I don't think it will have any effect on privacy. The hackers say they will delete the data, but how can you trust them?
Then again you have people who do it just for the lulz (err...meows?) -> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23957510
We've banned voluntary actions with externalities in the past.
>Making it illegal for them to pay just means that they can't look after that interest. Why would that be a good thing to do?
You only have the criminal's word to stand on when they claim to delete data. It's far too easy to simply hang on the to troves of collected data and wait for a rainy day.
I believe this is discussed in Schelling's book "Strategy of Conflict", which I've never read but has been much discussed online[1]. Indeed the article I've linked specifically mentions this case.
[1] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/tJQsxD34maYw2g5E4/thomas-c-s...
Whether or not trusting the judgement of administrators over the judgement of law enforcement is the best way to handle these situations is an open question.
I'm not sure I trust public university administrators to do much beyond stimulate the local construction economy and wider investment banking industry.
Making it illegal for them to pay just means that they can't look after that interest. Why would that be a good thing to do?