The basic view is that HFT increases liquidity, which in the abstract should help everyone.
My friend's view was, first, that privileged access, special order types, etc, were so egregiously wrong it need not be discussed further. Second they found the liquidity argument weak, and in general believed that signals on such short timescales were often more harmful than beneficial.
They preferred a solution similar to yours, quantizing the markets by time and having one formally specified "fair playout" algorithm within the quanta. Pick the quanta such that it makes global communication time irrelevant (ie a few seconds). There's some subtleties to it but they considered the idea both workable and superior to what we have now.
I have to be somewhat circumspect for privacy, but this person was quite successful at stat arb, and in a previous life very successful at finding zero days in kernel code. I generally believe they know what they're talking about in great depth on the topic. They're exactly who'd be near the top of your list of prospects if you wanted to set up a HFT shop.
Can you dial down the snark and explain what argument you're making that doesn't fall under the above?
If you limit HFT, then markets /do/ become less efficient. When two trading venues for the same instrument exists, say, in Europe and the US, there is no benefit to any participant for a price disparity to exist for a long period. If $GOOG tanks 10% in a day, and a retail investor buys $GOOG at its old price in Europe, who is better off? Similarly for a seller in Europe, what if you were fleeced 10% because your holdings moved favourably in the moments before you sold?
HFT also makes trading cheaper for everyone. Much of the time these firms are primarily competing with each other. One way that competition manifests is in the bid/ask spread. With firms fighting for order flow, if they can improve their offer by a single cent to ensure price-time order book priority then they'll improve their price. For Joe Retail buying or selling that instrument, he just received a small improvement on the spread as a side effect of essentially duelling titans.
There are more aspects I'm not smart enough to discuss, like how HFT basically enables entire asset classes through dynamic hedging. The only reason that option markets exist on most stocks is because there is an HFT counterparty that sold you the option rapidly buying and selling the underlying stock to ensure its exposure to the position was only the premium you paid for the option.
HFTs also provide some market stability, first through increasing liquidity having a volatility smoothing effect, and second through so-called "volatility compression" as a result of option market dynamic hedging causing HFTs to buy when others are selling and sell when others are buying. This one has a darker side as depending on their aggregate positioning, HFTs will eventually begin to dump just like everyone else.
I believe HFTs are also necessary for exchange-traded funds to be priced correctly and function correctly. That's essentially because two markets always exist for an ETF: a primary market between dealers and the fund where creation/redemption units are traded, and the secondary market where regular folk buy its shares. Given the prevalence of ETFs as a retail investing vehicle, if they were mispriced this would be potentially disastrous for individual investors.
Probably a bunch more good reasons for HFT, I'm not sufficiently versed in this stuff
> For Joe Retail buying or selling that instrument, he just received a small improvement on the spread as a side effect of essentially duelling titans.
As a Canadian, I take advantage of this to do USD-CAD currency exchange. Most big Canadian companies trade in Toronto and New York, so I can buy in Toronto in CAD$ and sell in New York for US$ because some HFTs are keeping them exactly in sync. All I pay is two trading commissions and a 1-2cents / $100share in spread. So converting $30k would cost me $20 in commissions and ~$12 in spread, so about 0.1% in cost and that goes down for as much as I'm comfortable in doing per trade.
I probably lose a bit more in whatever distortion I've created, but $30k doesn't account for much in their hundreds of millions of $ in daily volume.
Edit: because otherwise you’d need to also wire transfer, right? (Not saying this isn’t rational, just asking).
Looks like all the major Canadian banks are a good option for this (https://seekingalpha.com/article/93201-11-top-canadian-divid...).
Lots of cross-listed Canadian banks, railways, resource companies and telecoms. Usually I use something high priced to minimize spreads and avoid earnings seasons.
Edit: And your brokerage doesn't force the settlement funds into your local currency at an exorbitant rate or anything? (I am deeply amused by your backdoor currency exchange)
You do have to 'journal' the holdings between them for my broker. This is now possible online, but used to require a phone call.
The big gotcha with this method (depending on your account and broker) is that you might need to wait for your 'buy' to settle (2 biz days I think?) before journalling, so you face some market risk).
The procedure is somewhat formalized: https://www.finiki.org/wiki/Norbert%27s_gambit
I'd argue at $10/trade, the bank/broker is also ripping off for stock transactions.
Sometimes brokers have bribes to get you to switch to them, so I might play that game one-day. $400 or $500 would cover years of trades for me e.g. https://forums.redflagdeals.com/scotia-itrade-new-client-up-...
If you choose a thinly traded cross-listed share, you could end up in trouble.
Then you see articles that these ones that make my blood boil: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-12/global-wa...
> Melting Arctic Means New Undersea Cables for High-Speed Traders
Amazing!
I can't shake the feeling that there can't be a simpler and more elegant solution to this problem, such as settling all transactions on some global discrete "tick" on the scale of a second to let the time for all exchanges to settle on a shared view of the market. The problem is that the incentives right now are not to create such a system, but rather to lay wires in the arctic to trade between Tokio and NY few milliseconds faster.
There are certainly human beings who manually arbitrage some markets even today, but that tends to be more complicated kinds of arbitrage. The only real connections between latency and trading strategy that I know of are:
Certain strategies don’t work if you aren’t the fastest kid on the block.
Certain strategies are too complicated to do if you are the fastest kid on the block. (For an example of the latter, you are unlikely to succeed in reading news reports, doing complex analyses, and executing trades based on your analyses in 100ns. No amount of money spent on top-of-the-line nVidia gear or tensor processing units is going to change this.)
For example at IEX when they introduced their speed bump, it was to protect their so-called 'mid peg' hidden orders. What they found was that these orders were still the target of adverse selection because some HFT trader could submit speculative orders well in advance, by predicting price movements based on fast information from connectivity to the order books of other exchanges.
That PDF is an awesome read ( https://iextrading.com/docs/The%20Evolution%20of%20the%20Cru... ), but I think it speaks to a more general problem of trying to slow down. Even if auctions on all exchanges only occurred once every 10 seconds, there will still always be an advantage to whoever can aggregate information the fastest and use this to submit a best price at the latest possible moment to participate in the auction.
In my uninformed state, it doesn't seem possible to truly reverse this process, and I'm left wondering what problem would be solved by attempting to eliminate HFT from the markets
The paper is a bit confusing:
> Suppose at a given point in time, the market has been stable for awhile (meaning the best bid and offer prices have not changed for several milliseconds), and trading venue V has an accurate, up-to-date view of the NBBO in that symbol as $10.00 by $10.02. So the resting buy order is pegged to the midpoint price of $10.01. Now, a seller comes along and trades with all of the buy interest at $10.00, changing the best available bid to $9.99. The midpoint of the NBBO is now $10.005, but this information does not arrive at trading venue V instantaneously. There is a small window of time in which venue V still believes the midpoint is$ 10.01, so if a matching sell order arrives at venue V during this window, it can trade with the resting buy order at$10.01. This is bad news for the initiator of the resting order, because the NBBO has already changed in their favor, and this execution at $10.01 goes against the spirit of what a midpoint pegged order is intended to accomplish.
Now I'm not a securities person and I don't really know the spirit of what the midpoint order is intended to accomplish. But if I were a serious trader and I had a buy order resting at $10.01, I would be rather annoyed at the beginning of this process -- a seller came and sold at $10.00, but my resting buy at $10.01 didn't match the seller. Similarly, the seller should be annoyed that they only got $10.00 and not $10.01.
(I assume this only obeys the NBBO rules themselves because IEX midpoint pegs are non-displayed, but I am not an expert here.)
There appears to be disagreement about what exactly a midpoint order is. Interactive Brokers says:
> A pegged-to-midpoint order provides a means for traders to seek a price at the midpoint of the National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO). The price automatically adjusts to peg the midpoint as the markets move, to remain aggressive. For a buy order, your bid is pegged to the NBBO midpoint and the order price adjusts automatically to continue to peg the midpoint if the market moves. The price only adjusts to be more aggressive. If the market moves in the opposite direction, the order will execute.
Which is rather different.
Personally, I find fancy order types to make the market unnecessarily complicated, and I also think that Reg NMS and the whole NBBO mechanism is well meaning but actually mostly makes the market worse.
I think the best way to stop the timing arms race is through tax structures that encourage longer-term investing, and penalize extreme short-term investing.
But you're up against people making lots of money in the arms race.
HFTs do on average make a small profit on each trade: they are in the business of charging investors for liquidity. But the fierce competition between HFTs means that their margins get competed down and they cannot charge very much for liquidity. Their average profit per trade is tiny.
The Taiwan stock exchange used to match orders every few seconds, like you suggest, instead of continuously. They switched to continuous trading earlier this year, and they say a little bit about why here: [0].
I might be wrong, but I think there is no rule preventing anyone from setting up a Taiwan-style batch-auction exchange in the US. Note that there are already over a dozen US stock exchanges, each with slightly different rules and order types, each competing for market share. If there's investor demand for a batch-auction exchange in the US, someone could create one and make a bunch of money running it.
[0] https://www.twse.com.tw/en/page/products/trading/information...
When large well informed funds want to trade large blocks of shares the price tends to quickly move against them so they make their trade at a slightly worse price. These funds would all like it if the market moved slower so that they got better prices so they made an exchange that moved slower.
The trick is that other people don't want to trade on exchanges with less up to date prices. So IEX made up a bunch of false stories about how HFTs were bad for retail investors. They even tricked Michael Lewis into writing a book/advertisement for them.
They also produced a slick video wrapping themselves in the flag/americana to try to trick people. You can watch it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2OZkTesSx0
Who needs $1M for their business but can't wait a microsecond to get it?
Once you have the funds you probably have to wait 3 days for the bank to grant access.
1) it still matters when in that second my order came in, and there's still a race, or
2) it doesn't matter when in that second my order came in, and there's an incentive to delay my order in case we learn something in that second.
In either case, the details will differ quite a bit, but having the fastest connection and best tech is still an advantage.
the point is to make those that are advantaged by such tools to gain evergrowing more power over others. isn't that the whole history of human civilization? when's it ever been about serving a social good.
Finance is the glue that allows us to barter in parallel with the world and across time. It does enormous social good.
The alternative is going to the supermarket with some JavaScript to buy broccoli.
The way that the bigger/better hedge funds and such avoid someone else doing latency arb on them is by having their own points of presence near global trading hubs. Their traders and algo systems decide on the trades to make, communicate them all to the POPs where they're held behind a release gate, then the POPs do a global drop of the gate based on gps/atomic time synchronization. It becomes impossible for any external system to get a latency arb advantage. An arbitrary number of exchanges could implement the same sort of ingress/egress system.
1. There will still be a race to update your entry in the auction as close as possible to when it runs, because equity markets do not operate in a vacuum. Correlated futures markets don't operate this way (and the regulatory lift to make them do so is separate, and just as hard as doing this for equities), so there is still a race to incorporate the most up to date information ahead of a periodic auction.
2. This _will_ widen the bid-ask spread and reduce liquidity, for the following reasons. There are right now 16 distinct exchanges, excluding dark pools. As a market maker, I want to show my quote to buy/sell to as many participants as possible, and so I quote across a decent subset of these exchanges at any given time. I _don't_ want to get simultaneously filled on all these orders, and am relying on the fact that most of the time if I get filled once, I can cancel from all the other exchanges and then re-evaluate what I think the fair value of the stock is, and put out new orders reflecting that view. The more confidence I have that I can do this, the tighter a spread I can offer, and on the flip side the more risk of overfill there is, the wider I need to quote to account for that risk. In a simultaneous periodic batch auction world anyone can take all available liquidity market-wide trivially, so I have to either reduce liquidity across the market to a lower level to cap my risk, or substantially widen my quote to make that risk economically viable. Both are ultimately bad for counterparties.
3. This would likely serve to entrench existing wholesalers unless they were forced to stop crossing orders internally, or otherwise play by a stricter set of rules (and good luck with that). The vast, vast majority of retail activity never sees a public marketplace, but is executed by a wholesaler - so if you're leaving them out of this picture you're not really changing much.
My personal $0.02 on this is that the latency race is just a turf war between liquidity providers, but has no real impact outside of that arena. There are other areas of needed reform: market fragmentation to the degree it exists today is a net negative IMO. Similarly the market-wide best execution requirement is just extra complexity and creates opportunities for regulatory arbitrage. The proliferation of exotic order types and "differentiating" exchange behavior adds complexity and creates opportunities to game the system. Exchanges charge exorbitant fees for access that create barriers to entry for smaller participants. To name a few.
A) What do you do when bids and asks do not match up? Who's orders get filled and who's do not? There are several possible answers to this problem, but not are satisfactory.
B) You do not eliminate the advantage of speed because everyone is still incentivized to put in their orders at the last possible moment before the end of the interval.
The world is continuous, not discrete. Therefore, like it or not, trading must be continuous and not discrete.
That is not true, there are market models where you run auctions all the time (with short but random auction end).
At the end of the day if I can see something in the real world and react to it faster than you can, that will give me an edge. That's just reality.
Your argument may hold for "real world" information and even then there's probably ways to even the playing field; but I'm not so sure for market information (e.g. momentum trades). Most short term trading is of the latter category except certain dates. After all information asymmetry is something that markets tend to want to reduce.
You just need to make it long enough so that microsecond latency would be diluted by the time it takes to execute the order.
Something important happens. Whoever reacts the fastest has an edge. I don't really know whether we're measuring "reacts the fastest" in terms of microseconds yet these days, but fastest is fastest no matter how much you win by.
And a follow up question:
Wouldn't the results of this be unpredictable because the price could either be lower or higher than when the individual non-HFTer pulled the trigger to execute the trade?
If this is a problem, I had this notion that stock markets (or the clearinghouses or whoever responsible) should slow down the allowed frequency to aggregate all trades within, say, 1 second, and do the clearing/price setting at that frequency. Surely being able to trade at the speed of 1 second is not a big loss of utility -- for the "legitimate" trading going on.
Can't we stop this timing arms race? Or is the problem I'm thinking of not actually a concern? Are millions of us paying half a cent to these HFT trading firms' profits with every trade, just like the old notion of shaving a half a cent interest off of everyone's bank accounts to make some clever criminal rich?