News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by lanstin on Thursday October 15, 2020 @01:44PM (#24791412)
Are you saying publishers can’t arbitrarily decide what to publish or not? I think you will find that publishers have a lot more say so over their content than e.g. phone companies.
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by ggreer on Thursday October 15, 2020 @01:56PM (#24791570)
Publishers can be as arbitrary as they want, but they are held liable for what they publish. Section 230 gives civil immunity to "information service providers". If someone libels you on Twitter, you can't sue Twitter. But if Twitter starts making editorial decisions as to what is fit to publish and what isn't, then they could lose their section 230 protections and open themselves to tons of lawsuits.
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by messick on Thursday October 15, 2020 @02:57PM (#24792402)
This will help you with future Sec 230 hot takes: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200531/23325444617/hello...
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by ggreer on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:43PM (#24793663)
I've read that before and I've discussed it with a lawyer (among other related articles & topics). He rolled his eyes at much of it, but he also rolled his eyes at the "platform vs publisher" distinction that so many naive people make. Still, he agrees that social media companies are tickling the dragon's tail when it comes to Section 230 protection.

Before you dismiss my anecdote as one mistaken lawyer, note that the chairman of the FCC (who is a lawyer) and Justice Clarence Thomas both think that Section 230 doesn't offer nearly as much protection as social media companies seem to think it does. In response to recent events, the FCC plans to issue statements clarifying the meaning of Section 230.[1]

1. https://twitter.com/AjitPaiFCC/status/1316808733805236226 "Social media companies have a First Amendment right to free speech. But they do not have a First Amendment right to a special immunity denied to other media outlets, such as newspapers and broadcasters."

Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by mshumi on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:01PM (#24793124)
That was a very good read. Thanks for linking that!
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by stale2002 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:37PM (#24793598)
> Are you saying publishers can’t arbitrarily decide what to publish or not?

Publishers can do this, yes. They just are not offered the legal protections of being a platform, if they act as a publisher.

The point is, that someone is acting as a publisher, then they should have these legal protections taken away form them.

Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by rstupek on Thursday October 15, 2020 @01:57PM (#24791578)
I think what he said is if twitter wishes to be a publisher they should be treated as such. What they want to be is NOT a publisher but a platform since different rules apply to platforms than are applied to publishers.
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by lanstin on Thursday October 15, 2020 @02:16PM (#24791832)
I wouldn’t mind if people could sue Twitter but if your goal is unregulated speech then removing section 230 is counter productive.
Re:Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reig... by 75dvtwin on Sunday October 18, 2020 @01:01PM (#24819256)
I do not think that that's what will happen.

Section 230 will NOT get removed. ISPs and email service providers, and blog platforms, will still be able to use it.

But companies that add/remove/replace/gray-out/delete/hide/push-to-bottom content that they claim they did not editorialize -- will be called Publishers.

So these businesses will not be able to use statutory protections that are available for non-publishers under section 45.230.

An analogy might be: a for-profit-business cannot claim tax benefits available for a non-for-profit organizations.

So the tax-code does not get removed, just because somebody was actively abusing it. It stays the same, but the abuser would face criminal investigation.

And if the abuser was found to systemically and purposefully avoiding to be recognized as 'Publisher' (or as a for-profit business in this analogy), then the criminal penalties would be more severe, then otherwise.