with hundreds and thousands of years simply vanishing in one generation due to a combination of wars, famine and possibly climate change in the Mediterranean. Supply lines got dismantled, a lot of technology was lost, Mycenaeans even forgot how to write!

Sounds like a cautionary tale to our current situation.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:25PM (#24937315)
This statement is bizarre. Have you seen what a sea-level rise map of Bangladesh looks like? Unless Bangladeshis start evolving gills I'm pretty sure the area where many of them currently live will no longer support humans.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:47AM (#24939274)
The Dutch have been living below sea level for centuries. It’s not the end of the world and ultimately dikes cost a lot less than losing significant land area and moving massive population centers. A few places like Florida that are awkwardly situated above porous rock like limestone and have little elevation above sea level even well inland are kinda screwed, but for the most part sea level rise is an expensive but entirely solvable problem.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by polytely on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:21AM (#24940501)
It took a huge flood to mobilize the political will to spend a fuckton of money on flood prevention.*

I feel like the problem with climate change is that by the time the effects get so bad that everyone will be on board to actually put a significant amount of resources into prevention and mitigation, it will be too late to do anything, because there is a time lag between ceasing emissions and the climate stabilizing. Additionally, all the greenhouse gasses you have already emitted are still in the atmosphere so just stopping emissions will only stop the heating up (if we are lucky) and not automatically result in the climate returning to "normal".

*: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Sea_flood_of_1953

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:56PM (#24946269)
Building flood barriers is a lot cheaper and a lot easier to throw money at than reducing emissions. Barriers can also be constructed on a local or regional level, whereas emission reduction requires achieving an intractable global consensus. It doesn’t follow that the same dysfunctions that have prevented emission reduction will prevent the construction of flood barriers.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:45AM (#24950368)
Putting up barriers won't stop the water rising. And the vast majority of small island nations won't be able to afford to wall off their entire landmass
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:11AM (#24965217)
As mentioned above, places with porous geology that have low elevation even well inland are not salvageable. And the vast majority of small island nations don’t contain very many people. It seems like the goalposts are being moved here from “sea level rise is an existential threat to human civilization” to “sea level rise will disrupt the way of life of some people”.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rocgf on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:37AM (#24940578)
I see this argument all the time and it feels like I must be missing something. There is no way people actually believe the whole world can go Dutch, right?

I hope this doesn't come across as overly-aggressive, but it seems to me like you don't really understand much about how the Dutch lived below sea levels for centuries.

Yes, over many centuries, they have built all sorts of contraptions in order to gain more land from the sea or lakes. But this is expensive, takes up a vast amount of skill and planning and is only feasible in certain terrain. The Netherlands is also a small and very rich country. To believe that the whole world can do this is complete insanity.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:04PM (#24946337)
The whole world doesn’t need to. A sea level rise of 2m doesn’t matter for most of the world, or even for most coastal regions. And of the coastal regions that will be impacted most can be sacrificed with limited disruption. For the much more limited areas of the world that are coastal, have low elevation even well inland, and are densely populated or otherwise economically valuable, flood control is totally realistic (with the exception of some places like Florida that are screwed by the underlying geology).
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:48AM (#24950383)
A massive amount of humanity lives on or near the coast. In the US, 40% of the population is coastal. The cost of walling off the entire coast would be astronomical.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:13AM (#24965224)
I think you didn’t read the comment you responded to.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by newt_slowly on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:43PM (#24938928)
When the combination of heat and humidity gets high enough (look up wet bulb temperature) then it means death for even fit young people, even when sitting in the shade with access to drinking water. We are thermodynamically incapable of surviving too high of web bulb temperatures.

Huge swaths of the globe will experience fatal web bulb temperatures multiple times a year by the end of the century. Very clearly this makes a region "unable to support humans".

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:50AM (#24939292)
A large fraction of the human population have been living in parts of the world where the external environment is lethal for months of the year for thousands of years. It’ll certainly be an interesting development when air conditioning becomes a matter of life and death the way heating in winter already is in much of the world, but air conditioning is also much less energy intensive than heating.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by newt_slowly on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:20PM (#24943824)
I don't think it is reasonable to compare other hostile environments to one where humans are literally incapable of being outside for extended periods of time. Even in harsh cold climates, it is possible to wear suitable clothing, or build a fire. That is simple, resilient, low tech and low carbon. Requiring a structure with AC and power is a much larger challenge.

Furthermore, a lot of the areas that will suffer from fatal wet bulb temperatures do not have the wealth to provide AC to everyone. This will drive mass migrations of people on a scale we have never seen before, destabilizing neighbouring countries (or more likely, leading to mass murder).

Finally, this is another positive feedback loop: more AC required -> more energy required -> more severe global warning.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:52PM (#24946226)
Cooling and dehumidifying a residence to a non-lethal temperature and humidity doesn’t take all that much energy or particularly expensive or sophisticated technology. And emissions from the residential electricity generation required isn’t a particularly pressing concern. Intermittent power capacity like solar and wind is most available at the same time it’s most needed for driving residential air conditioning, and large countries like India, China, Brazil, Nigeria etc that are going to be facing this issue don’t have the same paranoia about nuclear power that’s so common in the West.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by amanaplanacanal on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:00PM (#24937123)
Land that is underwater would count as unable to support humans, I think.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:55AM (#24939303)
A few areas of the world that are unusually low-lying and situated over permeable rock like limestone will be flooded. For the rest of the world, dikes are a well-understood technology, and quite cheap compared to sacrificing large land areas or moving cities. Even worst-case shortest-timeline estimates of sea level rise are not an existential crisis.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:51AM (#24950396)
There are pacific islands losing land to water rise NOW. This is an existential crisis for them. What do you say to them? Sorry, we couldn't be bothered to fix the problem? (That we created and you are suffering the consequences of)
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:08AM (#24965205)
They should move. Perhaps it would soften the blow if they were also told platitudes about fault and blame, but realistically (a) the problem is not going to be solved in time, and (b) the plight of a small number of people is not going to move the needle in regards to the willingness of the world to address the issue. People who still think that the damage can be averted entirely are just as deluded as people who think that sea level rise is an existential threat to human civilization.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by btilly on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:54PM (#24935722)
On top of everything else, rate matters.

An example of a climate effect that nobody mentioned is ocean acidification. It turned out that if you add CO2 to water, you get carbonic acid. This melts calcium carbonate at the bottom of the sea. The buffering makes the pH of the oceans relatively constant no matter what CO2 levels happen to be.

Unfortunately that buffering takes place on the order of thousands of years. Which is fine when CO2 slowly increases in level. But when it rises suddenly, as it is doing right now, the oceans turn into a mild acid. Mild, that is, except for corals and shellfish whose shells dissolve. And anything that depends on them. Which, given how ecosystems connect, is pretty much everything in the ocean.

Already, 3/4 of coral reefs in the world have experienced bleaching event. Similarly mass die-offs of shellfish have been widely reported in fisheries. Future projections are..bleak.

All of this from a level of change that would have been fine if it was spread over 10,000 years rather than 100.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by floatrock on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:06PM (#24936660)
To expand on the coral example: before fish get large enough to catch and eat, they start off as little hatchlings. Coral reefs are fish nurseries that offer protected environments before setting off for the deep blue seas, where the fishing boats find them.

Something like 40% of humans worldwide rely on fish as their primary source of protein. What happens when there's no habitat to support that food source? Mass disruptions and migrations.

So yes, the earth was warmer before, but that warming happened over geologic timeframes that allowed ecosystems to adapt and change. 100 years is long on human timescales, but it's an instantaneous disruption on geologic timescales.

And despite the convenience of your neighborhood supermarket, we are not that detached from our ecosystems. The empty shelves at the start of covid should have been a wakeup call that our supply systems are still interconnected.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by vkou on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:25PM (#24933642)
A two-degree average increase in temperatures would significantly reduce crop yields in the world's breadbaskets.

If we didn't need to eat, we wouldn't be worried very much about global warming. I do need to eat, though, and I'd rather avoid having to eat global warming deniers when things get rough.

The earth was warmer in the past, but it also didn't support planet-scale agriculture of hyper-specialized, high-yield grains that are expected to feed 8+ billion people.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yters on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:42PM (#24933931)
is adapting our food production out of the question? it seems that might be a bit easier than fixing global warming
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by vkou on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:55PM (#24934133)
It hasn't been done, it's not clear that it can be, and the problem is not in the grains that we grow, the problem is in the land. If a formerly arable area becomes a dustbowl, there's no adaptation of our food production that you can do to fix this problem.

Moving our agriculture north doesn't work either, because of the poor quality of soil in what is currently the tundra/taiga.

If you have a handful of magic beans that will grow a magic beanstalk, that will be resistant to the temperature and weather and soil changes caused by global warming, sure, by all means, share it with us, and I'll stop worrying. We don't have that handful, though, and I'm not keen on hope-based planning.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by jjoonathan on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:02PM (#24934220)
> there's no adaptation of our food production that you can do to fix this problem

Norway got good enough at growing things in greenhouses to be considered a breadbasket. Norway. I think you severely underestimate human adaptability.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Arnt on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:17PM (#24934445)
1. Norway's a breadbasket with lots of greenhouses? Here's some prime land in Norway, see if you find a greenhouse. https://goo.gl/maps/Vzn3J3HS2Nm1P1mZ7 Norway has fed itself, more or less, for a few hundred years except the odd bad year, but never exported enough to feed even one big nearby city (say Copenhagen or Edinburgh).

2. You may be adaptive and want to move to some better place, but you're also just another penniless would-be immigrant with a big house loan in the country you want to leave, you don't speak the language, so what makes you think you'd be welcome in that better place?

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by antepodius on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:37PM (#24934685)
Seems like the move for hackernews people is to pre-emptively move to high land (Tibet?) and not take out loans.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:16PM (#24938115)
> and not take out loans.

That's always a good idea if you are an individual, and not a business.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by jjoonathan on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:25PM (#24935314)
1. Looks like it was the Netherlands, not Norway [1] -- embarrassing, but not of fundamental importance to the point, which stands: greenhouse farming is far from impossible.

2. I'm a penniless would-be immigrant? No, we are both captial-rich citizens of a capital-rich country in a capital-rich world capable of deploying enormous creativity and resources at incomprehensible scale to solve practical problems. Including this one, which doesn't actually require very much creativity or resources in comparison to our capabilities and needs. People predicting the doomsday love to downplay this side of economics -- the good side, the one that works. Their enormous pile of failed predictions should remind us to keep some perspective. Actual penniless immigrants? Yeah, they're going to be a problem, a big one, both in a humanitarian sense and in a cynical political stability sense. But is this the end of our civilization, or of human civilization? Not by a long shot, and claiming that it will be is crying wolf to such a shrill degree that it's an embarrassment to the cause.

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/09/holland-...

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Arnt on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:13AM (#24940465)
The Netherlands are such fine farmland that people spent enormous effort to keep the sea and rivers away. I was nearby recently and went for some bicycle trip. One pleasant little creek, perhaps 50cm deep and 1m wide, used to rise by 6m every so often. That area was settled eight hundred years ago, because the farmland was worth the effort required to keep the flooding under control.

It's hardly surprising that such fine land becomes a breadbasket, and it's not proof that it can be done anywhere.

And you're not capital-rich if your capital is a home in an area people want to leave, and your country isn't capital-rich if people there see no future. The fine infrastructure of your former home is worthless in the eyes of the visa applicants in the country you want to move to, because they, like you, don't want to live there.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by mythrwy on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:26PM (#24947455)
I don't think so. If anything there will be more arable land and more rain in much of the world. Additionally many crop plants grow faster with increased C02 (which is why marijuana grow ops put CO2 in the chambers of course). It also may be an opportunity to move off areas with depleted soils into virgin areas. At the time of the Cambrian explosion CO2 levels were ~20 times higher then they are or will be if we keep right on our trajectory. The earth didn't melt down and life flourished.

And this is assuming much at all happens. I've been watching this issue for over 30 years and no longer believe they can predict with much accuracy at all. I was quite an alarmist in 1990 but not any more.

Imagine writing a program to model this. With the interrelated variables (more CO2 means plants grow faster which uptakes more CO2. More heat means more evaporation, more small cloud cover, which means less heat. Industrial output means more air particles etc etc), the flux and all the various unknown factors (what will the energy output from the sun be in 50 years?). You mess up one small thing or make a bad assumption and it blows up. I honestly don't know how any rational person has much faith in the granular predictive power of this at all if they stop and think about it for a bit. Models are good to see how stuff works. Models at this scale to predict? Highly doubt it.

That being said, man does influence the climate to an extent it is clear. We should be cleaner. We should get off fossil fuels in an orderly fashion as they are filthy anyway. But, we don't have "12 years left to do something!". That is and always has been complete bullshit.

https://extinctionclock.org/

It's most especially annoying to hear the latest iteration of projections based on tenuous models touted as "fact" and anyone who doesn't believe is some kind of conspiracy theorist. The continual stream of failed predictions from the doom promoters is reason enough to be suspicious. The earth warms and cools. With or without us.

Finally, to all the 20 somethings turning red and mashing downvote right now, you will live long enough to see. In 30 years things will not be significantly different. Florida will still be there. There will be no mass climate migrations. The polar ice caps will still be there. There won't be a huge increase in anomalous weather events. But there will probably still be a loud group of people proclaiming "We only have 10 years to DO SOMETHING!".

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by nullsense on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:09PM (#24934330)
Mass extinction I'm guessing? Ecosystems are systems. They are resilient to a point, but losing enough diversity to the point it can't sustain itself leads to a collapse.

It's happened numerous times before.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:14PM (#24938100)
Back then we didn't have 8 billion people and nuclear weapons.

Consider the impact of ecosystem-related consequences others mentioned on habitability and food production. Once mass migrations and food shortages start, and starving migrants show up at the borders of higher-latitude/elevation countries in amounts orders of magnitude larger than before, what do you think will happen? Will these countries, worrying about how to feed their own citizens as crops fail due to weather anomalies, open up the borders and accept doubling their population? Will the migrants just accept being refused to enter? In the meantime, powers will be jockeying for mining rights of newly-unfrozen, but still not habitable lands. With all that pressure mounting, how long it'll take until someone starts shooting, someone else shoots back, and we'll have a WW3 on our hands?

If climate situation degrades fast enough, we'll wipe ourselves out way before the changing weather does.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by lovecg on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:34PM (#24943971)
Are there actually historical examples of mass migration due to food shortages? My understanding is that most migrants are relatively young, healthy, and resourceful. It’s hard to travel thousands of miles while literally starving.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rufus_foreman on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:50PM (#24947216)
Ireland: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)#Reactio...

1.5 million people emigrated out of a population of around 8 million.

"Of the more than 100,000 Irish that sailed to Canada in 1847, an estimated one out of five died from disease and malnutrition, including over 5,000 at Grosse Isle, Quebec, an island in the Saint Lawrence River used to quarantine ships near Quebec City. Overcrowded, poorly maintained, and badly provisioned vessels known as coffin ships sailed from small, unregulated harbours in the West of Ireland in contravention of British safety requirements, and mortality rates were high."

So some of them travelled thousands of miles while literally starving.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:55AM (#24950414)
The Irish Famine. One million people emigrated.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rtkwe on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:11PM (#24935160)
Because for starters a huge portion of the world's population lives on the coast so rising sea levels will wipe out a lot of cities. Secondly the entire human civilization has lived in the warming period coming out of the last ice age, we've never lived in that hot weather. Climate change isn't an end all life on Earth but it will drastically change how humans live on Earth.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:59AM (#24939319)
Rising sea levels will wipe out a few cities here and there that are exceptionally low-lying and built over permeable rock like limestone that allows the rising sea to infiltrate the water table. By and large cities will build dikes, as the Dutch have been doing for centuries.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rtkwe on Friday October 30, 2020 @11:42AM (#24943384)
Where do you build a dike in NYC where everything is built up to the waterfront?
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by rufus_foreman on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:53PM (#24947235)
You make a new waterfront, the same way NYC has already done.

You can look at the map at https://www.thirteen.org/dutchny/interactives/interactive-ma... to see how much land was added. Most of lower Manhattan is built on what was ocean in 1609.

It's an engineering problem, and NYC can afford to solve it.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by dodobirdlord on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:39PM (#24946076)
Well, first of all, sacrificing the outermost 10-20m of development to build a dike along the shore is a trivial expense compared to abandoning the city or dealing with regular flooding. But more likely the dikes will be built over the first 10-20m of what is currently the sea to avoid demolishing buildings built up against the water. That, or existing barriers will simply be raised. Whenever buildings are built directly against the sea they already require some sort of barrier to cover the difference between high and low tides and to deal with storm surge.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by kolinko on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:18PM (#24933514)
we weren't here the last time globe has been much warmer
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by TYPE_FASTER on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:38PM (#24934700)
>we are all here today

We weren't here then

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by macrael on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:32PM (#24933764)
Genuinely, this was helpful to my gut understanding of this issue: https://xkcd.com/1732/
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yters on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:44PM (#24933970)
according to that graph the world was as warm if not warmer relatively recently
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by Arnavion on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:59PM (#24934190)
It shows literally the exact opposite of that. 2016 is the highest temperature and at no previous point does the graph reach that value.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by yters on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:36PM (#24936260)
it looks like the line marked gold metalworking is the same, although hard to tell for sure. But long periods of history were at least pretty close to today's remperature according to that graph
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by sergeykish on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:12AM (#24939080)
The alarming part is rate.

Earth warmth comes from CO2 blanket, we can't suck it from atmosphere, we hardly can reduce CO2 production worldwide.

Also his "best case scenario" is humanity wiped from Earth ten years ago, not base case for me. "Optimistic scenario" is if world acted on current policies. And "current path" is denial (4°C–5°C raise).

https://ourworldindata.org/future-emissions

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by krastanov on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:42PM (#24938924)
This is kinda missing the point. Look at the slope. And think how a system responds to a gentle slow perturbation and how it responds to a fast drastic change.
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @07:02AM (#24950453)
1. No, the gold metalworking part is lower on the graph. 2. It's the slope of the change - systems that evolve over millennia aren't set up to adjust over decades
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by macrael on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:16PM (#24937704)
Once more and for the last time in good faith, it's the trend line that matters. The earth hasn't experienced even remotely close to this rapid a change in temperature in the 20,000 years captured by that chart.

To take your example from the gold smithing era. The earth warmed from -.5 -> +.6 degrees over the course of about 4000 years. We've warmed that much in the last 100 years.

Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by scythe on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:12PM (#24934369)
Re:The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen by peterashford on Saturday October 31, 2020 @06:33AM (#24950304)
The globe has been hotter, but not with humans on it