Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by visarga on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:30AM
(#24808433)
> it takes only two synapses for information to travel from the air, through your nose, and to the core cortex
I was expecting it would be just a low level feature detector since smell is like like a bag-of-words format (unordered) while vision is at least 2D (space) and hearing 1D (time).
Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by ternaryoperator on Saturday October 17, 2020 @03:42AM
(#24808192)
One fascinating thing about smell is that you can smell only on inhalations. On exhalations, the sensors shut down. Hard to figure out what the evolutionary benefit of that was. But so it is for humans, and I believe for most mammals.
Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by de_Selby on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:09AM
(#24808324)
I suppose it makes sense, otherwise the smells from our breath and most recent meals digestion would mix with and confuse our sense of the smells surrounding us.
I'm definitely glad we have this feature first thing in the morning before brushing my teeth!
Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by mturmon on Saturday October 17, 2020 @01:32AM
(#24807660)
Makes a great case that smell is very different than our “favorite” sense, vision. I heard her interview on Sean Carroll’s podcast, was super interesting.
Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by AndrewOMartin on Saturday October 17, 2020 @09:27AM
(#24809821)
Smell is the primary sense and the sooner that Computer Vision embraces that fact the better it will be for any system that needs any form of context sensitivity or relevance detection.
It's all well and good to have awesome algorithms for detecting X, Y, or Z in a stream of stimuli but it's smell that tells us which things to anticipate.
Re:Our Mind-Boggling Sense of Smell
by meowface on Sunday October 18, 2020 @04:43AM
(#24816373)
There is no "primary sense". It's primary only in terms of detecting molecules, but the presence or absence of molecules is just one environmental dimension.
I was expecting it would be just a low level feature detector since smell is like like a bag-of-words format (unordered) while vision is at least 2D (space) and hearing 1D (time).
I'm definitely glad we have this feature first thing in the morning before brushing my teeth!
Fun to watch this work when my dog is ratting for voles in the yard.
https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2020/07/13/105-...
Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvhwpUiQXdY
It's all well and good to have awesome algorithms for detecting X, Y, or Z in a stream of stimuli but it's smell that tells us which things to anticipate.