News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by neximo64 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:13PM (#24724496)
You have to give Doppler your secrets which is absolutely crazy. Is there a self hosted version?

How does it fair against Vault? Vault is self hosted and open source.

Does everyone in this thread know the founder or something? No one is asking these and they're in my view the absolutely most important questions.

Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 09, 2020 @10:00AM (#24729960)
I had the same response. In fact, I assumed that there must be some kind of client-side secret wrapping with a customer-managed key or similar (i.e. you end up managing one secret, rather than n). I still need to secure access to the Doppler API key in any case.

Then I looked at the API documentation and it seems, no, you're being encouraged to send your secrets verbatim over the Internet.

I understand how this invites comparisons with the CSP secrets management products (e.g. AWS Secrets Manager), but it seems strictly worse from a number of perspectives:

* blast radius: if I'm a multi-cloud, or hybrid-cloud, property then compromise of one environment doesn't necessarily lead to compromise of the others; if I have all my eggs in one basket, like Doppler, then it seems like it does.

* Internet traversal: if I'm using something like AWS Secrets Manager from within AWS, I can entirely avoid having to traverse the Internet for my secrets by using VPC endpoints. Having to cross the Internet just means I'm exposed to more bad actors, an increased variety of attacks and also operational risk factors unrelated to security.

* (probable/possible?) segregation of duties concerns: the design of products like AWS Secrets Manager means that some kind of active collusion across product teams within AWS is required to create inappropriate disclosures and to conceal that disclosure. If secrets management is the only product line, that seems less likely to be sustainable.

Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by kfrzcode on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:07PM (#24725354)
I came here to find/make this comment - especially with secrets management, I don't want to rely on an external vendor being up to access/manage my secrets. I want full access.

License the software, let me deploy and manage it.

Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by phist_mcgee on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:45AM (#24727747)
That completely changes the kind of software that is being built, and would be a radical departure to their cloud based solution. Where do you store your secrets? AWS? GCP?
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by shoo on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:18PM (#24732136)
They'd get stored wherever is appropriate given what we already depend on to deploy software. If we deploy to our own data centre, that's where the secrets would go. If we're deploying to AWS, that's where the secrets would go.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by SkyMarshal on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:13AM (#24728762)
Yes, for secrets storage it either needs to be e2e encrypted, or self-hosted. E2e partly to protect against internal employee theft, and partly to protect against Doppler’s db getting pwned by malicious hackers, as is so common these days. Storing secrets in the cloud unencrypted is kinda crazy these days.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by bvallelunga on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:42PM (#24724730)
We realize that storing secrets requires trust and for some companies it may be outside of their comfort zone at the moment. We are currently focused on creating a super easy to use solution. An analogy: there are open source versions of Dropbox for users that don't trust Dropbox with their files (NextCloud, ownCloud, etc.), however this comes with the friction of having to host your own solution. We are more like Dropbox, where we want to create a solution that is incredibly easy to install, manage, and work with. That being said, a self-hosted solution is top of our mind as we totally acknowledge that some companies would not want to use a hosted solution.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by jerrygoyal on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:54AM (#24727791)
just thinking out loud.. isn't it a better solution if you implement e2e encryption with dashboard and cli like how password managers do? i mean it's secrets and as a company you also wouldn't want to get into any trouble. if user losses the password he can always disable old keys of respective services and generate new ones.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by nicoburns on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:41AM (#24728286)
Totally agree with this. I'd love a hosted solution for secret management, but e2e encryption seems like an absolute necessity.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by mackenbach on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:25AM (#24728513)
If e2e encryption is a requirement for you, consider checking out https://secrethub.io

Full disclosure: I'm the founder :)

Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by edpichler on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:47AM (#24728320)
That is a fair reason and I understand the target market you are aiming.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by say_it_as_it_is on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:10AM (#24728441)
It does seem like astroturfing is going on here. It wouldn't be the first time that a YC-backed startup has done so on HN.
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by blago on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:53PM (#24726261)
Is it so much different from giving someone all of your source code, data, and conversations?
Re:Launch HN: Doppler (YC W19) – Easily manage your env vars... by alextheparrot on Friday October 09, 2020 @12:20AM (#24726792)
Not completely, that’s why most of those also have self-hosted solutions available.

It is different in at least one important way: secrets (Such as private keys) are used to secure things (Such as code, data, or conversations) and thus are usually given a higher security priority (Like much tighter access control).