News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by gottebp on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:16AM (#24854821)
Her last letter, written the night before she was executed, is so tender and touching; revealing a very different person from what we were generally taught [1]. The French Revolution was no exception to "History is written by the victors."

[1] https://teaattrianon.blogspot.com/2007/05/last-letter-of-mar...

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by peignoir on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:55AM (#24855524)
I’m French too and never read this letter before. But I don’t see much difference in the letter with who she was. She s just saying goodbye and ask for redemption as any catholic would. I don’t agree with the article who tries to focus on her personality and manner. She was wether she liked it out not a ruler, the French did not kill her and the king because of their manners and their personality (the king was a nice guy too) They did because of the course of history and because so many were suffering at the time and a greater effort was asked from them (paying debt / while Marie Antoinette kept burning cash)

It was awful and bloody and many revolutionary were awful people uneducated and prompt to bloodbath. But it soon inspired so many nations to move towards democracy that sometimes if not always history shows that awful people can build great things (pirates in New York etc..)

I remember she hated Lafayette for example to put some USA perspective she must have hated Washington too.

Rulers should be judged indeed on victory or defeat this current fashion of looking back at history to say individuals had good or bad personalities is dangerously capable of transforming the worst people into adorable ones.

Her story is the story of the Romanov in Russia or the Shah in Iran. People who loved to party and who had great education would be people You would love to hang out with today for sure.

But they did so while their own people were on the verge of collapsing... I don’t see a parallel with Hillary neither, if Hillary was burning millions of dollars when her husband was in power and partying all the time in the poorest city with people dying in the street then you would have had Marie Antoinette but Hillary acted as a ruler and worked hard to help her country (wether you like her politics or not)

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by Tainnor on Thursday October 22, 2020 @08:41AM (#24857367)
How many nations became democracies specifically because of the French Revolution?

I would argue that in many cases, the French Revolution might have had the opposite effect. Everyone was so scared of another reign of terror and the devastating revolutionary and Napoleonic wars that it directly led to the conservatism of Metternich and supported the conservative crackdowns in 1848. Monarchism in much of Europe - except France - was abolished after WWI, not after the French Revolution.

In the places where democracy was later established - say, Latin America - I think the US were much more of an influence than France.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by pasabagi on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:10AM (#24858193)
I think the french revolution turned republicanism and nationalism from fringe idea into mainstays of european political thought. I'm not sure if those trends led to democracy, but they certainly led to a democratization - even with the crackdowns and Metternich, if you count the number of states with e.g. a constitution, europe was more democratic after 1848 than it was before it, not less.

The revolutionary wars were devastating, but they also demonstrated the power of a republican state - a sort of power that even reactionaries (e.g. Bismark) wanted to harness.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by Tainnor on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:55AM (#24858668)
For sure I don't want to diminish the importance of the French Revolution, which is probably the single most important event in the span between 1700-1900. I just question that its influence necessarily was that of establishing democracy.

As for after 1848, I don't think that Europe was much more democratic than before 1789 (except for France, and the second republic was kind of DOA anyway). More states did have a constitution (in comparison to 1789, not necessarily to before 1848), so there was maybe a little bit more protection against absolute tyranny, but that doesn't necessarily mean that there was much effective parliamentary participation.

Although I will admit that the idea of liberalism was definitely in the air and maybe it wouldn't have been without the French Revolution, but that's hard to say (as said, the USA were always more of a poster child because their republic actually lasted).

I'm not sure if the revolutionary wars demonstrated the power of republicanism as much as they demonstrated the power of nationalism to someone like Bismarck, and nationalism is definitely something that was heavily influenced by the French Revolution.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by pasabagi on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:23AM (#24858993)
I think maybe I was thinking of 'the democracy' as a by-word for 'modern european state'. On second thought, this isn't all that reasonable. I think the modern european state is nationalist first, liberal second, and democratic (usually) as a distant third - that is, in order of how likely any characteristic is to break down under pressure.

It feels to me if you look at the trajectory from the start of the french revolution to the modern european state, even in periods of reaction, the arrow doesn't really turn much. Reactionaries usually see the advantages of nationalism, bourgeois the advantages of liberalism, and workers the advantages of democracy - and all of the three trends get reversed at points, but if you sum them, then it's a pretty steady gain. For instance, while the dissolution of the Frankfurt parliment was a blow against democracy, I think it probably pushed nationlism forward by putting so much power in Prussian hands.

So I'd credit the French Revolution with spawning and intensively testing the triad of political views that have ended up being totally dominant in Europe - you're right that this triad is not identical with democracy, but I think it is identical with what we generally call democracy in Europe today.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by speedgoose on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:44AM (#24855243)
I'm French and I think I read this letter at school before, not 100% sure it's a long time ago, but I remember learning about her correctly. We do learn about the atrocities before, during, and after the revolution. And no one is only good or bad. History is not a Disney movie.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:19AM (#24855378)
It might be that non-french learn about it less. I grew in post-communist block and French Revolution was basically "good peasants rose up for libertee fraternite and egualite, against bad aristocracy".

That is however not French victors writing history, it is more of foreign Communists writing history.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by TheTrueTDF on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:02AM (#24855555)
I would like to point out that we also are taught that "good peasants rose up for liberte fraternite and egualite, against bad aristocracy" (is there a good aristocracy ?), but we are taught of the massacres and other bad aspects too.

The revolution is still a founding moment of the french "identity", and apart from a few late-to-the-party 2020's monarchists, we pretty much all believe that we did the right thing by kicking out the nobility.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:04AM (#24855856)
We were not taught massacres and such is the difference I mean. That Robespierre was not like "good guy" or that French Revolution is actually completely complicated event with many fighting parties was completely unsaid.

There was French Revolution and then was the freedom and happiness, basically.

> is there a good aristocracy

I think that feudalism is fundamentally bad. But, I think that answer to this question is yes, there are non-evil aristocrats. Aristocracy is class you get born into, set of duties and privileges. Aristocracy holds power and have interests opposed to those who live under them. The image where all individuals belonging to that group are basically ugly and evil is not correct. It is not like all the the tortured and executed aristocrats deserved that.

And then there is question of huge amount of non-aristocratic victims of revolution which went completely unmentioned in our version of history.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by stareatgoats on Thursday October 22, 2020 @08:07AM (#24857131)
> I think that feudalism is fundamentally bad.

For the record, I think this is not how one should look at history. We have our current values, but to anachronistically apply these values to whole epochs long gone leads astray IMO.

Personal ethics is another matter, things like greed, dishonesty, callousness, betrayal between equals seem to be held in low regard wherever and whenever we choose to look.

There have been attempts to try and superimpose such personal ethics on grand epochs in history, but it requires a painful shoehorning of personal morals into some square holes where it doesn't belong. It doesn't hold up to serious scrutiny.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:22PM (#24860523)
We are actually allowed to have opinions on past organizations. Both in terms of ethics and in terms of whether this would be practical idea to follow. Also, we are allowed to judge past people.

Also, people are more likely to knee jerkly defend everything for by past important people and see them as unaware victims of circumstances them to judge them. Maybe except Hitler and Stalin.

Sometimes people do superimpose own values inappropriately, but other times those making judgements just know more about actual acts of those people - even including historical context.

Narcissists and sociopaths and what not are not modern phenomenon never heard about before. And their contemporaties for expressed a lot about them.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by edgyquant on Thursday October 22, 2020 @12:48PM (#24860089)
Eh Early (Pre-Charles Martel) feudalism came about as a way for Romans to expand their slave base while pretending they didn’t own slaves.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by me_me_me on Thursday October 22, 2020 @07:19AM (#24856842)
Lets take it to extreme, there were 'not evil' guards in concentration camps. They were just doing their job and minding their own business.

Are they to blame for the holocaust? Well no, but they help to run it.

Aristocracy might not be made up 100% of evil mustache twirling villains, but they benefit from fruits of other's toils.

Lets consider much much milder version of the problem that we can relate.

Nestle was caught buying chocolate from sources using child labor and child slaves. Currently AFAIK only Kitkat is using fair-trade chocolate as a token gesture. Anything else is using chocolate with some fake symbols set up by PR companies funded by nestle et al.

Are you eating their - non kitkat - chocolate product supporting child slavery? Even though you might have done it fully ignorant of the fact. Are you going to buy their stuff knowing that now?

Is it feasible to live in our society and not buy stuff from corporations that do things like that?

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @09:16AM (#24857657)
I see massive difference between concentration camps guard and aristocracy. The big one is that all camps guard have chosen to do that. The guards in death camps were voluntary members of SS - the elite German armed group.

Compared to that, not just that aristocracy is hereditary, but they had duties beyond "kill people". They were backbone of army, yes, but still it is not just that.

I think that making comparison between aristocracy and guards in concentration camps is more of political then actual attempt at reasonale historical analysios.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by me_me_me on Thursday October 22, 2020 @09:44AM (#24857901)
Well I don't think you are being honest. You didn't address the other extreme which is the whole sourcing of chocolate by Nestle.

The point i am trying to flesh out is how much one can be blamed for a big picture. One cannot change the world only affect it in a tiniest way. But when a majority of a group/class are pushing same way they can affect history.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:13AM (#24858229)
I am not being honest because I stopped at addressing nazi guards (which I know a lot about) and did not addressed Nestle (which I dont know much about and would have to do research)?

That is not honest argument, that is absurd accusation.

> The point i am trying to flesh out is how much one can be blamed for a big picture. One cannot change the world only affect it in a tiniest way. But when a majority of a group/class are pushing same way they can affect history.

That was not apparent from your comment. But also, I think that you are using straw idea of aristocracy rather then real societal system as it existed in various periods. The whole thread started with my look at real world historical aristocracy. You used made up nazi guard that was "just doing job" to tilt big picture, but it was not fair comparison.

All this is under article about Marie Antionette who specifically I don't really think was evil.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by me_me_me on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:49AM (#24858595)
I am illustrating the fact that you can be in position of power, and through your unwillingness to give up the privileges of your position or sheer ignorance of others fate, you are still responsible (to lesser or grater degree) for the acts committed by the group/social class you belong to (unless you are actually acting against that).

Direct historical example is the aristocracy of Hungary and Poland. Both undermined and exploited their rulers to extracted privileges and wealth of their respective nations. Resulting in weak states that fall pray to their neighbors.

> All this is under article about Marie Antionette who specifically I don't really think was evil.

I am not arguing she was evil, but that she was guilty of the situation and shouldn't be judged based on how nice she was to people and how great her writing skills were.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#24858792)
> I am not arguing she was evil, but that she was guilty of the situation and shouldn't be judged based on how nice she was to people and how great her writing skills were

I do not believe in guilt based on your birth circumstances. I also think that you are building flippant strawman in "shouldn't be judged based on how nice she was to people and how great her writing skills were".

You dont want to judge people on their actions, you want to build enemies to make it easy to judge people. I am not interested in that. You dont care about what who believed, actually tried to push for and why the old system malfunctioned or was impossible to reform.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by me_me_me on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:44PM (#24860824)
> I do not believe in guilt based on your birth circumstances

Nither do I.

Its not about birth but the action you take or not take.

> You dont want to judge people on their actions, you want to build enemies to make it easy to judge people. I am not interested in that. You dont care about what who believed, actually tried to push for and why the old system malfunctioned or was impossible to reform.

You completely mischarectarise what I say. You use formulations that put words into my mouth

> You dont care about

> You dont want to

This is the definition of building straw-man argument that YOU accuse me of. So maybe read what I write and critique what I wrote and not what you think that I think.

> I also think that you are building flippant strawman in "shouldn't be judged based on how nice she was to people and how great her writing skills were".

This is the definition of judging person by their actions. Just because she was polite and smiling and wrote a tearful letters, it does not make her a good person. I dont care if you believe in Jesus and go to church 3 time a week. If you stab someone to death on the street for giving you 'the look' you should rot in prison.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by coliveira on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:18AM (#24855119)
Her tenderness didn't stop her from exploiting peasants like every other noble at the time. Let's not forget the situation.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by dang on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:45AM (#24855249)
"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Also, let's please not fight the French Revolution here.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by watwut on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:17AM (#24855369)
Old system was fundamentally unfair and dysfunctional, that is true. But, in what way was she personally exploiting peasants? It is not like she would do business or made decisions of this sort, she did not even picked her own husband.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by seibelj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:23AM (#24855141)
I don't think beheading anyone, even a noble who benefited from serfdom, is an outcome we should all praise. Such beliefs will only lead to another horrible period of murder and senseless violence.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by coliveira on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:28AM (#24855164)
I don't praise the means, but the outcome should be celebrated nonetheless. I imagine this was the only way they found to make the revolution stick.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by pjc50 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:58AM (#24855541)
As with the Romanovs, the fear was that so long as the legitimate bloodline existed so did the motivation for putting it back on the throne.

It is difficult to see these things through modern eyes, especially in the human rights era. But we have to remember that hereditary monarchs tended to do this to each other a lot. Of necessity - most of the European rulers were blood relatives; power struggles inevitably meant disputing an inheritance. Antoinette's brother was the Holy Roman Emperor. When he died her nephew lead the invasion of France by Austria.

And the punishment for disloyalty was death. If somehow the Bourbons had restored their position, they would have had all the revolutionary leaders executed. As with the Romanovs. Or Elizabeth I'd execution of her cousin Mary.

Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by seibelj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:36AM (#24855200)
I’m not sure how much you have read up on the French Revolution but the murder and decapitation of Marie Antoinette along with thousands of other people did not solve any problems. This is why all modern democracies do not rely on violence to solve political differences. The Directory is about the worst possible outcome for a revolution you can imagine.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by coliveira on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:42AM (#24855232)
They didn't solve all problems, but they removed a large part of the ruling class of the time. And the French Revolution was the most important popular revolution of the western world, no question about it. Trying to minimize it because of the civil-war that resulted is nonsense.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by seibelj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:56AM (#24855298)
I simply cannot rationalize nor approve of senseless and indiscriminate murder. Such rationalization is what leads to the holocaust. All human life is sacred. I hope you learn to separate politics from violence.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by koheripbal on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:51AM (#24856037)
I wonder how many "ruling class" people you'd be willing to murder to get your way today...
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save... by bergstromm466 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:26AM (#24855153)
This seems like a bad take. Just because it’s slow-violence doesn’t meant it’s not violence or murder to be an exploited starving peasant.