News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:21PM (#24499727)
I've done a number of diversity & inclusion trainings and I'm always confused by the opposition to them. Being more aware is generally useful.

As a hiring manager, it's been helpful for me to be thoughtful about asking things like, "how did you get here, car, train?" - as this implies socioeconomic status, and if you reflect on why you asked that, what you wanted to know about it, and how it affected your thinking in general, and were honest, there's a chance it might have affected your opinion of the person in a way that has nothing to do with their ability to do the job. This opinion could be either good or bad, and isn't necessarily dependent on whether the person you're interviewing is from a marginalized class.

I still have bias, everyone does, these trainings do not aim to eliminate bias, they aim to inform people that it exists, and to offer them tools to be thoughtful about those biases, and to challenge folks to question the biases that potentially harm others, even if unintentionally.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by gizmo686 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:11PM (#24500079)
Empircally, diversity training does not work (at least according to this article).

If you are pro diversity, you should therefore be against the current iteration of diversity training; and instead advocate redirect that effort into either experimenting with new approaches, or following other approaches that might work.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by vinceroni on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:35AM (#24503355)
Aren't these two distinct things? The fact that one could be pro-diversity, while science says the way diversity training is being done so far is not effective, is not incompatible. It might mean that the way diversity training is being delivered and its content need to change, but not that pro-diversity "is wrong".

Imagine flight had not been invented yet. You wouldn't say that the Marquis de Bacqueville [1] attempt is the proof that flight is a bad idea or wrong. We continually improve and strive to find better ways to achieve goals we define as desirable. You might disagree with the latter, but this is a different point.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Fran%C3%A7ois_Boyvin_de_B...

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:18PM (#24500133)
Thanks for your advice.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by bhawks on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:37PM (#24499849)
From the article:

> Sometimes they even implant new stereotypes (for instance, if participants didn’t previously have particular stereotypes for Vietnamese people, or much knowledge about them overall, but were introduced to common stereotypes about this group through training intended to dispel said stereotypes).

Have you considered being more aware might have made you behave in a more bias or stereotype assuming way?

The question should be are these programs achieving the goal of making an inclusive workplace or not?

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:43PM (#24499892)
Yes, I've considered that. And it's great to be able to be open about it and talk. If you are unaware of a subject, it's much more difficult to speak about it.

I think a lot of the problems with diversity training, and reasons it may not work - are that it's not actually bought into by those participating - and by bought into, I don't mean believing everything you hear - I mean participating, active listening, asking questions, being open to the idea that one is wrong, and that you can improve and help make your workplace one which feels good to be part of.

It took me 20 years in my career, and most of the bad workplaces I had were a result of careless / unempathetic leadership. Once I actually had that, and saw that they were better at running a business than those without deep empathy and thoughtful reflection, I am not going back.

I'll never work for someone who isn't at least open to the ideas of transparency, open communication, and psychological safety, while at the same time, driving a business forward - these are not contradictions.

Last: The training can't make the workplace better - the people must. If they are unwilling to listen, or behave differently based on signals they are now trained on, or at least know why they are continuing their current behavior (an option) - it won't work, these things fall apart when there isn't widespread participation.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by bhawks on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:56PM (#24499977)
Diversity training and leadership environments seem like 2 separate discussions. Many types of leaders will do diversity training for their organization for various reasons. I too prefer leaders of organizations who have the values you are espousing.

Based on the article I do wonder if the approach of the training can make people more or less willing to create an inclusive environment. The way you approach someone to do something is definitely a factor in whether they will do it. If training approaches like these are making folks more likely to be biased, I think that is cause for introspection.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:19PM (#24500138)
I agree the approach had a huge impact - I wouldn’t argue against that as I’ve had diversity trainings that were better than others - this isn’t some finalized and well understood science so that is expected. We should always be trying to improve.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by itsdrewmiller on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:30PM (#24499804)
I think it's important to be open to the possibility that these trainings are in fact counterproductive, even if it is hard to intuit why that might be the case.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:40PM (#24499869)
It's benefitted me in many ways, both professionally and personally to be open to the idea that I could be wrong - and I don't feel like anyone has ever forced me to believe that.

I'm open to the science here, so will keep an ear to the ground.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by sokoloff on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:41PM (#24499880)
One of my objections to most of the HR training I’ve been to is the pacing. Some tech training videos are a little slow-paced, but nearly every HR training I’ve been to has felt like 30-45 minutes of content crammed into 4 hours.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:20PM (#24500146)
Agree. This is a huge thing in general relating to pedagogy and how people learn and internalize things. You need multiple approaches to be successful.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by yodelshady on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:29AM (#24502350)
How about a null-ish hypothesis: most people I know are opposed to mandatory company-wide training in general.

Health and safety training, for example. And I can talk to people who were around before that was a things, and count the number of limbs.

It's not entirely unjustified. Mandatory company-wide training probably is irrelevant to your specific role. It's also usually delivered by the lowest bidder, which is the strongest possible true signal I could receive. It's often not even attended by leadership - the people whose role is setting the culture!

I get a long (charged by-the-hour?) lecture from HopefulSlogan Consultants about ethics and integrity? I think the same thing as I would walking past the slogans on Enron's lobby walls. The top is almost certainly corrupt.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by throw_m239339 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:20AM (#24501455)
> I've done a number of diversity & inclusion trainings and I'm always confused by the opposition to them. Being more aware is generally useful.

Because they are based on a racist ideology, "'critical' race theory" and they are more akin to soviet style struggle sessions than any sort of actual training. In fact what is practiced in US would be probably illegal in a number of European countries.

Furthermore it's lower level employees that are subject to these "indoctrination" sessions, not higher ups that often treat low level employees like shit, no matter the race or sex.

So on one side, you are for victimizing low level employees, on the other, controversial management techniques that totally lack of any human empathy are never questioned.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by rayiner on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:38AM (#24501555)
> Because they are based on a racist ideology, "'critical' race theory" and they are more akin to soviet style struggle sessions than any sort of actual training. In fact what is practiced in US would be probably illegal in a number of European countries.

It might not be legal in the U.S. either, at least some of the stuff that's going on. TBD.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:05AM (#24501934)
How many diversity trainings have you participated in, and what is your feedback about how they could have been improved?
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by joshuamorton on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:35AM (#24501805)
What do you believe critical race theory is? I don't see any relationship between it and struggle sessions.

What trainings are you talking about? (my experience is that the extent of these trainings are that everyone must take the same thing, yes including the C-suite)

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by humanrebar on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:31PM (#24499808)
Everyone struggles with being selfish. It's good to be aware of our own self-interested impulses and work towards counteracting them. So why not have mandatory training at work that teaches us that we're all selfish at some level and that we need to address that character flaw?
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by throw_m239339 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:34AM (#24501532)
> Everyone struggles with being selfish. It's good to be aware of our own self-interested impulses and work towards counteracting them. So why not have mandatory training at work that teaches us that we're all selfish at some level and that we need to address that character flaw?

A for profit corporation is the very definition of selfishness. And you think that a corporation can teach you "not to be selfish" when the entire goal is productivity in order to make someone a whole lot more money that you will ever earn? You don't see a contradiction in what you are saying?

It can't get more hypocritical like that. These trainings only exist to benefit the corporation, not the individual subjected to these. The perfect alliance between soviet style propaganda techniques (struggle sessions to break the individual) and hyper capitalism.

And no, everybody does not struggle with being selfish. Everybody isn't selfish.

By victimizing their employees with "diversity training" on the other hand, corporations have found the perfect way to break them, with the approval and moral support of the left. In fact, many corporations known for their anti-union schemes do also force their employees through these "diversity training" sessions.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:55PM (#24499970)
>Everyone struggles with being selfish.

Sorry but that's just a completely baseless assertion. Not everyone is selfish, nor is it a struggle for everyone to not be selfish. Assuming that others think as you think is what we call in poker, "first level thinking". The same concept can be extended to those who obsess over "diversity" and insist, "everyone is racist". Its flatly wrong, and frankly, idiotic to make such an assertion. Saddling everyone with the insecurities and deficiencies carried by a few is counterproductive and wrong.

Your employer has every right to be concerned with your behavior at work, and take any sort of punitive or corrective measures that your misbehavior may merit. Your employer should have no role making sweeping judgements about your beliefs or personality traits that have not been manifested in the workplace, much less mandating Soviet-style re-education which hinges on their baseless (and flawed) assumptions about human nature.

Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by humanrebar on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:57PM (#24499990)
You disagree with me but then you reiterate my rhetorical point.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:11PM (#24500085)
If you equate judging people on their actions rather than making sweeping judgements about them to being selfish, then your problems extend far beyond selfishness.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:21PM (#24500150)
If you eat when you are hungry you are selfish.
[dead]
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:37PM (#24500249)
My point is that all people are selfish in some way and that is ok and natural.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by lliamander on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:53AM (#24501305)
I don't think it's correct or helpful to use the term "selfish" to describe rationally self-interested behavior which does not impinge upon the needs of others.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:06AM (#24501945)
That’s semantics.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by lliamander on Friday September 18, 2020 @09:17PM (#24523872)
That's equivocation.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by codezero on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:39PM (#24500257)
If you disagree we might be using the word selfish to mean different things. That’s also possible, and normal, these conundrums can only be discovered and addressed with communication, and a willingness to listen.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by StanislavPetrov on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:36AM (#24501542)
Yea, that or a dictionary.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by raxxorrax on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:49AM (#24503456)
I won't share my greed with you.
Re:Diversity-Related Training Meta-analysis by lenkite on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:49AM (#24501615)
Replacing the entire capitalist system of the world with a tyrannical socialist system would be the only way to avoid selfishness.