Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A...
by eska on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:39PM
(#24732361)
That contradicts with the article. The article states that the Muslim scholar theorized that god actively mutates the animals that want to adapt, i.e. god didn't just invent "the mechanism" of mutation, as you say.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A...
by pvaldes on Friday October 09, 2020 @02:55PM
(#24733146)
> Muslim scholar theorized that god actively mutates the animals that want to adapt,
This theory is a pastiche trying to use the "good parts" from Darwinism and is clearly worse than the original
Anybody claiming this, just don't have a deep understanding of mutations. Mutations are not a god's gift. Maths and science predict that they happen randomly, and most of the time they carry terrible consequences.
Lets take for example the people that inherited the butterfly skin syndrome. With a so fragile skin that it rips from the shoulder to the waistline at the minimum brush. Do this girl or this boy wanted to "adapt" to have a insufferable pain all the days of this life?
I seriously doubt that anybody would have asked for that. Lets be serious.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A...
by throwaway123x2 on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:40PM
(#24733627)
I mean it predated Darwin by a lot, we shouldn't be surprised it has its faults.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A...
by rtkwe on Friday October 09, 2020 @02:55PM
(#24733152)
I was talking in a more general sense not about the specific mechanism in the article, more about the general way science and religion can at least coexist somewhat coherently which is something a lot of online athiests perplexed by.
It leaves a little crack open for divinity and it's a lot around a question of why; why'd the big bang happen? why are the physical constants of the universe right in a series of bands such that stars, planets and everything else eventually formed? etc. It's a question parallel to science that has a lot of answers for what happens where this is more of a philosophical question of why.