News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by LatteLazy on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:18AM (#24835340)
No one in the West acknowledges it, but 80% of winning ww2 was Russia. People go on an on about D-Day, but the tide turned at stalingrad. People assume Nagasaki and Hiroshima convinced Japan to surrender, but it was actually the (surprise) Russian declaration of war...
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by JuliusPullo on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @12:34PM (#24839396)
And also maybe 80% of the blame for starting the war was Russia's too. The war started when Germany invaded Poland, knowing they had nothing to worry about Russia, because they had agreed with Russia to divide Poland between themselves. After Russia entered the war (when Germany surprise-attacked them), Russia received support from the US, who basically financed the war for the russians. The war ended, and Russia -who was an impoverished state before the war- ended as a nuclear superpower who controlled half of Europe. So they started the war, ended the war, and gained more than anyone from the war.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by Tainnor on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @03:36PM (#24841516)
How does this imply that Russia is 80% responsible for the start of WWII? Don't get me wrong, the Red Army committed horrible atrocities in this war, and the plan of dividing up Poland was illegal from both sides, but it was Hitler who started the whole thing, and it was Hitler who doubled crossed Stalin.

There might be some responsibility that the Russians share for the outbreak of WWII, but really, this was a war of Hitler's own design.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by rasz on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:38PM (#24844544)
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by srtjstjsj on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:14PM (#24843656)
> illegal

Under what government?

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by LatteLazy on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @01:31PM (#24840125)
Are you sure it was only 20% hitlers fault...
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by mrguyorama on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @01:17PM (#24839959)
Eh, there was going to be SOME form of war no matter what. Hitler was intent on getting a war, just as the austro-hungarians had been 20 years earlier
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by Tainnor on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @03:32PM (#24841468)
While we have to be very critical about the role of A-H in the leadup to WWI, it's not like they planned or even accepted the possibility of an all-out European war, unlike Hitler who sooner or later was going to envelop all of Europe (maybe except the UK who he would have liked to be his partner, at least for a time). Also, the roles of the Germans, Serbs, Russians and to some extent even French need to be critically analysed too in the case of WWI, while in WWII, you can squarely lay the blame at Germany's feet for the outbreak of the war.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by m-i-l on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:51AM (#24835529)
Although you could argue that Russia was only able to remain in the war due to intelligence: Moscow didn't fall in Oct and Nov 1941 because of the arrival of reinforcements from the east, and that was possible because British intelligence indicated that the Japanese weren't planning a land invasion of Siberia as everyone expected (given they were already in Manchuria) but for some reason were planning on opening up a new front against America.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by nix23 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:30AM (#24835399)
>but 80% of winning ww2 was Russia

Exactly, it's a real shame, Russia had the biggest sacrifices and the West just pats his own back.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by ErrantX on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:37AM (#24835441)
It's not right, but historically it "makes sense" - the Cold War is between us and WW2. Plus, of course, post-war it plays to the local government's interest to emphasise your own country's contribution.

Another factor is; a lot of senior (and sometimes non-senior) officers were comissioned after the war to write memoirs and histories - these were at best personal views and at worst outright biased. Because of secrecy (which the cold war didn't help remove) these were often the only reference material for 20th century historians.

A great example is a lot of the work on deception during WW2 (one of my pet subjects). Early works were heavily redacted and biased, and later seemingly scholarly works by real historians have since been shown to be simply parroting a lot of that misinformation. It is only in the last 5-10 years as material has been declassified that the truth begins to emerge.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by KaiserPro on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:04AM (#24835634)
> West just pats his own back.

It also colonised half of Europe, gaining huge amounts of territory that would have been totally unthinkable ten years previously.

The post WWII settlement for russia was spectacular.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by ant6n on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @12:32PM (#24839375)
Nobody colonized Europe after ww2, except maybe the movements of people as Poland moved a couple hundred km west.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by aronpye on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @02:22PM (#24840689)
Maybe try Googling the Warsaw Pact ...
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by ant6n on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @02:58PM (#24850901)
Maybe try Googling „colonization“
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by older on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:29AM (#24835395)
Also it looks like not many acknowledge that Soviet Union was not just Russia, so your 80% has to be divided somehow between ex-USSR countries.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by derriz on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:42AM (#24835470)
I think it's fairly widely acknowledged among those with any interest in history? Reading popular historians like Antony Beevor would leave it in no doubt.

It's also interesting that the Soviet Union would probably not have been able to put up such a fight without the massive shipments of aid from the US - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_Corridor

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by nickik on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:43AM (#24835480)
80% if of the causalities of the German army was in East. But I think people sometimes take it to far, including you.

If you look at the amount of material, technology, and cost the German had to spend on the air war, air defense, u-boat war and fighting on a different continent. This type of fighting doesn't kill as many people but its very important. Without the Western Allied efforts Soviet Union had basically no way to effect German economy at all.

And one of the single most important points that is often ignored is the economic blockade of Germany that started in 1939. This was a massive issue for Germany.

Overall is far, far more then 20% any way you measure it other then casualties.

And that is without even mentioning that literally from the moment the German invasion of the Soviet Union started Britain was sending them important war material and eventually the Soviets received massive amounts from Western allies that massively helped them to actually win the war.

Britain even sent ships full of the most advanced fighter aircraft that were planned for the defense of Singapore, poor choice there Britain.

> People assume Nagasaki and Hiroshima convinced Japan to surrender, but it was actually the (surprise) Russian declaration of war...

This is often claimed but its simply false. Japan hoped the Soviets could help them make a deal and once they declared war, Japan understood that there was no deal to be had. What Soviet joining of the war did was to convince the last few people in the war part that conditional surrender was not possible.

It was the US nukes that convinced them that surrender was inevitable and in response to the nukes the emperor formally asked by the war council to give his opinion.

I'm all for questioning national myths, but many people are simply willing to believe anything as long as it goes against the national myth because they are so sick of hearing.

Edit: And I'm European not American, this is just my study of WW2 history

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by nix23 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:48AM (#24835894)
>It was the US nukes that convinced them that surrender was inevitable

That is still a huge discussion in Historian Circles and NOT a Fact.

https://www.carnegiecouncil.org/education/008/expertclips/01...

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by opo on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @02:18PM (#24840650)
From the transcript in your link:

>…The Soviet Union’s declaration of war, on the other hand, fundamentally altered the strategic situation. Adding another great power to the war created insoluble military problems for Japan’s leaders. It might be possible to fight against one great power attacking from one direction, but anyone could see that Japan couldn’t defend against two great powers attacking from two different directions at once.

Trying to call the Soviet Union at the end of WW II, a great power that could attack from a different direction is bizarre.

The few navy vessels that the USSR had that would be useful in an amphibious landing were ones given to it by the USA as part of Project Hula. The Soviet Union was not a threat to Japan at the end of WW II.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Hula

Compare that to what the rest of the allies were planning on:

>...Operation Olympic, the invasion of Kyūshū, was to begin on "X-Day", which was scheduled for 1 November 1945. The combined Allied naval armada would have been the largest ever assembled, including 42 aircraft carriers, 24 battleships, and 400 destroyers and destroyer escorts. Fourteen U.S. "division-equivalents" (13 divisions and two regimental combat teams)[28] were scheduled to take part in the initial landings.

and if that armada wasn't enough:

>...Ken Nichols, the District Engineer of the Manhattan Engineer District, wrote that at the beginning of August 1945, "[p]lanning for the invasion of the main Japanese home islands had reached its final stages, and if the landings actually took place, we might supply about fifteen atomic bombs to support the troops.

The invasion of Honshu would have been even more devastating:

>…Operation Coronet, the invasion of Honshu at the Kantō Plain south of the capital, was to begin on "Y-Day", which was tentatively scheduled for 1 March 1946.[33] Coronet would have been even larger than Olympic, with up to 40 divisions earmarked for both the initial landing and follow-up.[34] (The Overlord invasion of Normandy, by comparison, deployed 12 divisions in the initial landings.) In the initial stage, the First Army would have invaded at Kujūkuri Beach, on the Bōsō Peninsula, while Eighth Army invaded at Hiratsuka, on Sagami Bay.[35] Later, a follow-up force of up to 12 additional divisions of the Tenth Army and British Commonwealth Corps would be landed as reinforcements.[36] The Allied forces would then have driven north and inland, meeting at Tokyo.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall

There is really no comparison.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by nickik on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:34AM (#24836542)
Japan was already so clearly beaten, its only in the fantasy-land where some army officers still held on to the 'we can continue to fight' but that would change if the Soviet Union joined the war.

However, many of those people then didn't actually follow threw with this, as even after Soviet Union joined some in the war council still didn't want to surrender.

What actually changed the situation in the war council was Hirohito coming out with a clear message, and he did not want to see Japan wiped out. Even then, some in the war council were still against surrender but they followed orders from the Emperor.

The people who believe nuclear weapons had nothing to do with the surrender always underestimate or ignore the opinion of the Emperor and simply put it as an 'excuse' rather then his actual opinion. His decision to come out with a clear opinion, against tradition, was not because the Soviets rolled up some Japanese armies in a far away land but rather what was happening to his subjects. That makes way more sense.

If you want to call it an 'excuse' then that fine also, but even so, a war its over then the other side admits its over. The war had been military decided for years, if it took nukes to give them an 'excuse' and allowed the emperor to make a statement then that is still the effect of that weapon.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by KaiserPro on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:02AM (#24835626)
Russia played a huge role in WWII, but at a monumental human cost.

The millions upon millions of lives that were wasted by russia is a utter tragedy.

> but it was actually the (surprise) Russian declaration of war...

its really not clear cut like that though is it? The timeline really doesn't back this up.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:24AM (#24835375)
My father was in the RAF in WW2 - he was pretty clear that he regarded that Soviets as having done most of the fighting against the Nazis. I don't think that was an uncommon view amongst those who actually lived through those times.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by nix23 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:35AM (#24835422)
Yes but that changed because of the Cold War, a Union that helped to win the war against Hitler was not the desired picture of a enemy for the Nato.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by opo on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @01:08PM (#24839843)
You are also oversimplifying. For example, how effective would the Soviet Union have been without lend lease materials from the USA?

>According to the Russian historian Boris Vadimovich Sokolov, Lend-Lease had a crucial role in winning the war:

>On the whole the following conclusion can be drawn: that without these Western shipments under Lend-Lease the Soviet Union not only would not have been able to win the Great Patriotic War, it would not have been able even to oppose the German invaders, since it could not itself produce sufficient quantities of arms and military equipment or adequate supplies of fuel and ammunition. The Soviet authorities were well aware of this dependency on Lend-Lease. Thus, Stalin told Harry Hopkins [FDR's emissary to Moscow in July 1941] that the U.S.S.R. could not match Germany's might as an occupier of Europe and its resources.

Nikita Khrushchev made the same point in his memoirs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend-Lease

(Or for that matter how would the events of WW II have been different without the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact?)

>...People assume Nagasaki and Hiroshima convinced Japan to surrender, but it was actually the (surprise) Russian declaration of war...

The Soviet Union did not have the amphibious capability to invade Hokkaido. Though before the declaration, Japan still had hopes the Soviet Union would help broker a peace agreement. Knowing no one was going to help them negotiate with the allies, the emperor knew they had to surrender and as the emperor said:

>...Moreover, the enemy has begun to employ a new and most cruel bomb, the power of which to do damage is, indeed, incalculable, taking the toll of many innocent lives. Should we continue to fight, not only would it result in an ultimate collapse and obliteration of the Japanese nation, but also it would lead to the total extinction of human civilization.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewel_Voice_Broadcast

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by cafard on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @09:14AM (#24836884)
For some value of "no one".

On the other hand, one could argue that 50% of starting WW II was Russia.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by ant6n on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @01:06PM (#24839820)
You could argue that, but it’s a difficult argument to make. Ww2 was really started by the nazis. You could argue that the rise of nazism in Germany is due to the way ww1 ended and the treaty of Versailles, but Russia wasn’t super involved in that.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by srtjstjsj on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:20PM (#24843699)
The "50%" is the Nazi-Soviet alliance.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by ant6n on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:30PM (#24843755)
That didn't cause WW2. In fact the nazis broke the Hitler-Stalin Pakt as part of WW2.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by rasz on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:42PM (#24844558)
Germany broke that pack two years into the war, two years into Russia killing and pillaging on Hitlers side.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by Someone on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:05AM (#24835636)
Russian blood, helped by western weapons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend-Lease#Significance_of_Len...:

“Nikita Khrushchev, having served as a military commissar and intermediary between Stalin and his generals during the war, addressed directly the significance of Lend-lease aid in his memoirs:

I would like to express my candid opinion about Stalin's views on whether the Red Army and the Soviet Union could have coped with Nazi Germany and survived the war without aid from the United States and Britain. First, I would like to tell about some remarks Stalin made and repeated several times when we were "discussing freely" among ourselves. He stated bluntly that if the United States had not helped us, we would not have won the war.”

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by rasz on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:25PM (#24844489)
80% of starting ww2 was also Russia, on the German side. By surprise Russian declaration of war you surely mean Hitler breaking Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact 2 years into the war.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by oblio on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:45AM (#24835492)
The thing is, the USSR had a huge Lend and Lease program with the US. I think they also got a ton of equipment and supplies as donations, basically.

So that puts a bit of a stain on their efforts. As much as their soldiers fought and died bravely, a modern war without modern equipment is hopeless. That's how they broke through at Stalingrad: they attacked the flanks occupied by Romanians, who also fought and died bravely, but without good equipment, especially anti tank equipment.

So in the end, it was still a joint effort.

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by srtjstjsj on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:21PM (#24843705)
"stain" is not the right word.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by oblio on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @03:30AM (#24845552)
Diminish, you're right.
Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by hn_acc_2 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @12:13PM (#24839093)
If the atom bombs had no effect in forcing surrender, why then are they mentioned specifically in the Japanese surrender broadcast (with no mention of Soviet aggression at all)?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewel_Voice_Broadcast

Re:Bletchley Park’s contribution to WW2 'over-rated' by boomboomsubban on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @03:57PM (#24841751)
I'd guess because they had yet to negotiate a ceasefire in the Soviet war.