News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by ceilingcorner on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:08AM (#24858171)
The extreme politicization of the ACLU over the last 4 years has really been a big loss for civil liberties. They used to be the ones defending the civil rights of everyone, no matter how heinous the defendant or extreme the situation. These days they seem to just repeat hyper-partisan viewpoints ad infintum.

Does a nonpartisan, alternative organization exist?

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by goatcode on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:21AM (#24858306)
> Does a nonpartisan, alternative organization exist?

If it does, it soon won't. The only permanent home of Liberty is in the individual and families. Organizations become attractive to power-hungry psychopaths when they become effective, and those who gravitate to leadership are skewed toward self-serving. Therefore, compromise and decay are right on the heels of success. Faith in a man-made establishment is a slow escalator to a shallow grave.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by nemo44x on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:12AM (#24858875)
> The only permanent home of Liberty is in the individual and families.

I agree. It has been unfortunate to see the attacks on individuality when it's the best way to view each other. Group identity has a long history of being evil and rationalizing inhuman or even dehumanizing treatment of out-groups. Liberty being associated with the individual, not a collective, is the peaceful path I believe.

The grand irony of concepts like intersectionality is that when you slice a person enough ways, you end up with an individual. But that leap just hasn't been made it seems and I assume because there is power to be gained by forming and controlling a collective through the seduction of victimhood and grievance.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:39AM (#24858481)
> They used to be the ones defending the civil rights of everyone, no matter how heinous the defendant or extreme the situation

They still are.

> These days they seem to just repeat hyper-partisan viewpoints ad infintum

Their involvement against broad interpretation of the CFAA in Van Buren v. U.S. doesn't seem hyperpartisan.

Neither does their action in ACLU v. Clearview AI

Neither does Nashville Community Bail Fund v. Gentry

Nor it's involvement in Georgia v. Public.Resource.Org

Sure, right now one party is more actively using the power of government against the rights that the ACLU has always defended, which has a lot do with party ideology (which in both parties have shifted over time so that one aligns morr with and one more against ACLU's long-held positions than used to be the case) and a lot to do with control of the executive branch of government (both federally and in states), without which you can't usually take the kind of government actions that the ACLU defends against.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by vorpalhex on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:56AM (#24858674)
I've stopped donating to the ACLU after being a donor for many years because they have stopped being nonpartisan from what I can tell. This is not only in their cases but their public statements, and it's become very clear they no longer are friends of free speech.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:17AM (#24858917)
> it's become very clear they no longer are friends of free speech.

Well, certainly they aren't a friend of the modern right-wing idea that “free speech” is a positive entitlement to compel other private actors to relay your speech, but they remain zealous defenders of the Constitutional right of free speech against encroachment by government, including against bipartisan assaults like the EARN IT Act.

https://www.aclu.org/news/by-issue/free-speech/

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:27AM (#24859042)
This memo[1] seems to assert that they would not be friends to free speech against encroachment by the government if the speech were speech they didn't like.

[1] http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/20180621ACL...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:19PM (#24859693)
> This memo[1] seems to assert that they would not be friends to free speech against encroachment by the government if the speech were speech they didn't like.

It explicitly says the opposite, but does indicate that they would not be able to legally represent people making such speech if the terms of such representation would restrict the ACLU from criticizing the viewpoint being advanced while defending the right to advance it: "While the ACLU vigorously defends the right to free speech of those who espouse views antithetical to our own, we also reserve our right to condemn those views. Our defense of free speech rests squarely on the proposition that speech deserves defending even if we, or others in the community, find it reprehensible. Accordingly, as a general matter we should be able to simultaneously defend a speaker’s right to speak and condemn their views, and we should seek to preserve that right through ethically appropriate representation agreements. [...] But we generally should not agree to represent people who will not agree to sign an ethically appropriate advance waiver of potential conflicts arising from our condemnation of their views."

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:16PM (#24862831)
I appreciate the correction, but I think it's noteworthy that they expect would-be defendants to waiver away the ACLU's disdain for them as a condition of representation.

Perhaps this is normal in the legal realm?

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:55PM (#24863199)
> Perhaps this is normal in the legal realm?

Yes, informing potential clients of, and conditioning representation on waiver of, a forseeable conflict of interest is generally mandatory for lawyers.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:09PM (#24865363)
Framed as you have it, I would agree...but I always understood a conflict of interest to be one which might compel an attorney to violate your confidence, or fail to keep your confidences sacrosanct.

Publicly stating "we do not agree with the language of our clients" does not seem to me to rise anywhere near the level of that to require waiver.

That said, I take you as more informed on the subject than I, so again I thank you for the information.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:41PM (#24860777)
It seems like people are confused about what non-partisan means. Non-partisan does not mean neutral on political issues. The ACLU has never been neutral on political issues, going back as long as they've existed [1]. Non-partisan means they pursue their vision of civil rights regardless of which party that brings them into conflict with. If they come info conflict with one party more than another, that doesn't make them partisan. It just means that their vision of civil liberties has been taken up more by one party than others.

[1] Just skim their wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_Liberties_Union

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by ceilingcorner on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:45AM (#24858533)
Taking a look at their Twitter, I have a hard time seeing how their viewpoints are anything but hyper-partisan. They often have nothing whatsoever to do with defending civil liberties in a nonpartisan manner.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by UncleMeat on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:08AM (#24858831)
ACLU knows that they've been politicized externally. This messaging is a funding strategy, not necessarily related to their actual legal advocacy.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by ceilingcorner on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:13AM (#24858890)
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:08AM (#24858834)
Can you provide a specific example of what you mean?
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:57PM (#24860198)
For example, they sent a lot of tweets yesterday about preferred pronouns and why you should use them in your personal and professional life. That's a quite controversial message in many circles, and it really has nothing to do with civil liberties, so an organization focused on civil liberties would want to stay neutral on it in order to best promote their core goals.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:36PM (#24860701)
> That's a quite controversial message in many circles

If you think the ACLU has steered clear of controversy historically, you are not very familiar with their history.

> it really has nothing to do with civil liberties

How so? It is about someone's right to exist as themselves without discrimination and be treated equally to others. The ACLU has been involved in LGBT rights since at least the 70s.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by sershe on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:15PM (#24865727)
That is absolutely not the right, not at all. Although I honestly don't give a crap about this particular issue, and would use whatever pronouns people prefer (as long as I don't forget them, as one sometimes does even with names), the civil right is free speech.

Claiming the right of not being offended by speech, to me, is a litmus test for an anti-civil-rights person/organization. Sure, if someone chooses to call everyone "you pitiful worm" it's their right to not associate with the caller, but they have no right whatsoever, and certainly not any kind of civil right, to be called anything else.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Friday October 23, 2020 @03:20PM (#24872849)
You have more than one civil right. It seems like people in this thread are taking civil rights to mean free speech and nothing else, but in fact you have many civil rights, and they may even come into conflict with each other at times.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by sershe on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:22PM (#24876413)
The only way using preferred pronouns could be related to civil rights, though, is as a restriction of free speech. So, either ACLU is tweeting something partisan and unrelated to civil rights, or they are tweeting something that is evidence for them not being fully supportive of cornerstone civil rights (also, partisan).
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:26AM (#24869833)
There’s more than one civil right, no?

Also your example is unrealistic and distorted - it’s not a useful hypothetical because no one is asking anyone to call them something insulting like that as their public form of address.

The fact that the example is an insult makes it different from “they/them”

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by sershe on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:24PM (#24876418)
See sibling response. The example illustrates the principle. My point is that it either has nothing to do with civil rights whatsoever (any, not just speech; if I'm wrong please elaborate), or it is slightly anti-civil-rights, in a way indicative to me of being much more anti-civil-rights than the tweets would let on.

What it is, though, even if it's the right thing to recommend, is partisan.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:01PM (#24887254)
I haven't thought about this too much, but, words are power.

Is identifying someone by a racial slur a civil-rights issue?

Obviously it's not a black-and-white issue, and is complex, but yeah, fundamentally calling someone something they don't want to be called (and I don't mean "your hair is blue / don't tell me my hair is blue") can be a civil rights issue.

Words define our selves. There's a reason jargon is such a big deal in the corporate world - words have power.

Consider this - if it wasn't a civil rights issue, would there be so much discomfort and/or backlash around it? Would it even be a big deal at all if it didn't matter?

Again, I'm not saying it's straightforward - it's not.

But a quick google search says civil rights are "the rights of citizens to political and social freedom and equality."

So that's pretty complex and broad in and of itself.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by sershe on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:26PM (#24933661)
I think it only looks complex because of halo effect/lack of clarity... you want to call it a civil right because it feels like a good thing. I am not saying it's not a good thing, but I am saying it's not a civil right. Like, it's good if everyone had affordable health care, but it's not a civil right.

There are also tons of issues that are not civil rights that have lots of backlash/noise around them (like healthcare).

In fact, in this case enforcement of any kind (outside of the private contract-based context like the office) would be quite obviously anti-civil-rights, which is a bummer with civil rights - sometimes, they inconvenience other people. Remember that being right and being wrong feels the same way. There are tons of people who would be very offended at you for all kinds of bogus reasons, like that you don't go to church, or are friendly with gay people, or whatever.

So yeah, if ACLU is about civil rights, it should focus on those. If it's going to pontificate that it's good to use certain pronouns, of for everyone to go to church, or whatever, then I'll take my money somewhere else :)

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:07PM (#24861167)
Civil liberties are liberties that you have from the government. That is, things that the government ought to allow you to do. So debates over whether suchandsuch interpersonal practice is polite just aren't issues of civil liberties, even if the people discussing such practices have related civil rights concerns. (It'd make perfect sense, for example, if the ACLU said that you ought to be able to put whatever letter you'd like in the "gender" field of your driver's license.)
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:24AM (#24869815)
> Civil liberties are liberties that you have from the government. That is, things that the government ought to allow you to do.

What do you think the ACLU did in the 60s? Not fight segregation where it was legal?

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by jahaja on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:30PM (#24861504)
So because one party has a problem with intolerance, promoting these things breaks the non-partisan label? Seems a bit like being non-partisan is an end in itself.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:22PM (#24863439)
It's just a thing you have to do in order to effectively achieve non-partisan goals. An organization that picks a side on every political battle in the country won't be able to effectively focus on its core mission.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by jahaja on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:31PM (#24863510)
That suggests that an organizations value system should follow along with a moving target - the current mid-ground - rather than their own values. At some point one party may just sway too far to accept a middle ground.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:46PM (#24863644)
Being non-partisan isn't about seeking out a middle ground and planting yourself there. It's about saying "you know, there's a lot of strongly held beliefs on this issue, and we're not the right organization to reconcile them".

It's the same principle as being a non-religious organization. If the ACLU went around telling people that accepting Jesus as your lord and savior is the most important liberty, I suspect you'd agree that's very strange - even though many devout Christians do hold that position and think it's important.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:29AM (#24869864)
Example - white supremacy is not a “strongly held belief” to those who believe in universal human rights and equality.

My belief system makes white supremacy not some other, legitimate belief I oppose, but one that is beyond the pale because it threatens the core of my belief system (universal human rights and equality).

Since the (current) Republican Party is running on white supremacy ...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by jahaja on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:58PM (#24863749)
But if it's one part of those strongly held beliefs that are simply wrong because they range from intolerance to bigotry, there's nothing non-partisan to make a stand.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:04PM (#24887276)
Maybe the ACLU really does believe it is a civil right.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dnissley on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:20PM (#24860496)
Do border walls have anything to do with civil liberties? https://twitter.com/ACLU/status/1318242920416366593
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:48PM (#24860887)
Sure, they make two arguments: 1) Trump is redirecting funds that were intended by congress for totally different purposes [1]. Doing this is anti-democratic and therefore infringes on your right to determine government policy. 2) Trump is interfering with natural and culturally significant sites that people have a right to. Destroying cultural sites and altering land that was set aside as a national park for preservation for future generations are obviously civil liberties issues.

[1]: https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-comment-supreme-cou...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:22AM (#24869798)
This is an informative cogent response and I was surprised to see it downvoted.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by adamsea on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:20AM (#24869785)
Yes, they do.

If nothing else the fact that you don’t seem to recognize the desire to build a huge wall as one big red authoritarian flag is concerning.

It’s like going on a date with someone who says he’s a nice guy but treats the waitress like shit.

And it’s not only Border Walls it’s Border Patrol / ICE. Which has literally been putting children in cages.

Plus as another poster said it’s not clear that the administration was building this wall in a legal fashion.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by mcv on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:06AM (#24858806)
> "These days they seem to just repeat hyper-partisan viewpoints ad infintum."

But that's only because everything is hyper-partisan these days. Even science. Or facts. Or the idea of an objective reality. It's impossible to be non-political in this kind of political landscape.

And civil liberties have always been political to some extent.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by ceilingcorner on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:08AM (#24858826)
I don't really agree with this take and I think it's highly over-simplified. The ACLU used to be the organization that defended the really unpleasant people and popularized ideas like, "I disagree with what you say, but I will defend your right to say it." They had a lot of responsibility.

Today they are basically indistinguishable from Huffington Post with a law firm attached.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:48AM (#24859298)
Can you give an example? As far as I know, they're still defending the free speech rights of the Far Right, famously including in the Unite the Right rally [1].

[1]: https://www.aclu.org/news/civil-liberties/the-short-life-and...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by ffdjjjffjj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#24859185)
Come on, that’s bordering on the kind of contentless dismissal you see in right wing propaganda today. Someone already provided examples contradicting your assertions, and others have accurately explained that defending civil rights appears political because, in fact, one political party tends to oppose protections of civil rights more than the other. Rather than doubling down on blithe, unsupported assertions, you should demonstrate that you are here in good faith by either responding to the fair criticisms or admitting you’re wrong.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by whatshisface on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:18AM (#24858275)
I wonder whether the problem is with finding nonpartisan donors, or nonpartisan charity leaders, of if there's plenty of both but partisan forces work subversively.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by sershe on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:09PM (#24865690)
I've canceled my ACLU membership and stopped donating a couple years ago, but it's really hard to get off their email lists. This year after receiving some emails that made my blood boil, I've actually done some research and now donate to Institute for Justice and Foundation for Individual Rights in Education - these are the reputable public interest law firms I could find; and also Reason Foundation, Foundation for Economic Education, and Cato Institute, that I think are all tangentially related.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by brennanpeterson on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:33AM (#24858430)
This has been said for the history of the ACLU. And there are difficult balances there: do you defend the Nazi March? What if that March includes armed marchers aiming guns at others? Is aiming a gun speech? Or speech the ACLU has interest in defending? Does it maximize the freedom for marchers, counter marchers, or citizens?

The ACLU had to come to terms with consequences, and harder answers. After defending and enabling a march where people died, the ACLU had to answer whether it was responsible...and it was.

So the organization is a bit different, but I am not so sure that the ACLU could have continued. It had avoided really hard problems, and then had to come to terms with it.

I prefer it this way: it is messy and tricky and also much less likely to be a disaster.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by HideousKojima on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:39AM (#24858484)
Aiming guns at people is already illegal under brandishing laws. The ACLU has refused to support any armed demonstration
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by whatshisface on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:44AM (#24858527)
That's an interesting example of how partisan-seeming biases can develop inadvertently. There may be an objective reason why the ACLU doesn't support armed demonstrations, but there's only one side that likes to bring guns to their protests, so in practice this only cancels support for one side. Reminds me of the "anyone is equally free to marry a person of the opposite gender" response to gay people having the same rights.

The ACLU may or may not want to support armed demonstrations, but if they want "docket diversity," they'd pragmatically have to loosen that rule, perhaps to "we don't support demonstrations where weapons were fired," or even, "we defend demonstrators in all cases except when they admit to specifically trying to shoot someone," or something like that.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by leetcrew on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:55AM (#24858664)
> There may be an objective reason why the ACLU doesn't support armed demonstrations, but there's only one side that likes to bring guns to their protests, so in practice this only cancels support for one side.

is this true? I can think of at least one recent event in kenosha where people on both "sides" had guns.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:25PM (#24859778)
It's mostly true... so far.

Although some elements of antifa are perfectly willing to use projectile weapons. Those are less dangerous than guns, but they aren't nothing.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by vorpalhex on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:00AM (#24858715)
> but there's only one side that likes to bring guns to their protests

NFAC [1], Pro-BLM Protestors in Austin [2] and that was after a protestor brandished his AK at an uber driver and the uber driver shot him (so we had armed protestors before that as well).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_Fucking_Around_Coalition

[2] https://www.kvue.com/article/news/local/protests/austin-prot...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:14AM (#24858901)
> There may be an objective reason why the ACLU doesn't support armed demonstrations

They flatly do not believe that firearm ownership is an individual right, rather that it is a collective right. This used to be plainly displayed on their website, but I'm having troubles finding it now, and perhaps that narrative has been challenged internally as certain chapters of the ACLU (Nevada comes to mind) have begun recognizing it as an individual right.

Moreover, arms rights challenges that could spur ACLU action haven't ever really come to fruition, such as a ban on arms sales to individuals on the no-fly list for example.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bumby on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:07AM (#24858820)
>do you defend the Nazi March

In the past they would [1]. I'm not convinced they would do so today.

[1] https://www.aclu.org/other/aclu-history-taking-stand-free-sp...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:24AM (#24858995)
They did recently (2017/2018) defend Milo Yiannopoulis' right to advertise his event in the DC metro, but after pushback related to that, they've softened their stance in a lot of ways, carving out exceptions, for example they have stated they would not defend the right of "hate groups" to march if they were armed, and stated in a memo[1] that they should no longer defend the right to speech against marginalized groups.

[1] http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/20180621ACL...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bumby on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:05PM (#24859510)
Thank you, that was enlightening. Among their considerations,

"the potential effect on marginalized communities; the extent to which the speech may assist in advancing the goals of white supremacists or others whose views are contrary to our values;"

It sounds like maybe they've adjusted their "unwavering commitment to the principle of free speech"

"That’s because the defense of freedom of speech is most necessary when the message is one most people find repulsive. Constitutional rights must apply to even the most unpopular groups if they’re going to be preserved for everyone."

[1] https://www.aclu.org/issues/free-speech