News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by geoffmunn on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:59PM (#24489417)
As a developer, I've found that the Agile methodology is great for weeding out bullshitters.

A decently run sprint planning session with a retrospective at the end will highlight who didn't actually do anything. The killer feature is that these people volunteered the amount of effort for the work and then have to explain why nothing got done.

They eventually leave the team once they realise they've been discovered.

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by Mc91 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @12:34AM (#24489559)
We spend our retros whinging about other teams that (are supposed to) support us.
Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by zimpenfish on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:26AM (#24490664)
Having worked at many places with many bullshitters who have successfully conned the Agile process for weeks (sometimes months), I'd have to disagree.

(Indeed, I have done it once myself when I was trying to leave but they were dragging their feet about signing the paperwork.)

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by Thorentis on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:23AM (#24491252)
The only way I've seen people con it, is where the people doing the tasks are also trusted with scoping and estimating it. You need to have multiple people "sign off" on or buy into the scoping and estimation process. E.g. One person does an "investigation" task (e.g. Look into feasibility / difficulty of x). This should be somebody with enough experience to give a good rough estimate. Their estimate can them be discussed at the next sprint planning session, and everybody should agree on the final estimate (story points, or size label, however you do your sprints).

Then, if the bullshitter gets to the end of the sprint and says they didn't complete a 1-2 day task in 10 days, you can start asking why. They do this consistently across 2-3 sprints, you know something is up. Assume they're more junior than their job title and try giving them easier tasks. Still not getting much done? They're a bullshitter. Fire them / raise with their manager.

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:36AM (#24492558)
> Then, if the bullshitter gets to the end of the sprint and says they didn't complete a 1-2 day task in 10 days, you can start asking why. They do this consistently across 2-3 sprints, you know something is up. Assume they're more junior than their job title and try giving them easier tasks. Still not getting much done? They're a bullshitter. Fire them / raise with their manager.

Another contributing cause of this can be that they have gotten into the habit of accepting other people's bullshit.

Example:

Bob says "I don't think I understand enough about X to do task T well".

Sue, (partly worried what people would think of her if she negotiated similar time for learning) feels great discomfort hearing Bob's self-deprecating* statement. Motivated to escape this discomfort, she 'helpfully' tells him that he is just suffering from impostor syndrome.

(Bullshit: It might be true, but the function to produce the statement did not take real-world evidence as a parameter)

Bob mostly-believes this and doesn't feel confident that it is wise to allocate his time to learn X. He should 'just get it done'.

Bob starts working on task T and feels frustrated and confused. Bob starts asking questions on slack that anyone with a solid understanding of X would know are irrelevant. He does not get helpful answers.

Bob, hearing that he's trying to 'understand the universe' doesn't see a way forward but to put more time into task T. He stays up late working on it ineffectively.

Bob goes into standup having accomplished very little and gained little understanding. Bob's duty to his team and his health is to confidently state this truth. Bob is sleep-deprived and ashamed of his lack of progress. He feels motivated to escape this discomfort. He says the task will be done by standup tomorrow.

(Bullshit: It might be true, but the function to produce the statement did not take real-world evidence as a parameter)

Bob stays up late again. Bob accomplishes little. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CLBO7L5G2DQ

10 days later, Bob still does not really understand how to make progress on his task.

----------------

Bob gets fired shortly thereafter. He has multiple hypotheses for what he should have done better, but none he is confident in. At his next job, he is on hyper-vigilant alert for a similar situation. When he encounters it, the memory of getting fired and the uncertainty of what to do makes him feel deeply uncomfortable. Discomfort-avoidance leads him to get on hackernews rather than focus on his work.

----------------

* "I have gaps in my skills and am capable of learning" is a healthy problem to have. "I am unqualified to judge when I need more understanding of something to move forward" is an unhealthy problem.

Thus, we should exercise a duty of care to the truth when telling people that they have Impostor Syndrome.

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by Thorentis on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:29PM (#24498191)
To be honest this seems more like a Bob problem than a Sue problem. "Just get on with it" (or some variation thereof, whether reference to imposter syndrome, stiff upper lip, etc) is thrown about all the time in all workplaces. If you are genuinely struggling or don't know what to do then it is your professional responsibility to make the right people know about it.

If Bob did stress this very strongly with Sue, and Sue was the person in charge of allocating tasks, then yes of course Sue is to blame. Giving people tasks they can't do is bad.

Perhaps Sue thinks that Bob should be able to figure it out within the 10 days and doesn't need more than that to both investigate and complete the task? If there is a large knowledge imbalance and Sue knows a lot more about the task than Bob then maybe she should take on that task instead.

So many variables!

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:03AM (#24501927)
> If Bob did stress this very strongly with Sue, and Sue was the person in charge of allocating tasks, then yes of course Sue is to blame. Giving people tasks they can't do is bad.

The trouble is if Bob doesn't know he can do it or not. It can be very hard to tell if you're actually confused about something or if you are just making excuses.

Sadly, if the latter, there really is only one way to stop making excuses.

--------

Note: While I am feeling very distressed these days. I want to reassure y'all that I am not going to stop making excuses. There are too many people who love and care about me dearly whom I know would be devastated.

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Friday September 18, 2020 @08:06AM (#24515643)
(Also, I don't think I actually make excuses very frequently at all. Occasionally I deceive myself, but far more often than that I give reasons that reflect a reality which is genuinely absurd in ways that are unfair to the listener yet still true.)
Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:54PM (#24498977)
yep, it is a complex multifactor problem.

> make the right people know about it.

You cannot _make_ someone else know something. Even if you to grab onto their skull and scream into their ear, it would do no good. (I assume. I have not tested this.) You can only say what you believe with whatever rhetorical skill you can muster. They can still choose to trust you with something you say you don't know how to do.

Whether the subcomponent is physical or psychological, sometimes the only way to credibly communicate about a risk is through the medium of catastrophic failure.

https://www.nasa.gov/centers/langley/news/researchernews/rn_...

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:29AM (#24502045)
How would Bob even know if he is qualified to tell if he is genuinely struggling or just suffering from impostor syndrome? How would he tell if he is just bullshitting himself about whether or not he has real a problem?
Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by afarrell on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:01AM (#24501914)
Or rather, maybe you know how to make people know about things. Many people do not.

I still do not know how to persuade people that I DO NOT have psychic powers -- other people's brains are separate from mine.

Re:Bullshitters: Who Are They and What Do We Know about Thei... by zcw100 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @12:10PM (#24494017)
Or maybe they just leave because of people like you who think Agile is like the Thunderdome of software development rather than a tool to manage a team.