The modern Unitarian Universalist (UU) church is very welcoming to people of all faiths, religions, and creeds. You do not need to be atheist to join, nor do you need to believe in anything. Most congregations are very welcoming of new members.
Four US Presidents, eleven Nobel prize winners, and Sir Tim Berners-Lee are Unitarians. There are many Unitarians out there, though they do not tend to proselytize much, which is maybe why you haven't heard of them.
As always, finding the right congregation is very important. The UU church has a good site here to help:
With the current Covid-19 crisis, local churches near you may be closed or only doing virtual services. Please check with the minister.
People were united by a monopoly on education and political power. It's too bad that we're losing that ubiquitous societal fabric, but in the face of the alternative, seriously, good riddance.
If spiritualism is your thing though, do drop by at a Unitarian Church close to you. It's an interesting experience. Not for me, but still warmly recommended.
As someone who grew up in a small, rural Christian community, this is a nice sentiment, but far from true in my experience. People instead become highly punitive and disparaging towards anyone who does not think and behave exactly like them. Whatever community exists is built around a hateful exclusion of “the other.”
That being said, there was definitely a “fear of the other “ with people being extremely suspicious of the few handful of outsiders who moved in and didn’t have any connection like relatives, existing connections, or children going to school there.
That might work for some people? I don't know?
But I do know that the Charleston church shooter sat down with a bunch of little old ladies for the duration of a bible study engaging in, what I can only assume was, a calm in-person discussion. Then he blew their heads off.
Point is that, for some reason, the internet has a much stronger hold over people than do in person connections. People deeply believe they are more connected to people in their virtual spaces than they are to their neighbors or even physical friends. That sense of connection is real to those people. To some of those people, it's real enough to kill for.
are there some people for whom virtual spaces are more real than their neighbors and IRL friends? sure, but most people don't seem to be like that. as far as I can tell, most people use social media to interact with an extended network of IRL friends/family. some people do try to get tons of followers that they don't know on instagram, but I think even this is best understood as jockeying for status among IRL peers.
note: IRL is a somewhat antiquated term this days, but I use it as a shorthand for "relationships that originate in in-person interactions". so if I had a friend A who moved away and befriended B there, but we all play video games together, B is still an IRL friend to me.
this is a rather ethnocentric view of religion based on what is clearly a limited historical understanding evidently informed mostly by judeo-christianity. just to pick one counter-example: the ancient greeks sought virtue and purpose from philosophical inquiry, not from their religious practices, which were much more transactional.
I get that the World, and Europe in particular, got badly burnt by Utopias in the 20th century. But still seems like something is needed - especially given the looming geopolitical changes.
It seems true to me that most individuals (myself included) are not up to the task of inventing a reason to exist. You can moan about how the stories are made up til Kingdom come, the point of it is practicing the belief. Otherwise you get what we're talking about in this thread, billions of people growing up believing nothing, having no rational reason to believe they are valuable, no reason to think the future warrants their contribution.
(Just found the author of the study/studies: Sosis[3]
[1]: https://www.amazon.com/Righteous-Mind-Divided-Politics-Relig...
[2]: A commune being defined as a group of people not sharing kinship deciding to live and work together.
[3]: https://anthropology.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/944/...
Maybe that is why the devil and the hell were introduced at some point ;-)
I expect that there will be a strong reaction on this forum to the word 'socialist', but the communities you describe definitely still exist.
I try to look at the long arc of human history as basically the story of how we grow the size of the "in-group" and shrink the size of the "out-group". It isn't easy, but we have made significant progress over the centuries.
I agree that they do exist. But they don't seem to be mainstream as they once were, and I'd very much like to change that.
But also, historically, these sorts of communities have been targeted by governments. Police literally went to war with unions to break up community power for coal miners. While communism is different than socialism, there's a huge public smear campaign trying to couple those two together. (And, in fact, historically there were major pushes to blacklist folks who were connected to communism.)
You're essentially describing (secular) Humanism, e.g.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secular_humanism
Your atom bomb mention is interesting considering Oppenheimer's Hinduism reference.
"Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds."
https://www.amazon.com/True-Only-Heaven-Progress-Critics/dp/...
"In the old days it was better", "golden age" - no it was not better. There were incompetent people in 1960's, there were scummy and incompetent clerks in 1500's. History lessons are about great people.
Maybe competition model is not that good, because instead of fighting for survival some people could start working on inventing their own things. Just like now billionaires are playing with rockets and having results. I would say there can be a lot of creativity when people are left alone and can build things, without having to think about threat of war. Going to the moon was necessity caused by knife on the throat, not some noble achievement because people wanted go to the moon. That is why no one went to the moon since then again.
Forgive me as I try to articulate what I'm thinking.
Being the sole super power somehow turned out to be bad thing. We (the USA) needs to an opponent, a competitor to better define and understand ourselves.
During the Cold War, aspirational preaching about human rights and democracy and capitalism was a way for us to differentiate ourselves from our opponents. A bit like Scott Galloway's thesis about Apple using privacy as brand laddering technique to differentiate itself from Google, Samsung, etc. Privacy is not central to Apple. But it makes for great ad copy.
I'm not saying USSR, China, whoever were (are) better or worse than the USA. I have no opinion and I really don't care. (Well, I do have an opinion. People in glass houses...)
What I am saying is the USA needs the idea of an opponent. So that domestically it (we) can set aside our differences to meet the external threat. And to have some kind of narrative to pitch why aligning with the USA is the better choice.
I don't think the USA is unique this way. Us vs them is base human psychology.
I do hope that The Powers That Be, on both sides, under stand the realpolitik is just kabuki and it matters don't degenerate into another Cold War. We don't need another arm's race.
While we did have to fight the Cold War, which led to much progress on a technological front, the US also had the advantage of reduced competition from previous world powers (UK, Germany, France, Japan, etc) which had been destroyed by WWII.
The Communists gave us focus. The end state of WWII provided the economic ability to put that focus to good use.
Or something like that. But, I do agree that the lack of a single unifying enemy is a problem when it comes to motivating society as a unit. It feels like we're more likely to be destroyed (as a nation) from internal factors than external, and that's not good.
2) You have almost no idea how incompetent or wasteful most private organizations are, unless they are so bad that they go bankrupt and dissolve.
The real question is whether this trend can continue forward. My bet is yes for the foreseeable future, but no power system lasts forever. So while we're seeing the gradual (seeming) decline of the West, we'll probably be repeating the pattern in a few decades for East Asia.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.09.21.20198796v...
Though honestly, the difference between the US can hardly be called drastically significant. Both are doing horid.
1. The lack of a real "competitor" in a geopolitical sense for the West. I don't think it is a coincidence that the US arguably had the most competence and scientific development circa ±1940 - 1990, when it had a direct competitor to measure itself against. Incompetence against the Nazis or Soviets got you killed, whereas today, nothing really happens (immediately.) The ancient Greeks (and subsequently Nietzsche) recognized the usefulness of competition toward keeping yourself sharp and called it agon. Ironically the rise of China can be seen as a good thing from this perspective.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agon
http://www.nietzschecircle.com/v3/2017/03/17/book-review-ago...
2. The loss of a civilization-wide teleological narrative. For the past ±1,500 years, that's been Christianity, in various forms. These days, there is no real "purpose" to the West, beyond some vague notions of individualism, choice and comfort. Institutions and standards become more and more difficult to maintain as a sense of apathy and the lack of a perceived future grows. Younger people especially seem unconvinced that there is anything waiting for them in 50 years.