News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by quicklime on Monday September 21, 2020 @12:31PM (#24545357)
I dunno. In my experience, Google was easily the most ethical company I've worked for on a "per capita" basis. The big thing Google has going against it is the size of its user base. Every little bit of evil multiplied out by billions of users ends up having a large impact.

But for two companies of an equal size, I don't think a company with an ad-driven revenue model is necessarily going to be less ethical. The sales and marketing people I've worked with at other companies were far, far worse than people at Google, and their evil was only limited by the scaling limits of their sales tactics.

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by Retric on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:30PM (#24546102)
Google is still a young company for it’s size. Ethically it’s been getting worse over time, which makes it’s current state less meaningful long term than the direction it’s headed.
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @07:35AM (#24553305)
It could be argued that Google is getting more evil relative to its size, not its age. Ergo, you can’t extrapolate the trend unless you expect them to keep growing infinitely.
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by ksk on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:01PM (#24546444)
Well, every ad-driven revenue model is at odds with privacy. There is zero chance that Google is going to support any privacy measure that will block themselves from spying on users. Google not only wants all your data to reside on their servers so they can mine it, but they're actively setting up tollbooths on the internet to take a cut from every online transaction. "Oh hey you Googled Tylers Texas BBQ, that must mean Google should get a cut from the order". Frankly its a bit scary that people honestly (and I truly believe you to be honest) believe Google could be a "most ethical" company.
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by username90 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:18PM (#24550514)
> Well, every ad-driven revenue model is at odds with privacy.

The correct statement is "every business model is at odds with privacy". Do you think your ISP isn't spying on you just because you pay them? Similarly you can sell ads without spying on your users, TV does that. And tracking user data is useful for businesses even if they don't sell ads etc.

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by Retric on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:56AM (#24555143)
VPN’s for example are not adverse to customer privacy. Generally customer data isn’t worth much, so every business is balancing that vs direct sales. Where an ISP has minimal fear, at the extreme other end, a brothel has serious risks.

Healthcare is an interesting example where regulations have shaped the landscape and similar regulations can easily hit other industries.

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by switch11 on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:10PM (#24547874)
Agreed 100% -> Frankly its a bit scary that people honestly (and I truly believe you to be honest) believe Google could be a "most ethical" company.

Among my friends there are so many that work for dodgy companies and believe they are doing something good

In Seattle my friends and I ran into a girl who worked for a spybar/spy install bar company and she was completely OK with it. She actually liked working there

Of course, now it turns out that Google, Facebook, Amazon do far worse stuff than spyware companies

*

reminds me of an old quote - It is impossible to make a man realize something when his pay check depends on him not realizing it

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by quicklime on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:25PM (#24548041)
The statement that a company is the "most ethical" is a relative one. It doesn't imply that the company is ethical, or a net good to the world. It simply means that it is relatively better than the others.

> every ad-driven revenue model is at odds with privacy

I agree with this statement (assuming you're talking about personally targeted ads). Believe it or not though, there are ways to be evil that don't require invading people's privacy, and there are a lot of companies out there that engage in this sort of bad behavior.

I'm not saying that Google is perfectly ethical. I'm just saying that the other companies I've worked at have been worse, and that the heuristic of "avoid ad-based business models" won't necessarily steer you in the direction of an ethical career.

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by samatman on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @12:28AM (#24550852)
Not if it's your only heuristic! c'mon

But staying out of the surveillance industry is table stakes for ethical employment.

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by pabs3 on Monday September 21, 2020 @10:44PM (#24550392)
> every ad-driven revenue model is at odds with privacy

Contextual advertising doesn't have this problem and in one recent case switching to it turned out to be more profitable:

https://www.theregister.com/2020/07/03/stop_tracking_increas... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23737352

Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by tboyd47 on Monday September 21, 2020 @01:22PM (#24546023)
Interesting. Ethics aside, do you think Google's ad-driven revenue model has affected the company culture at all?
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by quicklime on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:27PM (#24548066)
Probably yes, and to be clear I'm not disputing the author's argument that revenue will come to dominate over culture in the long-term.
Re:Is revenue model more important than culture? by eru on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:09AM (#24551053)
I worked for Google as well. They are fine as far as I can tell.

But similarly, the rank-and-file and the proclaimed policies at places like Bloomberg and Goldman Sachs were just as fine.

Especially Bloomberg seemed to go to crazy lengths to be squeaky clean in all respects. Eg when you leave Bloomberg they immediately put you on garden leave, and (here's the squeaky clean part:) then pay out your remaining leave instead of folding that into your one-month gardening leave.