But for two companies of an equal size, I don't think a company with an ad-driven revenue model is necessarily going to be less ethical. The sales and marketing people I've worked with at other companies were far, far worse than people at Google, and their evil was only limited by the scaling limits of their sales tactics.
The correct statement is "every business model is at odds with privacy". Do you think your ISP isn't spying on you just because you pay them? Similarly you can sell ads without spying on your users, TV does that. And tracking user data is useful for businesses even if they don't sell ads etc.
Healthcare is an interesting example where regulations have shaped the landscape and similar regulations can easily hit other industries.
Among my friends there are so many that work for dodgy companies and believe they are doing something good
In Seattle my friends and I ran into a girl who worked for a spybar/spy install bar company and she was completely OK with it. She actually liked working there
Of course, now it turns out that Google, Facebook, Amazon do far worse stuff than spyware companies
*
reminds me of an old quote - It is impossible to make a man realize something when his pay check depends on him not realizing it
> every ad-driven revenue model is at odds with privacy
I agree with this statement (assuming you're talking about personally targeted ads). Believe it or not though, there are ways to be evil that don't require invading people's privacy, and there are a lot of companies out there that engage in this sort of bad behavior.
I'm not saying that Google is perfectly ethical. I'm just saying that the other companies I've worked at have been worse, and that the heuristic of "avoid ad-based business models" won't necessarily steer you in the direction of an ethical career.
But staying out of the surveillance industry is table stakes for ethical employment.
Contextual advertising doesn't have this problem and in one recent case switching to it turned out to be more profitable:
https://www.theregister.com/2020/07/03/stop_tracking_increas... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23737352
But similarly, the rank-and-file and the proclaimed policies at places like Bloomberg and Goldman Sachs were just as fine.
Especially Bloomberg seemed to go to crazy lengths to be squeaky clean in all respects. Eg when you leave Bloomberg they immediately put you on garden leave, and (here's the squeaky clean part:) then pay out your remaining leave instead of folding that into your one-month gardening leave.
My experience with free (as in beer) software and services is that it's usually offered as a "strategic offering", maybe as an attempt to commoditize your complement(?) but I'm speculating here. The downside is that the wider business does not care that much about your software. It needs to work, but just enough that customers don't use your complement. And critically, when it comes to prioritization of resources (especially the most senior people who could mentor you), they would rather put their best people in other parts of the business.
I've become of the mindset that if you want to build best-in-class software with a best-in-class team, you should see if you can draw a direct line from the product to the revenue, or at least the core mission of the business.
I fully agree with you guys on a macro-scale. I didn't have this position years ago but now it's a firm position.
But my observation is that no one (read: a significant majority) is financially sovereign (FS), therefore they mis-calculate the time/labor costs and it's economic value/costs.
To think of this another way, if your (financial/material/etc) lives depended the Amish's* jam or chairs (or anything else they make). You can depend on their work, up to a certain scale. But even most software projects don't have this dependability because software is generally repackaged to fit a narrow use-case.
Iff (if and only if) the Amish were to embrace the automation technology, then you could depend on the Amish scaling for whatever you need.
Financial sovereignty is very powerful but the drawbacks are that the team, to do all the needed work, might not be FS. (Hence why I mention the Amish) This FS doesn't scale (this could with the Amish; if they wanted to provide jam to everyone, etc) with the complexity of the problem nor the robustness of the problem being solved. Another important drawback is that those that are FS tend to be myopic to those that aren't (i.e. their market/customers). This problem is pretty big as well. To find a product/service that solves all these criteria is immense and dare I say, improbable, hence my agreement to the two comments above. The simple solution is to try and align with the better alternative that have a positive feedback loop (i.e. monetary gain to improve the work).
* Note: I do understand that Amish charge money for jam/chairs/etc but the cost is tends to be nominal/small.
Regardless, the main idea is that I support greed as a motivator because financially sovereign teams don't exist nor scale enough to support a given cause (especially if it's a very difficult problem).
The second half of my career, even at larger places, was building MVPs where you go forever without a single user ever seriously using it.
This duality in my work experience created an odd existential crisis. Push to prod after awhile felt like fake urgency. Ideas being thrown around by team members after awhile felt like needlessness. New hires and growth initiatives felt stupid, we barely saturate the existing team. Demos/Presentations felt futile, with a part of your soul just screaming ‘Who the fuck uses this!’.
I'm thinking about jumping ship and taking a pay cut if necessary just to get back to something where I can actually solve real problems building software I know people will actually use. It's so much more satisfying to work on something you know is useful.
It’s not easy, but the feelings are valid.
Hope you find something better! What tech stack do you work in?
I would read an entire research paper dedicated to this topic if it existed, heh.
I never really considered that without that it would get too loopy.
There are tangible and intangible costs and benefits to every pursuit (interesting example, externalities in economics). Focusing on only tangible benefits (money) does, to me, seem very common - rarely do I see intangibles being considered.
For example, how many times I see profitable companies making money hand over fist, but when you look at their operations internally, they are completely inefficient and chaotic, maybe even damaging. Like, if they did things even 10% more effectively (let's say at a bit of reasonable cost), they would make even more profit. But doing so takes hard work, they are already making so much money, so they have no desire to look further.
If the profit is so good, that ignoring the money "left on the table" doesn't cause enough pain for the subject involved - well, I think that also creates inefficiencies, complacency, etc.
I also think, when profit is "so good" that other efficiencies go by the wayside, the same behaviors you describe continue. I don't find that the other behaviors go away, really.
I once heard a quote that said, if you wanted any data project funded, convince the CFO that it makes money and they'll go for it. Much like the approaches of TCO, ROI, NPV, IRR, etc - prove the profitable case and you'd think people would buy in.
I have found something like this to be somewhat true - except in companies where they are already making so much money, they don't care about doing the right (or "better") thing. The "more money" they could make is imaginary to them, and they are happy with how much they are already raking in. Until it's super, super tangible/convincing.
For example, the Fed can shower Wall St. with all the money it wants to, and it may actually make teams inside those companies less efficient and less of a joy to work for. Although money is available, making money is not the main goal of the team.
Or take a fictional company with 100 projects and 1,000 engineers, where only 1 project with 10 engineers makes 90% of the revenue. The 99 other teams at the company are probably not going to have the best culture because the revenue incentive isn't present on those teams. They might just exist to check some compliance checkbox or stroke the ego of some middle manager.
What I'm talking about is not necessarily the availability of money, but a direct relationship of your project to the money-making potential of the company. Big difference.
Still, seeing that a project is revenue-impacting or revenue-generating (has the relationship to the money-making potential of the company) is relative to the individuals who are viewing it. For example, if there is an effort you could do that generates 2x revenue, but those in charge of your company choose not to pursue it "because they are already making a ton of money and cannot see past the costs".
I guess this comes down to how good of a business leader one has.
I have so many times seen good projects/ideas, ideas that can clearly make money, even lots of money - but in the wrong company, with the wrong people, or attitudes, or beliefs - don't matter. These are the times when, if you are the person with such an project or idea, you ask whether or not you are the right "fit" for the organization - since they are not recognizing or prioritizing the value of your project/idea.
I suppose you could look at this as efficient capital allocation, if you assumed perfect business leadership. Perfect business leaders would only pursue the revenue generating activities that made the most sense.
I would argue that we are far from perfect, and that we often let ego, opinion, culture (or even "data") influence our decision-making about revenue-generating activities.. which brings us back to the point that culture is still relevant. Something that popped to mind related to this is the "Ultimatum game" from psychology/economics [1].
You don't need perfect leadership, if you have a reality check they can't ignore.
Alas, when you remove that particular focus, you don't end up with something pure left over. But more often with the worst pathologies organisations have to offer. As the original commenter points out:
> The drive to make more money is the only thing that trumps every other petty motivation people follow at work. It trumps favoritism, empire building, and intra-office rivalries. It trumps good ol' boys networks and tech bro networks. Money brings people into the same room who would never normally be in a room together, and they do it willingly. It forces people in power to listen to small fries. While money corrupts on an individual level, it purifies on an institutional level. Its universally accepted value allows a variety of individual motives to flourish.
Adam Smith wrote both "The Wealth of Nations" and also "The Theory of Moral Sentiments." Your comment is deeply insightful, and it is a feature of markets that wasn't missed by him. So dismayed that I think a lot of people overlook this important effect.
https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2019/12/31/does-big-business-ha...
I've found that the most dynamic and egalitarian teams are the ones that focus on making money because those are the ones where people are incentivized to keep an open mind and expect compensation for greater effort. On government and charitable projects, not so much. I don't really know why, but like the author, I suspected incentives have something to do with it. When your project is just a cost center, anything out of the norm will be seen as another risk or cost to avoid. As an engineer, this doesn't produce a great culture.
It surprised me to learn this because, like many commenters, I always associated corruption and overall shadiness with making money. But my career has shown me that there's either no correlation or the opposite. At least at the team or project level.
Does it? I associate those things very strongly with endeavors that are primarily concerned with making money.
Without money you have a cool place to work until they close. Without money and you have crapy cowokers it still is a crappy place to work until they close. With money a cool place to work can last a long time. With money and you have crapy cowokers it still is a crappy place to work but still have a job.
In my experience, internal customers are also fine, _if_ they are close to the money making side of the company, and especially if they have alternatives. Think eg traders in an investment bank.
Stock price should be the outcome of making money.
Financial engineering, when done right, is just a set of optimizations that makes sense at larger scales given the regulatory and market environment.
A lot of superfluous financial engineering would disappear with simpler policies. Eg many jurisdictions tax interest payments less than dividend payments (or stock buybacks).
Companies respond to that incentive by shifting the ratio of debt to equity.
Put both on equal footing, and companies would be less interested in loading up their balance sheet with debt.
(And stock buybacks are perfectly harmless. They are economically exactly equivalent to dividend payments, and have the essentially the same effect on a company's balance sheet.)
You (often) don't have any product, you just have the money, and the purpose of the engineering is to increase its amount. Seems like a powerful motivator as long as everyone's getting a sufficiently motivating cut.
OTOH, third prize is you're fired.
You want to make software that adds value either way. But this way the value is directly generated for your employer, with no customer in the middle.
I'm not saying that eliminates other influences, certainly I think (and have heard) this leads to workplaces dominated by strong and often eccentric personalities, which has its downsides.
But insofar as a programmer is motivated by creating value, and by value we mean money here, I can't think of a way to be closer to it without being independent.
The personality cliché in finance is the risk taking one. Men are more frequently found in riskier professions, including dangerous jobs like oil drilling.
Some fintech companies actually do produce a software product for finance. However, many of them work for banks or funds to generate capital gains beyond a wage or salary.
Regardless of personalities, the most important factor is profit. Everything else is secondary. It is not as flashy or famous as big tech companies, but this profit is paid in bonuses that far exceed the highest salaries for tech workers.
If you work for Netflix, maybe you get a free subscription. If you work for a restaurant, maybe you get a free box of takeout at the end of the day. If you work in the business of money, your incentive is large bonuses.
Depends a bit on what part of fintech you are working on.
There's lots of rank-and-file employees whose good salaries actually mostly depends on competition from tech companies. With a low-risk lifestyle mostly comparable to said tech companies.
To get the crazy bonuses, you need to move closer to the traders and some of the quants (or get very lucky). But generally those people work a lot harder and longer.
I've worked in tech companies (like Google and Facebook) and in those low-risk fintech roles (at eg Bloomberg and Goldman).
It seems that the finance industry as a whole seems to be moving away from the heroic model with enormous bonuses to the tech company model with good salaries.
The latter is cheaper and more predictable, and it fits the organisations as more and more work becomes automated.
(That observation is about companies like eg Goldman and only meant to capture an average. They still have plenty of individuals pulling heroics; and there are still plenty of hedge funds and similar on the old model.)
As another example, take high frequency trading market makers. They generally don't have any human traders at all, because humans would be way too slow. So their very nature forces them to become closer to tech companies in organisation.
Can you recommend any sources (blogs, whatever) for info on what it's like to work at such places?
I've always found it intriguing but I'm not sure if I have the right personality or skills or (very complicated) geography to make it worth trying.
I don't think it's accidental that investment bankers, the people who should be most savvy in valuing complex securities, get cash bonuses, while software engineers get options which take years to vest and in pre-IPO companies may not even be readily traded once they vest.
That was a genius move. It got those assets of Credit Suisse's balance sheet, looked good in PR, and receiving bankers were happy because those assets were worth more in the end than they looked like during the height of the panic when the transfer happened.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-01-26/at-credit...
As for software engineers: there's a tax dodge in them getting stock options in pre-IPO companies.
But in my one startup job, I negotiated a cash bonus, because we couldn't agree on how to value the options they were originally offering. (Basically, I thought they were next to useless, and the company obviously pretended otherwise.)
While Google, Microsoft etc are hiring, a software engineer who accepts a bad deal in options only has herself to blame.
(Stock options can also be a good deal. But they are hard to value.)
Good point, but it boggles the mind that those bankers got bonuses AT ALL in 2008 (CS had to be bailed out by the Swiss government that year).
If anything, it should perhaps boggle our mind more anyone got bonuses in eg 2007 that weren't clawed back later.
In general, I don't think bonuses by themselves are a problem. It's just a different way to structure total comp. And if you restrict bonuses, you just force banks to pay higher base salaries instead.
To make banks behave better, I would suggest abolishing (government-backstopped) deposit insurance. That way depositors will keep a sharper eye on their banks, and hopefully pro-actively move their funds to institutions with a reputation for low risk and transparency.
(Depositors who want to simulate the current regime could just pick a bank that for their money that invests only in short term government debt.)
Well said.
It purifies the institution to be a profit-seeking machine. That's had really good effects on the film & game industry.
It may sound overly hard-nosed and cynical to some people, but I find it's just the opposite. The drive to make more money is the only thing that trumps every other petty motivation people follow at work. It trumps favoritism, empire building, and intra-office rivalries. It trumps good ol' boys networks and tech bro networks. Money brings people into the same room who would never normally be in a room together, and they do it willingly. It forces people in power to listen to small fries. While money corrupts on an individual level, it purifies on an institutional level. Its universally accepted value allows a variety of individual motives to flourish.
This seems to change once a company goes public and hits a certain size, as the flow of money becomes less and less tied to actual sales and consumer behavior and more and more based on financial engineering and stock price.