All of the comments are getting flagged and killed. I don't see any rule breaking.
2. Nothing good is going to come out of adding to that flamewar.
3. It crosses into personal attack, which is particularly not ok.
4. Please email [email protected] with questions like this, rather than posting off-topic comments. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
“There is a sadly high level of Indigenous incarceration, I think it’s about 30% compared to 3% of the population,” Mitchell said, while interviewing the prime minister on Thursday. “But black deaths in custody, I mean, that’s, that’s a furphy, isn’t it? I mean, since the royal commission, as I saw it, there have been fewer Indigenous people, per head of prison population, dying in custody than have white people?”
Morrison replied: “That is welcome news.”
However, the death rate per prisoner is only part of the story. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are 10 times more likely to die in custody than non-Indigenous people in Australia."
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/death...
Unfortunate, an injustice, a tragedy, a disaster, a systemic failure to integrate, yes. But racist? You're going to have to spell that one out for me. Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist. Thats a symptom of a problem that predates most of us sitting here in our armchairs.
Talk about the real problem not the symptom, but whatever you do, don't start calling all white people racist for being nothing but white, all that does is alienate allies and make you look like a moron.
Edited to respond to your edits:
> Aboriginal people just commit more crime. That isn't racist.
Unqualified statements asserting that a specific racial group "just commit more crime" is pretty much an applied definition of the word "racist". Isolated statistics about aboriginal behaviour used to buttress your assertion that you are not racist, just seem to underline the fact that perhaps you have much to learn.
If you'd said, "statistically, aboriginal people commit more crime. Studies have shown that this is because of chronic health and economic issues which have never been adequately addressed by any Australian government", that would probably not be racist, but I'd want to defer to an aboriginal person before putting my neck out too far on that one either.
One of the difficult things about racism is that it does not matter how we (ie, people of European descent) feel about it, but how the people we're talking about feel about it.
> Thats a symptom of a problem that predates most of us sitting here in our armchairs
What problem are you talking about? The problem that we invaded their land, shot them, stole their children, and to this day oppress them both economically and legally?
> all that does is alienate allies and make you look like a moron
No ally of mine is going to be alienated or offended by simple statements of truth.
For what it's worth you are doing the EXACT same thing the post in this article is about: you are pushing a very American view on racism.
First of all, racism is absolutely not White -> Black. Or White -> Aboriginal. If you think that I'd assume you haven't met a lot of people form other parts of the world. Racism is everywhere and it's not a White-only issue. That's a very American view.
Second of all, it absolutely DOES matter what 'we' (white people) think of it. Saying only people we talk about get to have a say in this is also a very American viewpoint.
We really don't need to "defer to an aboriginal person", as you say. Just like this article states you are now assuming that all aboriginal people agree on this subject.
Saying we aren't qualified to say what's racist but we need a minority for that is the kind of generalizations the article pushes against.
I never said that racism was white/black, but I was writing specifically in the context of European racism against Aboriginals in Australia, which happens to be fairly black and white. I’m happy to discuss racism in other countries, but that wasn’t the topic at hand.
Of course it matters what white people think about racism. But it doesn’t hurt to get the opinion of those who are actually harmed by it, does it? I mean I have never had the misfortune of experiencing racism first hand, so if I say something that an aboriginal person considers racist, that’s something I would want to take very seriously.
I never said “we” aren’t qualified to say what is racist. What I’m not so confident about, when specifically talking about aboriginal people, is claiming that my statements are not racist.
Overt racism is pretty easy to spot, but just because I try to be considerate doesn’t mean that the things I say in good faith can’t nevertheless be racist.
Keeping an open mind and listening to how others feel is more important than my biased opinion.
One is extremely diminishing and the other is a pretty easy to write off as ignorance, differing upbringing, and a general intolerance of difference.
If you need me to spell out a clear cut example of racism it's a few comments earlier where you assumed I was white and discounted my views on this matter solely because of it. Either that or what I was saying didn't fit your American centric narrative.
For what it's worth,
"statistically, aboriginal people commit more crime. Studies have shown that this is because of chronic health and economic issues which have never been adequately addressed by any Australian government"
Was pretty much the gist of what I was getting at but I thought that was pretty obvious given the context and adding the context doesn't really make my statement any more or less factual. More credible maybe, but if you took my remarks on good faith it wouldn't have been a problem. But that is the problem with this American narrative, everyone is too busy trying to win, nobody is trying to look at facts for what they are and find the common ground therein.
These facts don't make aboriginal people any less human or any less successful as a people. They're just shitty truths about the world.
You are right that I thought you were white. It is because you said, "don't start calling all white people racist for being nothing but white". I apologise for the assumption.
You did, however, call me a moron, which doesn't really strike me as arguing in good faith.
You also said this:
> The aboriginal people of Australia face real problems. The police isn't one of them.
If you live in Australia and you don't think that cops are, at least until relatively recently, a huge part of the problem with Aboriginal welfare, then maybe you missed the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody [0]. I was in high school when that stuff went down, I remember how many people were being killed, and the fact stands that Aboriginal people are 10x more likely to die in prison than Europeans.
"The key finding of the royal commission was that Aboriginal people are more likely to die in custody because they are arrested and jailed at disproportionate rates. That remains as true in 2020 as it was in 1991." [1]
> For what it's worth, "statistically, aboriginal people commit more crime. Studies have shown that this is because of chronic health and economic issues which have never been adequately addressed by any Australian government" Was pretty much the gist of what I was getting
But that's not what you actually said.
> I thought that was pretty obvious given the context and adding the context doesn't really make my statement any more or less factual.
Mate, there was very little context in what you wrote. If I took you the wrong way then I apologise, but maybe you can accept your part in this too. Maybe you didn't express yourself as well as you might have. That's cool, but how you express yourself is not my responsibility.
> if you took my remarks on good faith it wouldn't have been a problem. But that is the problem
You called me a moron!!
> with this American narrative
...and you assumed I'm American? Or that I don't have my own reasoned narrative? That's not really good faith now is it?
> everyone is too busy trying to win, nobody is trying to look at facts for what they are and find the common ground therein.
When you say that "Aboriginal people just commit more crime", that's not a fact, it's a tautology; of course they commit more crime, they are generally poorer and sicker, because of how they've been treated. I'm pretty sure that poor white people commit more crime too. Aboriginality has nothing to do with criminality; and just because a statement is true, through some twisted logic, doesn't mean it can't also be racist.
That doesn't mean that I think you are a racist; I have no idea. But I do think what you said is.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Commission_into_Aborigin...
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/death...
edit: add quote
You're talking about white Europeans failure to integrate with Indigenous Australian societies, right?
Cultural integration requires both cultures to integrate.
No, it isn't equal sided, no it isn't fair what has happened, but ignoring the current status quo and positing Europeans should be actively trying to go bush is just facetious.
Isn't that the same argument people use in the US to justify why more Black Americans are incarcerated / killed by cops?
If that is actually your stance, I'm confused as to how you see Australia as fundamentally different from the US.
https://youtu.be/fNSRz-MCM1w?t=253
Seriously this trying to draw false comparisons with America where there aren't any is exactly what the OPs article is about.
In this video they also say that changing the date of Australia Day is “ridiculous”. That’s not necessarily bad in and of itself, but it’s certainly not an opinion shared by all aboriginal people and it strongly suggests that they aren’t impartial.
If this is the best you’ve got to defend your views, you don’t got much at all.
Jordan shanks is one of the small handful of legitimate journalists we have in this country.
Given chronology, that's not entirely or even largely on them.
Laws are written by human beings. In the US, a lot of laws were written with explicitly racist goals of denying certain groups equal access. We are still living with that legacy in myriad ways.
If you write laws designed to target certain groups and land them in jail, don't be all shocked when a lot of those folks wind up in jail. And then, yes, "x group just commits more crimes" is a racist statement because it glosses over the context that the "crimes" they commit are "crimes" invented by White power holders to intentionally deny such people rights.
White fragility is a best seller being heavily pushed by people all over America.
Er... that sounds incredibly racist?
Really, it's due to economic circumstance (I bet poor white people are convicted of more crimes than rich white people). It just so happens that the system makes it very difficult for indigenous people to move up the economic ladder. The system is set up in such a way that it assumes indigenous people want to and/or should confirm to white European ideas of what is "normal" as well.
Absolutely. Not that it's anything new. Nor is it limited to ethnic minorities. Consider Anatole France's observation[0]: "The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread."
Also, they called me a moron, which (accurate or not) is not cool.
> The system is set up in such a way that it assumes indigenous people want to and/or should confirm to white European ideas of what is "normal" as well
I suspect that the system does not assume that aboriginal people want or should be European; rather, it doesn't think about aboriginal people at all.
If only we had a convenient word for this, "the confluence of negative formal and material circumstances put upon someone because of race"...
Racist is a race discrimination. Race discrimination is when you are treated differently because of your race.
https://equalityhumanrights.com/en/advice-and-guidance/race-...
Skin color is not the reason of a certain person to have certain ability, or certain moral standard.
"Aboriginal people just commit more crime." is a factual statement about how many aboriginal people committing crime. It could be true or false. If the statement is "Aboriginal people just commit more crime, because they are aboriginal", then it is racist because it draws a causal relationship of race and crime rate which is completely false.
Nowadays, from a statement of "Aboriginal people just commit more crime.", someone can see through the proposer's mind to assume he has stereotype impression on aboriginal people and inside his/her mind, the proposer thinks because of people's skin color, they will just magically commit more crime. So, it is concluded that the proposer is racist. This is thought crime, and law should assume people is innocent until proven in case of criminal law.
It is really bad, because it does not let people to lay out the data based on race, and therefore cannot solve the real problem behind it. Why a specific race would commit more crime in a country? There must be a reason behind it. Maybe only one community with majority of a specific race committing most of the crime, and other communities of that race are completely normal. Then you have to further find the reason why that community committing so many crime etc.
However, the left in America does not think like that. They just get a aggregate data of the country and lay out many disadvantage of certain race facing, and so it can justify minority group to victimize themselves.
A term systematic racism is coined. If there is no equal outcome for each race then the society is racist. No active actors of racist is involved. The system itself is designed which cause non equal outcome among races and therefore must be overthrown and replaced with a non racist system.
The whole idea is just giving up thinking analytically about the root cause of non equal outcome and blame it all to the society. If there is not enough educational resource because the state is consist of mainly poor blacks, then just let the rich state to subsidize the poor state. Rejecting better grade non-black is just solving the problem by a racist measure which is not moral. And it is also racist against the black because it implied black are just dumber, and I find it strange for black to accept that. No, because they are poor and does not have enough educational resource.
I think the America left is so irrational that it starts to be very similar to Soviet Union style of thinking.
PS: Not-White. Just a observation from other race outside America.
The statement "people who have been abused continuously for 200 years commit more crime" might be true, and is not racist. [0]
The statement "Aboriginal people just commit more crime" is true only because Aboriginal people have been abused continuously for 200 years.
If you single out the race but leave out the cause, then the statement is clearly racist.
> Aboriginal people just commit more crime
More crime than who?
More crime than "Normal" people?
Or, More crime than all other groups with the same economic opportunieis?
More crime than groups with the same health issues? More crime than other people who go blind from trachoma and trichiasis despite it no longer being a public health problem in any other developed country in the world? [0]
More crime than other people who have had their children systematically stolen?
More crime than other people who have been racially abused in public, while playing a game of football?
I mean, come on, you're a smart cookie. You can't accept a claim that "aboriginal people commit more crime" unless you compare it to some equivalent group. Aboriginal and non-aboriginal people are not remotely equivalent, because aboriginal people have been systematically denied the freedom, health outcomes and economic opportunities available to almost any other group in Australia.
[0] https://healthinfonet.ecu.edu.au/learn/health-topics/eye-hea...
A fact is a statement about reality. It can induce racism, but cannot be racist in itself. Facts are scientific, and science is not political.
> More crime than who?
Of non-Aboriginal people.
> Or, More crime than all other groups with the same economic opportunities?
Maybe or maybe not. That is beside the point. If you compare incarceration rates of Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people you have already decided that that is the division of the population you want to reason about. You cannot argue that the reason group A has higher incarceration rates of group B is because of racism, and when someone else proposes crime rates as an explanation, suddenly you switch to different population subdivisions: by economic opportunities, by health issues, etc.
The question about incarceration is: are Aboriginals more likely to be incarcerated for the same crimes than non-Aboriginals?
It can be produced with a racist intent, or it can be interpreted as such. You can talk of the result of the calculation in a racist way, or derive racist conclusions from it. But per se, it cannot be racist. And you cannot decide to ignore the result of a calculation because you don't agree with the discussion or the questions it generates.
EDIT (rate limited): as for your other answer "By saying "Aboriginal people just commit more crime" you are declaring that race is a relevant factor..." you are confusing correlation with causation. Or you are assuming that I might be confusing them.
Surely that means that information generated by the system is also going to be influenced by that racism?
If we over-police, over-charge, over-prosecute, and over-convict one group of people then the system will generate "facts" that tell us this group of people commit more crime. Obviously we don't know if that group of people do commit more crime because we're relying on broken data.
By saying "Aboriginal people just commit more crime" you are declaring that race is a relevant factor in someone's propensity to commit crime.
I'm so over hearing about this bullshit here. The aboriginal people of Australia face real problems. The police isn't one of them.
PS, keep your debates to yourselves too. Nobody cares and your media cutting Trump out of context is obvious and gross. You are literally becoming the fake news he always said you were.