Yes in your instance, evaluated from an individual perspective, it seems absurd to worry about some imagined nefarious types breaking into your computer to get data like this.
But analysing the implications from an individual perspective is akin to forgoing fuzz testing on a web app because you'd never type all those sorts of inputs in as a normal user.
These things should always be analysed from a societal perspective. Having this type of data unencrypted means the father going through a child custody case may find all his movements lifted by a private investigator, the local politician who frequents a red light district may be at even greater risk of blackmail, and the small-town activist may find themselves harassed in new and interesting ways by local police of dubious moral character.
When presented with plausible scenarios like this there are certainly people who would still shrug and say, "I still don't care". That's fine - they're just not the people you'd trust to debate these issues, just like you wouldn't trust them debating internal security issues in a corporate environment.
However it appears that a certain segment of the community only get as far as analysing the immediate, personal impact of said security / privacy issues before giving the thumbs up. To them, there is no value in discussing / considering the wider social implications, because they don't actually care.
Perhaps that tendency should be called the narcissistic defect of security / privacy analysis.
Some number of people will lose their phone and their ex-spouse will find it and blackmail them with their location data (but not any other data on the phone). I have tabulated the total damage to society caused by this problem and arrived at a total of X. I have also tabulated the total cost of fixing this problem and arrived at a total of Y. Which is bigger, X or Y?
This narcissistic / short-term mindset is unhealthy, and is manifested in discussions around security ("I'm boring, who wants to hack me?") / privacy ("I'm boring, who's interested in me?") / liberty ("I have nothing to hide!") / environment (tragedy of the commons).
Someone working up a societal cost calculation as you outline clearly does not suffer from the narcissistic defect of security / privacy analysis that obviously rankles me. As long as people take a broader view it's perfectly reasonable to disagree on the importance / severity of a particular security / privacy breach.
In this particular instance the cost of modifying iOS to encrypt consolidated.db, store less data points, or allow users to easily opt out would be negligible.
If it was a little Silicon Valley startup they'd potentially go down in flames as HNers howled at them for taking such an amateur and reckless approach to users personal data. It'd certainly be a software defect that would quickly be patched by any little software house.
It's not like anyone can get access to it without breaking into your computer and it's not a real time feed. On top of the fact that it's only recording the gps location of the cell tower you're connected to (supposedly) it seems about as much of a security issue as my 4square feed.