News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by alangibson on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:42AM (#24920080)
It's always good to see someone take a big swing and try something new, but I'd love to hear the VC case for this service. I have trouble believing that 1) many people will want this 2) churn rate won't be murderous.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:08PM (#24920453)
Hey - I really appreciate the sentiments on the swing we are taking. Regarding your on point concerns — I gotta share that we felt the very much the same before launching beyond friends and family.

Thus far (and, admittedly, it's early days), we are growing organically. When people are interview guests for an Artifact or listen to Artifacts involving, friends, family, or colleagues, they are becoming customers.

In this way, people are telling us that they can see a "constellation" of Artifacts around them and the people in their lives — and that they'll add to it over time. So, we might do an annual Artifact interview with your child from age 9 to 18, capturing their voice and their thoughts, and then you might sit for an Artifact with colleagues as a send off before leaving for a job, capturing that work together. You also might use Artifact to capture family heritage - with parents, aunts/uncles, and grandparents, and do so incrementally over time, etc.

So yeah, early days but this is what we are seeing. We'll be keeping our heads down, focused on providing quality service day in and day out.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by alangibson on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:11PM (#24920493)
I can definitely see the value. Definitely not trying to shoot at your business, just honestly curious.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:13PM (#24920527)
100%. We have a ton to learn and figure out about engaging customers over the long haul. Absolutely don't have all the answers today. Really appreciate the curiosity!
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by jdamon96 on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:54AM (#24920252)
My quick thoughts on a VC case: it's a $100M revenue company at ~500k sales / year. There's apparently 144M podcast listeners in the US, so you need 0.34% of that population to purchase your product each year. That may be an aggressive assumption, but investors also may think 'podcasts are a huge and growing market, even if this idea isn't the one that works out, there's a lot of potential in the "podcast creation" space'
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by alangibson on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:09PM (#24920459)
At $175 for one podcast, I guess that's a pretty health number even if you mostly have people ordering them as birthday presents and for family reunions.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:30PM (#24920760)
That's right. We are seeing that an event like an anniversary, birthday, reunion, starting the school year, is a reliable trigger into that first episode for a family or friend group, and then that group creates additional episodes organically from there.

I'll also say that (and this is off in the future), that we hope to bring this per episode price point down as we streamline ops. We really want our service to be accessible to all. Not there yet.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by vbordo on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:56PM (#24921121)
I really like this idea. I'm unfamiliar with podcasting overhead in a marketplace model. What can you streamline to reduce episode prices?
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @01:10PM (#24921340)
Thanks for support! To your question: The core interview itself will remain consistent, but we do see opportunities around streamlining the match of the interviewer to the interview guest, scheduling, providing a rock solid remote recording set up for interviewers, and the edit.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:24PM (#24920665)
Nice analysis! I should also share that since launching in June, we've felt fortunate to serve customers across five continents. We'll definitely focus on the US as our initial market, but it's been exciting to see the potential appetite internationally.

I also like to think about podcasting as the "modern" medium for oral history and story creation. At its core, we think about Artifact as a service that makes it easier to go deep - and it just so happens that this podcast interview setting seems to be a good way to do that.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by CosmicShadow on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:07PM (#24920432)
Seems like something that could spread like wildfire via word of mouth with people where word of mouth actually matters most and works the best.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @12:12PM (#24920509)
Hey - So you're spot on. See my comment above. This is what we are observing thus far and what we plan to focus on going forward. We just want to focus on the core experience and letting the product speak for itself among friends and family.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ponker on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @04:53PM (#24924018)
Why does a service need a "VC case?"
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @06:06PM (#24924645)
Agree. It doesn't. We think about investment (of any type - including reinvesting revenue) in pretty simple terms: As a means to support our goal of making Artifact available to people who can benefit from our service.

If a "VC case" ends up supporting that goal, great. If not, so be it.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ponker on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @06:17PM (#24924741)
Please don't go and do something crazy to pursue some kind of Forbes Magazine exit... "what if we did Artifact, but for the corporate training market." or VC bullshit. This is a genuinely important company to exist and you can make millions or tens of millions dollars doing it, I hope no VC invests to try to get billions out of it.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by netsharc on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @05:02PM (#24924112)
For a snarky response, if the aim is to have a VC exit, the 5th minute of the artifact would be, "This artifact is brought to you by [Square Space|Harry's|MeUndies]"...
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @06:11PM (#24924691)
Hey - I don't take that as snarky at all! Totally fair point. See my comment above about how our team is thinking about investment.
Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by subpixel on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @05:51PM (#24924525)
I'm not particularly high on the DIY scale but this just screams do it yourself. Record Zoom calls with my mother's closest friends? Edit that together with some punchy music? Match to a slideshow? Share on any service I want?

All that is both pretty straightforward and fun. If I hire Artifact to do this for several hundred dollars, I've essentially paid someone else to have the fun.

I may be an outlier but this inspires me to do something, not to buy something.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @07:35PM (#24925411)
This is really important feedback. Thank you. We actually think about what we are building as very much "Do-It-For-You".

Your feedback is making me think that we're not doing a great job of making clear the importance of the role of the professional interviewer in what we create for our customers.

Separate from the important logistical aspects of our service that other contributors mention on the thread, our customers continue to share with us that the role of the professional interviewer is just really important.

This space that gets created between professional interviewer and guest makes it possible for the guest to go beyond that first question about, say, the relationship between two people, and get much deeper into particular periods in each others lives when that relationship has really mattered, and also sharing makes sharing lighter moments a lot of fun.

I'll just say that the art and skill of the follow up question is real.

I'd also say that if reading a bit about what we are up to inspires you to interview your mother's closest friends about her and their relationships, that means a lot to me and please go for it. Also, let us know how we can help!

Feel free to email me with any questions you might have as to how to best set things up: [email protected]

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by mgkimsal on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @06:53PM (#24925107)
> Record Zoom calls with my mother's closest friends?

Will they necessarily talk to you, based on the relationship with your mother? Outsiders can often get info from people they wouldn't share with family members.

> All that is both pretty straightforward and fun.

Not for most people, and not with any reasonable assurance you'll get something 'good' at the end. Even scheduling time between multiple people can be a deal breaker. The OP had posted there never felt like a 'good time' to do it.

Asking good questions, prompting people who aren't great (nerves, whatever) can all add a lot of stress to the process.

I think you're probably a bit of an outlier. If it works for you, great, but... I know far more people that want the end result of something like this than have the time to do it.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @07:38PM (#24925430)
Thank you for effectively addressing a number of the important aspects of our service.

I really appreciate.

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by achillesheels on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @06:58PM (#24925143)
I think there are many people that consider your "fun" toil. There are some people that, when presented with the opportunity, will pay to have their story be told :)

I think it is a great idea for a product to be spec'ed into family lore :)

Re:Launch HN: Artifact (YC S20) – Personal podcasts with the... by ross_chanin on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @07:40PM (#24925441)
Thank you for the sentiments! And I agree, there are many people who do prefer to DIY - and we are going to think about how to bring that into our product as well. We also look forward to serving those who like us to "Do It For You".