That's a different experience than Madrid, where the virus hit much earlier. By the end of April, daily case counts were 1/5th of their peak in Madrid.
I'm not aware of a more recent study.
Here's daily deaths in Spain:
https://i.imgur.com/G84d20p.png
All numbers about total reported cases from the spring are going to be way, way off. There simply wasn't enough testing.
Deaths do not lie, which is why we should focus on those numbers. And by those numbers, this is in no way a repeat of Spring for Spain.
The daily number of cases in Spain appears to still be on the rise, and the death curve is usually 3-4 weeks lagging the cases. So deaths is likely still on the rise.
All that said, it may not reach the same proportions as the spring. But it is too early to wave it off either.
The outbreak in Spain isn't as severe as you might think, there's a lot more positive tests, yet a lot less illness.
Herd immunity just means that R=1 without precautions. I would agree that Spain hasn't quite achieved herd immunity, but spread right now isn't anything like earlier this year.
One could speculate that because Spain went into such a strict lockdown, herd immunity could not be achieved, or that herd immunity was achieved, it just didn't last because COVID immunity doesn't last.
That being said, in one hard-hit area of Stockholm, seroprevalence was 19% (https://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/publicerat-material/publ...). Stockholm as a whole has about 11% seroprevalence in their most recent numbers, but again, I believe antibodies are starting to fade now (https://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/publicerat-material/publ...).
Sweden didn't lock down because they wanted to achieve herd immunity quickly, while still taking measures to protect the most vulnerable. Spain locked down, actively attempting to minimize the spread of the virus.
How is the failure of Spain to achieve herd immunity (while actively attempting to achieve the opposite) a counterpoint to the Swedish example?
This is a popular myth. There are no such statements (no not even from internal communication and similar). It was never a “strategy”
https://www.newsweek.com/sweden-herd-immunity-mastermind-who...
Lockdown also seems to increase the threshold for herd immunity and increase deaths, by dramatically changing the demographics of who is infected. Without lockdown, the youngest and most mobile people are likely to be infected - with minimal/zero deaths since COVID mortality is incredibly age dependent.
Under lockdown, those people are at home and intermingling with family. The only 'social' activity is shopping for food, leading to an unnatural mingling of old and young.
I live in Ukraine which has masks and little else against COVID. In shopping centers particularly in the evenings there are essentially zero old people - they fear for their lives, as they should.
The most effective policy we could have adopted was 6AM-10AM public transport and shopping for the aged only, and everyone else from then on. Segregate the elderly population into the mornings and let the masses in in the afternoon. This might have required shifting school and work to later hours in the day for three months, which seems a minor inconvenience.
Literally everything in your post is as poorly considered. It's important not to spread misinformation.
In addition to immunity based on T cells, the HIT depends on how individuals are networked. The original 60-70% estimates were based on 100% of people being vulnerable and also a random distribution of individuals interacting. In reality a small fraction of the population will have many interactions and once they become immune those transmission vectors away and the average R number drops. So based on the latest research plus observations of the worst hit places, 20-25% seems plausible.
https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/3433488/5579620/KS-S...
Looking at this data for the US, it could be a factor for COVID mortality being higher in minorities:
https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2010/03/18/the-return-of-the...
The numbers you cite are explained by old people living in retirement facilities or coliving arrangements, but that doesn't imply cohabitation with young people. Under these circumstances, special precautions can and must be taken.
As for Sweden, there's a lot of variety in human behavior and a lot we don't understand about the virus, and there are many possible explanations for the lack of major spread in any particular area. Sweden has continued to post a steady low level of cases over the last two months, not a continuing bell-curve decline, suggesting the virus is still consistently finding new hosts, just at a low and steady pace.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-spain-...
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/21/just-7-per-cen...
[2] https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-09-doctors-hard-hit-madr...