News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by daguava on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:35PM (#24585720)
It's really funny reading this and seeing the lower-ranked comments saying "Time to switch!"

Yeah, you won't. Stop being hyperbolic. You're amazingly served by google and you'll forget this 20 minutes after service is restored.

It makes me wonder, what duration of outage is necessary for people to actually switch?

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by vmception on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:11PM (#24585909)
I tried Zoho for my last startup, since gsuite nuked the free tier.

That lasted 2 weeks. Being locked out of or requiring special considerations for the first calendar invite, or video conference, or collaborative document was a complete unnecessary pain. “But you can make a google account with your external email” barf.

Its sad because Zoho is trying so hard too. Imagine planning and working on all those equivalent products. lol

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by fg43g443g on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:51PM (#24586110)
Nothing on planet is worse than Zoho. I tried their email service and even after I marked the same sender more than 100 times as spammer, their creepy service still not putting their emails automatically to the spam folder. There were many other issues with their service. Don't use Zoho or you will regret it.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by ZohoMailSupport on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:25AM (#24587421)
We are sorry that we gave you this perception. Our Spam filter is self-learning and the algorithm responds to user markings. If we have your account information or the headers of the sample mail, we will be able to look into it and identify what went wrong. We request you to write to support (at) zohomail (dot) com with those details and description about the other issues you faced. We will definitely address it for you.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by lallysingh on Friday September 25, 2020 @10:08AM (#24589857)
Downvoted for: (a) Sounding like a canned response (b) "We are sorry that we gave you this perception" passive aggressive gaslighting and abdication of any responsibility to the user. Really, I've barely ever heard of zoho and had no opinion of them _until_ this response. Now zoho's on my fuck-them list for talking this way to a customer.

Speak like a human for fuck's sake.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by ZohoMailSupport on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:28AM (#24616949)
Hello! This was definitely not a canned response, but we can understand why it was seen that way. Tone is a really tricky thing through text, and we didn't mean to sound like a robot. We hope you won't mind if we try again:

We are very sorry that the spam filter is giving you such trouble. It has self-learning capabilities, but algorithms are not always perfect. If you could send us your account details and the headers for some of the emails, we will look into this right away. Please send us an email at support (at) zohomail (dot) com when you have a few minutes and we will dig into the details.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by lallysingh on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:07AM (#24617423)
I appreciate y'all trying again. Here's some constructive feedback:

(1) Look at other responses from people directly responding to issues from customers here at HN. Look at how specific, authentic, and action-oriented those responses are. Then look at yours again.

(2) Notice how they don't use the royal "We." It's 2020, we're all working from home with small spots of clean behind us for zoom, the royal We has to die. Unless the speaker is actually a committee or Borg, please use I.

(3) "not always perfect" is garbage. It failed the user at its basic job. Say so. Any apology without admission isn't an apology. Actually, kill the entire sentence. Nobody cares about the capabilities of a system that doesn't work right.

(4) They've already said that they tried you and you failed. Explicitly ask for a chance to make it right. Why would they bother working with you again, if you don't even ask them? They'd be doing you a favor. Ask for the favor.

(5) Nit: The last two sentences redundantly ask for the customer to contact you. Combine into a single request for an email with (btw, you don't have to explicitly "send us an email" when you're giving them an email address to contact -- it's a side-ways way of talking down to the customer's intelligence) account "details" (Which details? The account name? Credentials? What?) and headers.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by ZohoMailSupport on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:41AM (#24617827)
Hey, thanks for taking the time to offer such constructive feedback. It's really hard not to sound like an automaton at times, and I am grateful for your help.

As for the royal we...I think you are right. In 2020, with the world the way it is now, I think everyone can use more personalization and less of the anonymity provided by we. I take your point, and will do my best to implement it.

Again, thanks for your time, and for your passion. Have a great one!

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by lallysingh on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:58AM (#24618046)
A real human! Welcome! I'm glad to hear from _you_!

One last bit of unsolicited advice: your job is writing. This is the best writing book I've ever read that deals with the issues I saw in your writing: https://www.amazon.com/Writing-Well-Classic-Guide-Nonfiction...

You can tell the author knows what they're talking about because the book is a really easy read!

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by hobofan on Friday September 25, 2020 @10:19AM (#24590000)
Responding to "your spam detection is not working" with what is essentially spam has to be one of the most unintentionally funny things I've read on HN.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by tilolebo on Friday September 25, 2020 @10:19AM (#24589999)
Your message is actually much more problematic than its parent, IMO.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by dx034 on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:25AM (#24587785)
How are you locked out of business by not using Google? Enough companies run solely on Microsoft products without any issues. Others use separate providers for Email and conferencing (e.g. Zoom). I don't see how not using Google is a problem when dealing with other companies.

Quite the opposite, it's still much harder to not use Excel if you exchange data with a lot of business partners.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by vmception on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:28PM (#24591509)
"but you can use separate services for video conferencing, calendars, emails, look at all these other organizations that are less convenient and doing it just fine"

yeah I'm aware. if you have a choice on a new organization, low budget but still able to access good, fast and cheap, use Gsuite.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by dx034 on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:29AM (#24614314)
Or Office, same prices for similar features.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by viraptor on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:19PM (#24585951)
I'm not sure I understand. What do you mean by locked out and by special considerations?
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by _-___________-_ on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:36PM (#24586046)
Presumably they were still trying to collaborate with people inside Google's walled garden of documents, calendar events and videoconferences.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by vmception on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:26PM (#24586297)
Which is everyone, or at least a very predictable friction.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by ZohoMailSupport on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:17AM (#24587361)
Sorry to learn about your unpleasant experience with us. We request you to elaborate the lock out and the special considerations you are referring to, by writing an email to support (at) zohomail (dot) com. Having specific details along with your account information will help us to analyze and make necessary corrections and enhancements. Looking forward to hearing from you.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by chki on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:08AM (#24587689)
I think you are misunderstanding OP. At least I assume that Zoho will not be able to change Google's policies, otherwise that would truly be outstanding customer service.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by vmception on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:27PM (#24591492)
For me you're not the problem, you just have no power here. Google services are more convenient to use with Google email accounts, they are more prevalent and there is no point in burdening an organization with another email provider if there is a choice.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by leesalminen on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:46PM (#24585772)
We switched from Rackspace’s cloud to AWS due to terrible failure modes with their managed MySQL product. We’d have a db cluster go down and wait hours for them to fix several times a year for several years. Switched to Aurora and haven’t looked back.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:18PM (#24585945)
The only Google domains I allow on my pi.hole are youtube.com and a google subdomain that serves the css for youtube.

Nobody who can afford to pay for a reputable webmail provider should be on Gmail. If not for privacy, because its design is terrible.

If you use Google Chrome, or Youtube, or Google Docs, or Google DNS, or an Android device, you should not use Google Search. That's too much data to hand to one company. I use DDG, and when it's not good enough, I use Bing (and if I used Windows, I'd rule Bing out, too).

Aside from privacy considerations, Google search quality has been declining for at least a year. I want to skate to where the puck is going, not where to where the puck is a mountain of ads followed by nonsense.

"I left Google" is going to be the 20's version of "I left Facebook."

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:26AM (#24586580)
> "I left Google" is going to be the 20's version of "I left Facebook."

So you mean it will be all the rage to talk about in tech forums but somehow the number of active users will continue to go up every quarter?

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:56AM (#24586700)
Yes, it will be almost exactly the same. The people leaving Google will be young users and techies. Google has plenty of smart employees, and they will eek out growth from the rest of the population.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by pb7 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:49PM (#24586100)
The way you choose to live your life sounds like punishment.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:20PM (#24586258)
Over the next decade, a lot of Google data will leak, piling up in giant torrents (literally) forever on the net. Photos and emails and search histories from millions of users.

Over the next decade, downloading and storing and processing such dumps of leaked data will continue to become quicker, and require smaller devices.

Over the next decade, mobile devices will shrink, resulting in smart glasses much more powerful than today's smart phones.

Put that all together...

It's 2030 and you're walking down the street. You pass by a stranger wearing Apple Glasses.

The stranger once spent an hour installing an "Intel on Everybody!" app, and downloaded 100 TB of random leaked data from a torrent site on everyone in the world.

As you enter the stranger's view, the glasses use the leaked data to facially identify you.

Now that the glasses know who you are, they automatically alert the wearer of the types of data they know about you.

The bored stranger occupies himself by reading your gmails from 2022, perusing compromising photos you saved, checking out your medical records, reading arguments you had here in the comments of HN, etc etc.

Maybe my understanding of technology and security is wrong somehow, but that future seems awfully plausible to me.

If the downside to minimizing my footprint is that I use DDG instead of Google, the upside is worth it.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by forgotmypw17 on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:18AM (#24586792)
I agree with your prognosis completely, and I think it will not just be Google, but all the big data troves out there, even NSA and such. It is just inevitable that on a long enough time scale, all data will either become public or fade away.

I think that there will be a new form of entertainment which will basically generate a soap opera-like experience from real lives based on aggregated camera data, recorded conversations, and the blanks filled in by guessing.

I've adapted a different strategy from you, however. I have accepted the new privacy terrain, and I lead my life as if someone is always watching, which means I try to be my best self at all times. :)

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:35AM (#24586859)
Alas, there exist photos of me wearing multicolored parachute pants back in my nightclubbing phase that I can never allow to come to light under any circumstances. So it's too late for me.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:43PM (#24586370)
I do wonder which part of my premise readers find unrealistic?

- technology is getting more powerful and smaller

- large companies can be hacked

- leaked data is easily available on the net

- smart glasses will become more common

- apps can be made to facially id people using leaked data

Are any of those statements outlandish?

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by judge2020 on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:33AM (#24586610)
I find it hard to imagine Google being leaked, though. The sheer amount of data (drive files, gmail data, etc) Google has in its silos makes it almost impossible to copy anywhere else other than on Google's own servers or another giant's DCs. Even just the metadata of every GMail message is probably a few dozen exabytes at the least. Any sort of Google data leak that would allow for you to find a random person would require a persistent backdoor into their systems.

The only realistic attack on Google would be some targeted/filtered dump of celebrities or perhaps entire GSuite organizations' emails and files - and even then it would only make headlines, not cause any real trouble for Google outside of <1% of their regular user base ditching for protonmail or what have you.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:51AM (#24586677)

  I find it hard to imagine Google being leaked
Not all their data, and not all at once, but a little here, a little there.

  The sheer amount of data
It won't be possible to collect all of Google's data. It will get easier to collect more and more of it though (as storage grows larger and the net becomes faster). I wouldn't be surprised if all the email Hotmail handled in the 90s could fit on a consumer 20TB drive from today.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by samoa42 on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:23AM (#24587410)
> The sheer amount of data (drive files, gmail data, etc) Google has in its silos makes it almost impossible to copy anywhere else other than on Google's own servers or another giant's DCs

my first computer had a two Megabyte Harddisk - around twenty years later my Phone has a 256 Gigabyte MicroSD card

it's going to happen

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by tester34 on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:50AM (#24587912)
People also generate more and more data.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:08AM (#24587994)
That's another great point, and it does mean that users always have less to worry about when it comes to recent data. But when it comes to a user's old data... well, you see where I'm going with that :)
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by AnotherTechie on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:17AM (#24586534)
>Are any of those statements outlandish?

websites that host the leaked celebrity nudes are torn down constantly. I can't imagine that you can upload that chunk of data or that app onto any platform without repercussions. On top of that, my tin-foil hat take is that internet access will eventually be completely de-anonymized. Social security or gov. ID to sign on.

It becomes much harder then to spread TB of personal information. Especially since even in 2035 I can't imagine there being very many hundred(S) of terabyte datasets being passed around social circles.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:40AM (#24586635)

  websites that host the leaked celebrity nudes are torn down constantly
That is true, yet surely most live on as torrents (and discoverable via hundreds of sketchy torrent websites that pop up and fizzle away)? Even before most people had broadband, nerds traded collections of pirated software via "sneaker net"

  internet access will eventually be completely de-anonymized. Social security or gov. ID to sign on.
That scenario seems possible to me, too, and I agree its outcome would make what I envisioned less likely. It's not guaranteed to happen though.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by jovdg on Friday September 25, 2020 @09:43AM (#24589598)
The (most) unrealistic part for me is probably Apple allowing such an app in their store...
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @08:26PM (#24595400)
Good catch! Apple would likely close off the most common avenues to provide such an app. There are nevertheless many ways a developer could make it available. Off the top of my head, one could distribute it as a webapp, or use an exploit to install, or provide as an Xcode project to compile and install directly.

It also is possible someone will force Apple to permit third parties to run app stores.

I should point out that while I chose Apple in my comment, there will be other brands with fewer restrictions.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by pmontra on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:15AM (#24587350)
It won't happen in that way, because reality likes to defy predictions, but that's the general direction we're heading to.

My take: it won't be something everybody does (unless provided by some service, which looks illegal at least under GDPR) but be prepared for extensive profiling by whoever really cares about doing it.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:02AM (#24587652)
That's probably an accurate take. I agree, your average internet user isn't likely to configure their devices to do such things. It will be the domain of techies, oddballs, and assorted edge-cases (eg: someone who wants to avoid the law, mob, stalker, etc).
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by pb7 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:25PM (#24586291)
You have a very active imagination. What’s your favorite metal to make hats out of?
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by dang on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:43PM (#24594419)
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:33PM (#24586330)
I get why that would be someone's reaction. Unfortunately there's no way for me to explain what concerns me about the way things are going that doesn't make me sound like a prat :(

As outlandish as my comment may come off, all the pieces (maybe aside from Google leaking data) leading to such a future are conventional takes. As far as big companies leaking data, it's not that it happens every day, so much as it is the cumulative nature of leaks: each leak adds to the pile.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by CookieMon on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:23AM (#24586564)
And if entrusting everything about your life to one company ever does backfire, you still won't get to call this out, because then it will be 'blaming the victims' ;)

I don't know the likelihood of this all going dystopian, but I did realise a while back that it isn't hard to pick a not-google option early when a thing is new. Rather than attempting to go cold-turkey you can just stop growing more locked in. After a few years you notice you're not stuck any more.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by jakeogh on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:14AM (#24587715)
How would you know? It's entirely possible that not using google is a fantastic choice.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by pb7 on Friday September 25, 2020 @02:29PM (#24592722)
Could be. Maybe the Amish are living the peak human experience. I'm not going to find out but you can.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:18PM (#24593194)
I find Bing considerably closer to Google than a horse-and-buggy to an automobile. In some ways, Google is more like a horse-and-buggy, since, like an aging horse, Google Search increasingly ignores the user's instructions, and does its own thing instead.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by pb7 on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:58PM (#24593533)
Consider that the vast majority of users are not like you and they need help using the right search terms. Searching used to be an art and I vividly recall a lot of folks struggle to articulate in search query terms what they were looking for. Nowadays those types of people find what they're looking for at the cost of you not being able to treat it like a command line interface. I'm sure Google has the data to back up that it's a net gain. You're welcome to use whatever you'd like.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Friday September 25, 2020 @06:34PM (#24594797)
I see two ways in which Google Search is changing. Neither of them work for me.

It is true that, as you point out, the majority of Google users probably prefer a less literal algorithm. Do the ways Google Search is changing benefit people who aren't me?

One way that Search is changing does align with what the average user wants: it increasingly interprets results semantically (synonyms,contextual data,domain-specific knowledge,etc) instead of just 'grepping' text content.

The other way Search is changing is user-hostile. Google is an established monopoly now, whose founders have ridden off into the sunset. As its competition and idealism have waned, so has its willingness to put search quality above profits and strategy.

It does not serve the user to include more paid content, to find excuses to personalize search, to cross-promote other Google products, to make Privacy settings inscrutable, to steer customers to AMP pages, and so on. Google has "actually, it's a feature!" rationalizations for these changes, I am sure. No matter!

If the only metric Google cared about were customer satisfaction, I would agree that their surveys, statistics, and A/B tests matter. Sadly, Google seems increasingly concerned with attributes that are at odds with their users: advertising revenue, marketing, etc.

In my judgment, even for normal users, Google Search's bad changes already outweigh the good. I reckon the bad incentives will remain in effect for years to come, too, which does not bode well for Google users.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by uniqueid on Saturday September 26, 2020 @02:21AM (#24596815)
Complete tangent, but it turns out I was wrong about horses: apparently they become more agreeable with age, not less.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by toomanybeersies on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:50PM (#24586399)
Maybe not time to switch, but it shows the value in distributing your services across different providers.

Bit annoying to have your email, documents, cloud services, analytics, and video conferencing all go out at the same time, especially when everyone is working from home.

I was supposed to have a Meet call with someone from the UK this morning, I couldn't join the call and they couldn't email me (I could still email them though, as I don't use G Suite for my email).

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by mrweasel on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:16AM (#24586783)
Duration and frequency of outages. We switch to GSuite two years ago, because it did’t really make sense for us to continue maintaining a Zimbra installation, it cost to much time. GMail has been unavailable at least four times since switching, making it at least twice as unreliable as our old on-premise self-managed mail server.
Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by bonestamp2 on Friday September 25, 2020 @11:34AM (#24590886)
My guess is it's less about the duration and more about the consequences.

If our VPN was down a week we might not switch because we have an alternate workflow, but if our production servers were down for a few hours we'd switch.

Also, I missed one really important email and that's all it took to switch the hosting for that.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by swiley on Friday September 25, 2020 @07:33AM (#24588708)
I was already slowly moving off google but then they locked me out of my account. At that point the only service I had been using was gmail.

It's easier to switch than you think.

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by amelius on Friday September 25, 2020 @08:19AM (#24588935)
> It makes me wonder, what duration of outage is necessary for people to actually switch?

If Google's security measures had an outage ...

Re:Google Services Experiencing Disruptions by tempay on Friday September 25, 2020 @08:32AM (#24588999)
I'm not sure this is a reference this is relevant regardless: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4GB_NDU43Q