San Francisco is perhaps the worst, but these problems are widespread.
> City councils legally prohibit landowners from adding dwelling units to their own property.
Remember - all this "pent up" demand for housing is a result of homeowners being denied permission to modify their own property.
Historically, all cities evolved from fields because landowners incrementally upgraded their own property, when the price of rents justified additional improvements.
In the 1920s, city councils gave themselves permission to prevent property modifications "for planning purposes", and the US Supreme Court never struck it down.
The early goals of zoning were explicitly laid out by the mayor of Atlanta in 1922[0], with gems like:
Zoning will keep the apartments out of the private house sections. The coming of the apartment drives out the private home.
And: The residence districts are further subdivided into three race districts:
R1 or white residence district.
R2 or colored residence district.
R3 or undetermined race district.
The above race zoning is essential in the in interest of the public peace, order and security and will promote the welfare and prosperity of both the white and colored race. Care has been taken to prevent discrimination and to provide adequate space for the expansion of the housing areas of each race without encroaching on the areas now occupied by the other.
Nearly every US city still has R1, R2, and R3 zoning, though of course no one includes the racial element anymore.I gave a high-level overview/rant on zoning, racism, and Denver here: https://twitter.com/josh_works/status/1294726871574179840
My next order of business is to help other non-out-of-state-developers start moving to Golden.
Along the way I want to make golden become a more affordable place to live, and also an even more desirable place to live.
(I know - it's a tall order.)
I've been connecting with folks who live (or want to live) in the area.
Feel free to send me a message (email, twitter, whatever) and I'll try to help you in this goal!
I'd much rather you move in than some rich out-of-state-er who's working on their second vacation home.
It's not SV money ruining these cities - it's local restrictive zoning laws that limit the construction of new property, while driving up the price of new construction and existing construction.
Denver, Boulder, and Golden ALL have implemented severe growth caps:
From Attempt to emulate Boulder 1% growth limit across Front Range stirs controversy (Denver Post) [0]:
> Since Boulder in 1976 instituted a 2% limit on dwelling unit increases in city limits, the idea has proliferated. The city revised it down to 1% in 1995, the same year Hayes said he pushed a growth limit of the same rate into effect in Golden. This summer, Lakewood voters approved an almost identical municipal law local officials are in the process of implementing.
SV money isn't ruining cities. Their own city councils and legislators are catastrophically mis-managing their cities.
There is plenty of space for everyone who wants to live somewhere, if you let price signals coordinate a desire for various locations with an ability to pay to consume more or less land area.
I'm starting to build momentum for a fix in Golden, CO, but it sure feels like a long slog.
[0]: https://www.denverpost.com/2019/11/16/boulder-1-percent-grow...