News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by cle on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24812878)
Is fear bad a priori? I don’t think so, this is an unprecedentedly dangerous virus, I think if you’re not at least a little scared then you’re delusional.

Dismissing action as motivated by fear is ridiculous, we should be scared of dangerous things and let that fear motivate us to take rational action.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by ACow_Adonis on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:39PM (#24813142)
um, I'd argue respectfully that "unprecedentedly dangerous" is the phrase approaching the delusional.

when this whole thing started, I did what any self respecting analyst would do: try to calculate the numbers and calculate the likely outcomes and risks (primarily to my own family).

And I kept arriving at the conclusion: it's statistically bad in the sense of spread and infectiousness, but as a virus and comparative lethality it's not THAT bad. The main danger was from responses/strongly compressed infection timing, and assuming you didn't overreact and your health system held out, if your family were in their 50s or younger and healthy, existentially it wasn't much worse than the flu (and for the youngest, possibly even less dangerous).

but what I was scared of was the human response.

Because it targets the old and infirm, and because they largely control most wealth and power, and because we largely don't have mature ways of dealing with mortality in common cultural discourse, and because a lot of our countries have become increasingly partisan, I figured the response would probably be bad/chaotic/ and have lots of badly targeted over-reactions, unintended consequences, and probably a lot of name calling, fear mongering and virtue signalling. our media has just gone crazy.

6 months later (and in the lockdown in Melbourne), I stand by most of my initial judgements. One problem locally (and maybe NZ shares this problem, I dunno), it's that the trump/Johnson swing to the right/populism left the opposition (we have Labor in power locally too, so the opposition is conservative) being relatively flirting with anti-science and anti-int tellectualism as well as general juvenile behaviour and responses, so even though one might not fully support local actions (I don't fully support the lockdown extents in both Melbourne or NZ long term), there isn't really a viable political alternative presented either.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by cle on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:09PM (#24821865)
I regret saying "unprecedentedly dangerous" because it puts the focus on comparing this with past pandemics, which is irrelevant to my point, and I'm not really interested in having that conversation.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:24PM (#24812994)
Oh come now, we can exercise and advocate for caution and good sense without pretending that this virus is more dangerous than polio or measles or the 1918 flu or any of the markedly more severe viruses.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by cle on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:38PM (#24813132)
Why should I care? How should the accuracy of qualitative comparisons of this with past pandemics affect our decision making? If this isn’t as bad as the Spanish flu, how should that change our response to the current pandemic?
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by throwaway894345 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @11:50AM (#24818714)
No need to deflect; you we’re simply incorrect. It happens. Own up and move on.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by cle on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:02PM (#24821828)
I presented an argument that your point is irrelevant to the discussion, and you provided no meaningful counter-argument in response.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by throwaway894345 on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:25PM (#24829900)
You do realize that anyone who reads your comment can also read the rest of the thread and see for themselves that you’re incorrect, right? What advantage can there be in doubling down? In whatever case, I corrected your error and you don’t dispute it, so I think this thread has served its purpose. I’ll be ducking out now.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by taurath on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24812888)
They can go out to a bar or movie theater right now. All movie theater chains in the US are about to close for good, and 1/7th of small businesses in the US are now closed for good.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by iso947 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @05:08PM (#24813384)
They can, but with no major film releases cinemas don’t have an easy ride
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by taurath on Saturday October 17, 2020 @05:51PM (#24813697)
Socially distanced, theaters lose money if they open. They aren’t open and therefore no films because the studios do t want to take more of a write down, since they’re already trimming 20% of their muscle (fat is long gone)
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by tshaddox on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:09PM (#24812840)
I’m not sure why some people conflate pandemic devastation with freedom.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by martyvis on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#24813000)
And a very big island just next door, not quite as authoritative but doing almost as well in the pandemic, Australia, has just opened its doors to New Zealanders. I think we are doing quite well down under thanks to good government and a community that seems to think other lives are as important as our own.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lostlogin on Saturday October 17, 2020 @08:31PM (#24814679)
Sometimes it’s quite healthy to be scared, it prompts a response.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by patagurbon on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:19PM (#24812931)
Who has been innovative? Because the results speak for themselves here.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lightgreen on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:21PM (#24812953)
Short term results only. We don't know yet about long term results (for the economy, for global poverty, for people mental healths, for extra deaths of cancer, for obesity people getting spending time at home, and so on).
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lostlogin on Saturday October 17, 2020 @08:35PM (#24814704)
NZ has has 1/8900 of the US death toll. We have 1/66th the US population.

It’s hard to argue that our response is going to cause more deaths than the US response. It almost feels like cheating to compare NZ to USA where covid is concerned.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by patagurbon on Saturday October 17, 2020 @05:08PM (#24813385)
Short term results of hundreds of thousands dead... I'm not sure excess cancer deaths would ever eclipse that.
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by c0nducktr on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#24812999)
For extra deaths of cancer?
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lightgreen on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:33PM (#24813073)
Yes, coronavirus safety driven restrictions sometimes lead to hospitals lesser ability to handle common diseases like cancer.

This is the story from the UK, something like this might happen everywhere: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8848991/Dead-31-che...

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by iso947 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @05:09PM (#24813395)
UK didn’t deal well with covid

NZ hospitals have been fine.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lightgreen on Saturday October 17, 2020 @09:39PM (#24814923)
> NZ hospitals have been fine.

So every organisation from kindergartens to factories was affected by coronavirus, but hospitals were not affected at all? I don't believe so.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by eganist on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:10PM (#24812845)
and yet less people died. And those who lived are enjoying a higher quality of life.

Also, you need citations for everything in the first sentence.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by lightgreen on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#24812998)
It's unfortunate, that comments like one above gets downvoting into abyss completely damaging the author karma.

This is a perfectly valid and reasonable comment.

The whole upvoting/downvoting system in HN sometimes works just for silencing the minority opinions which is quite dangerous.

Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by gohbgl on Saturday October 17, 2020 @06:08PM (#24813792)
I created a stylesheet to remove the censorship for the viewer. https://userstyles.org/styles/190934/hacker-news-top-comment...
Re:'Near extinction' of influenza in NZ as numbers drop due ... by SkyMarshal on Saturday October 17, 2020 @07:50PM (#24814414)
This isn't about freedom, it's about responsibility and competence. Pandemics are our new normal. We've been anticipating pandemics for decades, in movies, books, etc, and here they finally are. They are both predictable and predicted.

There's a competent, pro way of handling pandemics, and incompetent, amateur way of handling them.

The pro way is brief but comprehensive shutdowns + distancing + masks + sanitizing + testing & tracing + travel restrictions. It only takes 4-8 weeks of that to shut down a pandemic, then everyone can get back to being their normal, self-centered, freedom-loving selves.

The amateur way is to scream about it like a child, refuse to take measures to help stop the outbreak, and be so brainwashed that you're unable to distinguish a conspiracy for a real emergency. Which is of course what Trump and half the US has done.

Sometimes a pandemic is just a pandemic, not a conspiracy of the global elites.