Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by hanniabu on Saturday October 03, 2020 @08:36AM
(#24671596)
Makes more sense now than ever with the advent of starlink.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by DennisP on Saturday October 03, 2020 @08:46AM
(#24671668)
Yes, and in a positive way. Starlink plays a big part in funding Starship/Superheavy, and giving it an initial customer to get launch volume up. That's what will allow the much lower space transportation costs, cited by an astronomer in the article as making this observatory feasible.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by _Microft on Saturday October 03, 2020 @09:02AM
(#24671766)
I have seen lots of complaints from astronomers about Starlink interfering with optical observations but cannot remember hearing about radioastronomy being affected.
On the other hand - if it is up there, it sure can reflect radiosignals from Earth back again.
Has anyone heard about Starlink and the radioastronomy community?
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by gammarator on Saturday October 03, 2020 @11:28AM
(#24672646)
The impact of these constellations on radio astronomy is arguably worse, not least because it’s harder for the average person to see the impact.
https://www.thespacereview.com/article/3702/1
(They don’t just reflect radio waves, they broadcast them!)
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by whimsicalism on Saturday October 03, 2020 @11:37AM
(#24672701)
There's just no way that we as a society when deciding between "some shiny new satellite thing produced by an American corporation" versus "the quality of the VLAs operations" will pick the latter.
It pains me to say it, but the average person does not know what the VLA is, nor care at all.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by hutzlibu on Saturday October 03, 2020 @04:49PM
(#24674566)
I am not an average person, but have not heard of the VLA before either ..
Anyway, evem when you rephrase it:
Do you want fast internet everywhere?
Or better conditions for science to maybe find aliens?
Not many people would vote for science. Which is economically understandable, so I am all for a moon observatory.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by whimsicalism on Saturday October 03, 2020 @04:58PM
(#24674626)
It's not just science to find aliens, radio astronomy answers so many questions that we might not even think to ask - and it is not cost feasible to do all of those observations from space. It's as if in the 18th century, you were like "do we want to spend more money on roads? or do we want to keep funding these stupid experiments that Edison is doing for science?"
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by coryrc on Saturday October 03, 2020 @06:23PM
(#24675123)
No. I love space science, but knowing the origin of the universe will not bring us indoor lighting, refrigeration, clean energy, or anything like that. It is valuable in so far as it's worth some investment, but not so much it prevents us from providing global Internet.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by wbl on Saturday October 03, 2020 @10:31PM
(#24676151)
Starlink is not going to solve last mile access problems except for a small number of people. Even rural areas have towns, and it's a matter of spending the money to bring Internet to them the way we did electricity.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon
by whimsicalism on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:52AM
(#24679466)
You have no idea of what basic physics could learn from cosmology a priori, and neither do I.