And you can bet your ass the best schools and universities only have kids from upper middle class parents. Turns out free education just means subsidising rich kids' education with public money here, just like everywhere else.
The essay stresses the unfairness of depriving a subset of that underclass — ie: strivers — of a chance to pull themselves up.
The goal instead should be universally to lower American inequality. We should bring it closer to Finnish levels, even if Finnish levels are imperfect.
Yes, we have really high income taxes which means our income equality is less in Nordics than in the USA. However, that also means that strivers are unable to get rich. You can't get rich by working.
That means our wealth inequality is just as bad as in the US. Our 1% has just as much of the wealth and power as in the US.
Whereas in the US, that 1% is mostly entrepreneurs with minority having inherited, in Nordics it's the opposite.
Happy to dive deeper into statistics if you want to.
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/05/we...
I know that you know that poverty in your country, compared to the US, is a non-issue.
I know that you know that citizens in your country don't have basic educational deficits that many Americans have.
I know that you know that your country is very capable of competing in the world market.
As a reminder of the scope of the differences, see: https://youtu.be/YEywCppqeZo or https://youtu.be/JHDkALRz5Rk
So, I too am confused.
Both have a population of about 5 million.
And even Wisconsin is more diverse at 86% white to Finland's 96%.
Another fun note:
The population of Finland is only 20% bigger than the San Francisco-Oakland-Hayward, California Metropolitan Statistical Area, which is 4.1 million. If we add in the San Jose-Santa Clara-Sunnyvale, California MSA at 1.9 million, what we tend to consider the "San Francisco Bay Area" has a greater population than Finland.
In all but a few states, poorer school districts receive similar funding to rich ones: https://hechingerreport.org/in-6-states-school-districts-wit.... In several, poor school districts receive more funding.
Also, the U.S. is more comparable to the EU than to any individual EU country. Obviously, EU countries make their own funding decisions. But many EU countries push funding decisions even further down to individual localities. Germany and Sweden, for example, have highly decentralized education systems. The same is true for Canada. Indeed, in Canada, an even smaller percentage of school funding comes from federal sources (just 2%) compared to the US (about 5-10%).
* Poor kids are more likely to require special-needs programs and other kinds of extra attention.
* The district has different maximum class sizes for lower and higher income schools.
* On the other hand, the system lets teachers apply for transfers while keeping their seniority, so the higher income schools (where it's easier to teach) end up with higher salary costs.
So I'd have to see a breakdown on actual costs to know whether the general level of funding is actually a measure of whether rich and poor schools are receiving comparable funding relative to their actual needs.
https://www.texastribune.org/2019/02/15/texas-school-funding...
This article mentions multiple times how some funding calculations have not been adjusted in decades and ends with, "Most agree that the patchwork set of calculations for how to distribute money to Texas’ schools is ready for a major facelift." Convoluted formulas are piled on top of one another without achieving the goal of well-funded school systems, so I'd be all for throwing those out and going with something straightforward.
How does a large population affect policy? How much do economies of scale make things easier? How much does bureaucracy make things harder?
What does diversity mean? How much is in the eye of the beholder?
To what extent does diversity cause division? To what extent does diversity spark innovation?
In addition to these questions, the debate entails comparisons and contrasts of nations, most of which you hasn't visited. You end up trading pairs of statistics, without intimate knowledge of their correctness and equivalence.
For such reasons, I just avoid arguing about size and diversity. I'd have to write a book to provide a solid answer.
It’s a trope in itself to see the US as dumb for not simply adopting ‘sensible’ policies that seem to work elsewhere.
This comment is unnecessarily and rudely exclusive.
I went to a county-wide gifted magnet school that was a satellite to one of the regular county high schools. The athletes played sports at the main school, and non-athletes took gym classes there. About 20% of each class were varsity athletes, and the athletes fit in quite nicely with the non-athletes in academic and social settings.
It’s sad that you added this line, since your first sentence regarding the need for kids and (most importantly) families to take academics seriously is a very important point.
> This comment is unnecessarily and rudely exclusive.
Indeed. It's also completely wrong about TJ, just as it is about the school you went to. From my experience (graduating in '02), lots and lots of TJ students played sports -- and quite a lot of them were very serious about it and quite proud of how well they did. I believe our crew teams, in particular, were nationally competitive.
This is counter-intuitive to a lot of people who don't expect "nerds" to be interested in sports or "jocks" to be good at math, science, or technology. (Including me when I first got there.)
But I don't think it's a coincidence. It turns out that working hard, showing up, and keeping at it even when things aren't easy is a powerful way to get better at something. That's just as true for a sport as for an academic subject.
There are studies that school districts that dropped sports have better academic outcomes: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/10/the-cas...
Especially, what's with the focus on competitive sports? At school you absolutely want to reach the unfit kids because school sports is the only time they get any kind of exercise. You have to be inclusionary, the purpose is public health, individual fitness, not competition, but competitive sports is exclusionary.
Also, what's with the focus on team sports? American schoolkids have a staggering need for conformity, and team sports seem to feed that need.
I don't see such a study described in that article. After not finding it, I searched for "study", "studies", and "research", and still didn't. Can you perhaps quote a key sentence from the bit you're thinking of?
There is a story about one district that dropped football (not all sports), under severe budgetary pressure. Seems like the right choice. I should add some context that may not be obvious outside the US: that district is a small town in Texas, and Texas and especially its small towns are where high-school football is a really especially big deal. (My dad grew up in a small town in Texas.) In the rest of the country it's generally not so extreme as it was in that town.
That’s the system in France, where public schools can’t refuse kids, but those kids can only move classes if they passed. If you aren’t interested in studying you’ll spend your life in middle school until you’re 16 and just drop out.
Theoretically this can happen, but in practice it is very rare.
No school wants to be in such position.
A school with "bad" teachers would just get better teachers if it was warranted (in practice, everyone understands why kids are failing, and they'll send low experience teachers instead, because fuck them, I guess)
The surveys that I've seen show that bullying is pretty universal. About ⅓ of students worldwide are bullied at some point in their education, and these rates don't change all that much from country to country, although the form of bullying does have drastic differences. (Notably, Europe and the US tend to have less physical bullying and more psychological bullying compared to the rest of the world).
Ok, sure, but we don't need to destroy the great schools in order to work on making more pretty good schools.
If you want to turn bad schools into pretty good ones, please leave the great ones alone, while you go about that.
Different subsets of students require different amounts of attention, different specialties, different classes, etc. Go too fast and the bad students fall behind. Go too slow and good students will get bored and act out. One of my top students failed my class for missing too many lectures -- because attendance was written into the student contract to motivate the lower-performing students.
It would help America more to have universally "pretty good" schools, than a few great schools in a sea of "pretty bad" schools.
So, like many other American issues, the argument reminds me of two people in a tiny parking lot squabbling angrily over who is at fault for boxing the other in. If the business that designed and painted the lot allocated insufficient space, neither driver should blame the other.
The premise that there are groups in America who need saving from poverty and lousy schools is true, but why save only a few of them by sending them to a school for gifted students? Deal with the inequality of income and of the school system. Last time I checked, Finland does pretty well with that strategy.