Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by coliveira on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:28AM
(#24855164)
I don't praise the means, but the outcome should be celebrated nonetheless. I imagine this was the only way they found to make the revolution stick.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by pjc50 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:58AM
(#24855541)
As with the Romanovs, the fear was that so long as the legitimate bloodline existed so did the motivation for putting it back on the throne.
It is difficult to see these things through modern eyes, especially in the human rights era. But we have to remember that hereditary monarchs tended to do this to each other a lot. Of necessity - most of the European rulers were blood relatives; power struggles inevitably meant disputing an inheritance. Antoinette's brother was the Holy Roman Emperor. When he died her nephew lead the invasion of France by Austria.
And the punishment for disloyalty was death. If somehow the Bourbons had restored their position, they would have had all the revolutionary leaders executed. As with the Romanovs. Or Elizabeth I'd execution of her cousin Mary.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by seibelj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:36AM
(#24855200)
Iām not sure how much you have read up on the French Revolution but the murder and decapitation of Marie Antoinette along with thousands of other people did not solve any problems. This is why all modern democracies do not rely on violence to solve political differences. The Directory is about the worst possible outcome for a revolution you can imagine.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by coliveira on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:42AM
(#24855232)
They didn't solve all problems, but they removed a large part of the ruling class of the time. And the French Revolution was the most important popular revolution of the western world, no question about it. Trying to minimize it because of the civil-war that resulted is nonsense.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by seibelj on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:56AM
(#24855298)
I simply cannot rationalize nor approve of senseless and indiscriminate murder. Such rationalization is what leads to the holocaust. All human life is sacred. I hope you learn to separate politics from violence.
Re:Why Was She So Hated?: How Marie Antoinette Tried to Save...
by koheripbal on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:51AM
(#24856037)
I wonder how many "ruling class" people you'd be willing to murder to get your way today...