This does not follow. As a heterosexual man I too wonder what it would be like to sleep with most women I meet that are in the fertile age range. This is less of an idiosyncratic personality trait than one built in by millions of generations of ancestors that all successfully bred. It does not imply that I consider those women to be less than human. In my own mind at least, it does not demean the women I speculate about.
But, in a nutshell, I am dirt poor and cannot seem to escape poverty in spite of apparently being the only woman to have ever spent time on the leader board of HN. Plenty of men have no problem using HN to network and make money. For me, it's mostly been a dead end in that regard.
And I get a zillion personal attacks and excuses when I say that, but if it is "just me" then explain to me where all the women "doing it right" are. Because I appear to manage to fit in here better than average in spite of my gender, yet cannot turn it into an adequate income even though that's an explicit goal of mine.
So when five million mostly men step over my body in the gutter and go "Meh, not my problem she can't afford to eat. It's not like I'm sleeping with her." it's pretty freaking dehumanizing.
And after eleven years here, I am quite clear that boils down to "Most men don't really want to engage me with me in a substantive and meaningful fashion if I am not going to sleep with them and even if I did sleep with them, I would merely be a sex object. They still wouldn't engage me meaningfully in a lot of the ways I want to be engaged."
That opinion is based on 55 years of living, lots of reading and yadda. It's not an uninformed or knee jerk opinion by any stretch of the imagination.
Eleven years ago, I showed up here (on HN) all naively assuming I should be treated like a person simply because I am one and that's not been my firsthand experience of participating here.
Those same men also step over male bodies in the gutter because of their same lack of utility. They dehumanize both sexes with equality.
There is always some justification for how it somehow isn't sexist that I cannot successfully use HN as a means to establish an adequate income, even though plenty of men do so and even though I appear to be the top ranked woman here and it is an overwhelmingly male space and so forth. But I still get told over and over and over "Well, that's not evidence of sexism. You're just basically a Loser."
Uh huh. Whatevs.
That's actually a human thing (now I'm equating and I threw in an 'actually') but it's so, so, so, much more ubiquitous with guys+internet.
The steps between me doing that by default and sometimes not doing that - well, it was a lot of steps. Or time. Something.
I'm a slow learn so I have to grind away at things repeatedly before I really get a handle.
But if I weren't already extremely good about assuming good intentions and interpreting the actions of others through a lens of benign and reasonable motives, I couldn't have stayed this long.
The problem is that me understanding why guys do the things they do and yadda keeps the focus on guys and how important their feelings and what not are and fails to move anything forward in terms of me resolving my very real issues with trying to make ends meet.
I spent a ton of time in therapy because I was sexually abused as a kid and I have thought a lot about it and if just sleeping my way to a solution would work, I would have no qualms about doing that.
The problem is that I don't get treated like an actual person whether the answer to sex is "yes" or "no." In neither case does it ever lead to me being able to establish some kind of earned income for something other than sex work, in essence.
Honest to god, if just sleeping with a guy would open career doors for me, I would take that option in like a heartbeat. But it doesn't work. (See Theranos for evidence of how very poorly that works.) My last two serious boyfriends were supposedly potential career contacts and they never did the first thing for my career aspirations.
Once a guy gets sexually involved with me, sex is all it is. And if he doesn't get sexually involved with me, in most cases that means he doesn't get involved with me at all. (And I don't think that's "just me." Again: See Theranos for an example of how poorly it works to intentionally try to open doors for your career by sleeping with men with money.)
Most men do not want to support my work, promote my work, discuss my work, open doors for me career-wise, etc etc etc etc etc.
And that leaves me unable to establish an income while having to listen to the same really lousy explanations, dismissals, sympathetic noises and so forth year in and year out while my income barely budges.
I run r/GigWorks and a zillion other little subreddits and I run a bunch of homeless websites. If you are not familiar, Street Life Solutions has a list of some of the most pertinent ones in the sidebar:
https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/
Pocket Puter has this link on its Links page:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JfNAbUX_lN9K3MCNHO15...
I"m actually getting a surprising amount of support in this discussion. Things used to be a lot rougher for me on HN. At least some of the worst and ugliest stuff tends to get fairly promptly flagged to death these days.
but what about online? often you wont get to know how these women look like. more often than not, imagination is better than reality. what makes women attractive online?
That actually means it is impossible to get any kind of decent treatment as a woman, no matter what you do.
If someone wrote, "as a man, an awful lot of women are list of stereotypical anti-women comments", I would have responded in kind. I would have called him out for being a sexist and point out that men also misbehave.
In what world is saying men and women are equal human beings who can equally be horrific be a flamewar comment.
> and it wrecks what it is for.
This doesn't? Is this what hacker news is for?
"If you are a woman, an awful lot of men treat you like you are nothing but a pussy to fuck and their entire interaction boils down to deciding if they would like to fuck you in specific or not and whether they want to fuck you or not, it's all downside for the woman. If they want to fuck you, they will be using you and mistreating you. If they don't want to fuck you, you will not be treated like a human being. You will be ignored, at best, or treated with open hostility.
I've spent a lot of years trying to "just be a human being" on the internet and, just like off the internet, the vast majority of men I run into find out I am a woman, wonder to themselves if they would like to sleep with me and regardless of the answer, the outcome is I will never, ever, ever, ever be treated like a human being. I will be treated only like a walking, talking sex object who utterly doesn't matter and has nothing whatsoever of value to add other than maybe sex and doesn't deserve any respect, any intellectual outlets, any friends, any money, etc. unless I am sleeping with some man who has an adequate income.
No, I am not exaggerating."
So if I wrote a highly exaggerated politically biased statement starting with "a lot blacks do X", "a lot of chinese do Y", "a lot of muslims are Z", etc and claim it isn't an exaggeration, that would be okay?
I'm more than willing to admit my mistakes, but I didn't here and if you want to stop flamewars, go speak to the OP.
It's easy to understand how DoreenMichele's post could have triggered a defensive/offensive response. I get activated by comments that way all the time. For thoughtful discussion, we need the skill of processing that activation energy in ourselves, rather than allowing it to turn directly into words. Lashing out does provide momentary relief (which is why we do it of course), but it's not a real solution and it damages the container (the community environment) in the process.
The difference with DoreenMichele's comment is that she was speaking about her personal experience. It's true that the comment was provocative. But it wasn't really an abstract generalization. If you had responded by speaking about your personal experience on the same level, that would be a conversation—perhaps a difficult one—but not a flamewar.
Of course, where to draw these lines is matter of interpretation and different people would draw them differently. But watch out for the bias where we always see our own comments as less harsh than they actually land with others. As I said in a different context recently, comments in the rear-view mirror are much larger than they appear!
The other issue of course is that moderation responses are conditioned by an account's past behavior on the site. You've unfortunately been making a habit of posting in the flamewar style and/or including harsh swipes in your HN comments:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24666716
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24665961
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24665856
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24654852
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24618909
...and we already asked you to stop doing this. That's why my reply to you used stronger language this time.
You're 100% welcome here. We just need you to take the site guidelines more to heart and practice them going forward: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. That isn't easy, but we all need to work on it in order for HN to be the community we want. That is in all of our interests.
Perhaps objectivity may not be the most precise word. Maybe "another point of view". Or better yet, the middle ground. I was trying to counter her extremism the best I could.
> It's easy to understand how DoreenMichele's post could have triggered a defensive/offensive response.
Because it was flamebait. It was intentionally divisive and toxic extremism. It's no different than what racists, chauvanists and all kinds of extremists do. By now, it's obvious to most people who aren't ideologically blind. Replace "men" with "women" in her comment and you'd spot the hateful sexism right away. I'm sure of it.
> The difference with DoreenMichele's comment is that she was speaking about her personal experience.
No. It's not. There was no personal anecdote, no mention of personal event. Just generalizations like "if you are a woman ... " and some bizarre projection about "what men think". That's the point. It's an obvious exaggeration. The easy tell is that she ended her diatribe with a defensive "No, I am not exaggerating.".
Even if her experience were real, her sexist comment is clearly not what HN is about. If you are truly sincere, would you allow people who had negative experiences with "jews", "chinese", "blacks", "gays" or "women" to freely express their views here? Can someone take their personal negative experience and then extrapolate that to most jews, most chinese, most blacks, most gays or most women? Of course not. It would be insane to paint millions or billions of people with the same brush.
> You've unfortunately been making a habit of posting in the flamewar style and/or including harsh swipes in your HN comments:
Yes, I made a mistake here or there, but then again, it was mostly in response to flamebait from an obvious bigot and trolling throwaways. I've never went out of my way to attack a certain gender, race, religion, etc like DoreenMichele.
> ...and we already asked you to stop doing this. That's why my reply to you used stronger language this time.
And it's why my response to DoreenMichele was far tamer than my response to the throwaway. And it may be personal bias, but the more I read her comment and mine, the more it feels like hers is extremely biased and hateful while mine is relatively benign.
> That is in all of our interests.
Fair moderation. That's all I ask for. I know it's a tough job but honestly, if I felt that the commenter would have been admonished, I wouldn't have wasted my time responding to her in the first place. Because her comment is like all hate speech - they all follow the same pattern and hit the same beats. It's boring. But if left unchecked it'll fester and grow. Still shocked she hasn't been reprimanded and her hateful comment hasn't been flagged. But I'll try do better and I'm sure you will try to do better and hopefully DoreenMichele comes to terms with her hate and has a better life both on and off the internet.
I've spent a lot of years trying to "just be a human being" on the internet and, just like off the internet, the vast majority of men I run into find out I am a woman, wonder to themselves if they would like to sleep with me and regardless of the answer, the outcome is I will never, ever, ever, ever be treated like a human being. I will be treated only like a walking, talking sex object who utterly doesn't matter and has nothing whatsoever of value to add other than maybe sex and doesn't deserve any respect, any intellectual outlets, any friends, any money, etc. unless I am sleeping with some man who has an adequate income.
No, I am not exaggerating.