News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by IgorPartola on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:16PM (#24610583)
This is the first time I have seen nuclear described as more expensive. My understanding was that it was several times cheaper than coal. I could be totally wrong of course.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by hwillis on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:36PM (#24610744)
That's because its a bit of a bait and switch. When people pull that out, it's about keeping existing plants running- extending them to run for 60+ years. That's pretty cheap, since the cost of fuel is tiny and you just need to pay for the ~1000 people onsite. The issue there is risk- you can't just open up all the valves to check how worn out they are, or if all the computers still have nice transistors and clean relays. You can do some basic stuff like looking for cracks, but the system is ancient. Who knows if that is okay or not.

Then, if you talk about new construction, the issue is cost but the conversation is entirely about risk. There's very, very little danger even for many decades. Cost is another matter. The best estimates are that nuclear costs as much as the most expensive other technologies to build, but the actual end figure has just gotten higher and higher over time. Manufacturing is not what it used to be and these huge plants have been outpaced by smaller plants and different technologies.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:43PM (#24610767)
That’s just part of the story, annual nuclear refueling is also surprisingly expensive. The raw material is cheap, but you need to refine it to reactor grade, creating fuel rods, and only use ~6% of it before replacing the rods. So on net it ends up being quite costly before considering long term storage. You also need to shutdown the reactor for refueling. Other costs like maintenance starts to really add up over time. Similarly, reactors are small but nuclear power plants take up a lot of land for security, staff, etc.

It’s really a combination of several factors that’s keeping Nuclear so expensive in every country around the world not just the US.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by HarryHirsch on Sunday September 27, 2020 @07:01PM (#24610907)
Also the nuclear waste problem. Nuclear reprocessing looks nice on paper, but the technical implementation is problematic, it's chemistry but in a radioactive environment. If something catches on fire there's problems.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by titzer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @08:16PM (#24611480)
France has successfully processed 23,000 tons of spent fuel, or 14 years worth. With zero incidents. In fact it works so well, they process other countries' spent fuel, too.

https://www.heritage.org/environment/commentary/recycling-nu...

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by natmaka on Monday September 28, 2020 @07:34AM (#24615510)
Spent-fuel processing isn't sufficient. After ~50 years with running nuclear plants France doesn't have any long-term waste disposal facility, and is actively searching a solution.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meuse/Haute_Marne_Underground_...

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by arnoooooo on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:30AM (#24614330)
They have also very successfully "outsourced" part of the reprocessing to eastern Europe… there have been documented reports of storage in huge open vats of fuel officially sent for reprocessing.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Sunday September 27, 2020 @08:58PM (#24611729)
That article shows the issue. “The entire process adds about 6 percent in costs for the French.”

Reprocessing is simply not cost effective due to how cheap reactor grade Uranium is.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by titzer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @09:42PM (#24612083)
So you are saying the reason a huge problem exists is because money? Hold the phone.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Sunday September 27, 2020 @10:14PM (#24612285)
This is mostly just a problem in the minds of the general public.

Individual nuclear fuel rods get significantly less radioactive over time as short half life byproducts decay. Which makes both reprocessing and long term sequestration cheaper. Storing them for ~100 years is relatively cheap and can be funded ahead of time, so punting the issue seems quite reasonable IMO.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by titzer on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:44AM (#24614427)
Well, sure, we are lucky that the waste from nuclear reactors is primarily solid heavy metals rather than fly ash or anything else, so we can just plunk them into pools and forget about them for a while. But eventually it makes sense to do something with all that waste.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Monday September 28, 2020 @02:41PM (#24619926)
Reprocessing doesn’t actually get rid of the highly radioactive waste though. You have exactly as much Caesium-137 and all the other nasty fission products before and after reprocessing, all it does is separate the waste you need to store from the useful fuel while contaminating all your reprocessing equipment. As we have plenty of fuel so that not particularly valuable.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by johnisgood on Sunday September 27, 2020 @10:52PM (#24612503)
What nuclear waste problem?

"Nuclear waste generally is over 90% uranium. Thus, the spent fuel (waste) still contains 90% usable fuel! It can be chemically processed and placed in other reactors to close the fuel cycle. A closed fuel cycle means much less nuclear waste and much more energy extracted from the raw ore. Additionally, this process allows you to convert your waste into chemical forms that are totally immobilized. France currently recycles their spent fuel. They put the remaining good nuclear fuel back in their reactors in the form of MOX fuel and immobilize the remaining waste in vitrified borosilicate glass.

The US had a recycling program featuring the use of advanced fast reactors (which have not been deployed on any major scale yet) that was shut down because it created Plutonium, which could be used to make a nuclear weapon. Were some plutonium diverted in the recycling process, a non-nuclear entity could be one step close to building a bomb. However, under programs such as the (now stalled) GNEP [wikipedia], where only countries who already have nuclear weapons recycle, proliferation-free waste recycling can exist. Since the many of the largest energy users are already nuclear weapons states, a massive expansion of nuclear could be done there with no additional proliferation concerns whatsoever.

If all the electricity use of the USA was distributed evenly among its population, and all of it came from nuclear power, then the amount of nuclear waste each person would generate per year would be 39.5 grams. That’s the weight of seven U. S. quarters of waste, per year! A detailed description of this result can be found here. If we got all our electricity from coal and natural gas, expect to have over 10,000 kilograms of CO2/yr attributed to each person, not to mention other poisonous emissions directly to the biosphere (based on EIA emissions data).

If you want raw numbers: in 2018, there were just over 80,000 metric tonnes of high-level waste in the USA. Between 1971 and 2018, nuclear reactors in the USA generated 3000 GW-years of electricity to make this waste.

For comparison, in 2007 alone the US burned 948,000,000 metric tonnes of coal. This means that coal plants made 32 times more waste every single day than the US nuclear fleet has made in the past 45 years! Granted, coal made a higher fraction of the country’s electricity, but the numbers are still crazy impressive for nuclear."

Source: https://whatisnuclear.com/waste.html

---

Interesting: "2018 Nobel Prize for Physics-winner Gérard Mourou has proposed using Chirped pulse amplification to generate high-energy and low-duration laser pulses to transmute highly radioactive material (contained in a target) to significantly reduce its half-life, from thousands of years to only a few minutes."

---

Aaaand then I have not yet mentioned fusion reactors... Just check it out here: https://www.iter.org/sci/Fusion

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by ncmncm on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:17AM (#24613845)
There will be no useful fusion power produced on Earth in this century, at least in a Tokamak.

Tokamak fusion is a jobs program for high neutron flux physicists, to maintain a population to draw on for weapons work. It does not need to produce other results.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by willis936 on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:12AM (#24616259)
The first part is very likely wrong.

Fusion won’t be a major grid player in this century and by extension may be “too late” for meaningful climate change. However, we may be more fucked than people think. Seasonal energy storage (10^14 Wh scale) has no solutions. Where are the low carbon alternatives to base load power production?

The second part is entirely wrong. That only applies to IEF programs in the US. NIF is the weapons program. Most of the money going into fusion energy research is to say “at least we tried” when the energy crisis causes a societal collapse.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Monday September 28, 2020 @12:08PM (#24618162)
There is zero need for seasonal storage. Solar is insanely cheap, just build excess capacity. If on average 50% of annual solar generation was wasted, that bumps it up to ~4c/kWh. Assuming 40% of your energy needs comes from battery‘s that adds 10c/kWh * 40%. So your total 24/7 365 grid energy including peaking power averages to just 8c/kWh which is vastly less than nuclear.

Further that’s optimistic from nuclear’s perspective, hydro and wind power significantly reduce the needs for battery storage.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by ncmncm on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:07AM (#24624330)
You seem to be saying that all that is needed to conceal weapons-targeted budgeting from you is to label it "EIF"?
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by willis936 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:00PM (#24631610)
Sorry I should have said “ICF”: inertial confinement fusion. IEC is inertial electrostatic confinement. It’s a confusing set of acronyms that are easy to fumble.

NIF has always been a weapons project. It was made to step around test ban treaties. That’s how it was bankrolled. It’s time on energy research is up and its current primary objective is to keep a team of nuclear weapons experts sharp. The next largest ICF machine is tiny by comparison. I don’t generalize “all ICF machines”, but NIF is the representative of the technology, similar to W7-X for stellarators and ITER for tokamaks.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 27, 2020 @08:57PM (#24611717)
What is "quite costly", compared to wha? The statement is so vague its not informative - how much is it actually?

It's cheaper than millions of tons of coal needed to produce an equivalent amount of energy, or any other fossil fuel. Only renewables have lower running costs.

Nuclear is not expensive in Russia , France or China

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Retric on Sunday September 27, 2020 @09:09PM (#24611832)
If Uranium fuel rods where the only cost, nuclear would be ~50% as expensive as direct Solar in the US. Unfortunately, it represents 10% of of nuclear’s overall costs per kWh in the US. So compared to the perception or competing energy sources, refueling is surprisingly expensive.

With current US nuclear subsides it’s less expensive for power companies to use unsubsidized solar power and lithium batteries than build Nuclear. That’s not a question of which is more green, just basic economics.

PS: Numbers from a very pro nuclear article: https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/economic-aspec...

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by jka on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:20PM (#24610609)
A useful term to search the web for related to this is 'LCOE' - an acronym for 'levelized cost of energy'.

It's essentially the same notion as 'total cost of ownership' in IT, but in the domain of energy generation.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by jojobas on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:26PM (#24610676)
You haven't read much from a particular mindset then.

They tend to evaluate nuclear waste storage as pretty much an eternal cost.