News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by aristidb on Thursday April 14, 2011 @08:54AM (#2446606)
Amazon does however have an incentive to maximize revenue and there is a lower bound to what a developer gets (a percentage of the list price), even if Amazon promotes it for free, so Amazon loses money on that.

I think Amazon is better at optimizing pricing than most game developers are, so I expect this to improve revenue for both Amazon and the game developers. But only time will tell for sure. Panicking is not the right response.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by _delirium on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:00AM (#2446814)
I can believe that if Amazon were sticking to terms for its own market, but Amazon is attempting to prohibit anyone who sells through its market from simultaneously trying other pricing strategies in other channels. That seems more like a classic attempt at using market power in one channel to coerce behavior in other channels, rather than competing on the product's actual strength (unlike Google or even Apple).
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by jonknee on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:26AM (#2446910)
You can try other pricing strategies, it's just that you need to give Amazon the lowest list price. No different than Apple really, requiring your in-app content to match the lowest pricing available.

Amazon and [to a much greater extent] Wal-Mart play these games with physical goods too. It's just you never get to read the terms and big distributors don't complain publicly.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by _delirium on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:30AM (#2446921)
You do hear complaints from smaller publishers a lot w.r.t. physical goods, and their troubles are one reason I hope this doesn't catch on. They're left with the poor choice of selling through booksellers, or selling direct to consumers at a reasonable price, but can't do both.

If their break-even price is, say, $8, then they might want to sell it for list $9.99. But then Amazon wants it for $5 wholesale (half list), which would be a loss per book. To sell it to Amazon for at least $9 (a $1 profit), they have to set the list price at $18. But now that's too high for how they want to price it on their own www.publishersite.com online store, and they aren't allowed to discount it back down to the $9.99 they actually want to charge.

So you have a weird situation where as a condition of selling on Amazon, they aren't allowed to sell outside Amazon for a reasonable markup above cost!

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by jrockway on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:47PM (#2447742)
Can't you just give people 50% off coupons?
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by irons on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:38AM (#2446965)
No different than Apple really, requiring your in-app content to match the lowest pricing available.

IGDA says the Amazon terms limit you to the lowest price "available or previously available on any Similar Service" — it's the "previously available" that's the sticking point.

Tweetbot is having a $2.00 introductory sale on the iOS App Store, where the price will eventually go up. If Tapbots were foolish enough to do an Amazon version, they'd be constrained to offer that price forever. Absurd.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by sliverstorm on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:44AM (#2446992)
That depends on whether it's a Similar Service. Seems like you'd have a lot of wiggle room there.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by jonknee on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:43AM (#2446990)
I don't think Tweetbot would have any trouble launching at whatever list price they wanted on Amazon. Amazon isn't selling iOS apps so the Apple App Store isn't a similar service. Google's Android Market would be though.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by irons on Thursday April 14, 2011 @11:05AM (#2447077)
Your optimism would be touching, if it wasn't coming in the defense of such flagrantly hostile behavior.

Even if this clause did apply only to Android recompilations and not to ports, I trust you'll concede it is not status quo ante with Apple's already-appalling pricing terms.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by jonknee on Thursday April 14, 2011 @12:09PM (#2447334)
Apple has a monopoly in the iOS app distribution game, so their pricing terms are appalling for a different set of reasons (regardless of what they are you must agree if you want to ship the app). While I think Amazon is playing hardball, they in no way are the only way to sell Android applications. If the terms aren't agreeable, just don't use their store.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by metageek on Thursday April 14, 2011 @10:24AM (#2446901)
It's exactly like Apple's rule for in-app purchases.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by itg on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:22PM (#2447644)
The rules Amazon has in place are much worse than what Apple requires.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by metageek on Thursday April 14, 2011 @02:41PM (#2447922)
Yes, but the "must match" rule is what I was talking about.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by bmelton on Thursday April 14, 2011 @11:53PM (#2449384)
That's definitely true in the long term, but while I don't believe that Amazon is necessarily going to abuse the power they ask for just because they have it, heavily discounting apps at the developer's expense is a great way to get traction for a new app market that most people haven't heard of.

For many of the discounted apps, those that depend on the purchase revenue (vs. ad-based) and that might be fad, or temporarily popular, this could effectively kill them off in the name of helping Amazon.