I agree, but commuting has significant mental-health benefits. It provides a clear mental separation between "work" and "home".
I and several of my coworkers have noticed that we never feel "off work" anymore. Work just bleeds into everything because there isn't that 30 minute period (enforced by the need to arrive home in time to make and eat dinner) to clear your head at the end of the day and mentally switch contexts.
My experience has been the exact opposite. I've been fortunate to have very reasonable commutes in all my jobs, but WFH is much better than my 25-30 minute commutes. I no longer get the "it's 5:50PM but can you take a quick look at this because you're the only one still here" issues that had me commuting home at 7 or 8 pm every few weeks. And then there's the 20 hours a week of time I get to play with my kid, do chores, or relax. Sure I still get the occasional slack message mid evening, but that was happening before WFH as well. There are downsides around ease of communication and sense of camaraderie, but work life balance/separation has been pretty much 100% win.
It seems to be a universal characteristic of people to co-opt largely harmful activities such as smoking for useful things such as social interaction or relaxation.
Again, that time on the bike/train/car provides head space to mentally context switch away from work time and into home time.
Plus, it's very easy to do "just one more" commit while you're boiling pasta for dinner.
This seems like a stretch for anyone who has ever dealt with rush-hour traffic in a major city.
I really feel like an ideal commute is one of the ultimate luxuries, given how much impact it has on daily life. Even better than 20 mins by car is 20 mins by bike/ on foot.
January 2019: https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/325959
January 2019: https://slate.com/human-interest/2019/01/jobs-workplace-priv...
February 2019: https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/327142
November 2019: https://hbr.org/2019/11/the-truth-about-open-offices
August 2020: https://www.businessinsider.com/open-offices-over-due-to-cor...
Still, I'm more productive in a cramped room with a door that closes than in an open offices, and I'm sure many others are too.
A lot of great startups start out in garages, but frankly most of us can't afford a garage, and some even sleep in less space than that. If we could afford homes that have garages, that would likely beat working in some big city skyscraper.
Only if you try to reimplement the traditional office and its processes in a WFH setting. That's an endeavour that's bound to fail.
In remote-first settings communication works differently, especially in that ideally it should happen mostly asynchronously, i.e. as written communication, which has the huge additional benefit of avoiding information silos through readily available documentation and decision records.
YMMV. Your home can be your ideal office, and is for many of us working remote (myself included). There are technology companies with hundreds of employees with billion dollar+ valuations who are fully remote. There is no proof they would be more efficient if you colocated all of those folks in person.
It is much harder to create a new billion dollar company if everyone is WFH, especially if there is a physical product as opposed to something that only manifests on screens.
It is much harder to on board and mentor new co-workers.
It is much harder to make a transition to the next position in your career, like a promotion or move within the company.
It is much harder to develop and maintain relationships that result in respect and trust for coworkers.
All of the above especially if most people are in the office.
I’ve become a bit like a contractor grinding through a series of similar projects, my career growth has stalled, and my only interactions with my coworkers who used to be friends now always boil down to ‘when will X be done?’
I would avoid WFH for anyone not in the sunset years of their career.
I think that one of the main reasons some people, and some professions (like banking), prefer working in person is because it is less accountable without the written/recorded history.
However, few offices are ideal. Traffic and commuting is one of the worst little things of daily life. It's dangerous. It ruins the environment. Parking sucks.
Good offices are wide open spaces, with good air, good climate, and cheerful environments. Many offices are bad environments and overcrowded.
There's a balance that COVID has tilted. Some will learn that they don't need offices anymore, especially when people have decked out their home offices. It's likely we'll see employers double down on home offices where they can. Some, like Airbnb or Apple might find that morale is better in their offices. Some smaller companies might set up theirs out of major cities, where lifestyle is cheaper and less crowded.