If I were making the rules, those students would be out of the university the same day. There is no shortage of smart people who would love to attend Stanford, especially the engineering school. I have no idea why enforcement is so disgracefully lax.
In the electrical engineering department, I regularly had classmates ask me if we could "compare answers" on homework problem sets. Sometimes (rarely), this was for a genuine goal of education-- if your answer is wrong, you want to know that so you can figure out the right answer. More often, it was clueless people trying to collect answers from multiple other people. Drove me up the wall.
The same goes for homework problem sets: me and two others would usually first solve them ourselves to the best of our ability and then compare answers, which was always an educational experience; the more so when no one had successfully solved the problem on their own or when it took someone a while to convince the other two their (identical) solutions were wrong.
That sounds like a flawed assumption to me. There are lots of social and economic incentives that might lead someone smart to do others' work.
I tend to agree that working with others on problem sets can be quite beneficial. Many classes I took had the same policy on those. But at some point you have to prove you can do it yourself.
I flunked the final exam for physics. I knew I was flunking it as I took it. I also knew EXACTLY where in the book the one bit of information was that I needed to pass that exam was. All I had to do was reach over a couple of feet, in my private, closed room, and spend 30 seconds in the book, and all would be well. But Caltech was on the honor system, and the instructions on the test said closed book, so I flunked and was kicked out.
(I then spent a year at a community college, acing everything, to show Caltech that I could actually do college work if I tried. They let me back in, and enough of the credits from the community college transferred so that I was able to come back as a sophomore. I still ended up spending way too much time hacking, but ended up with a B average at graduation).
Any money borrowed for purposes of education in the United States is unattachable. That debt will stick with you, NO MATTER WHAT. We have Reagan and 98' Republican Congress to thank/blame for this. The only other debts that have this status are ones granted by a judgement for crimes (for example, murder).
As I am reminded by that art student who had 160K in debt that was posted a few days ago, it is fiduciary irresponsible of you to have that kind of situation possibly happen.
What's your response to the problem of folks declaring bankruptcy to get out of student loans right before they start earning real money, such as MDs?
> As I am reminded by that art student who had 160K in debt that was posted a few days ago, it is fiduciary irresponsible of you to have that kind of situation possibly happen.
Which "you" is that about? Are you saying that art students shouldn't be given such loans or they shouldn't accept them?
Multiple choice, simple fact recall -> easy to cheat
Real idea synthesis, non-trivial 'show your work' calculation required -> hard to cheat
It comes down to amount of data that needs to be moved surreptitiously to mimic a correct answer. When you frame it that way it almost looks like a problem in the security domain (secret keys, side-channel data leak, time bound attack)
There are other reasons to not use simple fact recall type tests, of course. Like actually testing transfer.
But, in support of what you said: I went to Uppsala University in Sweden, and all exams were 6h long and happened in a giant special-purposed exam hall with 6 feet spaces between each desk. Cheating by communicating was a lost cause and even if you could, the amount of info you'd need to transfer to make a dent in a 6h-long test would be way too large. I don't recall anyone trying to cheat, but if it was to happen, it would have been done by adding notes to the bible-sized book of tables and formulae that we almost always were allowed to use.
And also harder to evaluate and grade; the professor or TA must be willing to invest an hour or several in reading through the longer answers to see where the students went right or wrong. That would be no problem in a hypothetical ideal educational framework, but realistically TAs (even at Stanford) aren't always that dedicated.
Given the time of year, when I read about cheating and the honor system, my first thought is about taxes, specifically, paying state sales tax on items bought online and shipped from out of state.
Most states don't have an easy way of catching sales tax cheaters, so it usually comes down to the honor system: When you file your state income tax return, you are supposed to add up all your "mail order" receipts for the year and pay sales tax on them.
How many HNers actually do this, I wonder? This seems like an instance where there is an honor system, but everyone cheats anyway.
Tax law has become so complex that a lay person can't get the job done without either paying someone to do it, or having to use software that may not include all of the options required...
I think the deciding factor in successfully inculcating the value of fairness in academia is ensuring the students actually value academia. If the work's viewed as strictly an impediment by a student there's almost no way to change that.
In my engineering program I have had plenty of teachers walk out of the room for large amounts of time or do something like grade papers without looking around the room and haven't once seen an issue of cheating.
However in my freshman chemistry course which was required for a large amount of students from many disciplines they had 8 T.A.s and electronically moveable cameras (the class was recorded so the cameras were just being re-purposed) monitoring a class of about 200 and I do believe some cheaters were caught in my semester.
If a different class of functions doesn't exist, it seems like your classmates just had better study material.
(I'm thinking about a calculus test with a previously unseen e^x. Wouldn't knowing the answer from looking at a previous year's test be more akin to 'learning' than 'cheating'?)
Sometimes, it can work against the student. Particularly if the student doesn't attend class (low-level blow off class) and the teachers / method changes. I TAed an intro to programming course for non-majors. My fellow TA and myself created new tests for the class (it went from GWBasic to QBasic). A couple of students from one of the fraternities attended the 1st day of class and then the first test (missing the homework programs). I handed out the first test and got the following reaction: "This isn't the right test!". Oh well.
If you prevent cheating by having a person who's job it is to catch you then you feel like if you don't get caught you have won. On the other hand if you are expected not to cheat because it is not what a honorable person does, then if you cheat it is because you have failed.