It's not SV money ruining these cities - it's local restrictive zoning laws that limit the construction of new property, while driving up the price of new construction and existing construction.
Denver, Boulder, and Golden ALL have implemented severe growth caps:
From Attempt to emulate Boulder 1% growth limit across Front Range stirs controversy (Denver Post) [0]:
> Since Boulder in 1976 instituted a 2% limit on dwelling unit increases in city limits, the idea has proliferated. The city revised it down to 1% in 1995, the same year Hayes said he pushed a growth limit of the same rate into effect in Golden. This summer, Lakewood voters approved an almost identical municipal law local officials are in the process of implementing.
SV money isn't ruining cities. Their own city councils and legislators are catastrophically mis-managing their cities.
There is plenty of space for everyone who wants to live somewhere, if you let price signals coordinate a desire for various locations with an ability to pay to consume more or less land area.
I'm starting to build momentum for a fix in Golden, CO, but it sure feels like a long slog.
[0]: https://www.denverpost.com/2019/11/16/boulder-1-percent-grow...
San Francisco is perhaps the worst, but these problems are widespread.
> City councils legally prohibit landowners from adding dwelling units to their own property.
Remember - all this "pent up" demand for housing is a result of homeowners being denied permission to modify their own property.
Historically, all cities evolved from fields because landowners incrementally upgraded their own property, when the price of rents justified additional improvements.
In the 1920s, city councils gave themselves permission to prevent property modifications "for planning purposes", and the US Supreme Court never struck it down.
The early goals of zoning were explicitly laid out by the mayor of Atlanta in 1922[0], with gems like:
Zoning will keep the apartments out of the private house sections. The coming of the apartment drives out the private home.
And: The residence districts are further subdivided into three race districts:
R1 or white residence district.
R2 or colored residence district.
R3 or undetermined race district.
The above race zoning is essential in the in interest of the public peace, order and security and will promote the welfare and prosperity of both the white and colored race. Care has been taken to prevent discrimination and to provide adequate space for the expansion of the housing areas of each race without encroaching on the areas now occupied by the other.
Nearly every US city still has R1, R2, and R3 zoning, though of course no one includes the racial element anymore.I gave a high-level overview/rant on zoning, racism, and Denver here: https://twitter.com/josh_works/status/1294726871574179840
My next order of business is to help other non-out-of-state-developers start moving to Golden.
Along the way I want to make golden become a more affordable place to live, and also an even more desirable place to live.
(I know - it's a tall order.)
I've been connecting with folks who live (or want to live) in the area.
Feel free to send me a message (email, twitter, whatever) and I'll try to help you in this goal!
I'd much rather you move in than some rich out-of-state-er who's working on their second vacation home.
Can you go into more details? I feel like this is a dangerous kind of statement because it is hard to draw a line for people to say what shouldn't and should be.
Here is why the statement feels dangerous, it doesn't make arguments directly related to the group and can easily be expanded to: "But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when [people of color, poor people, lacking education, etc] move in. It shouldn't be that way."
Perspective is always valuable even applied to what would be the unpopular opinions.
When poor people move in they don't have the resources to tell everyone else what to do and they don't tend to pick fights with whoever is there first. When rich people move in they get the government to cater to them and local laws change, often to the point where what was previously normal behavior (burning brush, discharging guns within city limits) is no longer even legal. They often pick fights with the local businesses ("I don't like how that second generation pig farm I knowingly bought property adjacent to smells" or they complain about the environmental impact of some third generation junkyard not because it's not folowing the law but because they find it unsighl). Furthermore they co-opt locals with their money. People who genuinely hate all the other changes they bring bury their heads in the sand because the newcomers are spending more money at their business (or whatever) until it finally negatively affects them personally.
I would much, much, much rather have poor people move in than the white collar crowd because the former has bigger problems than me and the people around me Doing It Wrong(TM).
Entitlement is people with money thinking they can and should be able to change existing communities to their liking, just because they have money.
It's weird, but there seems to be a common blind spot about certain kinds of wealth-enabled antisocial behavior.
I guess you could do preferential tax policy but that almost requires high taxes as a prerequisite which is a non-starter in a lot of places.
I don't think something like that necessarily needs to be some kind of constitutional mechanism. It could be a social norm, kinda like the ones that discourage people from casually insulting others and which punish them if they do.
Though I suppose if you're looking for a constitutional mechanism, clearly defined but longish residency requirements for voting probably wouldn't fall under the category of "voter suppression" (which I take to mean policies designed to indirectly disenfranchise certain kinds of voters for partisan political advantage).
Until The Great Migration happens (or something like it), and suddenly the long residency requirements look precisely like racism ... unless, of course, you've had the in place for 300 years already.
I think that voting is among the least significant of the acts of "new arrivals", particularly if they have money.
> I don't know what it is. I don't know how to fix it. But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when richer people move in. It shouldn't be that way.
Definitely agree. I live in Salt Lake City, and we're seeing the same thing here. A large part of it is failing to adapt to the local culture. I don't think it is just a growth thing, since Utah's population has been growing rapidly for a while due to the high Mormon population and it's only been recently, when the composition of new residents has changed that problems have started to surface.
Did you mean to link an example of that with the [0]? I'm curious to read about that.
As just one example, I'll take homelessness. Utah did so well with solving its homelessness crises until recently that you would find articles in Bloomberg, NYT, etc., asking "will Utah be the first state to solve homelessness?", stuff like that. The reason Utah was so good at dealing with homelessness was a strong coupling between the Mormon church providing social services, the police departments being lenient with the homeless, and the local governments helping to redirect the homeless to the church (social) services. When a new mayor was elected and a new person became police chief this balance was shaken up and the whole system came apart, so now our homelessness problem is about as bad as everywhere else.
For what it's worth, I'm not from Utah originally, I'm not religious at all, feel no desire to be so, and was never Mormon, though I have gone to a couple of their church services as a guest. So these are just my observations and I'm trying to be as fair as possible in giving them.
> When a new mayor was elected and a new person became police chief this balance was shaken up and the whole system came apart, so now our homelessness problem is about as bad as everywhere else.
You listed 3 reasons, 2 of which has to do with the church, the third reason changed with new mayor, so now it all fell apart?
What happeneded to the mormon social services? Were they not successful without the local government redirecting people to the church services (which should be illegal?, separation of church and state)
"which should be illegal" - is exactly an example of the coastal attitudes that are disrupting a very well ordered, high trust society. Consider that this state basically solved the homeless problem by violating a sacred principle which, fully expressed in coastal cities, neither seems to actually help the homeless nor the residents around them. It's possible that the firewall between civic and religious institutions isn't a universal evil.
"Separation of Church and State" being a sacred principle is quite ironic.
I think one of the biggest political problems in the US right now is the fixation on dogma for its own sake. It's happening all over the political spectrum and predictably leads to the dysfunction of polarization (where factional dogmas conflict) or dysfunction of purity (where there's little dogmatic conflict, because the dogmas are always incomplete). We're probably overdue for an era of pragmatic compromise.
Now if they were busing them over and unloading them directly in the waiting hands of the church, without consent, then that sounds less like independent organizations.
I don't think it is illegal for the government to redirect people to faith based charities, any more than it would be illegal to redirect them to secular charities, however, I am not a lawyer.
Like what?
>The write-ups of westerners working from Bali goes into a bit of this. Yes, it adds to the local economy. No, not always in constructive ways. Feeding young egos desire for european beer and fixing their skateboard falls costs time feeding local kids in schools and providing primary health care in a stretched local economy which is 10x lower down the scale.
You're being far too nice by choosing the example of a digital nomad living in Bali.
A much closer to home and harder to ignore example is what SV money has done to places like Denver, Boulder and is doing to Boise.
I don't know what it is. I don't know how to fix it. But there's some very, very, very wrong stuff that happens when richer people move in. It shouldn't be that way.
And before any east-coasters or Mid-westerners start laughing, NYC money is doing a very good job destroying upstate, PA and VT. Masshole money is crapping all over NH and ME. Chicago is slowly eating more and more of Wisconsin and Michigan. This is a relatively universal problem at least in the US.