News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by georgiecasey on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:51AM (#24827475)
I used to cheat on chess.com. It started as a small bit of cheating here and there, just checking every now and then if the move I was going to make was the best. Of course, the computer always had a better move and then I examine the line and told myself I probably would have thought of that! Like a drug, it escalated and I was checking moves all the time. I was never caught but I was ashamed and just stopped playing. Actually, more than ashamed, cheating took all the joy out of it as it felt like a job, switching tabs, and you don't get the dopamine hit when you think of a great line yourself. I uninstalled scid vs pc and opened a lichess account and never cheated on that. Though lichess tells me loads of opponents I've played have been banned for cheating. I never suspect a thing.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by busyant on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:36PM (#24829406)
I cheated on Lichess--once.

Story:

I got paired with someone rated 400 points higher than me (no idea why). The dude was destroying me, but somewhere in the middlegame, he let his guard down and exposed himself to a mate-in-one. For once in my life, I saw the mate and I won.

The dude was FURIOUS. He immediately asked for a rematch and I said I had to go. Then the insults came ("chicken shit", etc.).

He even messaged me a few times over the course of a few months (same kind of name calling) and challenged me a few times.

Eventually, I thought, "You know what will really upset him? If I accept a rematch and win again."

So, I accepted one of his challenges and I used a computer. Obviously, he lost and he was FURIOUS again.

Not my proudest moment, but I enjoyed it while it was happening.

But yeah, regular cheating just kind of takes the joy out of the competition.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by egsmi on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:52PM (#24829587)
That has happened to me more than once too. I usually take the rematch because I can often win the second game too, I’ll guess 15% of the time. Almost always the better player is trying an opening trap which is dubious but will cause me to loose in the first 10 moves if I miss it. So I just make really sure to look for tactics extra carefully in the opening. If I survive I can often win. And if I loose I get to learn a new opening trap. :)
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by autokad on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:15PM (#24829802)
on lichess, after every game I use the analysis tool to see all the good moves I missed, and sometimes play out alternate endings. my game has improved a lot because of it, but people get furious with me because I don't accept rematches. If I rematch, I wont have the game fresh in memory and miss the opportunity to learn
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by sbierwagen on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:51PM (#24829575)
>I got paired with someone rated 400 points higher than me (no idea why)

If you haven't played in a while, then glicko will give you a wide ratings deviation, and pair you against much stronger or much weaker opponents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glicko_rating_system

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by bonzini on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:05PM (#24830363)
Or the guy was tilted and intentionally looked for weaker opponents.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by SilasX on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:52PM (#24830210)
>But yeah, regular cheating just kind of takes the joy out of the competition.

Well, as the saying goes, "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em."

Maybe we should just move over to computer-assisted human chess and compete that way?

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by dwohnitmok on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:35PM (#24830718)
I thought computers playing by themselves are equal to or better than computer+human pairs now (i.e. centaur chess is dead and humans provide no help but are only a hinderance). Is that true (this is just a half-remembered hunch)?

Also even if that's not true, computer-assisted human chess for all but the highest levels of play would still be just "human accepts computer move."

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by mjcohen on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:33PM (#24830693)
As in Fritz Leiber's 1962 story "The 64-square Madhouse".

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/61213/61213-h/61213-h.htm

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by ritchiea on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:18PM (#24829179)
Lichess will flag your account as a cheater w/o notifying you so that your opponents see the flag and avoid games. I know this because a friend of mine who is an average player got flagged that way after a stretch of games he won handily, including one against me where I checked computer analysis and noticed he made zero incorrect moves. A red flag popped up next to his screenname, I asked if he was aware of it and he said he couldn’t see it and got no notification of it.

I love the shadow flag method for cheaters because opponents can avoid games with them and the cheater may never figure out what the problem is.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by bufferoverflow on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:50PM (#24829573)
They should pair cheaters with cheaters.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by thope on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:19PM (#24829830)
this is how it works, there is a whole alternative lichess universe where shadow-banned users play each others.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by grecy on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:20PM (#24830521)
Number of players: 0
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by Waterluvian on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:52PM (#24829595)
I learned the “it sucks all joy out” lesson as a child when I cheated my entire way through Goldeneye 64. I got to the end and felt so unfulfilled.

I discovered that you’re better off walking away from a game that feels so insurmountably difficult rather than cheat a bit or a lot.

“I’m not going to finish so why not cheat to see the ending?” Was always disappointing. I’d rather that mountain still exist off in the distance that I’ll never summit.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by supersrdjan on Monday October 19, 2020 @07:10PM (#24832067)
When I was a kid my dad prohibited me from using cheats in Civilization I :D And if I remember well, the cheats were readily available through a toggl in the dropdown menu
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by glerk on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:45PM (#24831868)
Cheating in a solo game is not as bad as cheating in a competitive game where you are misrepresenting your abilities to other players.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by ALittleLight on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:07PM (#24830377)
My game of choice is Go rather than Chess, but this seems similar.

When I was young I hated playing games against the AI. It always felt unreal to me and there was no satisfaction in it. Now, I immensely prefer playing the computer - it goes at my pace, I can get up and leave, I can take all the time I want for my move, and if I do something dumb I just undo back to where I feel comfortable and play better. When I get legitimately stuck I ask the computer for advice.

In this way, I basically always win against a superior player. It may not be ideal for practice, but I just play for fun and find it satisfying to win.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by sfblah on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:17PM (#24829166)
I recently quit online chess completely. The last straw was lichess sending me a warning because I pointed out to a guy he was obviously using an engine. The cheating just got tiresome. I’m going to go back to playing over the board with actual people.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by FreshFries on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @02:48AM (#24834528)
I used to play Battlefield (an FPS) a lot. Organised games ranging from 5 vs 5 up to 32 vs 32.

The one sure way to find / detect players with cheats was... to use the same cheats. It saved my sanity but cost me the joy of playing.

I now can't play FPS's anymore but am limited to MMO's :(