News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by Danieru on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:47AM (#24567721)
In the interest of driving conversation away from nostalgia-ism let's talk about the economics of a high-tier game career.

Morhaime has now left the company he helped found, and one he sold off eons ago. Now stepping into a new vessel he gets to sell a bit less equity this time around and bring along the cream of his leadership team. No doubt he funded the initial paperwork out of his own pocket, but soon accepted one of the flood of investment offers.

It is an old play book yet no one talks about it when the play succeeds. Remember that falling out Martin O'Donnell had with Bungie? Did you notice how Martin moved on to found his own studio, one which successfully shipped a non-trivial game? Now not only does he get all the creative control he wanted, but even all of the financial upside.

Video games are so successful even those people getting pushed out of the "golden castle" have the skills and connections to build their own castle. No doubt this would change if games were not such a quick growing industry, but we've maintained that growth for a couple decades now.

This I think leads back to a fan favorite topic: unionization in games. For the opposite reason one might think: those successful enough to be "too important too lose" for studios are more likely setup new studios before they ever spend their political capital on unionization. This leaves the suits, who by definition are incapable of setting a studio, and the "bulk of the creative team".

Hollywood could unionize because no matter how famous no star alone is capable of walking out the door to make a new studio. Thus the stars and more importantly directors saw the studios as overlords, not future peers. Games does not have that, and it is a core problem the games unionization movement needs to figure out a solution to.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by WarChortle on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:00AM (#24567912)
Actors make their own production studios all the time.

That's why Hollywood unionized the way it did. A specific studio couldn't unionize because they would just get dissolved and reformed under a new LLC.

No actor or famous game designer is capable of creating a AAA movie/game by themselves. They need a lot of people to work on it.

The only difference is Hollywood the entire pool of workers unionized they have no choice but to hire a union worker.

Game designers/programmers need to follow the same formula. The two industries have exactly the same problem, Hollywood workers have been around long enough to figure out the solution.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @12:15PM (#24568667)
As a former member of Local 600 - saying “the entire pool of workers unionized” is inaccurate. A significant number of feature films are produced ever year with non-union crews. They may or may not know what they’re doing, but they exist. I worked on them prior to joining the Cinematographer’s Guild (you have to start somewhere).

Also of note, the various film industry unions were largely created back in the day when unionization was generally more popular in society. They have remained strong - like steelworkers - because the protections are worth joining, apprenticeship and training is available/valuable, and the working conditions are often potentially hazardous. People Don’t realize, but industry workers get injured/die every year on movie sets (though it is better than it used to be).

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by rewq4321 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @07:58PM (#24573730)
I love it when someone who actually knows what they're talking about enters a thread like this. It quells the tendency for people (almost always men - myself included) to confidently string together a handful of facts (that they once overheard in a cafe) and explain their way to some sort of hot take.

(Not claiming that the conclusions drawn by the GP or GGP are incorrect here - I don't know much about the games industry. Just talking about HN more generally.)

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by JSavageOne on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:11PM (#24574285)
> almost always men

no need to generalize an entire gender, especially since that has no relevance to this discussion

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by rewq4321 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:28PM (#24574701)
It's a pattern that does tend to exist in my experience, and talking openly and constructively about problems is just part of fixing them. To be clear, I'm not saying that all (or even most) guys have this tendency. I think you may have mentally categorised my comment into the "men bad" bin, but that's really not what I was going for. It's literally a pattern that I have noticed in my own behaviour, so I'm not out to attack anyone here.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:51PM (#24575064)
I think it has more to do with where you look than gender. If you looked at antivax posts likely you would think otherwise.

> The "vast majority" of people commenting, sharing and liking anti-vaccination information on Facebook are women, a new study finds.

https://www.livescience.com/61305-most-online-anti-vaxxers-a...

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by phaus on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:55PM (#24569897)
>People Don’t realize, but industry workers get injured/die every year on movie sets (though it is better than it used to be).

Is this largely due to construction projects like sets and the use of heavy equipment, or is it more from stunts or something else I haven't considered?

Also, since you're an insider, when they build sets and props and stuff, do they still have to follow OSHA requirements and get safety inspections and stuff?

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by sprafa on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:14PM (#24570112)
Fatigue, carrying heavy equipment (film lights, rain equipment, set construction all involve you know, huge amounts of physical stuff being moved), equipment failure during a FX such as an explosion or a car crash.

Deaths and permanent injury were actually horrifyingly common from what I know of very early film industry. Unionisation, at least of stuntmen, has probably saved a couple of hundred lives, both literally and in avoiding permanent injury.

Simple exhaustion can do it. There was a famous case about a woman who got hit by some kind of railcar being used in production a few years ago. She died. There was a documentary made about it called “who needs sleep”. Conditions can be really really difficult sometimes, because a stars time Immensely valuable, while crew time is cheaper. So a star is ie 10k p hour While keeping crew around awake for 12/16 hours a day to shoot when they’re finished makeup / shooting another scene somewhere else is often more economical to keep the crew awake for too long. You have to finish “the day” since the star is payed per diem, afaik. I don’t work in Hollywood but film and commercials.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:11PM (#24570076)
Q1: all of the above. Moving vehicles and equipment. Stunts/practical effects/etc. High power lighting and electrical cords strung everywhere. Tripping hazards. Falling hazards. Oh, and as a rule, never get in the helicopter.

Q2: I don’t know. I imagine it depends on how much is being built and how controlled the environment would be.

Edit: I should also stress the impact of sleep deprivation on accidents and mistakes. Filmmaking hours are often pegged at 12+ as a standard day, and a well financed production won’t bat an eye at paying the penalties to push a crew.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by walshemj on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:49PM (#24571851)
I was talking with some one in Prospect/BECTU (IATSE) and she mentioned her first job was on Coronation Street helping the older actors onto set and making sure they didn't trip over any thing.

I was/am on the same committe (SOC)

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by acomjean on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:26PM (#24574691)
I don't know about movies, but I worked on construction sites for 5 years. OSHA never showed up. Our understanding was they don't show up unless there is a fatality.

I've done the OSHA 40 hour training and even had a reportable OSHA incident (minor cut finger on a soil density gauge that got infected and required antibotics), I never heard from the agency.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:09PM (#24570722)
> They have remained strong - like steelworkers - because the protections are worth joining

Do you think they would join if they weren't forced to join? If so why should they be forced to join? This kind of arrangement is illegal in Europe so it isn't required to get high union participation.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:41PM (#24571030)
They aren’t forced to join.

I’m going to be a bit handwavy here:

generally - crew members do not work for a specific company, so the problem of a “Union only” job is perhaps somewhat different. Crew members are all functionally contractors for that one specific production. There are no long term contractual obligations. After that production is over, they have to hunt around for their next gig which reinforces the relationship based job economy of Hollywood labor.

When a production is kicking, off department heads will be hired (for instance, a Director is Photography) and they will hire the crew members below them in the hierarchy. Many department heads will have their regular group of people they call, and it can be difficult to break into the network. Most people who join a union have experience, training, references, etc which help build those connections.

Again, non-union film production happens all the time. The benefits of joining one of the unions are positive enough that most people do, but You don’t have to be in Local 600 to shoot a movie.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:09PM (#24571383)
They are forced to join if they want to work on the same production set as union members. That kind of forcing is illegal in Europe.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by aspaceman on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:58PM (#24571956)
Again, you’re speaking from ignorance alone here.

This is only required in some cases. In a “union shoot” as it were. These are rare in comparison to non-union films. Every actor has many examples of non-union films they participate in.

Usually big stars work in non-union roles and films to give younger professionals an opportunity. The star provides marketing power for a smaller Non-union production. Then people can join the union as well.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:04PM (#24572016)
> Every actor has many examples of non-union films they participate in.

Actors aren't allowed to participate in non-union films. They sometimes do anyway but the contract says they can't.

> SAG-AFTRA members cannot accept an acting role in any studio, independent, low-budget, pilot, experimental, non-profit, interactive, educational, student, or ANY production, unless that producer has signed a Contract or Letter of Agreement with SAG-AFTRA.

> Members who are found in violation of these rules are subject to serious fines and discipline by a panel of union peers.

https://www.sagaftra.org/what-happens-if-i-accept-non-union-...

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @06:21PM (#24572796)
That is one of many unions. Not all have such a restriction.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by Talanes on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @08:29PM (#24573971)
One of many unions known for having many American film stars in it's membership?
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:21PM (#24574339)
I’ve met a few. Who cares.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by Talanes on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:45PM (#24586378)
You've met a few unions? It's not really feeling like you have any specific domain knowledge here, given how sparse and off-kilter all of your replies have been. If you have actual counter-examples of other unions that operate differently in that space, then just name them.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Friday September 25, 2020 @11:02AM (#24590528)
Stars. Their economically useful for the industry, but entirely irrelevant to union requirements outside of SAG. Bringing them up when discussing labor practices in the industry at large is essentially a non sequitur.

To your question, I was a member of IATSE Local 600 (Cinematographer’s Guild) as a loader, 2nd AC, digital utility and sometimes focus puller. I noted my union affiliation upthread. Members are explicitly allowed to work on non-union jobs, but there is an expectation that you call it in if the budget is over ~1 million. Below that, the union is not particularly interested in attempting to flip the show so no one cares.

(This is where I would call you out for your tone of ignorant self superiority, but I’ll just defer to the HN guidelines and let it drop)

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @06:20PM (#24572786)
This may be role dependent. There are non-union laborers all over a union production.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by walshemj on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:51PM (#24571886)
Not Shure pre entry closed shop is illegal in all European countries.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:08PM (#24572042)
It is a part of EU law, so at least the EU countries.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by conjectures on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:51PM (#24571147)
Interesting, the gig thing probably promotes unionization, because the membership actually carries some signaling value to the hiring org.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by aspaceman on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:12PM (#24572111)
Yes, running a “union gig” or “non-union gig” is a concern of the directors and producers. Union means higher level of talent and skill, but increased costs and bureaucratic pains. Non-union means young, fresh talent (with on average less skill), so they work linger and cheaper.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:04PM (#24571322)
I believe that is to be true.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by cjsawyer on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:48PM (#24570493)
One difference is that film requires in-person work while games can be made 100% remotely. Globally unionizing isn’t the same as unionizing a town. I don’t see it happening.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by chrisseaton on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:22PM (#24570195)
> A specific studio couldn't unionize because they would just get dissolved and reformed under a new LLC.

If your workers are members of a union... how does closing the company and starting a new one help? They're still in the union.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by speeder on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:18PM (#24570821)
That was exactly his point.

In USA (I dunno where you are from), sometimes the union is company-specific, as in: the union forms inside the company and has only that company workers and has some say on the company management.

In Holywood that didn't work, because movies often have a one-off company created just for them (it still works this way).

So the actors and whatnot created non-company unions, so this way they get what you just said (ie: company dissolves, but employees are still in a union, since the union wasn't tied to a company).

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:11PM (#24570742)
US unions are tied to a company so shutting the company shuts the union. There are some old exceptions like in the movie industry that were grandfathered in but you can't create new such unions.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by walshemj on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:53PM (#24571910)
Are you sure? which law is that?

The CWA is/has tried recruiting in tech

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by username90 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:33PM (#24572329)
Outlawed might be a bad word, but there are no protections for them and things like sympathy strikes are illegal.

> The CWA is/has tried recruiting in tech

I don't see a way for individuals to join, just how to get them to help you organize a company union.

https://cwa-union.org/join-union

Compare to Swedens engineering union which you just have to fill in this form for and then you are a member:

https://www.sverigesingenjorer.se/ansokan/

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by claudeganon on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:51PM (#24572511)
Yes, the NRLA and Taft-Hartley acts were structured to prevent the growth of unions and sector-wide labor organizing by stating that unions can only be formed on the basis of company-level votes.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by walshemj on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:42PM (#24582036)
There isn't a general branch you can join then - and in the Swedish case not all employers have recognition.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by stale2002 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:50PM (#24571132)
> Game designers/programmers need to follow the same formula.

Thats basically impossible though. Because, at some point, programmers from other industries, will just enter the market.

What, are you going to try and unionize the entire tech industry? Because I'm not going to go along with that (I will defect, every step of the way, if people try to push me into that arrangement).

And if you don't unionize all of tech, then programmers from outside the industry will be able to compete for those jobs.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by jay_kyburz on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @08:19PM (#24573883)
That's why I think we are better off focusing our efforts across our entire society. Minimum Wages, Leave Entitlements, Superannuation, Medicare.

I don't think game developers need to be paid more than somebody working in the supermarket or digging a trench.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by brundolf on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:48AM (#24568420)
You're missing a big factor: money. It takes significant capital to start your own studio. In games, only the founders are making real cash, and only if they're actually successful the first time around. Programmers make significantly less than they do in other fields, for example.

And then in terms of reputation, very few people in games - usually designers - are household names. I'm talking maybe a dozen or two people in the entire industry (vs hundreds in film). And I would assume that it's very hard to get outside investment without that star power.

Finally, games is an enormously crowded space. Thanks in part to the massive influx of indies, improvement in tools, etc there's an insane amount of oversaturation on platforms like Steam. This means that thousands of high-quality games go completely unnoticed and die a quiet death. Unless you have that star power to get people paying attention in the first place, or you win the social media lottery and go viral, you're probably toast.

So yes, the market is huge and growing, but despite that it remains a really brutal industry to be in. Big studios know this, and they take full advantage of it, knowing that their employees would likely have it even worse if they left.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by _mkef on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:55PM (#24569891)
>This means that thousands of high-quality games go completely unnoticed and die a quiet death. Unless you have that star power to get people paying attention in the first place, or you win the social media lottery and go viral, you're probably toast.

Even star power isn't enough persay

https://www.playstationlifestyle.net/2020/09/17/disintegrati...

Games can take thousands of people to make, from coding to marketing. Maybe one or two will be able to start a new company with any success. I do really like John Romero's smaller projects though.

Not everything needs to be a AAA game

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by fxtentacle on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:35PM (#24571685)
They must have seriously screwed up marketing. I loved Halo, Portal, Titanfall. I liked those games on Facebook. I read the usual game magazine websites. I watch SciFi let's plays on YouTube. This game looks like I'll very much enjoy it, yet I had literally never heard of it until you mentioned it.

How come with all this data collection and targeted advertisement, I never saw an ad for this? Google and Facebook should know that I'm interested in a Halo-like new game.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by pvg on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @06:47PM (#24573108)
Like the article mentioned, it had terrible reviews. It's a game in which the 'new and fun hybrid gameplay' ambition doesn't match the reality. They didn't screw up the marketing (lots of 'iterative' or 'persistent' shooters have become massive hits almost organically), they screwed up the game.

I don't think the premise upthread - that there are zillions of high quality games that nobody notices is really true. Yes, it's a crowded market but it's also absolutely mobbed with people looking for the next big or interesting thing - to play, to stream, to make a catchy review of, etc.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by megameter on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:38PM (#24574439)
The problem games face is that most games, small or big, are reasonably well-produced but ultimately settle on doing more-of-the-same things, commoditizing themselves into a position where they can't address any market in particular, so instead of getting a "fair share" they get almost nothing because all attention goes to a path-dependent established best in the category. Big productions can break through that with spend, but only somewhat. And any time there is a breakout hit it gets followed by a sea of clones.

And as a whole the industry remains stuck on the problem of how to run the production, since it's still challenging to ship anything even now.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by jay_kyburz on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @08:31PM (#24574004)
I just watched the launch trailer. I have no idea what the game play is
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by echelon on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:47PM (#24569822)
What can fix this?

If everyone adopts the same game engines and assets become cheap and easy to produce, could there be a renaissance of small gaming studios that are sustainable and pay competitive wages?

What's the blocker? Why aren't things better?

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by manfredo on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:25PM (#24570238)
There's no way to "fix" the laws of supply and demand. Making games is a lot of people's dream jobs. People are willing to take a pay cut and worker longer hours to have a job in the game development industry. Same reason why you have aspiring actors working tables to make ends meet.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by imtringued on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:26AM (#24576532)
Let's say each game needs to sell 100000 copies to be profitable. If you make more games you need to sell more copies. The amount of games people buy doesn't increase simply because there are more games. Lots of people buy one or two games and play them for a long time. So eventually you end up in a situation where you have 1000 games (must sell 100 million copies) but only 50 million customers are willing to buy stuff.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by ChuckMcM on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @12:45PM (#24568995)
As others have pointed out this is a very old design pattern.

In tech, it is this:

Stage 1: Graduate college and get hired by a growing company. Observe all you can about what works and what doesn't while networking with the best people. Ideally a public company so that you can participate in its growth through equity ownership (stock options, employee purchase plans, Etc.)

Stage 2: Found (or join as founder) startup composed of good engineers you know, that is funded by VC money. Build it up to an exit to get a bigger slice of the pie given your greater equity.

Stage 3: Found a new company where it is primarily funded by your founders and not VC. Build that company up to an exit and you and your friends collect the big bucks as you still own most of the equity.

At this point you're independently wealthy and can do what ever you want with your life[1]

It has been the "silicon valley dream" for a lot of people over the last 30 years. And since each stage is typically 4 - 6 years that is really a 15 to 20 year plan.

Doesn't work for everyone though, and I have observed that people who are on this trajectory and recognize they are unlikely to reach orbit (so to speak), can get pretty vicious. You have a relatively short window to decide if the current stage is going to meet your goals for that stage or not, and if a stage doesn't provide the necessary lift, you probably only get one additional shot at making it work. As a result this path also leads to a place of depression for some.

[1] Assuming along the way you've learned to manage your wealth in a sustainable fashion.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by stingraycharles on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:49PM (#24569849)
> Doesn't work for everyone though

I’d say that there is an extremely small portion of people that are able to complete Stage 2. “Doesn’t work for everyone” seems like an understatement.

Stage 3 is probably easier to do once you completed stage 2, but still is very difficult.

Really, how many people can you count that would have successfully pulled this off? 100 maybe?

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by ChuckMcM on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:48PM (#24570497)
My guess would be a few thousand in the Bay Area. Crunchbase could probably give you a better number by doing a bit of data mining on their database to find former Sun, Yahoo, Amazon, Facebook, Tesla, Apple, and Google employees who have gone on to create startups and exited those startups. Those companies alone have minted > 10,000 multi-millionaires who were simply employees at the company either prior to an IPO or prior to a large run up in value (like Apple).

Of people I know who have stepped off at stage 2, they pocket enough wealth that they no longer have to work to maintain a moderate lifestyle, and then move to a place that interests them and work on other pursuits.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by thisalreadyiss on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:15PM (#24570788)
I think 90% failure rate at every stage is honest. I mean even stage 1 I am sure has an ever-increasing number of people that "want to learn to code" or go through an online bootcamp, watch a youtube series on javascript, etc. and never code professionally a day in their lives.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:06AM (#24575420)
I think it is challenging (but not impossible) to fail at stage 1. If you join any tech company that is already public and part of their compensation is incentive stock options and/or restricted stock which is refreshed annually, then 4+ years can deliver a pretty solid "boost" for you to do Stage 2. Stage 2 is harder of course, but 90% harder? A bunch of companies fail in the seed/series A stage. That can happen reasonably quickly (1 - 2 years), so stage 2 can take 3 - 5 years to catch the right one. And then stage 3 is kind of up to you're ability to hit the market at the right time. More difficult still, but not impossible.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by hinkley on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:04PM (#24569997)
In games there are also production companies, and the studio might stay intact for years but produce their own games, as a stage 1.5 or alternate Stage 2. Most of the musicians who side with the recording industry have followed a similar pattern. They build their own studio (different definition of studio) to greatly increase their slice of the pie.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by kochthesecond on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:02PM (#24570645)
This is such an understatement it feels like the equivalent to «buy low, sell high»
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by markus_zhang on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:16PM (#24569401)
Nicely summarized.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by M5x7wI3CmbEem10 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:56PM (#24569908)
advice for networking in stage 1?
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by ChuckMcM on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:53PM (#24570542)
Get to know people. Talk to them at lunch time, or offer to help on their project when they are stuck, and ask for help on your project when your stuck.

The latter is especially helpful for differentiating between people who talk a good game and actually know what they are talking about.

Practice not assuming anything about someone based on their appearances. Learn to listen uncritically so that you can hear the insights they bring to the table. I know some folks who are genius level smart and have a horrible time trying to express themselves. I've often suspected it was because they think about things so differently that it is hard for them to translate how they think about something into concepts "normal" people understand.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by objclxt on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:12AM (#24568037)
> Hollywood could unionize because no matter how famous no star alone is capable of walking out the door to make a new studio.

I don't think that's quite true: United Artists was founded specifically by stars that walked out of the door, hence its name.

And today lots of stars have their own production companies, and the studio simply acts as the distributor. They handle getting the movie into cinemas, but otherwise don't have a financial stake.

Some examples that come to mind:

* Will Ferrell: Gary Sanchez Productions * Tom Cruise: Cruise/Wagner * Adam Sandler: Happy Madison * Brad Pitt: Plan B * Shonda Rhimes: Shondaland

Both Shondaland and Happy Madison aren't beholden to regular studios at all, they simply have multi-picture deals with the highest bidder (in both cases, Netflix).

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by toby on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @12:08PM (#24568606)
From Wikipedia: "Many high-profile actors refused to join SAG initially. This changed when the producers made an agreement amongst themselves not to bid competitively for talent."

Tech companies have tried this in the past, now this would typically be met with an antitrust suit rather than creating a guild. Not sure which is preferable.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by gamblor956 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @12:37PM (#24568891)
With an antitrust suit: grievances are addressed years after the fact, if at all, with little meaningful compensation for the aggrieved employees.

With a guild/union: grievances are addressed immediately or before they occur (depending on the structure of work contracts), minimizing the economic suffering to employees.

Generally, from the perspective of employees, guilds/unions are better.

EDIT: a "guild" is a union for independent contractors.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by smogcutter on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:37PM (#24569714)
For a similar reason, it seems to me that unionizing is the answer for uber/lyft drivers to get protections they want without being tied down as permanent employees.

The list of reasons unionizing drivers would be difficult to impossible is long and obvious, but the outcome would surely be better than some hamfisted state law.

Also, right now uber is framing the issue as drivers vs the state. A union push would make it uber vs the drivers, much harder to spin.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by naravara on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:14PM (#24570109)
> The list of reasons unionizing drivers would be difficult to impossible is long and obvious, but the outcome would surely be better than some hamfisted state law.

The state could mandate sectoral representation for all the drivers, functionally requiring unionization. That way the nitty gritty details are still just contract negotiations between the union and the gig economy companies, but there isn't too much space for overly broad or stifling regulatory requirements (from the State anyway, between the lawyers on all sides of the issue is a different story).

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by gamblor956 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:45PM (#24569796)
Technically, non-wage workers (i.e., independent contractors), would form a guild rather than a union.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by walshemj on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:56PM (#24571935)
Are sure about that you can call your self a guild or the BMA but you are a union.
Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by rmah on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:17AM (#24568090)
Well... first, the "studio system" where actors were tied to a single studio by contract hasn't held sway for half a century. Talent (stars and especially directors) have been founding their own studios off and on for a century now.

Examples: United Artists was started in 1919 by W.D. Griffith, Charlie Chaplin, Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks. Or Mercury Theater, founded by Orson Wells and Houseman. Dreamworks, founded by Spielberg (and Katzenberg and Geffen). And there are dozens of production companies owned by actors and directors. Many of these firms eventually get acquired by major studios.

While it may be easier to find success with an indie game than an indie film, I don't see why one is easier than the other assuming the team has the appropriate skillset. The parallels between film making and game making are quite substantial, IMO. Both the business and process.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by thisalreadyiss on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:03PM (#24570668)
Well, the physical engineering world already has an alternative to unionization: contracting firms.

The best mechanical, electrical, and chemical engineers in the world work for big engineering firms (and make mega bucks).

We have a few relatively small contracting firms in software right now, but there is no reason why we could not have large Software Engineering firms that can handle entire design and engineering for any game studio far better and more efficiently than the studios could ever do themselves.

For example, if the top 1000 game designers and developers started their own firm, then I imagine every studio would be forced to use them at whatever price for competitive reasons.

Are you a VC? Invest in that. Insta-monopoly. Top talent (especially in bulk) is very much the most difficult thing to replicate in any market.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by megameter on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:34PM (#24574986)
One of the issues that has made it difficult to discuss labor in games generally is a lack of any role standardization. This has calmed down somewhat as more and more games turn towards standardized content creation systems, but the whole endeavor historically has been completely upended on four year cycles, with games made by solo teenagers usurped by those made by teams, and then by teams with marketing and sales backing, and then by teams with increasingly higher specialization, with new waves of hardware at each turn.

The people in these high profile roles that gather as "founding core members" often found themselves in the position of right-place-right-time and afterwards just tried to keep up with the changes, and so, to some extent, they end up branded as creative and business talents, when the thing being tested most often in their career was their ability to sufficiently manage and delegate to get the project over the finish line.

So every time I see a story of a AAA vet starting something new I think to myself "prepare for some hard knocks", cause they are now being retested on their scrappy start-up abilities, but often get burdened by the expectations of an established studio, and entrenched in a particular approach. They can raise a lot but very often it means they fail big, too.

Re:Blizzard cofounder launches new gaming endeavor Dreamhaven by yread on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:35AM (#24568268)
Let's hope it turns out as well as Dan Vavra's founding Warhorse and making Kingdom Come: Deliverance after making Mafia.