Restaurants spend a lot of time and effort to build up loyal, lifetime customers that are created by giving them three exceptional experiences in a row. There is a lot of research on getting to three exceptional experiences in return for a lifetime customer. Those exceptional experiences require investments in staff and training and take a long time to pay off.
Having GrubHub break that effort through misrepresentation they are destroying the lifetime value of those customers. If you apply that math to slightly more premium venues, GrubHub is easily costing restaurants hundreds of thousands in revenue through lost lifetime value.
Restaurants are complex, fragile businesses, and this practice damages them at the core of their business.
Will be interesting to see how this plays out in court.
I suspect that what restaurants fear, though, is that Grubhub is trying to grab as much marketshare as possible then once they are in a position of strength they'll go and demand a commission from the restaurants, or else...
GH is pretending to be the restaurant, so you get mad at the restaurant, not GH, when your order arrives late/cold/wrong. The restaurant didn't agree to this representation and you, the customer, weren't informed of it either.
an individual is free to hire someone to go and pick up food from a restaurant on their behalf
They are commercially advertising names, logos, menus, etc not taking random orders from people.But yes, in principle they can get into trouble for using trademarks and logos without authorization (menus are fair game), although I suppose it is fair use to mention the names of the restaurants they can pick up food from. Going after them for that shows that they are not doing anything unlawful by running their intermediary service if this is the only thing the restaurants hope might stick.
My counterpoint is that I don't believe that there is anything wrong with that or that permission is needed. Of course as long as there is no misrepresentation, which may indeed be an issue here.
If you think otherwise I'm happy to hear your argument...
• Gruhub tells consumers it’s working cooperatively with restaurants
• Grubhub decides to add unaffiliated restaurants to its website and mobile apps without the restaurants’ permission
• Grubhub’s unauthorized use of restaurants’ names and logos misleads consumers and harms restaurants
• Restaurants have good reasons for choosing not to work with Grubhub
◦ Grubhub knows restaurants don’t want its business and tells drivers to disguise their affiliation with Grubhub
◦ Consumers continue to believe restaurants on Grubhub are working cooperatively with Grubhub
◦ Customer confusion leads to poor experiences that hurt restaurants’ hard-earned reputations
◦ Grubhub diverts and impairs demand for local restaurants
• Grubhub knows it is harming restaurants and uses that harm to force restaurants into unwanted partnerships
[1] https://www.classlawgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/Grubhub-Cla...