News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by rswail on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:47AM (#24754848)
Is there any wonder that moving to IPv6 is delayed?

Assuming an average $25/address, that's $400m/class A.

Some of the organizations that own a class A:

Apple, Ford, Softbank, Daimler, Prudential, Comcast.

Softbank needs the money and the others wouldn't sniff at $300m+.

Not sure how long the 100m odd addresses would last though.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by tzs on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:07PM (#24755889)
Comcast started rolling out IPv6 across their network a long time ago. They hit 100% support on their broadband network in 2014. They run a lot of the own stuff on IPv6, such as on-demand video on their set-top boxes. I think any home modem/router that they support that did not support IPv6 hit EOL long ago and was replaced.

There may be some class A owners who are trying to hold back IPv6 so they can make money off their class A, but Comcast isn't one of them.

Apple has long had IPv6 support in their operating systems, so I don't think they have been trying to hold it back either.

Ford, Softbank, Daimler, and Prudential? It is not immediately obvious to me if they could do anything to hold it back even if they wanted to.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by ArchOversight on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:54PM (#24756481)
Comcast ran out of RFC1918 addressing to manage all the devices on their network (think cable modems/set top boxes/routers/everything) and had a massively segmented network setup.

They rolled out IPv6 because it flattened that network again, and instead of worrying about being in the right segment for reachability everything now gets a globally unique IP address. It massively simplified their internal management.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:30PM (#24756922)
> Apple has long had IPv6 support in their operating systems, so I don't think they have been trying to hold it back either.

And Microsoft has supported IPv6 since Windows 2000: https://news.microsoft.com/2000/03/15/microsoft-announces-ip....

I understand that LTE networks are exclusively IPv6, ditto "5G".

My frustration with IPv6 is that my home ISP (Wave Broadband's DOCSIS service) is still IPv4 and they still have no plans to roll-out IPv6 even though Wave's WaveG service has been IPv6 for as long as I can remember. I understand the cause of this is because Wave's network is incredibly hetereogenous because Wave's business-model was to expand by buying-up smaller regional cablecos but to retain their infrastructure (and talent) compared to Comcast's approach of asset-stripping (bad for employees, but good for customers...).

I want IPv6 so I can stop having to faff around with NAT. I'd love to be able to RDP-in directly to my desktop at home without having to pay companies like TeamViewer and Splashtop.

----

Update: I found Wave's peering page's IPv6 status page and it remains unchanged since 2011 (and possibly since 2008). Wow.

Compare:

https://web.archive.org/web/20110102140910/http://as11404.ne...

Live:

http://as11404.net/ipv6.html

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by KA9Q on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:26PM (#24758397)
Do you know about Hurricane Electric's free IPv6 tunnel broker? www.tunnelbroker.com. I have used it for a very long time, and it has been very stable and reliable. The only technical requirement is that you have control of a globally routable IPv4 address where you can set up a tunnel endpoint. I.e., "carrier grade NAT" (a contradiction in terms) won't suffice.

I still use HE's tunnel even though Spectrum Cable has provided good native IPv6 service for several years. Ping times over HE are just as good as native Spectrum, probably because everybody peers at the same place in Los Angeles.

The only problem with HE is that Netflix is clamping down on VPNs, and they consider a HE tunnel to be a VPN. So my home router advertises the native Spectrum prefix with a higher priority than the HE prefix.

My own frustration with IPv6 is that virtually no public hotspots support it. My Verizon phone does, so I often use it as a hotspot even when public WiFi is available.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:45PM (#24758631)
> Do you know about Hurricane Electric's free IPv6 tunnel broker?

I was aware of it, but I could swear that I heard news a couple of years ago that they shut it down due to decreased demand, but thank you for letting me know it's still running. I'll see if I can use it!

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by davidbild on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:47PM (#24759275)
Unfortunately, streaming sites like Netflix block access from HE tunnels, because they could be used to skirt around region controls (like VPNs).

My ISP (RCN in Chicago) doesn't support IPv6 either. I tried HE, but ran into the above issue. Now I'm seriously considering getting an IPv6 block directly from ARIN (and paying the few hundred a year fees) to use with HE tunnels, to work around the Netflix block.

Would love to find a cheaper solution though.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by p1mrx on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:39PM (#24759735)
SixXS is the one that shut down: https://www.sixxs.net/main/
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by ArchOversight on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:38PM (#24760266)
My friend/co-worker signed up for Wave thinking that it supported IPv6, their websites and marketing is so incredibly fragmented...

We were working on some IPv6 projects that require IPv6 connectivity, and he didn't want to faff about with a tunnel or something along those lines, so he cancelled his Wave account and switched to Comcast.

Wave lost a customer due to not supporting IPv6... it's high time that ISP's started getting on-board.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:16PM (#24761331)
What are has both Comcast and Wave available? Most cities only allow a single cableco at a time - or was this an apartment complex?
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by criddell on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:26PM (#24757688)
> I want IPv6 so I can stop having to faff around with NAT.

What makes you think your ISP will give you more than one IP even when they are no longer in short supply? If it's something that has value to you, it's something they will want to be paid for.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:36PM (#24757822)
IPv6's has a fixed subnet size of 64-bits[1]. A router needs its own subnet, ergo everyone gets their own 64-bit address range. ISPs cannot give each customer a single IPv6 address because that would require each customer to have a single device connected directly to their router with no router in the CPE - basically like how dial-up used to work. There's no demand for a service like that.

[1] See https://www.ripe.net/about-us/press-centre/understanding-ip-... . I note that there is a lot of misinformation and badly-informed blog posts in the top search results for "ipv6 subnet size" like this one, ugh: https://www.crucial.com.au/blog/2011/04/15/ipv6-subnet-cheat... - which is wrong because IPv6 simply doesn't have 128-bit-sized subnet option (whereas you can have a 32-bit sized subnet in IPv4, which is how most residential ISPs/CPEs are configured).

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by KA9Q on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:32PM (#24758472)
It is not true that an ISP cannot give each customer just a single IPv6 address. The Linux box I use as a router gets a single (i.e., /128) address from Spectrum Cable on its upstream interface, and it has to explicitly ask for a separate /64 prefix to advertise on the local interface (this is called prefix delegation, PD).

So it's certainly possible for an ISP to give a customer just one IPv6 address. I'm not sure, but I think there is no rule that prefixes obtained with PD must be /64's. They could in principle give you a /126 or /127 to limit you to just a few hosts on your LAN, and charge to give you anything better. This would break stateless autoconfiguration but it would still work with DHCPv6.

Your best workaround is still www.tunnelbroker.com, HE's free IPv6 tunnel service.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by sedachv on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:05PM (#24759431)
> The Linux box I use as a router gets a single (i.e., /128) address from Spectrum Cable on its upstream interface, and it has to explicitly ask for a separate /64 prefix to advertise on the local interface

Ask for a /56! Spectrum in Los Angeles hands out /56s, and I understand many other residential IPv6 ISPs do as well. You get your own 8 bits worth of subnets on top of /64 for easy SLAAC address assignment. This works "for free" not only because the IPv6 address space is large enough to do this, but more importantly because IPv6 does NOT have any fixed subnet sizes - routing is hierarchical and subnet assignment is transparent. /64 is just the size used by SLAAC address auto-configuration, another bit of IPv6 magic.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by jlgaddis on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:52PM (#24796959)
Phil,

Thank you so very much for NOS, which was my very first introduction to IP over packet and what initially got me interested in amateur radio (going on 30 years ago!) and is, in part, what led to me initially getting licensed and drawn into the world of networking at a young age.

73,

N9WWV

--

P.S. Welcome to HN!

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:46PM (#24758642)
Thank you for correcting my misunderstanding of IPv6! :)
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by jrwr on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:53PM (#24757994)
RIPE just has a rule about only having ISPs hand out those /64s there is nothing to prevent someone internally to then split that /64 into smaller chunks to hand out to internal clients. Thats the would point of a subnet!
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:07PM (#24758177)
I'm not sure if that's well-supported by IPv6 though. Documents I've read do agree that it's possible to have smaller subnets in IPv6 (e.g. https://docs.netgate.com/pfsense/en/latest/network/ipv6/subn... and https://serverfault.com/questions/426183/how-does-ipv6-subne... ) but that the pain and hassle required to do-so isn't worth it.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by tekromancr on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:58PM (#24758061)
Wait, so does that mean that every customer would have 18.45 QUINTILLION addresses to use?

God, I knew the IPv6 space was insanely large, but Jesus h, man.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by dbt00 on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:31PM (#24758446)
2001:: is a 16 bit prefix in which every single customer could get a /48, i.e. you could allocate 65k subnets of 18.45 quint addresses on your network and give one of those to everyone with an ipv4 address and not run out, and that's still only 1/65536th of the total address space.

128 bits is a lot.

(the /64 as the physical subnet allows using hardware MAC addresses and RNG temporary/private addresses instead of needing DHCP/etc).

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by md5person on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:11PM (#24758241)
I'm not sure why you're getting downvoted, but I think it's yet another confirmation that this place has gone full Reddit.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by wmf on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:21PM (#24758344)
Performative cynicism + speaking hypothetically about past events = I'd downvote it twice if I could. In reality very very few ISPs are giving one IPv6 address per customer. ISPs are greedy but they're not wantonly cruel.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by md5person on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:39PM (#24758554)
> "In reality very very few ISPs are giving one IPv6 address per customer"

In actual reality, global IPv6 adoption is at ~33% [0, 1], so I'd say this is, at best, a premature and naive presumption. ISPs actively engage in rent-seeking, and resource scarcity is another contributing factor. In-short, there's nothing in OPs comment that warrants the downvotes.

[0] - https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html [1] - https://www.akamai.com/uk/en/resources/our-thinking/state-of...

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by criddell on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:10PM (#24760018)
wmf does have a point though. When it comes to ISPs and telecom companies, I'm pretty cynical. It's a well earned cynicism though.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by mike_d on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:45PM (#24757127)
Deploying IPv6 is nice, but it doesn't impact the value of IPv4 at all.

Any internet service you want to be widely available will need to be dual-stack as long as we are alive.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by Animats on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:01PM (#24758094)
Maybe not. Google says their traffic is now at 30% IPv6, and climbing at 5%/year.[1]

Worldwide, Google is undercounting, because they are blocked in China. Google claims that China is 0.27% IPv6, but actually China is around 55%, according to APNIC. Policy goal in China is all IPv6 by 2025.

[1] https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by mprovost on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:36PM (#24758517)
So it's taken 25 years to get to ~30% adoption. And a few years ago APNIC reported [0] that the rate was going down - I haven't found an updated report.

In 2005 the US government mandated that all their computers be v6 connected by 2008. [1] This year they updated the mandate to 80% by 2025. [2]

I learned networking in college in 1996 and I remember v6 coming up but so far I've never had to use it and chances are that I'll be able to retire still getting away with only working with v4.

[0] https://blog.apnic.net/2018/05/21/what-drives-ipv6-deploymen... [1] https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/omb/memoranda/fy... [2] https://www.cio.gov/assets/resources/internet-protocol-versi...

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by zajio1am on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:51PM (#24759307)
Considering that World IPv6 Launch was 2012-06-06 and nothing really happened before, it makes more sense to say that it has taken 8 years to get to ~30% adoption.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by mprovost on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:04PM (#24759971)
I don't think you get to roll back the odometer and start counting again just because nobody adopted a technology from the start. That's not to say that adoption won't take off at some point - a lot of technologies experience exponential growth after a slow start. But the longer it takes to get started, the bigger the risk that something better will come along.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by wmf on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:30PM (#24757734)
If (eventually) each service needs an IPv4 address, that implies that there isn't a shortage and thus the value of addresses would be near zero.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by elihu on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:16PM (#24758972)
Yeah, that's been my theory for awhile: that IPv4 addresses are effectively a currency, and that a move to IPv6 would devalue that currency. A disproportionate amount of that currency is held by companies and institutions based in the United States, and in many cases they're the same companies and institutions that one might otherwise would expect to be responsible for much of the work of transitioning to IPv6.

Meanwhile, Asia has a relative scarcity of IPv4 addresses and so is (as far as I know) ahead of the curve because their incumbents have less to lose.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by laurent92 on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:56PM (#24760890)
Sorry for the stupid question but each time I got allocated an IPv6 address, I was allocated a /124 subnetwork (16 IPs) and not a single IP. How is IPv6 not going to be in shortage if even a small random actor like me gets allocated many IPs for each server?
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by dragonwriter on Monday October 12, 2020 @08:08PM (#24760972)
The IPv6 address space has 2^128 addresses. If you assign 2^4 addresses to every actual node, that still supports 2^124 nodes.

There's about 2^33 people on the planet, so that still supports about 2^91 nodes nodes per person.

A shortage isn't likely.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:24PM (#24756848)
> Assuming an average $25/address

It'll be $50/address in a year, $100/address in 2022; I'm sure of it.

Methinks now would be a very good time to invest^wspeculate in IPv4 addresses - I reckon it will be the next Bitcoin bubble-type event and likely even make it to the silly segment of TV news, with lampoonably inaccurate explanations of what an IPv4 address is to the general public.

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by nixgeek on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:57PM (#24757297)
Its been appreciating slowly for the last 5 years, I’ve seen deals in the $20-25 range throughout that time, and a few larger contiguous blocks going for a little more but not $50/ea.

You can monitor secondary market prices through RIPE fairly easily. What’s leading you to be sure it will increase 400% in the next 24 months?

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by DaiPlusPlus on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:31PM (#24757750)
> What’s leading you to be sure it will increase 400% in the next 24 months?

Honestly? Just a hunch. But also looking at trends on IPv4Auctions.com (now auctions.ip4.global), a few years ago blocks would go for $7/address, now they're $25/address - and as demand for IPv4 addresses won't be going away[1] and supply will only decrease (barring rare gluts of supply like AMPRnet's when a major /21 or /16 is broken down into smaller blocks to auction off).

I think $100/address would be an upper-bound though, because at that point it's likely cheaper to finally invest in IPv6 deployment, including issuing new CPE than it costs to retain IPv4.

[1] If an ISP could have deployed IPv6 by now then they would have done 5+ years ago. Any ISPs that haven't already deployed IPv6 by now (or even 5 years ago) must be facing some massive internal hurdles, such as incompetent management who see it as a massive and unnecessary technical expense when CG-NAT is good-enough for the majority of their customers - or have a hetereogenous network that would be a nightmare to bring up-to-code on any reasonable timescale). The only way these ISPs will upgrade is when the cost of operating an IPv4 network becomes unbearable - hence why I want to see IPv4 address costs skyrocket :)

Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by icedchai on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:04PM (#24760534)
I own a /24 registered back in the 90's. This is a "legacy" registration predating ARIN, meaning I pay no fees and never have. I have people emailing me about it now and then, but haven't sold it yet. I am using it for some dev servers.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by wmf on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:44PM (#24757901)
Note that IPv4 speculation is technically against the rules. Be sure to factor in the cost of "laundering" the IPs into your business plan.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by mindslight on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:19PM (#24760123)
You've got the incentives backwards. An organizational push for IPv6 would allow a company to free up their IP addresses and sell (/lease) them, actually realizing that valuation.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by wmf on Monday October 12, 2020 @07:50PM (#24760844)
So far it looks like companies are mostly selling IPs that they have never used so they get the money and they get to stick with IPv4.
Re:Sale of amateur radio AMPRnet TCP/IP addresses raised $108M by manquer on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:51AM (#24755689)
Apple and Comcast probably can use them.

Also Comcast may have to invest more in NAT grade infra if they sell significant chunk of their Class A allocation so it may not make sense for them.