News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Perfect Pitch Ear Training by amelius on Friday October 23, 2020 @05:56PM (#24874691)
> My mom has perfect pitch, and I do not. I can play a record and move the pitch knob to make it play a bit fast, and it will bother her enough to get up off the couch and change it back.

This makes me wonder why someone would want to have perfect pitch.

Re:Show HN: Perfect Pitch Ear Training by biggieshellz on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:48PM (#24875626)
I have a friend who's a trumpet player who has it. He can lay in bed and write out an arrangement, whereas most of us mere mortals would need to reference a piano or a guitar.

Other than that, it's mostly a cool parlor trick. The best story I've heard of someone who had it is that of Woody Shaw, the great jazz trumpet player. A piano player tried to test him on it once, and played a bunch of different chord voicings -- Woody correctly identified all the notes in each of them. Then, to up the challenge, the piano player played a random cluster of notes. Woody listed them all out, and the piano player replied, "Wrong," thinking he had finally stumped him. Then Woody replied, "Now take every note I just said down by a half step." Of course, Woody got them all right, and everybody's mind was blown.

Re:Show HN: Perfect Pitch Ear Training by amelius on Saturday October 24, 2020 @06:51AM (#24878341)
> He can lay in bed and write out an arrangement, whereas most of us mere mortals would need to reference a piano or a guitar.

Why wouldn't that be the case with someone who can "only" hear relative pitch? I mean, you start writing a note and from then on all other notes are relative to that note, where the actual pitch (in Hz) doesn't really matter.

Re:Show HN: Perfect Pitch Ear Training by kelnos on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:12PM (#24874842)
Right. It's perhaps useful if you're a musician (though I'd argue having relative pitch is much more useful), but otherwise it just feels like an annoyance that will reduce your enjoyment of many everyday musical things.