Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by userbinator on Friday September 18, 2020 @10:46PM
(#24524480)
I agree, this lens looks like a Fresnel lens taken to microscopic extremes:
the new fisheye lens consists of a single flat, millimeter-thin piece of glass covered on one side with tiny structures that precisely scatter incoming light to produce panoramic images
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by LolWolf on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:47AM
(#24525169)
It’s not. The mechanism by which it acts is quite different. The lens is a metasurface lens, which has small structures that cause the phases of light to constructively or destructively interfere. The result is caused by the fact that, by carefully picking how light interferes, one can form an image on the other side of the lens. This differs from a Fresnel lens (or other classical lenses), which essentially form images by having rays of light which emerge from one spot, on one side of the lens, converge to another spot on the other side.
(In particular, wave theory is not needed to predict the behavior of classical lenses.)
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by phkahler on Friday September 18, 2020 @10:56PM
(#24524532)
>> this lens looks like a Fresnel lens taken to microscopic extremes:
Except I don't think it is. It's probably more like a diffraction grating or a hologram. You can actually make a flat lens by creating a hologram of a real lens and it will be flat.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by dTal on Saturday September 19, 2020 @07:41AM
(#24526750)
Wavelength specificity. You only get the original focal depth at the wavelength you used to make the hologram, and it changes proportional to the wavelength. When you consider that blue light is 2/3 the wavelength of red light, you can see that this is chromatic aberrations big brother.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by cycomanic on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:39PM
(#24528644)
Diffractive elements are very wavelength dependent so while something like this would only work for monochromatic light (like a laser), but not for multiwavelength light. For that you would need to do some colordiversity.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by dvh on Friday September 18, 2020 @11:19PM
(#24524685)
Laser is light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. Fresnel lens doesn't amplify light it focuses it. It is not stimulated, it is just passive component.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by foxdev on Saturday September 19, 2020 @07:05AM
(#24526591)
This is true, but I don't think many people think of laser as anything other than "dangerous light." That's how I used it. Colloquial meanings can be frustrating when they clash with the technical meaning, but trying to fight them is typically futile.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by klyrs on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:09PM
(#24528417)
> This is true, but I don't think many people think of laser as anything other than "dangerous light."
"Many people" have taken first year physics, or at least read a wikipedia article, and understand that the defining feature of a laser is its coherence.
But, sure. It's 2020. We live in a post-factual society, words have no meaning and it's impossible to know anything. Why resist?
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by andreareina on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:30AM
(#24525080)
I suspect "nanoscale structures" means that it's going to be highly sensitive to the wavelength of light, I'm interested in seeing what kind of chromatic aberration is going to come out from this.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by Lramseyer on Saturday September 19, 2020 @02:32AM
(#24525619)
I'm glad somebody pointed this out! Meta materials and diffractive structures are not known for being low dispersion. This article mentions nothing about bandwidth. However, I think the writer assumes that the indented reader knows this already.
Also in the video you can see spatial ringing, which is highly indicative of coherent light (single wavelength, like in a laser.)
This is still a cool discovery and could definitely have a lot of important applications, but it's important to clarify what this is, and what it isn't.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by gus_massa on Saturday September 19, 2020 @06:34AM
(#24526454)
In the video and the top image, the caption says
> 3D artistic illustration of the wide-field-of-view metalens capturing a 180° panorama of MIT’s Killian Court and producing a high-resolution monochromatic flat image.
My guess is that it is only good for monochromatic light.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by xoa on Saturday September 19, 2020 @09:49AM
(#24527400)
>My guess is that it is only good for monochromatic light.
Does anyone know how much of a limitation that'd be in practice though? CCDs are monochromatic too, which we deal with using either Bayer filters (usually RGGB IIRC) or (in fancier high end stuff) a splitter prism leading to 3 separate CCDs. Modern computational photography is also increasingly able to do sensor fusion, even between different cameras. I can see how making use of this would still be an extra challenge in a small form factor, because normally the split/filter happens after the lens which simplifies things a lot. Having to do 3x multisensor fusion with meta material fisheye only definitely would be more effort and bulkier. Seems like it might still be pretty useful though depending on final cost? Otherwise maybe it'll end up niche, but it's really cool research anyway.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by andreareina on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:56AM
(#24527826)
CCDs aren't monochromatic though: they detect a wide band of frequencies, they just can't tell the difference. High dispersion in the lens is a problem because a blue photon and a red photon originating from the same spot on the same object, hitting the same spot on the lens, will be deflected to different spots on the CCD. This causes fringing and fuzziness in the image.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by em3rgent0rdr on Friday September 18, 2020 @08:28PM
(#24523420)
Yeah. It currently works in infrared (though they say it can be modified to visible light) and the video from the lab shows the images to look quite noisy and blurry, honestly.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by MichaelZuo on Friday September 18, 2020 @10:00PM
(#24524199)
Depending on the wavelength of the infrared even noisy and blurry may be notable or it may be mediocre for their setup. All the important details are in the paywalled paper so which type of infrared they calibrated for is unknown.
Just too much stuff missing from the article to actually judge for technical merit.
And plus making one for visible light is likely the main challenge as micro machining precision optics is not subject to moore’s law type scaling. Though I wouldn’t put it past Apple to sink billions into it if it helps making camera modules a few mm thinner.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by ashtonkem on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:06AM
(#24526869)
At the claimed 180 degree field of view? Yes. Fisheyes that wide have lenses that are not only incredibly thick, but also bulbous enough that protecting the lens is quite difficult.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by MichaelZuo on Friday September 18, 2020 @10:09PM
(#24524244)
For an add-on lens yes. It’s probable Apple already has prototype lenses optimized for thinness that are less than a cm thick, since a lot of the bulk is unnecessary if it’s directly integrated to the sensor.
Re:Engineers produce a fisheye lens that’s completely flat
by lioeters on Friday September 18, 2020 @10:55PM
(#24524528)
I believe the "flat" was meant in contrast to "curved", as in typical fisheye/ultra-wide-angle lenses.
> the new fisheye lens consists of a single flat, millimeter-thin piece of glass covered on one side with tiny structures that precisely scatter incoming light to produce panoramic images.
With a thinness of a millimeter, I'd say that's flat. The "tiny structures" are in the form of a film, which further qualifies as flat.
> Their new metalens is a single transparent piece made from calcium fluoride with a thin film of lead telluride deposited on one side. The team then used lithographic techniques to carve a pattern of optical structures into the film.
> Each structure, or “meta-atom,” as the team refers to them, is shaped into one of several nanoscale geometries, such as a rectangular or a bone-shaped configuration, that refracts light in a specific way.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fresnel_lens
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TshYfYIxR9E
the new fisheye lens consists of a single flat, millimeter-thin piece of glass covered on one side with tiny structures that precisely scatter incoming light to produce panoramic images
(In particular, wave theory is not needed to predict the behavior of classical lenses.)
This is slightly unclear. I meant more specifically:
[...] which has small structures that change the phase of the light, which, in turn, causes it to constructively or destructively interfere [...]
But i will read the paper later.
Except I don't think it is. It's probably more like a diffraction grating or a hologram. You can actually make a flat lens by creating a hologram of a real lens and it will be flat.
What are the downsides?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmlXR2nsis4
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/laser
>> "2 : something resembling a laser beam in accuracy, speed, or intensity "
I gave up on fighting "CPU means the entire computer" a long time ago.
"Many people" have taken first year physics, or at least read a wikipedia article, and understand that the defining feature of a laser is its coherence.
But, sure. It's 2020. We live in a post-factual society, words have no meaning and it's impossible to know anything. Why resist?
Also in the video you can see spatial ringing, which is highly indicative of coherent light (single wavelength, like in a laser.)
This is still a cool discovery and could definitely have a lot of important applications, but it's important to clarify what this is, and what it isn't.
> 3D artistic illustration of the wide-field-of-view metalens capturing a 180° panorama of MIT’s Killian Court and producing a high-resolution monochromatic flat image.
My guess is that it is only good for monochromatic light.
Does anyone know how much of a limitation that'd be in practice though? CCDs are monochromatic too, which we deal with using either Bayer filters (usually RGGB IIRC) or (in fancier high end stuff) a splitter prism leading to 3 separate CCDs. Modern computational photography is also increasingly able to do sensor fusion, even between different cameras. I can see how making use of this would still be an extra challenge in a small form factor, because normally the split/filter happens after the lens which simplifies things a lot. Having to do 3x multisensor fusion with meta material fisheye only definitely would be more effort and bulkier. Seems like it might still be pretty useful though depending on final cost? Otherwise maybe it'll end up niche, but it's really cool research anyway.
Just too much stuff missing from the article to actually judge for technical merit.
And plus making one for visible light is likely the main challenge as micro machining precision optics is not subject to moore’s law type scaling. Though I wouldn’t put it past Apple to sink billions into it if it helps making camera modules a few mm thinner.
Isn't a typical consumer fish eye lens for an iPhone a couple of cm in depth? Sounds like we're talking a more than a few mm here
If it works for visible light too, Apple seems like a ripe buyer. Supports a thin enclosure and an obvious camera upgrade thus a win for them.
Will be interesting if it's a gross exaggeration.
Click bait. Not "completely flat" at all.
> the new fisheye lens consists of a single flat, millimeter-thin piece of glass covered on one side with tiny structures that precisely scatter incoming light to produce panoramic images.
With a thinness of a millimeter, I'd say that's flat. The "tiny structures" are in the form of a film, which further qualifies as flat.
> Their new metalens is a single transparent piece made from calcium fluoride with a thin film of lead telluride deposited on one side. The team then used lithographic techniques to carve a pattern of optical structures into the film.
> Each structure, or “meta-atom,” as the team refers to them, is shaped into one of several nanoscale geometries, such as a rectangular or a bone-shaped configuration, that refracts light in a specific way.
The 3µm-wide structures in TFA deviate <1µm from the surface, so it's even flatter than glass, and your objection sounds rather petty.