News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:22AM (#24481480)
This is why you always use GPL
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by Dork1234 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:33AM (#24481613)
Re branding a MIT license software and selling a commercial version is a good thing if done correctly. Clearly Zen is not providing any added value.

The key takeaway from this is you don't sign contracts with overly aggressive business executives. I also think Non-competes should be almost completely banned for most employees.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:44AM (#24481743)
The key takeaway for me is that a third party is able to use thousands of manhours of someone else’s labor as a basis for their closed source product without having to share their enhancements or pay a dime.

If zig were licensed GPL, the zig foundation would be able to sell permissive licenses to companies that don’t want to share source as a way to fundraise.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by kristoff_it on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:52AM (#24481841)
As the author of the statement, I disagree. Parent poster got it right: the license is MIT precisely to allow the highest degree of freedom.

Companies that want to profit from Zig are welcome to do so, but in this particular case, we consider connectFree a bad actor and so we crossed the language barrier to make sure Japanese developers would be able to hear from both sides.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:01AM (#24481939)
From the statement:

    “We can’t in good conscience recommend to Japanese professionals and businesses to make their livelihood depend on a closed-source, superficial rebranding of Zig“
Does the zig foundation have a problem with recommending closed-source superficial rebrandings of Zig or just from connectFree?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by judofyr on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:32AM (#24482390)
Regardless of the legality of a thing, the foundation might of course recommend against using it. Imagine that someone wrote a shitty book (without stealing any content) which ends up as the only result on Amazon. It’s perfectly legal to release such a book and it would be sensible for the foundation to warn the Zig community about the lacking quality.

Just because the license allows anyone to fork it and sell it doesn’t mean that Zig is obliged to endorse it.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:38AM (#24482475)
It’s fine for the foundation to recommend against certain companies, but it’s inconsistent to recommend against any specific company on the basis of it being “closed source superficial rebrand” if they claim to have no issue with people using their code on those terms.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by dnautics on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:13AM (#24482091)
did you read the description of what happened?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:17AM (#24482153)
Yes
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by dnautics on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:20AM (#24482193)
then I submit that your rhetorical question at the end of your statement is flawed. Maybe consider the question: Does zig have a problem with closed-source rebrandings by companies that cause serious damage to the ecosystem outside of merely forking the code?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:26AM (#24482292)
It was not flawed nor rhetorical, if their concern is with ecosystem damage, then the fact that the company makes a closed source superficial rebrand should have no bearing on that. Unless they indeed have a problem with companies profiting from Zig.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by ModernMech on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:06AM (#24481999)
> a third party is able to use thousands of manhours of someone else’s labor as a basis for their closed source product without having to share their enhancements or pay a dime.

This is my favorite part about open source. Why are you painting it as a bad thing?

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by pfraze on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:16AM (#24482141)
There's a difference between using open-source in your work and doing a superficial fork & rebrand. The latter is clearly trying to steal the upside from the creator of the code.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by ModernMech on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:50AM (#24482641)
Of course there is a difference, but again that's what I love about open source. You put something out there, and then it has a life of its own. So what if some people come along and try to sell your code with a new name? Good luck to them, I hope they become very rich off my code (are there any examples of this actually happening?). Personally I write open source code because I like writing open source code, not to get rich.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by magic_quotes on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:08PM (#24482907)
> If zig were licensed GPL, the zig foundation would be able to sell permissive licenses to companies

That would be against the spirit of GPL, which is ideologically opposed to all proprietary software.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by mhh__ on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:12PM (#24482951)
Stallman himself has said he approves of GPL/Commercial dual licensing.

It's a good way to support a project - companies don't like the GPL but they also want to spend money on support.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:28PM (#24483167)
> It's a good way to support a project

I disagree. GPL/Commercial dual licensing is always a game of perverse incentives. Even if you aren't actively crippling the free part of your product you're incentivised to make it difficult enough to work with or otherwise support that companies will be inclined to pay you to do it.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by mhh__ on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:38PM (#24487952)
Not necessarily - the GPL is a no-go for some companies regardless of the difference in quality between the free and not free.

Remember that it's not free it's about lawyer approval.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by 1980phipsi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:23PM (#24483931)
Can you dual license with both GPL and MIT (or other)? Would that make sense?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by mhh__ on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:30PM (#24484026)
Maybe, the idea is that a company who wants to use my work can either comply with the GPL and give back that way or financially support the project (and therefore not need to comply).

You could grant them an MIT license, I guess.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by magic_quotes on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:21PM (#24483073)
FSF isn't vehemently opposed to permissive licenses either (they are merely discouraged), but that is the argument GP decided to bring here.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by AsyncAwait on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:19PM (#24483037)
> Re branding a MIT license software and selling a commercial version is a good thing if done correctly.

GPL does not prevent you from selling a commercial version, only from closing up the source.

Having no access to the source is to direct user determent.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by kodablah on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:12AM (#24482070)
For those that believe in software freedoms as fewer restrictions, you have to accept that people may take advantage of your fewer restrictions. This is the cost of giving more (beer) freedom, and you don't have to abandon your principles because of how it manifests. (this has obvious political analogies in other restriction-less freedom contexts too)
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by bachmeier on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:38AM (#24482486)
> For those that believe in software freedoms as fewer restrictions, you have to accept that people may take advantage of your fewer restrictions.

This argument has never made sense. "The software is more free because you can impose restrictions on the way it's used." It's more of an attempt to rationalize than a concern about the freedom of the software.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:18PM (#24483035)
To paraphrase Stallman on the topic of permissive Free Software licences:

Some people prefer permissive Free Software licences, and feel that copyleft licences like the GPL introduce unwelcome restrictions. I don't understand this objection. They're unhappy that the licence doesn't grant the power to deny other people their freedom?

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:16AM (#24482133)
The existence of this blog post suggests to me that they either don’t believe in total software freedom or they haven’t yet accepted that people will take advantage of it.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by kodablah on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:19AM (#24482178)
I read it a bit different, I read it as they're proud of their freedom stance, and they are just informing users about a hostile fork without even hinting at reducing their principals henceforth.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:34AM (#24482418)
Then why do they imply in the blog post that “closed source superficial rebrandings” should be avoided by potential customers?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by wrsh07 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:37AM (#24482459)
Because zig is free? A marked up superficial re banding is a scam
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:36AM (#24482453)
They are warning contributors to not inadvertently sign a contract that would prevent them from contributing to Zig.

Me telling you there is a cliff here, be careful does nothing to infringe on your rights to walk off that cliff.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:44AM (#24482565)
This is precisely my point. Why allow anyone to walk off the cliff if you’re just going to tell them it’s wrong anyway? They could have avoided all of this if it were GPL in the first place.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:04PM (#24482846)
Because you believe in personal freedom?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:19PM (#24483042)
I do not mean this disrespectfully but isn’t that taking the idea of “personal freedom” to absurdity? I believe in personal freedom as well but I don’t think walking off a cliff or maliciously using someone Else’s labor is freedom.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:27PM (#24484822)
Tools like EULAs end up being fairly coarse in practice.

Presumably the Zig authors prefer a world in which it is possible to maliciously use the tools under MIT, and non-malicous actors could do various things downstream that the GPL would be a barrier to, to the world in which the GPL prevents both of those things.

There is a cost to preventing harms, and people will disagree whether the cost is worth it. There are many evils in this world that I do not push for collective action to eliminate merely because I do not yet see a feasible solution that is worth the cost. That doesn't preclude me from individually speaking against those things, warning people about the pitfalls of them, and shaming those who do them.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by aidenn0 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:57PM (#24496140)
I replied to the substance of your comment already, but I also wanted to say that it's a bit frustrating to me that you are downvoted without other replies.

While "freedom" is a fairly generic term (I can be free to kill you or not free to kill you), circumscribing "personal freedom" is reasonable in such situations. Many libertarians would agree that "personal freedom" is bounded by the "Harm principle" so any supposed right to shoot you without fear of reprisal would not be included in the term "personal freedom." Those same people would probably also argue that self-harm (and behavior that places one at risk of self-harm), are absolutely part of personal freedom.

Anarchists might say that "personal freedom" encompasses the right to harm others, and would argue that the repercussions would be natural; the damage to your reputation from harming others would deny you the assistance of others that could be necessary to succeed (or even survive) in the future, and it could also open you up to reprisal.

Some people argue that "personal freedom" includes all, or nearly all forms of free speech. In the US, it is generally agreed upon that defamation and incitement to riot are exceptions due to the harm principle. Many people take it further and say that allowing e.g. a KKK parade in a town should be excluded because it causes harm to the black community by fostering an environment of fear and mistrust, resulting in mental, emotional and financial harm.

I take no disrespect, and agree that a reasonable person could exclude harm to others as part of "personal freedom" I'm less convinced that harm to self isn't "personal freedom" as I think even most of those who support e.g. seatbelt laws would agree that they are a very small infringement on personal freedom in exchange for a very large public-health benefit and are knowingly making that tradeoff.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by tl on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:46AM (#24481773)
Taking the story at face value: Zen lied to customers and the community, hired a developer away from Zig, and that developer cannot work on Zig now due to an NDA.

GPL violations are not unknown. Would Zen have really cared about breaking the license? Would legal mechanisms work fast enough to limit damage?

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:52AM (#24481851)
All of that developers work on zen would be available to the zig foundation if it were licensed GPL.

If it were licensed GPL and they were violating that license they could sue in the legal system instead of writing a blog post with dubious effect.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by we2341 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:02PM (#24482823)
>All of that developers work on zen would be available to the zig foundation if it were licensed GPL.

False. the changes and the license only need to be extended to Zen's customers. They don't need to be provided back to Zig.

>If it were licensed GPL and they were violating that license they could sue in the legal system instead of writing a blog post with dubious effect.

Suing isn't a good idea even if you have a case. The blog post does more with less effort.

Even if Zig and Zen were GPL the employees agreement can be structured such that his work on Zen can not be used for Zig. There's an FAQ for this sort of stuff: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#DevelopChangesU...

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:58PM (#24483543)
>>All of that developers work on zen would be available to the zig foundation if it were licensed GPL.

>False. the changes and the license only need to be extended to Zen's customers. They don't need to be provided back to Zig.

Zen makes their system available for free download to the public, thus would be forced to provide source to the public. https://zen-lang.org/ja-JP/download/

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:31PM (#24483191)
Has anyone ever perused legal action based on a GPL violation? Last I checked, even the biggest piece of GPL software in existence, the Linux kernel, gets its violated without legal repercussions.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:24PM (#24488637)
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by monocasa on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:56PM (#24483518)
Yes, there have been several successful GPL violation lawsuits.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by dnautics on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:14AM (#24482095)
and where would the money and time to pursue a lawsuit come from?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by mouldysammich on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:21AM (#24482215)
This is the purpose of the FSF as far as I understand. One of their goals is enforcement of the GPL
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:13PM (#24482963)
I believe the FSF only use their legal resources to defend software whose copyright has been assigned to them.

https://www.fsf.org/bulletin/2014/spring/copyright-assignmen...

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:19AM (#24482180)
From the Zig foundation
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by dnautics on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:22AM (#24482231)
that's laughable. How much do you suppose it would cost to hire an international lawyer to pursue a case in a foreign country. Even if there were enough resources, do you think that the stakeholders in the Zig Foundation would consider that to be a reasonable use of the funds that they've donated?

I certainly wouldn't. As a donor, as far as I can tell, this is as good as they could do. I'm much happier that they spend their money on code, and leave it at a statement that can grab attention, like what they have done.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:32AM (#24482389)
Roughly $100K-$200K maximum and it would be a good use of time if it would recover potentially millions for the foundation.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by AndyKelley on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:23PM (#24483103)
good lord. our budget is public; you can see we have some 30K in the bank, with $3500 income per month. We will not be wasting donors' money on a lawyer.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:38PM (#24484134)
In this specific case it may not be worth it but if a large corporation were redistributing a hypothetically GPL-licensed version of zig without releasing source, then you would be doing your donors a disservice by not seeking retribution to the foundation.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by rtfeldman on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:10PM (#24484557)
I'm a Zig donor and I disagree. I'm happy that my donations are funding development instead of lawsuits.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:04AM (#24489988)
My point is that by funding certain lawsuits, their ROI could result in funding an order of magnitude more development
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by nemothekid on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:10PM (#24482933)
>recover potentially millions for the foundation.

You really believe a guy setting up a superficial fork in his basement has "millions" to pay out in damages?

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:21PM (#24483071)
If he doesn’t then there is little point in writing this blog post as well.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by nemothekid on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:01PM (#24483587)
The point of the blogpost isn't to shutdown Zen, it's to ensure new people who find Zig or Zen aren't confused into thinking there is a relationship between the two.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:12PM (#24483739)
Why would anyone think there was a relationship between the two? Nothing in Zen’s marketing mentions Zig.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by nemothekid on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:55PM (#24484362)
I have more faith in my fellow human beings that when they do due diligence to decide whether they should pay a monthly fee to use a language, that they would do a little due diligence and look into the history and syntax of the language and see that it's a fork of Zig instead of taking marketing at face value.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:05PM (#24484487)
By that logic, If you have faith in the due diligence of your fellow man, why would a rational person assume there is a relationship between software forks with no claim to that effect?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by nemothekid on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:53PM (#24485976)
>why would a rational person assume there is a relationship between software forks

Because many open source foundations bless commercial offerings. Having the open source foundation come out and say the commercial package is rubbish is the exception, not the norm.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:59AM (#24489966)
The norm is a neutral relationship
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by mStreamTeam on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:34AM (#24481620)
Most programmers would benefit by stepping out of their bubble and learning more about the business and legal side of their work
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by fengb on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:48AM (#24481796)
How would GPL help? It doesn't stop hostile forks.

Pretty sure the ask isn't the Zen source.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:50AM (#24481823)
Hostile forks would not be able to keep their enhancements private, thus ensuring a reciprocal relationship.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by nemothekid on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:14PM (#24482986)
If they were actual enhancements, I doubt the Zig Foundation would care. A company making a closed source release doesn't seem to be the point of ire here.

The issue is, another company has forked Zig, made 0, or negative enhancements, and the Zig foundation is making sure to distance itself from the fork incase anyone gets burned by Zen. You don't want the first impression of your new language to be tarnished by some commercial company who dumped everything in marketing and 0 in development.

The GPL wouldn't help in this case at all. It's very clear that the Zig Foundation doesn't care about the changes, it cares about it's reputation. On the contrary having a high quality commercial fork would probably be a good thing for Zig (see MySQL <-> Percona, Cassandra <-> Datastax, Postgres <-> Citus)

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by kristoff_it on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:01AM (#24481941)
While I can't speak with absolute certainty, we probably would not want to merge any "improvement" Zen made.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:05AM (#24481994)

    “Since then, “No. 2” has resigned from their position at connectFree, but won’t be able to contribute to the Zig project for some time because of a “non-compete” clause present in the contract.“
So why do you care if No. 2 is not able to work on Zig if you don’t value the contributions he’s made to Zen?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by learc83 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:10AM (#24482045)
Maybe they believe that No. 2 is capable of making valuable contributions, but that the specific contributions made at the direction of the Zen founder aren’t valuable.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by kristoff_it on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:18AM (#24482171)
Precisely.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by CyberRabbi on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:30AM (#24482375)
Two logical issues with that position:

1. Why do you believe that No. 2 can make valuable contributions to Zig if you do not value his contributions to Zen?

2. Why do you believe that No. 2 would be a potential contributor to Zig if he weren’t otherwise legally restricted?

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by masklinn on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:39AM (#24482490)
> 1. Why do you believe that No. 2 can make valuable contributions to Zig if you do not value his contributions to Zen?

Because the project does not care for Zen's desired direction and following this direction is the form No. 2's contributions to Zen would have taken as they were a contractor to Zen.

The contributions No. 2 would make to the Zig project as an individual and independent of Zen are… unrelated to the direction Zen wants.

> 2. Why do you believe that No. 2 would be a potential contributor to Zig if he weren’t otherwise legally restricted?

Because No. 2 is the number two contributor to Zig and is actively stopped from contributing by the NCC. That's literally in the statement.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by masklinn on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:18AM (#24482167)
What they care about is not the contribution they made to Zen, it's the contribution they would make to Zig and can not due to the NCC.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by efnx on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:21AM (#24482211)
Because they could make meaningful contributions to Zig, just as they had in the past.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by floatboth on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:13AM (#24482076)
Changes are not necessarily enhancements, and the upstream project might not even want the "enhancements" that are developed in a commercial setting.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by bencollier49 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:54AM (#24481867)
And there's nothing to stop the current Zig team from making future releases GPL, is there? Problem solved...?
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by wolco on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:05AM (#24481987)
Sort of but only the new parts would fall under gpl the rest bsd.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by a-nikolaev on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:36PM (#24484110)
If I'm not mistaken, if all code authors agree on the license change, then, the new release can be made fully GPL. While the old copy will be still available as MIT.

A malicious actor can pretend that they merged MIT parts with new GPL parts, but I think, it would not take a lot of time, until such merging would become technically hard, and the code can be effectively converted into GPL.

However, since Zen's guy was a contributor, it's probably not possible to get all authors' permission to change the license for the entire Zig codebase.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by YorickPeterse on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:49PM (#24484290)
A language licensed as the GPL likely would not see any users, as programs built on it would link to it (or at least parts of it, such as the standard library); thus requiring either an exception clause, or that all software using the language also be licensed as GPL.

IIRC the AGPL is better for this, but most GPL licenses are just blacklisted by companies; reducing the likelihood of the language catching on.

Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by pjmlp on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:14PM (#24486772)
Like GCC and Linux, total failure trying to cater for users, while FreeBSD rules.
Re:Statement Regarding the Zen Programming Language by pjmlp on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:29AM (#24481557)
Indeed, no tears dropped here.