News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by vorpalhex on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:56AM (#24858674)
I've stopped donating to the ACLU after being a donor for many years because they have stopped being nonpartisan from what I can tell. This is not only in their cases but their public statements, and it's become very clear they no longer are friends of free speech.
Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:17AM (#24858917)
> it's become very clear they no longer are friends of free speech.

Well, certainly they aren't a friend of the modern right-wing idea that “free speech” is a positive entitlement to compel other private actors to relay your speech, but they remain zealous defenders of the Constitutional right of free speech against encroachment by government, including against bipartisan assaults like the EARN IT Act.

https://www.aclu.org/news/by-issue/free-speech/

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:27AM (#24859042)
This memo[1] seems to assert that they would not be friends to free speech against encroachment by the government if the speech were speech they didn't like.

[1] http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/20180621ACL...

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:19PM (#24859693)
> This memo[1] seems to assert that they would not be friends to free speech against encroachment by the government if the speech were speech they didn't like.

It explicitly says the opposite, but does indicate that they would not be able to legally represent people making such speech if the terms of such representation would restrict the ACLU from criticizing the viewpoint being advanced while defending the right to advance it: "While the ACLU vigorously defends the right to free speech of those who espouse views antithetical to our own, we also reserve our right to condemn those views. Our defense of free speech rests squarely on the proposition that speech deserves defending even if we, or others in the community, find it reprehensible. Accordingly, as a general matter we should be able to simultaneously defend a speaker’s right to speak and condemn their views, and we should seek to preserve that right through ethically appropriate representation agreements. [...] But we generally should not agree to represent people who will not agree to sign an ethically appropriate advance waiver of potential conflicts arising from our condemnation of their views."

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:16PM (#24862831)
I appreciate the correction, but I think it's noteworthy that they expect would-be defendants to waiver away the ACLU's disdain for them as a condition of representation.

Perhaps this is normal in the legal realm?

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:55PM (#24863199)
> Perhaps this is normal in the legal realm?

Yes, informing potential clients of, and conditioning representation on waiver of, a forseeable conflict of interest is generally mandatory for lawyers.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by bmelton on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:09PM (#24865363)
Framed as you have it, I would agree...but I always understood a conflict of interest to be one which might compel an attorney to violate your confidence, or fail to keep your confidences sacrosanct.

Publicly stating "we do not agree with the language of our clients" does not seem to me to rise anywhere near the level of that to require waiver.

That said, I take you as more informed on the subject than I, so again I thank you for the information.

Re:Civil Liberties in Times of Crisis [pdf] by notJim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:41PM (#24860777)
It seems like people are confused about what non-partisan means. Non-partisan does not mean neutral on political issues. The ACLU has never been neutral on political issues, going back as long as they've existed [1]. Non-partisan means they pursue their vision of civil rights regardless of which party that brings them into conflict with. If they come info conflict with one party more than another, that doesn't make them partisan. It just means that their vision of civil liberties has been taken up more by one party than others.

[1] Just skim their wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_Liberties_Union