News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by musicale on Saturday October 17, 2020 @07:58PM (#24814464)
I'm amazed that Zoom has so much uptake.

Even disregarding the malware-like behavior of its installer and the ongoing security issues, I've never had a satisfactory experience with Zoom. It's particularly bad for conferences with lots of people - the audio quality is choppy and often unintelligible, and often the audio will just cut out entirely after a couple of minutes. Moreover, the video and screen sharing features don't seem to work reliably either.

I've had drastically better experiences with basically any other system: Google, Microsoft, Cisco/Webex, Gotomeeting.... all seem to actually work. I haven't tried Apple's group facetime but they'd have to work pretty hard to make it worse than Zoom.

Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by ramraj07 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @08:29PM (#24814670)
You are absolutely in the minority with your experiences then. Zooms success is unarguably due to its comparably smooth operation. Granted, some other services offer better video and audio quality, but it's often dependent on location, and zoom is more graceful at lower bandwidth than most other systems anyway.

Most important, it's ease of use (precisely due to their malware like installer behaviour among other things) and thoughtfulness (as creepy as it might be) makes it the most "reliable" service for most and hence you see it's success. You are not left fiddling with installers and multistep protocols just to get into a video call.

Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by spurgu on Saturday October 17, 2020 @09:32PM (#24814889)
Have you tried their web client, for those of us who aren't comfortable putting up with Zoom's shenanigans? Pretty much unusable.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by ramraj07 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @11:14PM (#24815258)
Anyone who knows tech reasonably knows Zoom does some "unscrupulous" things to provide a seamless VC experience. To me, it's a bit clear that unless you also control the underlying OS (even when you do apparently), they are doing whatever they need to get what can be considered basic UX needs of a VC app. Contrary to popular belief in places like HN, the average Joe isn't a dipshit, they really don't care about these lapses from Zoom and will very happily make these concessions evenn if they're fully educated on everything to know about security. I'm not a technotard and mostly know everything and I make the concession.

It's not even clear to me they're being genuinely unscrupulous anyway. This is like not trusting the government when they do mass surveillance but more benign. The majority of the population has decided they are not worried about it, right or wrong, they just want to get on with their life.

Keep complaining for sure, we need dissent, but don't argue that Zoom isn't good at what it does, the only argument might be that it's practices aren't ethical. You choose to use the web application it's your choice not theirs.

Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by Sebguer on Saturday October 17, 2020 @09:33PM (#24814894)
And to that person's point, by using your web client, you are significantly in the minority. Most people are comfortable putting up with Zoom's shenanigans. Whether or not they should be is a completely separate question.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by smt88 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @12:23AM (#24815529)
I loathe Zoom, but its web client works as well as its desktop client.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by spurgu on Sunday October 18, 2020 @03:51PM (#24820563)
May I guess you're not using a Mac? For me it's using 100-150% CPU (according to Chrome task manager) and sound stutters constantly. Supposedly it works fine on Windows.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by musicale on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:47AM (#24824109)
I guess you all have partially answered my question: most Zoom users are not using the web client in Chrome or Firefox (it doesn't run at all in Safari) on macOS; as noted above, its poor audio quality and broken features render it essentially unusable.

Unfortunately I don't trust Zoom's native app, and I don't want to reboot into Windows, though I guess I could make a "Zoom VM" or something. ;-(

Moreover, Zoom-based conferences that I've attended have been plagued by audio issues that have rendered the remote presentations largely unintelligible, even using a Windows client.

In any case, I've usually solved the issue by using anything other than Zoom when I have the choice.

Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by AlexCoventry on Saturday October 17, 2020 @11:55PM (#24815428)
The web client has been pretty seamless, for me.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by spurgu on Sunday October 18, 2020 @03:51PM (#24820565)
May I guess you're not using a Mac? For me it's using 100-150% CPU (according to Chrome task manager) and sound stutters constantly. Supposedly it works fine on Windows.
Re:Together: New version of Jami (alternative to Zoom and Ji... by techwizrd on Saturday October 17, 2020 @08:33PM (#24814692)
To add some add alternative anec-data: I've had poor experiences on Hangouts, Teams, WebEx, Hop.in, etc. Zoom and GoToMeeting are the only options that don't turn my computer into a jet engine. For our government working groups, we prefer ZoomGov because it's fairly painless and has excellent audio and video performance.

It seems that people have had a multitude of experiences, and there are no clear winners.